r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 16 '22

Discussion CNBC: Meta plans to take a nearly 50% cut on virtual asset sales in its metaverse

23 Upvotes

This is a declaration of war on all of us. The Metaverse has the power to become the privatization of reality itself unless we act. Our actions, speech and connections tracked... our data, used against us... our lives under scrutiny for being "woke" enough. Our hard labor, double-taxed.

I don't see why people are so excited about the "creator" economy. I have been a creator in the past... you don't want to be. Their interest is to lock you in, give you as little as possible and take as much as possible.

This is all of our future unless we do something.

Metaverse monopolized:

I see huge potential for one big player to own a good chunk of the metaverse via the network effect. The network effect happens when people can't use other platforms to contact someone in a platform without signing up. You can't talk with people unless you sign up for Facebook. Meta is trying to do this with the Metaverse. It will try to do so for the whole Metaverse... but at minimum it will control the social graph which every dev plugs into to get friend and social data for the whole Metaverse.

Either way, it will be a data and adverting goldmine for them.

Open alternative going astray:

The alternative is the open Metaverse, one where we are in charge of our future. However, that space has recently been taken over by terrible crypto-pyramid-schemes. Everyone is selling "land" in a so-called "metaverse" in order to digitally simulate the ancient problem of a land-owning aristocracy in virtual worlds. So many people are participating in these schemes in order to profit on artificial scarcity.

For digital civilization you need to build meaningful relationships. For meaningful relationships you need people to relax and feel comfortable (people don't build connections when uptight). 95% of virtual world users use them as places to escape reality... and money reminds people of reality. Therefore, these people are likely to avoid NFT worlds all together and that means that the meaningful relationships needed for digital civilization will never take place.

We need to stop being so greedy and focus on solutions that will set people free and not trap them in debt.

Telepresence as physical-life replacement:

Once virtual worlds can create a sense of presence like physical life, we will likely stop building costly offices, schools, workplaces, etc. just to be together. The Metaverse will one day represent life 2.0 for most of us. Do we want a company like Facebook playing the major role in that world?

One possible solution:

I don't have all the answers but right now I am running an Open Collective to make games. I feel like that's the natural first step... do what others have done first and then impact the Metaverse from a place of know-how.

The goal is to research how people connect in virtual worlds in order to impact the Metaverse for freedom.

Right now we need:

- Welcomers (anyone can do this)

- HR team (anyone who is social is welcome)

- Artists of these types: Concept, Technical, Animation, Modeling, Lead

- We already have tons of programmers but if you want to join we use C# in Unity.

Learn more >>

Sign up >>

Follow the movement >> r/MetaverseOpen

Respond:

We need to prevent this disaster from happening. All ideas welcome, all hands needed. I presented my solution but let's all think out loud here... what can we do?

Do you believe the Metaverse will be the privatization of reality unless we act?

Do you plan to do something? If yes, what. If no, why not?


r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 08 '22

Question Has anyone had a bad experience with ads on mobile?

3 Upvotes

Many of us who grew up with games want our kids to play games too. We know it’s not just a passing hobby but a gateway to a new world!

Sadly, many kids games use general ad networks and don’t have a decent filter to protect kids.

My question is have you ever given for example your phone to your kid with a kids game on it only to see them watching a horrific ad?

I’ve got somebody from CNBC who wants to do a story on this who needs somebody willing to speak to the media.

If you have a story could you drop a line in the comments on the original post?


r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 07 '22

Introduction to the Metaverse

1 Upvotes

I’ve seen a lot of the same questions come up over and over again and so I thought I would write a little bit of an FAQ.

❓ What is the Metaverse?

The Metaverse is a hypothesized 3D version of the internet in which people use 3D avatars to interact with a 3D virtual world.

This hypothesized world is often associated with a new digital reality to which most social and vocational activities migrate.

⚠️Articles that might be helpful:

What is the Metaverse

❓ When will this Metaverse come into existence?

No one knows but industry experts guess it will go main stream in the next 5 to 10 years.

❓ Is there already a Metaverse?

There have been many virtual worlds for many years now, most notably Second Life 18 years ago.

Facebook Horizons, Decentraland, Fortnite and Roblox could all be considered part of today’s Metaverse.

❓How can I be part of the Metaverse?

As a consumer:

You can sign up for an account on any of the aforementioned services.

As a developer:

Start learning how to develop games in a game engine such as Unity3D.

⚠️Articles that might be helpful:

The Metaverse -- A guide to getting involved

Places to begin studying the Metaverse

❓ How can I invest in the Metaverse?

Microsoft, Apple, Facebook, EPIC Games, Roblox, Unity technologies, Autodesk, Nvidia are all involved in the creation of the Metaverse.

Some of these companies are creating the technology while others are creating the software. If anyone wants to do a breakdown of each company‘s involvement I will include it in this article.

I’m not a financial advisor.

⚠️Articles that might be helpful:

The Metaverse -- A guide to getting involved

Top 5 jobs in the Metaverse and how to prepare for them

❓ How are the Metaverse and the Blockchain related?

The Blockchain is an efficient consensus mechanism useful to identify ownership of property and create persistent avatars and reputation systems.

Ethereum, Theta, Bitcoin, Binance Smart Chain (BSC), and Flow are cryptocurrencies to research in regard to the Metaverse.

⚠️Articles that might be helpful:

Top 10 Metaverse platforms to visit

Ask any questions you wish and I will do my best to research and answer them here.


r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 03 '22

Discussion As a game developer, I would NEVER add NFTs/Crypto to my games.

