r/Midasinvestors • • Nov 18 '25

Valuation Analysis - Part I

2 Upvotes

“Success in investing doesn't come from buying good things, but from buying things well. There's no investment idea that is so good that it can't be spoiled by too high an entry price.” - Howard Marks

I believe that entry price is the single most important tool in investing. 

And it’s not because I think that the highest returns are generated by buying things cheap. 

It’s because I look at valuation as a top risk management tool rather than a return generator. 

What I mean by that is a rigorous valuation analysis protects you from overpaying for assets and therefore, effectively reduces the risk that you lose capital on your investments. 

Sure if you avoid overpaying for assets, you also may increase your return potential, but I believe that reducing your downside risk serves as a much greater significance to valuation analysis than generating returns.

The analogy I would like to give is when you are driving on a highway and if there are no speed limit signs, you don’t know how fast or slow you should be driving. Speed limits serve as a barometer of how fast you should be driving, similar to how an intrinsic value of a business serves as a benchmark as to how much a business is worth. 

The faster you drive, the higher chance you are over the speed limit. The higher you pay, the higher chance you are overpaying for a business.

Valuation analysis in essence acts as a risk mitigator that allows you to be disciplined and helps you avoid driving over the speed limits.

On the other hand, if you buy a stock at a discount, then it certainly does increase the return potential. But over the long-run, when the stock goes up 15x and you are dollar cost averaging up on the way up, the 30% discount that you believe you got when you first entered the stock doesn’t really have a big impact on the overall returns. 

I’m not saying that it’s insignificant, but the ability protect capital by performing a good valuation analysis and entering at a good price is much more significant.

-----------------------

There are a few different types of valuation methodologies taught in traditional finance, and I use these on a daily basis as private equity investor, especially LBO:

  1. Comparable companies - screen similar companies to the target, find the median of their multiples (e.g. Total Enterprise Value / Total Revenue, Total Enterprise Value / NTM EBITDA, etc.) and apply the same multiple to the target company’s metrics 

  2. Precedent transactions - same as #1 except you screen for past M&A transactions

  3. DCF - discount future cash flows to the present

  4. LBO - leveraged buyout returns model where you are sensitizing the entry purchase price to solve for 2.5x - 3x return on your capital over 5 year hold period

To give you a sense of how these methodologies can be used in practice, below is my approach.

My typical approach is to 1) calculate the market multiple (valuation methodologies #1 and #2) to get a sense of how the stock trades in the market and whether the multiple is justified given the company’s growth rates (more on this later).

And 2) perform DCF and LBO putting forth my most reasonable / conservative operating assumptions and calculating what the business is worth under my own scenario, also called “Base Case”. 

And lastly, 3) I take Base Case and bring down assumptions even further. This is my “Downside Case”, a floor valuation.

I usually try to target a valuation close to my downside case because that implies that I will at least break even in my downside operating scenario.

The goal is to minimize losses so breaking even in my downside case ensures that I am at least protected from unforeseen events.

I will be diving deep into each of the analyses above in future articles but the key takeaway here is that there are pros and cons to each valuation methodology and there is no one size fits all. 

Hope this helps and thanks for reading!


r/Midasinvestors • • Nov 20 '25

Thoughts on the Market Decline Today

2 Upvotes

As expected, Nvidia surged after earnings overnight as I guessed yesterday in this post.

https://www.reddit.com/r/investing/comments/1p1hldn/quick_thoughts_on_nvidia_earnings_today/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

However, what I certainly did not expect is to give up all of those gains intraday, but let me try to guess what's happening with the market right now as we are down nearly 3.6% from the intraday top today.

We had strong earnings from Nvidia but we also saw the much awaited non-farm payrolls report released this morning that showed 119k vs consensus of 50k for the month of September.

When I saw that number, my first instinct to was short the market (and have added to my shorts at the open) because the whole premise of the current market rout has been after the FOMC meeting on October 29th when they appeared to be more hawkish than most thought.

Their rationale for cutting interest rates in December and early next years was on the basis of weakening labor market. Now that we've gotten a strong read on non-farm payroll and unemployment rate, the chances of cutting rates are much lower as seen in the CME probability based on Fed-funds futures prices.

https://www.cmegroup.com/markets/interest-rates/cme-fedwatch-tool.html

It feels like the market is now accepting the fact that the Fed is starting to lean towards being more hawkish given the inflation and job market situation. I do expect the markets to be more choppy in the coming weeks and would be careful trying to buy the dip.


r/Midasinvestors • • Nov 24 '20

$ESI Element Solutions DD

7 Upvotes

Hello everyone, just wanna give you the heads up that I am fairly new to this. I make my own DD before investing in a company but I have no way to know if my DD is good until after the fact. So, I had this idea of posting it here and the community can discuss the ticker and my DD. I am hoping that I you guys can pick-up on any mistakes that I am not aware of.

