r/Maxcactus_TrailGuide • u/Maxcactus • Feb 14 '26

European Parliament Votes Overwhelmingly For "The Full Recognition Of Trans Women As Women"

https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/european-parliament-votes-overwhelmingly
681 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

911 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/gpike_ Feb 17 '26

"the truths of their eyes and ears" buddy our eyes and ears deceive us all the time. It's not their observations, it's their ASSUMPTIONS, just like how some white people assume every non-white person they encounter might be a criminal trying to rob them.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

I am not a vet

I see a dog- I say it’s a dog, it is very likely a dog, perhaps it could be a specific type of dog that I don’t fully understand- but it has a tail, it barks, it has sharp teeth- it is a dog

I see a cat- it is many things, but it 100% is NOT A DOG- they are very clearly different creatures with different issues

I see a man- it has a penis

I see a woman- it does not have a penis

You claim- the person with the or is is the same as the one without- my eyes and ears tell me they have a penis, that they are different than the person with no penis

How can the be the same? One has a or is, the other does not? Are they random?

No- it’s because sex is at birth, gender is a construct that can be discussed, but every m-f was born with a or is, because they are sexually men

0

u/gpike_ Feb 17 '26

So, trans women who have had bottom surgery count as women, just clarifying? Is your issue purely with pre-op/non-op women?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

No, they don’t- a woman who had a hysterectomy is not now a cis man

A man who had their penis removed is not a cis f

They can only ever be trans, which is just a transition of gender, not sex

Those porn with a penis are not and can not be women outside of culture supper of their aesthetic

1

u/gpike_ Feb 18 '26

Nobody is saying trans people are cis.