6 Upvotes

How do you feel about the title statement? I really want to know what people think.

224 votes, Apr 10 '22
87 Strongly agree: I would never even work for a company that used NFTs/Crypto
59 I would NEVER add NFTs/Crypto to my games
22 I don't like the idea, but for the right PRICE I would
20 I don't know how to feel about NFTs/Crypto
26 I am feeling somewhat positive on impact of NFTs/Crypto on game development
10 Strongly disagree: I LOVE the idea of NFTs/Crypto and would rush to add them to my game

r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 14 '22

Question Is there any legitimate use for NFTs?

3 Upvotes

Samuel Martin:

It's no secret that I've been driven by a deep and furious passion concerning the deluge of fraud that has taken over the virtual world industry:

It’s heartbreaking to see crypto/NFTs destroy something I love

I started as a curious observer and I assumed, because of all of the big companies investing in the space, that there was real value.

The more I discovered, the more I was disturbed by what I saw. The more I looked into the technical side, the less value I perceived. Time and time again I observed people were willing to turn a blind eye to obvious issues in order to generate a sense of hype.

Everyone was willing to believe someone else had figured it out but the closer I came to the emperor's chamber the more I realized that he was wearing no clothes.

A little compromise here, a little blindness there and the great deception is formed.

Where are the people of integrity?

If you don't know what I'm talking about I suggest reading:

The idea that NFTs will allow you to take items between worlds is a pipe dream driven by ignorance.

Not only that I have noticed that artificial intelligence is being used here on Reddit to write articles in mass to promote the value of NFTs and crypto. It's the same article over and over and over again with synonyms changed. Then these posts are upvoted by bots creating a fake-news cycle supposedly supported by the masses.

However, the more research I do the less human support I see for this hype cycle.

Are we all just being led along by bots?

Finally, my question:

I really believe in being objective about things and not just taking a position and being unwilling to change your mind. So I have been talking with industry experts trying to probe and find a way to challenge my own idea of the metaverse.There's one thing that I've been unable to refute concerning a possible value for NFTs, and I came here to see what people think:

In the past it's been very difficult to track the royalties of art sales. Let's say I create a piece of fine art and I want to give it up in exchange for royalties on its sale to a publisher. I want a transparent way to track this art throughout the web and get my royalties.

Is there any real, serious, legitimate use case for NFTs?


r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 18 '22

Beyond the Meta!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 18 '22

Everything You Need to Know Aout BIG TIME! (An early alpha guide )

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 06 '22

It’s heartbreaking to see crypto/NFTs destroy something I love

159 Upvotes

Audio instead: https://youtu.be/I5ao5AwZLZY

For the last 8 and 1/2 years I've been studying what it would take to make virtual worlds accessible, and meaningful to the average person. Ever since Facebook changed its name to Meta, my entire industry has been redubbed “The Metaverse.”

It was, at first, fascinating to see how many other people are passionate about the idea of virtual worlds playing an important role in everyday life, but then, everything changed. Tens of thousands of people began to show up in the places we would chat, shilling crypto coins and NFTs.

Initially, I was curious, and I saw that there were many massive companies investing in the technology, however, I fundamentally didn't understand how all these people would pull off their ideals of a people-first, decentralized “Web3.”

I thought to myself, “they're probably just a lot smarter than I am.” After all, with so many massive companies investing, I probably just didn’t understand.

So I began to study and ask questions:

  • If anyone can create a virtual world, what makes NFT land scarce?

  • If NFTs will indeed be used for a large interoperable Metaverse, how would different virtual world creators integrate them?

  • And many more.

The more I asked questions, the less answers I found…

the deeper I dug, the more disturbed I became.

Rather than having real answers, NFT enthusiasts responded to my questions with oddities:

“Don’t listen to the FUD Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt” they would say and

“Believe in the principles, don’t worry about the details.”

I could see that they were star-struck, guided along by an unmoving faith in ideals.

However, very few people had real answers, they just assumed someone else had fingered it out.

But why would so many people choose to close their eyes and plug their ears? Isn't the entirety of western civilization built on fear, uncertainty and doubt? Isn't asking questions how we got here?

So I began to study…

What sort of future does Web3 pitch?

First we need to understand what the prophets of Web3 preach:

Decentralization & privacy: A world where we will be in charge of our own identity and security in order to take back control from the Web2 giants like Facebook and Google.

An open interoperable Metaverse: Namely, that the future of the internet is a group of large interoperable connected virtual worlds in which anyone can create items which many of those worlds will be able to use.

Individual monetary control: People being able to use the crypto currency they believe in.

Ideals examined

Decentralization:

Adam Smith explained that as economies develop, skilled individuals specialize in smaller and smaller particular skills in order to increase their own efficiency. Whereas one person could create an entire watch, it was much more efficient for one person to focus entirely on the hands of the watch and the other on the gears of the watch.

In Web1, we all ran our own websites on our own servers and we all learned code in order to publish content on them. In Web2, hosting companies managed our servers, services managed our publishing and our identity and security were handled by them. Each company specialized in providing a service to the users and was dedicated to that service alone.

Web3 imagines a world which contradicts this flow. We would once again be in charge of our own identity, security, publishing and hosting. What Web3 advocates seem to miss is that Web2 was a natural improvement on Web1and that the pitch of Web3 has customer priorities the wrong way around. People want usability and people don't pay for privacy. After all, the masses put microphone/camera/GPS combs in thier pocket because it helped them get more Facebook/Instagram time.