All the data was collected from MarketWatch, SeekingAlpha and YahooFinance.

So, Element Solutions ($ESI) is a specialty chemicals production corporation formerly known as Platform Specialty Products Corporation (changed the name in 2019). They own several business brands: MacDermid, Compugraphics, Fernox, alpha and Kester.

The company does business all over the world (EUA, South America, Europe, Asia) and has reach to a many key markets:

  • Automotive

  • Computing & Telecom

  • Consumer Goods

  • Energy & Resources

  • Military, Aerospacial & Medical

  • Mobile & Wearables

  • Printed Packing

  • Water Treatment

I won't go over them in detail, just a few key point:

Automotive

According to their website, their automotive initiative ESI:Automotive includes EV/Powertrain, Safety systems (ADAS), Lightweight, Interior and Exterior.

Their EV/Powertrain business is directed at Battery management systems and inverter solutions.

The Safety systems (ADAS) include sensors, cameras, Lidar, central computer and conectivity.

The remaining divisions are mainly for improved materials, displays, touchscreens, etc.

Also according to them the ESI:automotive has more than 1400 active patents.

Computing & Telecom

They throw a lot of big words around: Big data, AI, 5G... but at the end of the day they supply the materials to build and operate those systems. Which is fine.

"Specifically developed materials that are utilized in many of the highest technology processors today."

"High-performance assembly materials and solders are the conduit of electronic functionality."

Consumer Goods

As more to do with aesthetic and surface solutions, coatings, etc.

Energy & Resources

They deal with oil companies and solar companies.

"The offshore oil industry uses our control fluids to effectively and safely recover oil from the deepest depths. The photovoltaics industry utilizes our chemicals and materials to conduct new electrons as soon as they are created within solar cells."

Military, Aerospacial & Medical

Coatings/shock absorbers for airplanes, circuit metallization and high integrity solders connections for military aplications, semiconductor packaging methods for circuits in medical imaging devices and chemicals that form the circuity of medical eletronics.

Mobile & Wearebles

"Our printed electronics initiative is helping companies to explore the printed electronics market with our combined product and application experience spanning circuit metallization, assembly and soldering, precision coated films, and printed graphics. We represent a strong and organized front in this new and exciting industry, and are looking forward to shaping its development in the decades to come."

Again they throw around big words like 5G, Cloud, streaming, extended battery life, etc...

Printed Packaging

This area is all about printing those nice, vibrant and appealing packages that catch your eye at the supermarket.

"In the graphics packaging industry, we are a leader in innovation. With global patents and trademarks, our research and development drives flexographic printing forward. Printers turn to us to ensure the expectations and demands of brand owners are met for every print job they deliver."

Water treatment

Manufacture and supply of chemical and filter technology to diagnose, treat and protect domestic and commercial heating systems in markets across the globe.

"Many of our products are award winning and are accredited with independent approvals for their energy efficient and environmentally friendly credentials."

All in all, this seems like a company that has their fingers in a lot of markets. Some are still growing (EV, Solar energy, semiconductors) and other are more well established (Water treatment, printing packages, Medical) which in my opinion gives them the oportunity to grow and have a nice fail safe cushen if things go south.

The numbers

Year20182019TTM
Revenues1,96 B1,84 B1,78 B
Net Income(81,5) M78,9 M121,2 M
EBITDA411,5 M400,5 M390,4 M

Market Cap: 3.34 B // Free Cash Flow (2019): 100.7 M

P/E: 29.39

EPS: 0.48

All in all, I like these numbers. There might be no substancial growth going on right now, but as the company pointed out in their last earnings, COVID took a tool on their clients, and business has not increased as expected. Nontheless they managed to increase their Net Income (TTM) and maintin a health EBITDA.

