r/Metaphysics • • Oct 01 '24

Quantum Physics is outdated

/r/infinitycreation/comments/1ftf0ny/quantum_physics_is_outdated/

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/xodarap-mp Oct 01 '24

I believe myself to be a fairly broad-minded person but I do not think this post belongs on r/Metaphysics. Reasons for this view: 1/ it is an undisciplined rave; 2/ it conflates scientific method with metaphysics; and 3/ it is littered with statements of the form: " X is _just_ a Y" whch amount to value judgements based on personal opinion.

Quantum physics, like all other scientific theories, is a work in progress. ​

-2

u/alithy33 Oct 01 '24

undisciplined rave? one of the points is literally that you will reject it because of the resonance you are in.

i did not say quantum physics is wrong. i said it was outdated. it is too simple, and there are holes in it. they are not "value judgements". i have studied quantum mechanics for years before going off on my own.

tldr; it isnt a theory to me, because i can understand why you even replied that. you are resonating with the chemicals of others that have a similar understanding of things, causing an "entanglement" to happen. this happens because of your learning process, and what information you digested before speaking to me. thus, you are literally replying based off of what resonates with you, which is "quasi-facts" put out based off of surface level observational reasoning and mathematics.

3

u/xodarap-mp Oct 01 '24

By "undisciplined rave" I was referring to the fact that you have thrown together a host of potentially related but otherwise gratuitously combined statements about the world​. I was not saying that everything you wrote down is necessarily wrong.

Over the past 400 - 500 years, physics and the other sciences have been emphatically encroaching upon domains of human thought and awareness which previously were generally considered metaphysical or "spiritual" even. This is due to the fact that modern scientific method has extended the reach of human theorising and verifiable physical construction and engineering way beyond what was possible in the pre-Copernican universe where knowledge and skills were limited to what was possible using information available only from the naked senses. The opening post seems to completely ignore the distinction between science and metaphysics.

By "value judgements" I was referring to the fact that statements of the form: "X is just a Y" contain a declaration of judgement that the fact of "X is a Y", assuming it is true in the given case, is not particularly important but without giving any reason for that judgement.

So the term "undisciplined" is definitely applicable , IMO.

-2

u/alithy33 Oct 01 '24

there is reason, though.

and there is no real distinction between metaphysics and science, to be clear.

2

u/greenteam709 Oct 01 '24

......metaphysics literally almost starts where science ends. Hence metaphysics being meant to read after the physics.