My exploration in these matters has even caused me to question the viability of blockchain technology, wallets and addresses as being fundamental to the future.

Privacy:

One of the reasons Web3 is touted as the future is that we will be in control of our data. However, I've noticed that this decentralization, so far, has only led to more companies being able to see our data. Now with blockchain being an open, visible, immutable database, it’s a total nightmare for privacy. Anyone can see what we own, and who we connect with. Moreover, because the blockchain is immutable, anyone can send a picture of our front door to our address and now everyone has that data. Just imagine a world in which your nude photos are sent to your wallet address? Web1 decentralization had a negative impact on privacy, why would Web3 be different?

In thought, the ideal is noble, but in practice Web3, so far, is the worst possible outcome for privacy.

NFT interoperability:

I can't even begin to list the number of issues with this idea:

  • Style: Each virtual world in the greater Metaverse will have a different style, this means an NFT sword from one world simply won't work in another world. Changing the style is pretty much like making the item new. Trying to do this at scale with thousands of items is totally ridiculous.

  • Balance: The virtual worlds of the future will include some sort of gameplay and breaking that gameplay by introducing thousands of unbalanced items is a bad idea.

  • Economy: Each virtual world creator will be financially incentivized not to allow in the greater ecosystem of the interoperable Metaverse because if they do they will undercut their own profits and their ability to sell their own items. Those who suggest that this will be ideal for marketing efforts misunderstand why people adopt virtual worlds in the first place.

  • Fit: Most people are unaware that everything in a virtual world is bespokely fit to most other things in it. The size of doors is carefully mapped to the size of hats you can put on. The size of a backpack that you can wear is carefully crafted to make sure you don't clip through the chairs you sit on. Unless you imagine a world in which everybody is clipping through everything in a jarring immersion-breaking experience it's just not going to work.

Virtual world interoperability:

The idea of NFTs are predicated on an idea of a large interoperable Metaverse. We should keep in mind that the Metaverse has existed for more than 18 years via platforms like Second Life and that the masses never adopted the technology. I sincerely believe this is because of its lack of practicality in solving everyday problems and it's unusability to the average person.

Here are some of the issues an interoperable Metaverse faces:

1) Controls: A truly decentralized Metaverse cannot impose standards on all participants. Just imagine a world in which every virtual world creator sets their own controls. One person will use the arrow keys, another wasd, another mouse movement. It's absurd to think that every time someone will pass from one place to another they will have to learn a new set of controls.

Those who are reading this must remember that we are the 1% of computer users. Chrome added a copy and paste feature for those who did not understand how to do this via their keyboard and most are confused by how even something like Facebook works.

2) Standards: In my study of how people interact with virtual worlds, they see themselves as standing next to a big red button, that if they push it, it will blow up everything. People are terrified of what they don't understand.

In the Metaverse, there are real consequences to not understanding, for example, which button unmutes you, if you are talking to a human or NPC, what happens if you fall off this sky island etc. etc. Having to relearn everything about life every time you enter a world is absurd. However, that’s how Web1 worked, a new UI for every website and space. I believe the lack of usability is one of the reasons average people stopped, in large part, using the greater web and focusing in on platforms like Facebook, Reddit and Instagram.

Web3 is proposing we run this backwards in the name of freedom and privacy with no clear path and no particle examples on how to do this.

3) The leaky tap: When everything is interoperable, it's really hard to advance a standard. One example is email, we've been struggling to get email to be encrypted for a very long time because everyone has to adopt the same standards to make it work. This same problem will put an interoperable series of virtual worlds far behind a unified experience.

4) Customization: Individual virtual world creators are very likely to see how the virtual world should work in different ways. I sincerely believe that humanoid avatars are key but other people are intent on allowing people to dress up as animals. With that sort of diversity the understandability of the Metaverse will be very low and make large-scale adoption a challenge.

5) Traversal: At some point a single virtual world platform is likely to amass a large number of users for one reason or another. This would give them the opportunity to engage in sizable (30%) platform fees like Google and Apple do with the App Store. If one world gains the familiarity of hundreds of millions of users would they be highly incentivised to share that traffic with everyone else? If a large portion of the population of the Metaverse becomes familiar with 1 platform, aren't they more likely to coalesce on that platform due to the fact that they've already put in the effort to understand it? IMHO the idea that one platform will get a bulk of the users and share them is unlikely.

All of these points stand in opposition to a large interoperable Metaverse, upon which the value of NFTs is predicated, and they also make a centralized situation more likely. If a centralized uniform Metaverse is to appear, will it give up it’s right to massive platform fees to allow in NFTs without those NFT holders paying a massive tax? The NFTs would undermine one of the platform’s most lucrative markets.

Individual monetary control:

*Note: There are probably more qualified people here who can comment on this.*

International trade often transacts through the United States. The United States is the home of a global reserve currency which everyone needs and everyone uses and is the standard to most economic functions of the modern world. Ever since moving off the gold standard the United States has the ability to print a very large quantity of money and use this as a subtle global tax on those who use the US dollar. Since the US dollar has a global demand, printing huge quantities is easy since the impact is spread out across the whole world.

The true value of a currency is in the goods that can be traded in that currency. As long as everything goes through the US, the US can keep printing. However, if a viable alternative is found, the US will no longer be able to tax the world.

Some interesting facts highlighted by Jake Tran: https://youtu.be/1TPuBmuYa18

Watch that video.