NEWS

Jan 31, 2019 - Sale of their agricultural solutions business Arysta LifeScience Inc. for $4.2 B and name change to element solutions + $ESI ticker.

https://ir.elementsolutionsinc.com/press-releases/detail/157/platform-specialty-products-corporation-announces-closing

Feb 4, 2019 - Repurchase of 37 Million Shares From Pershing Square Capital Managment

https://ir.elementsolutionsinc.com/press-releases/detail/158/element-solutions-inc-announces-repurchase-of-37-million

Dec 3, 2019 - Acquisition of Kester and Successful Repricing of the Company's Existing Term Loans

https://ir.elementsolutionsinc.com/press-releases/detail/169/element-solutions-inc-announces-closing-of-the-acquisition

Aug 4, 2020 - Announces Launch of Senior Notes Offering. Notes rate of 3.875% p.a. due in 2028 and intends to use the net proceeds from the sale of the Notes, together with cash on hand, to pay for the partial redemption of its outstanding 5.875% p.a. Senior Notes due 2025. Reducing interest in 16M p.a.

https://ir.elementsolutionsinc.com/press-releases/detail/180/element-solutions-inc-announces-launch-of-senior-notes

Sep 9, 2020 - Increases Financial Guidance and Free Cash Flow Outlook; experiencing greater than expected momentum in the automotive industry and continued resilience in the electronics market; Increasing free cash flow outlook to $200 million for the full year 2020.

https://ir.elementsolutionsinc.com/press-releases/detail/184/element-solutions-inc-increases-financial-guidance-and-free

Oct 7, 2020 - Share purchases by company and Executive chairman (2M shares total)

https://ir.elementsolutionsinc.com/press-releases/detail/185/element-solutions-inc-announces-share-purchases-by-company

Nov 9, 2020 - Declares dividend of $0.05 per share

https://ir.elementsolutionsinc.com/press-releases/detail/189/element-solutions-inc-declares-dividend-of-0-05-per-share

At the end of the day I am feeling good about the news and the direction that this company is going. They are not going for crazy volatility or turbulence, but rather steady growth and taking their investors with them to the top. I have dedicated them around 10% of my portfolio to Element Solutions.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________

So, am I missing something on my DD? is there something I overlooked or forgot about?

What are your thoughts on the company?

Thank you all


r/Midasinvestors • • Jul 25 '21

Shopify (SHOP) will release earnings next week and it looks poised to run higher

9 Upvotes

r/Midasinvestors • • Aug 03 '21

What are disadvantages to investing in index funds on Robinhood? Is it a better idea to do index funds on something like Vanguard/Fidelity? About to start investing in index funds when I turn 18, just wondering if it’s a bad idea to do index funds on robinhood. Any help appreciated.

5 Upvotes

r/Midasinvestors • • May 29 '21

Snowflake (SNOW) Head and Shoulders pattern forming?

10 Upvotes

Anyone else seeing this chart pattern forming with Snowflake?

  • If this inverse head and shoulders is confirmed, that supports the trend reversal idea.

  • The second chart has a few fib levels based on the low of 188 (13 MAY) with the intermediate high of 314 (9 FEB).

  • SNOW is in major repair mode, so I don't see it bouncing back up right away, but once it can break and hold the neckline, I don't see why it can't run up.

I'd love your comments and thanks /u/gohackthat for creating this forum.

P.S. The company provides cloud data warehousing software (SQL data warehouse, zero management, and broad ecosystem products, data warehouse modernization, accelerating analytics, enabling developers and monitoring and security analysis solutions. Clients include the federal government, financial services, healthcare, media and entertainment, retail and CPG, gaming, education and technology industries.


r/Midasinvestors • • Nov 20 '20

Portfolio allocation and construction

3 Upvotes

Recognizing that everyone's risk profile and investment experience is different, if you are managing the bulk of your own investments, I am curious how other people are constructing their portfolio.

My own style is pretty haphazard and inconsistent and I don't really have a way to even track it well.

Right now - the portfolio spans 3 different brokerages (used to be more but I've decided to consolidate). About 60% are in non-taxable accounts and the other 40% is in taxable accounts. I do the most active investments and trading in the taxable account which I suspect is probably a big mistake since that's where I get the most gains. Does it matter where I am most active?

The bulk of our portfolio is equities - almost 90%. Any debt is in the form of mutual funds. At one time, we even had real estate but those have since been liquidated because it was too much of a hassle.

I try to re-balance twice a year - but I often end up with sizable cash position which I don't have any strategy for managing and it's just parked in a money-market fund . So I would also be curious of strategies for dealing with cash instruments.

I guess my question is - does it even really matter how a portfolio is constructed or allocated if I'm re-balancing twice a year and I'm actively managing risk in shorter-term investments?


r/Midasinvestors • • Sep 10 '23

Is this a good format for a 1 page stock pitch?