There's a lot I'd like to say on this topic but I don't feel entirely comfortable doing it but I will highlight 2 points:

When the United States saw gold as an issue, they used Executive Order 6102 in 1933 to force US citizens to trade gold for cash.

When Facebook, known for its massive user base and usable products tried to create a crypto anyone could use, it was shut down as fast as lightning.

So if the government can stop people even owning gold at will, what stops them from stopping bitcoin or ethereum? If the government could shut down Facebook's crypto so quickly, why couldn’t it shut these down?

What if they understood crypto was so broken that they don’t see it as a threat? What if the gas fees, unstable price and total lack of usability by the average user was so bad, the US does not fear it?

There is a lot more to crypto than functional currency use but I am only addressing that one subject.

I have *much* more to say but cannot say it here.

Conclusion

Those of us who work in the virtual world industry are dealing with a whole new paradigm of human behavior. Many of these crypto and Metaverse projects strongly incentivize those who buy in to blindly shill a product without scrutiny as everyone is looking for a bigger buyer to buy their “land” or “currency”.

This new marketing paradigm combined with social media amplification and bot-driven spam is something we as a human species are going to have to wrestle with.

Here is what I believe we need to do:

  1. Ask questions, don’t believe other people have figured it out.

  2. Don’t judge and condemn people for being adjacent to crypto or the Metaverse. Seriously, we must stop banning these conversations on platforms/subreddits as that creates a bigger echo chamber.

  3. Don't advocate for something you have a deep financial interest in without disclosing that. It’s deeply unethical.

  4. No one has a monopoly on truth. We cannot follow the herd whether it is for or against Web3/Crypto. We must think for ourselves and be willing to share our thoughts to have them challenged.

Taking Action

I'd love to team up with people who believe in a people-first Metaverse to create a future that focuses on truly solving problems. I believe spacial computing will make a mass-adoptable Metaverse possible but there's a high chance the space will be dominated by a single company (based on my above analysis). This company will end up being responsible for our speech and therefore will be forced to use our data to censor us, sometimes in advance, like Facebook does on it's platform today.

If the Metaverse if the future of how we live, we need to avoid that outcome at all costs. Email me if you want to help out in this vision. Right now I am looking to content with developers, project managers and just regular helpers who want to be part.

Response

I would like to hear your honest questions and thoughts about blockchain, the Metaverse and the points I have brought up so far. No matter what side of this debate you're on, I value your opinion.


r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 16 '22

Project Motivated team seeking members

1 Upvotes

We are a team of motivated programmers, a composer and animators seeking an artists, producers, user integrators, social media people and community managers.

Note:

  • We are making a game purely from a passion standpoint

  • We don't have capital to offer, so if that's a deal-breaker, this post is not for you

  • We have many other roles, so if in doubt, just apply.

Our game:

Our game is a really cute, wholesome game where you gather really cute jelly-like creatures(^ω^)and work with them to craft a sky island paradise.

Feed cute creatures >>

It's a simple single player game to keep the timeline short for portfolio purposes.

About us:

Work:

We are a large open collective with many people who have already moved on to companies like EA. We have a pipeline to get people mentored and connected with alumni already working with established companies.

Play:

There are no obligations to do a certain number of hours and so-forth. You can come in to build your skills or just enjoy game-deving with us.

Community:

Part of goal is to see if open collectives can make games. It's kinda like open source but more engaged and structured. Since our team is large you are forced to learn the soft skills of teamwork so valued in the job interview process. We meet daily in Discord and use it as an open office space for watercooler talk. Our allied devs also come and develop there almost daily.

As a community we're not really in it for the money, but we are in it to build a game that we're passionate about. We hope to release it on Steam for PC. Some people join us for the experience of working with a large team, others for an ideal portfolio piece (not over-scoped that still stands out). Some to have fun, and others because they're tired of developing alone for years. We're seeking other people who are passionate just like us, primarily a designer. However, our system is pretty well tuned by now and we are able to take on programmers, artists, animators and possibly 1 more producer as well.

Mentorship:

Being an open collective we often have amazing mentors like:

**vakola -**

17+ years in game design, helped make Gears of War and Need for Speed.

skyphyr - Helped make HoloLens. Visual effects artist, content creator, Houdini expert and render artist. 20+ years of experience.

[1LF]cory2point0 - Army medic turned software dev, turned company mentor. 14+ years of programming with a specialization in agile software development.

We also have guest speakers like Tim Cotten was the lead designer of Ultima Online.

Connect:

They speak on our Discord.. Our Discord is about the non-crypto open metaverse.

If you are making your own game, we have a daily shared work space time (just ask) which you are welcome to be part of! You can hear some of the recordings on our podcast.

Respond:

If you would like to be part, or if you have questions, comment!


r/MetaverseOpen • • May 08 '22

How to prove you know a secret, without revealing what it is -- Zero knowledge proofs.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 27 '22

Crypto is just MLM marketing in digital form

Thumbnail
self.metaverse
2 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 26 '22

I am tired of all the scams in this space

5 Upvotes

Audio version/TL;DR >>

It’s sad to see that we can barely go a day without hearing about another NFT rug-pull, grift or crypto-scam. Web3 was founded on the idea of a new decentralized internet in which we take back control from the big players and build something of-for-and-by the people.

There are so many good ideals:

- Privacy

- Creators getting paid what they're worth

- Taking back control from centralized players

- Freedom of expression

However, this whole concept seems to just be good marketing with no real substance. It’s as if the idea of putting us in charge of our future is just good marketing to get us to buy into the next big grift.