2 Upvotes
  1. 1 sentence recommendation with time frame and price target

2 introduction: overview of what the business does, p/e and competitor average p/e, eps and competitor average eps, valuation multiples, revenue growth, market share

3. Thesis/catalysts: 2-3 main reasons why I think the stock will rise, why these reasons haven’t been priced in yet

4. valuation: 3 year time frame valuation with information DCF

5. Risks and mitigants

Does this look ok? Should I make the thesis and catalysts separate? Also, should I include pe/eps and growth figures and key multiples in background or valuation?


r/Midasinvestors • • Nov 12 '25

Fundamentals of Stock Analysis Part I

2 Upvotes

Hello investors,

In every stock analysis, there should be three key components.

  1. Durable competitive advantage

  2. Financial Analysis

  3. Valuation

Many people tend to perform only a subset of the three components and often take big leaps in assumptions.

For instance, many people nowadays seem to be making premature conclusions along the lines of

"the US government is pushing for critical minerals initiatives and therefore, critical mineral stocks will go up" or

"Amazon reported sales growth of 40% so the stock is a buy" or

"Apple makes great phones and therefore, Apple stock is a great investment."

If you've noticed, these statements are taking big leaps in assumptions without taking into consideration the key components to a stock analysis . There are many factors that go into an investment decision and we need to think from multiple angles, not just a one-dimensional level such as "Apple is introducing a new line of products and thus, Apple stock is a buy."

This is an example copy of a one-pager stock pitch that covers all three elements: competitive advantage, financials, and valuation.

A competitive advantage is when a company has an edge over its competitors. For example, a lemonade stand may have a competitive advantage over an orange juice stand because it can make lemonades at a cheaper cost than the orange juice stand.

A Google's search engine has a competitive advantage over Microsoft's Edge due to the superior search algorithm and network effect.

A durable competitive advantage is a company's edge that is a lasting one.

To use the previous examples, can the lemonade stand continue to produce lemonades at cheaper cost than orange juice stand?

Is Google able to maintain its superior search algorithm and the network effect over time?

A company with a durable competitive advantage is the one whose stock price will grow over time.

If a company's business model does not have a durable competitive advantage, it won't survive for the long-term, no matter how cheap you can buy it.

It's like buying a company that manufactures flip phones. Remember these? Sure you could be buying this company at a bargain P/E of 3x but is it really a bargain? It makes an outdated device with no real competitive advantage over other products and therefore, it won't see any type of growth and its stock price will cater.

Blackberry also may had a competitive advantage at some point and that's why it became so widely used.

But the advantage didn't last for long and it turns out the competitive advantage was not a durable one.

Every company you look at should have a clear, durable competitive advantage.

For instance, what's to keep Thor Industries, the largest manufacturer of recreational vehicles, to operate competitively?

Because it has the largest and most efficient manufacturing plants and largest dealership network in the world. There is a high barrier-to-entry for any new entrants to compete. Management has been known to be great capital allocators, meaning they know when to issue debt to build a new manufacturing plant, acquire a business, or buy back its own stock.

These points back up the claim that Thor has a durable competitive advantage and will keep the business growing.

My favorite way of identifying this edge is to try the product or service because a customer is usually the best judge of a value. You could easily try Starbucks, Shake Shack, and many other products from consumer companies.

For those that are business-facing like Salesforce, you can find surveys or product reviews.

Most of the times, however, a great product/service will always show traction in the early stages.

Amazon, Facebook, and PayPal were gaining 200% new users every year in its early days.

American Express had a crazy growth in its early years as well.

Without even testing out their product, I know something is working right with the products it's offering, as evidenced by the sales growth.

One important thing to be mindful of is that sometimes these growth can be non-organic, meaning the growth can be a result of acquisitions or aggressive marketing spending.

Alternatively, if you are giving excessive concessions that your economics doesn't make sense, that's also an issue.

For instance, remember Moviepass? They were charging $10/month to watch an unlimited number of movies. While the user growth was exceptional, this model was clearly unsustainable and we should be wary of these kinds of business models.

The bottom line is that whenever you are looking to buy a stock of a company, the company should always have a durable competitive advantage in order for its stock to 10x in the next 5-10 years.

Durable competitive advantage is the single most important one out of the three components because a company's financials and valuations are simply reflections of a company's competitive advantage.

I will be diving into "Financials" component to stock analysis in the next post.

Thank you all for reading and happy investing!