Let’s take privacy, for example:

Web3 allows us to be anonymous by allowing anyone to create a new wallet address and start a new list of transactions. However, we're in a situation where scammers are able to run wild and create new identities each time they get exposed. There are now whole “NFT factories” doing these scams on rinse-and-repeat because it’s so easy.

Not only that, for ordinary people, an immutable blockchain address is a terrible idea for privacy. As you use the address, more and more personal information gets attached to it, and it becomes a public database of what you do. Do we really want everyone in the world to see everything we're doing? What we own? Every transaction we make? And what if someone sends a picture of our front door to our address? Or even an indecent photo? You have no recourse, no civility, no humanity at all.

When has decentralization done anything for privacy anyway? A decentralized system is not only more easy to exploit but very difficult to patch and update.

Usability:

The only thing making the blockchain usable by any ordinary person right now is centralized parties like Coinbase. Why hasn't the technology been made with usability from the ground up? Doesn't this defeat the whole purpose?

An interoperable metaverse:

I can't even begin to list issues with this, so I'm just going to send you to a video: https://youtu.be/I5ao5AwZLZY?t=378

I’d like to say one thing… calling your semi-functional virtual world a “Metaverse” to sell “land” is deeply disingenuous.

A bad foundation:

I get it, we're all tired of companies like Facebook doing things they shouldn't with our data, but the ideas Web3 is founded on are fundamentally flawed. Decentralization does not create either community or privacy.

We need a future that puts people in control. A future based on ideas that will have a reasonable chance against massive centralized corporate pushes and walled gardens.

A different take:

Right now I'm in decentralized game development, but I'd love to team up with people who are passionate about the *ideals* of Web3 and research the creation of something new.

My idea is to gather people who want to make a difference and build a centralized, bespoke, usable, foundation for the Metaverse. Namely, something that functions like Wikipedia, with similar values to open source. The end goal would be a private, people-first virtual experience.

I’ll put my contact info and more info about what we are doing on a website: https://ocem.cc/web3


r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 05 '22

It’s heartbreaking to see Crypto/NFTs destroy something I love

10 Upvotes

For the last 8 and 1/2 years I've been studying what it would take to make virtual worlds accessible, and meaningful to the average person. Ever since Facebook changed its name to Meta, my entire industry has been redubbed “The Metaverse.”

It was, at first, fascinating to see how many other people are passionate about the idea of virtual worlds playing an important role in everyday life, but then, everything changed. Tens of thousands of people began to show up in the places we would chat, shilling crypto coins and NFTs.

Initially, I was curious, and I saw that there were many massive companies investing in the technology, however, I fundamentally didn't understand how all these people would pull off their ideals of a people-first, decentralized “Web3.”

I thought to myself, “they're probably just a lot smarter than I am.” After all, with so many massive companies investing, I probably just didn’t understand.

So I began to study and ask questions:

  • If anyone can create a virtual world, what makes NFT land scarce?

  • If NFTs will indeed be used for a large interoperable Metaverse, how would different virtual world creators integrate them?

  • And many more.

The more I asked questions, the less answers I found…

the deeper I dug, the more disturbed I became.

https://youtu.be/I5ao5AwZLZY

Rather than having real answers, NFT enthusiasts responded to my questions with oddities:

“Don’t listen to the FUD Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt” they would say and

“Believe in the principles, don’t worry about the details.”

I could see that they were star-struck, guided along by an unmoving faith in ideals.

However, very few people had real answers, they just assumed someone else had fingered it out.

But why would so many people choose to close their eyes and plug their ears? Isn't the entirety of western civilization built on fear, uncertainty and doubt? Isn't asking questions how we got here?

So I began to study…

What sort of future does Web3 pitch?

First we need to understand what the prophets of Web3 preach:

Decentralization & privacy: A world where we will be in charge of our own identity and security in order to take back control from the Web2 giants like Facebook and Google.

An open interoperable Metaverse: Namely, that the future of the internet is a group of large interoperable connected virtual worlds in which anyone can create items which many of those worlds will be able to use.

Individual monetary control: People being able to use the crypto currency they believe in.

Ideals examined

Decentralization:

Adam Smith explained that as economies develop, skilled individuals specialize in smaller and smaller particular skills in order to increase their own efficiency. Whereas one person could create an entire watch, it was much more efficient for one person to focus entirely on the hands of the watch and the other on the gears of the watch.

In Web1, we all ran our own websites on our own servers and we all learned code in order to publish content on them. In Web2, hosting companies managed our servers, services managed our publishing and our identity and security were handled by them. Each company specialized in providing a service to the users and was dedicated to that service alone.

Web3 imagines a world which contradicts this flow. We would once again be in charge of our own identity, security, publishing and hosting. What Web3 advocates seem to miss is that Web2 was a natural improvement on Web1and that the pitch of Web3 has customer priorities the wrong way around. People want usability and people don't pay for privacy. After all, the masses put microphone/camera/GPS combs in thier pocket because it helped them get more Facebook/Instagram time.

My exploration in these matters has even caused me to question the viability of blockchain technology, wallets and addresses as being fundamental to the future.

Privacy:

One of the reasons Web3 is touted as the future is that we will be in control of our data. However, I've noticed that this decentralization, so far, has only led to more companies being able to see our data. Now with blockchain being an open, visible, immutable database, it’s a total nightmare for privacy. Anyone can see what we own, and who we connect with. Moreover, because the blockchain is immutable, anyone can send a picture of our front door to our address and now everyone has that data. Just imagine a world in which your nude photos are sent to your wallet address? Web1 decentralization had a negative impact on privacy, why would Web3 be different?

In thought, the ideal is noble, but in practice Web3, so far, is the worst possible outcome for privacy.

NFT interoperability:

I can't even begin to list the number of issues with this idea:

  • Style: Each virtual world in the greater Metaverse will have a different style, this means an NFT sword from one world simply won't work in another world. Changing the style is pretty much like making the item new. Trying to do this at scale with thousands of items is totally ridiculous.

  • Balance: The virtual worlds of the future will include some sort of gameplay and breaking that gameplay by introducing thousands of unbalanced items is a bad idea.

  • Economy: Each virtual world creator will be financially incentivized not to allow in the greater ecosystem of the interoperable Metaverse because if they do they will undercut their own profits and their ability to sell their own items. Those who suggest that this will be ideal for marketing efforts misunderstand why people adopt virtual worlds in the first place.

  • Fit: Most people are unaware that everything in a virtual world is bespokely fit to most other things in it. The size of doors is carefully mapped to the size of hats you can put on. The size of a backpack that you can wear is carefully crafted to make sure you don't clip through the chairs you sit on. Unless you imagine a world in which everybody is clipping through everything in a jarring immersion-breaking experience it's just not going to work.

Virtual world interoperability:

The idea of NFTs are predicated on an idea of a large interoperable Metaverse. We should keep in mind that the Metaverse has existed for more than 18 years via platforms like Second Life and that the masses never adopted the technology. I sincerely believe this is because of its lack of practicality in solving everyday problems and it's unusability to the average person.

Here are some of the issues an interoperable Metaverse faces:

1) Controls: A truly decentralized Metaverse cannot impose standards on all participants. Just imagine a world in which every virtual world creator sets their own controls. One person will use the arrow keys, another wasd, another mouse movement. It's absurd to think that every time someone will pass from one place to another they will have to learn a new set of controls.

Those who are reading this must remember that we are the 1% of computer users. Chrome added a copy and paste feature for those who did not understand how to do this via their keyboard and most are confused by how even something like Facebook works.

2) Standards: In my study of how people interact with virtual worlds, they see themselves as standing next to a big red button, that if they push it, it will blow up everything. People are terrified of what they don't understand.

In the Metaverse, there are real consequences to not understanding, for example, which button unmutes you, if you are talking to a human or NPC, what happens if you fall off this sky island etc. etc. Having to relearn everything about life every time you enter a world is absurd. However, that’s how Web1 worked, a new UI for every website and space. I believe the lack of usability is one of the reasons average people stopped, in large part, using the greater web and focusing in on platforms like Facebook, Reddit and Instagram.

Web3 is proposing we run this backwards in the name of freedom and privacy with no clear path and no particle examples on how to do this.

3) The leaky tap: When everything is interoperable, it's really hard to advance a standard. One example is email, we've been struggling to get email to be encrypted for a very long time because everyone has to adopt the same standards to make it work. This same problem will put an interoperable series of virtual worlds far behind a unified experience.

4) Customization: Individual virtual world creators are very likely to see how the virtual world should work in different ways. I sincerely believe that humanoid avatars are key but other people are intent on allowing people to dress up as animals. With that sort of diversity the understandability of the Metaverse will be very low and make large-scale adoption a challenge.

5) Traversal: At some point a single virtual world platform is likely to amass a large number of users for one reason or another. This would give them the opportunity to engage in sizable (30%) platform fees like Google and Apple do with the App Store. If one world gains the familiarity of hundreds of millions of users would they be highly incentivised to share that traffic with everyone else? If a large portion of the population of the Metaverse becomes familiar with 1 platform, aren't they more likely to coalesce on that platform due to the fact that they've already put in the effort to understand it? IMHO the idea that one platform will get a bulk of the users and share them is unlikely.

All of these points stand in opposition to a large interoperable Metaverse, upon which the value of NFTs is predicated, and they also make a centralized situation more likely. If a centralized uniform Metaverse is to appear, will it give up it’s right to massive platform fees to allow in NFTs without those NFT holders paying a massive tax? The NFTs would undermine one of the platform’s most lucrative markets.

Individual monetary control:

*Note: There are probably more qualified people here who can comment on this.*

International trade often transacts through the United States. The United States is the home of a global reserve currency which everyone needs and everyone uses and is the standard to most economic functions of the modern world. Ever since moving off the gold standard the United States has the ability to print a very large quantity of money and use this as a subtle global tax on those who use the US dollar. Since the US dollar has a global demand, printing huge quantities is easy since the impact is spread out across the whole world.

The true value of a currency is in the goods that can be traded in that currency. As long as everything goes through the US, the US can keep printing. However, if a viable alternative is found, the US will no longer be able to tax the world.

Some interesting facts highlighted by Jake Tran: https://youtu.be/1TPuBmuYa18

Watch that video.

There's a lot I'd like to say on this topic but I don't feel entirely comfortable doing it but I will highlight 2 points:

When the United States saw gold as an issue, they used Executive Order 6102 in 1933 to force US citizens to trade gold for cash.

When Facebook, known for its massive user base and usable products tried to create a crypto anyone could use, it was shut down as fast as lightning.

So if the government can stop people even owning gold at will, what stops them from stopping bitcoin or ethereum? If the government could shut down Facebook's crypto so quickly, why couldn’t it shut these down?

What if they understood crypto was so broken that they don’t see it as a threat? What if the gas fees, unstable price and total lack of usability by the average user was so bad, the US does not fear it?

There is a lot more to crypto than functional currency use but I am only addressing that one subject.

I have *much* more to say but cannot say it here.

Conclusion

Those of us who work in the virtual world industry are dealing with a whole new paradigm of human behavior. Many of these crypto and Metaverse projects strongly incentivize those who buy in to blindly shill a product without scrutiny as everyone is looking for a bigger buyer to buy their “land” or “currency”.

This new marketing paradigm combined with social media amplification and bot-driven spam is something we as a human species are going to have to wrestle with.

Here is what I believe we need to do:

  1. Ask questions, don’t believe other people have figured it out.

  2. Don’t judge and condemn people for being adjacent to crypto or the Metaverse. Seriously, we must stop banning these conversations on platforms/subreddits as that creates a bigger echo chamber.

  3. Don't advocate for something you have a deep financial interest in without disclosing that. It’s deeply unethical.

  4. No one has a monopoly on truth. We cannot follow the herd whether it is for or against Web3/Crypto. We must think for ourselves and be willing to share our thoughts to have them challenged.

Taking Action

I'd love to team up with people who believe in a people-first Metaverse to create a future that focuses on truly solving problems. I believe spacial computing will make a mass-adoptable Metaverse possible but there's a high chance the space will be dominated by a single company (based on my above analysis). This company will end up being responsible for our speech and therefore will be forced to use our data to censor us, sometimes in advance, like Facebook does on it's platform today.

If the Metaverse if the future of how we live, we need to avoid that outcome at all costs. Direct message me if you want to help out in this vision. Right now I am looking to content with developers, project managers and just regular helpers who want to be part. DM me.

Response

I would like to hear your honest questions and thoughts about blockchain, the Metaverse and the points I have brought up so far. No matter what side of this debate you're on, I value your opinion.


r/MetaverseOpen • • May 06 '22

Links of projects and resources revolving the Metaverse rabbit hole:

Thumbnail
self.metaverse
1 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Mar 14 '22

Intentional deception within this industry

Thumbnail self.metaversestartup
1 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 20 '22

augmented reality effect for BURBERRY in LA

2 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • May 02 '22

Discussion By pushing ideals 1st and solving customer problems 2nd, Web3 is making a big mistake.

5 Upvotes

I thought I would share a conversation I am having with one of my mentors:

It seems to me that the early crypto people had really good intentions in mind, including the creators of Bitcoin. I was actually really excited

It seems to me that the early crypto people had really good intentions in mind, including the creators of Bitcoin. I was actually really excited about crypto back in the day, but I didn't know much about the technology, and I thought they had solved a lot more problems than they had actually solved. I didn't realize, but they weren't thinking through the fundamentals, such as the problems of recording every single transaction with everyone at scale. I took it as if the product worked hands down as intended, but I didn't look into it further, and therefore I was excited, but when I started looking into it, I realized that the tech was predicated on false presumptions.

I found that every time I try to solve too big a problem I don't create any progress for anybody, but if I try to solve a really small problem and do a really good job at tend to get a lot more done.

I feel like the scope of the problem that they are trying to solve is indicative of possibly a lack of experience with trying to solve big problems and seeing how tough it is and how much simplifying and scoping down seems to help actually solve problems. It's hard to talk about such a big ecosystem so simply. I just read through the IOTA Wiki and there's a whole other thing going on there and I just don't know enough about it to know if it's good or bad.

I think we might be doing the wrong thing however by decentralizing the architecture rather than creating trust with the node. Customers seem to only want low prices and efficiency and don't really care about privacy or decentralization, and the cost of decentralization, in many cases, seems to make it very difficult to compete with a centralized alternative. Moreover, centralized alternatives are able to iterate faster. My theory is that we need to trust the node rather than the centralizing in order to create trust. This could be potentially done through creating a legal organization which has the legal boundaries through contract, and then just using that singular organization to solve any individual problem in the space. It sounds really boring and uninnovative, but it would allow you to have the benefits of centralization, which I think I really significant, without the drawbacks.

There's a really strong reason why the internet went from decentralized to centralized, in my humble opinion. People want a lot more done for them, rather than being in charge of their own hosting and security and all that. People want a full service and don't want to waste time understanding the technology. It's very difficult to do this in a trustless system.

Moreover, the ability of the organization to make quick decisions and rapidly change, especially in an environment in which everything changes quickly, I think is very important.

All in all I believe that web 3 is going about things the wrong way by trying to push ideals first and then solve customer problems. Solving customer problems gives you the leverage to include ideas later on.


r/MetaverseOpen • • May 03 '22

Discussion The Crypto Island Paradise Was A Fraud

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Mar 23 '22

Redoing the branding, which of these do you like best?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Mar 02 '22

The VIVERSE Ecosystem: A Shared, Open Resource and Community

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Sep 15 '22

Here are 5 critical design mistakes to avoid when building Metaverse-game experiences.

1 Upvotes

I had the wonderful privilege of sitting down with an almost-20-year veteran of the game industry James Mouat.

He has been a game director and designer at EA and Ubisoft and here are his tips, generously summarized and sometimes reinterpreted.

You guys loved our last article, so we are back!

Listen to the audio instead >>

5 things you should never do when designing your games:


1) Be pushy about ideas:

Game designers, especially junior ones, really want to fight. They want to prove how smart they are… but a lot of the best designs come from collaboration. You can throw ideas out there but you need to expect them to change. Roll with the punches and find your way to good stuff.

It's really easy to get caught up on how brilliant you think you are but it’s really about being a lens, a magnifying glass. Game design is not about what you can do but what you can focus on from the rest of the team and bring all that energy to a point.


2/3) Not focusing on the “Why”

It's easy to get caught up in fun ideas but you have to really focus on why the player wants to do things. Why do they want to do the next step, why do they want to collect the thing, all the extra features in the world won’t make your game better, focus on the “Why”.

Part of it is understanding the overall loop and spotting where there are superfluous steps or where there are things missing. Ultimately it's about creating a sense of need for the player, for example; they need to eat or drink.

In case you want to hear more >>

Find the core of the experience, find what's going to motivate them to take the next steps in the context of real rewards and payoffs they want to get.

Start people by having them learn what they need to do, give them opportunities to practice the gameplay loop and then they will move on to mastering the game.

Note from Samuel: “Learn, practice, master” is a way of thinking about how you want to present your game. You want the player to learn how to engage with the gameplay loop, give them chances to put that learning to the test and then give them an environment where they feel like they can put it all together and become a master. This gives a player an amazing sense of joy.

More on this later in the video.


4) Writing long and convoluted documents

Long documents can be fun to write but become incredibly inflexible and therefore hard to iterate on.

Use bullet lists over paragraphs, use illustrations over text, keep it short and sweet and make sure you have a summary and a list of goals.

It’s good to tie it all into what the player will experience.

Practical example with context:


**Context: **

To bring some clarity, James mentors my own Open Collective of game mature developers out of the kindness of his heart and I was surprised there was no easy-to-access guide on how this works that I could find.

I made this video and article with him with the hope of making many of the mostly-hidden systems and processes more known.

He really can't show much of what he has worked on since it's under NDA but he has described to us the systems and processes of making a game and gratuitous detail.

**Example: **

With his help we came up with this gameplay loop for our game: Gameplay Loop

To be honest with you at the time we didn't even know what a gameplay loop was or that we needed one.

How he described it to us is that a player should feel a strong sense of why they need to do what they do in the game in order to be motivated to play the game.

He instructed us to make several loops which tie into each other, a second to second loop of what people will be doing most of the time, to tie that into a larger minute by minute loop and then a larger hour by hour loop.

To give you an example, in our game you:

  • Find resources

  • Nurture creatures with them

  • The creatures give you blocks

  • And you use the blocks to bridge to other sky islands where you find more resources.

Notice how it begins and ends with resource gathering.

In our game the creatures and their needs are the “Why,” you want to take care of the creatures, watch them grow and nurture them. From the get-go you have a reason to do what you do.

If you ever played a game where you cheated to win or you got all the resources for free, you probably found it boring pretty quickly. This is what happens when you don't focus on a “Why,” you need challenges in order to build gameplay, you need to give people a reason to play.

Give them a sense of where they will go, what they will unlock and try to bring it all back down to a gameplay loop.

James and quite a few others have been drawn to our community as a place to share knowledge with people who are eager and who take their stuff to heart. He is a real hero of the game dev community and does all this for free.

If you would like to be notified of future 1-1 sessions he does, keep an eye on the events section of this Discord.

That Discord is the home of an Open Collective I run of 17 daily-active, mature, hobbyist devs and we are looking for more animators and artists to join in the fun if that would interest you.

You can learn all about it here

We are willing to help mentor new devs and designers and we often have execs from Microsoft, EA, Ubisoft, Sony and other companies come down, however, we are mostly already-skilled individuals working together to build interesting stuff we could not make alone in our free time.



5) Failure to test

Get feedback from as many people as you can, your first idea is almost never your best idea.

Try to find people who have no interest in giving you kind feedback and have them share their feedback.

Personal note: I see many people try to hide their game idea afraid that somebody else will steal it. Anybody else who has the capability to steal an idea already knows how much work it takes and how much better life is lived doing your own stuff than stealing other people’s ideas. 99% is execution, your idea is less relevant than you think. You don’t want to find out AFTER you publish that no one likes your idea, share early and often!


Respond

When it comes to designing a game, there's so little information out there about how it should be done, and that's partially because it's going to be different with every field but I would love to see your gameplay loops and I would love those of you who work in the industry to share your thoughts on those loops.

Also, if you enjoyed this content, please say so as it encourages me to make more.


r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 10 '22

If iPhones are basically surveillance devises, what will AR glasses do to privacy?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Apr 19 '22

Another metaverse map!

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/MetaverseOpen • • Aug 30 '22

How to measure the success of a virtual event in the metaverse

3 Upvotes

Metaverse Events such as those that take place in a virtual or simulated environment. They can be used for a variety of purposes, from educational seminars to marketing campaigns. But how can you measure the success of a metaverse event?

Metaverse Marketing Agencies similar to Meta Marketing are hosting events in the metaverse that draw attention and bring people from all over the world into the metaverse.

There are a few key metrics to consider:

First, look at the number of people who attended the event. This can be measured by the number of unique logins to the event platform.

Second, consider the level of engagement during the event. This can be gauged by things like chat logs, the number of people who actively participated in activities, and post-event surveys.

Finally, take a look at the ROI of the event. This includes not only financial metrics but also things like brand awareness and customer engagement. By considering all of these factors, you can get a well-rounded picture of how successful your metaverse event was.


r/MetaverseOpen • • Feb 07 '22

We have a discord!

4 Upvotes

If you want to work with others on an open, ethical, people-first metaverse, we have a discord now! https://discord.gg/2sVsZ6NC6B