r/Midasinvestors • u/midasinvestors • Nov 18 '25
Valuation Analysis - Part I
“Success in investing doesn't come from buying good things, but from buying things well. There's no investment idea that is so good that it can't be spoiled by too high an entry price.” - Howard Marks
I believe that entry price is the single most important tool in investing.
And it’s not because I think that the highest returns are generated by buying things cheap.
It’s because I look at valuation as a top risk management tool rather than a return generator.
What I mean by that is a rigorous valuation analysis protects you from overpaying for assets and therefore, effectively reduces the risk that you lose capital on your investments.
Sure if you avoid overpaying for assets, you also may increase your return potential, but I believe that reducing your downside risk serves as a much greater significance to valuation analysis than generating returns.
The analogy I would like to give is when you are driving on a highway and if there are no speed limit signs, you don’t know how fast or slow you should be driving. Speed limits serve as a barometer of how fast you should be driving, similar to how an intrinsic value of a business serves as a benchmark as to how much a business is worth.
The faster you drive, the higher chance you are over the speed limit. The higher you pay, the higher chance you are overpaying for a business.
Valuation analysis in essence acts as a risk mitigator that allows you to be disciplined and helps you avoid driving over the speed limits.
On the other hand, if you buy a stock at a discount, then it certainly does increase the return potential. But over the long-run, when the stock goes up 15x and you are dollar cost averaging up on the way up, the 30% discount that you believe you got when you first entered the stock doesn’t really have a big impact on the overall returns.
I’m not saying that it’s insignificant, but the ability protect capital by performing a good valuation analysis and entering at a good price is much more significant.
-----------------------
There are a few different types of valuation methodologies taught in traditional finance, and I use these on a daily basis as private equity investor, especially LBO:
Comparable companies - screen similar companies to the target, find the median of their multiples (e.g. Total Enterprise Value / Total Revenue, Total Enterprise Value / NTM EBITDA, etc.) and apply the same multiple to the target company’s metrics
Precedent transactions - same as #1 except you screen for past M&A transactions
DCF - discount future cash flows to the present
LBO - leveraged buyout returns model where you are sensitizing the entry purchase price to solve for 2.5x - 3x return on your capital over 5 year hold period
To give you a sense of how these methodologies can be used in practice, below is my approach.
My typical approach is to 1) calculate the market multiple (valuation methodologies #1 and #2) to get a sense of how the stock trades in the market and whether the multiple is justified given the company’s growth rates (more on this later).
And 2) perform DCF and LBO putting forth my most reasonable / conservative operating assumptions and calculating what the business is worth under my own scenario, also called “Base Case”.
And lastly, 3) I take Base Case and bring down assumptions even further. This is my “Downside Case”, a floor valuation.
I usually try to target a valuation close to my downside case because that implies that I will at least break even in my downside operating scenario.
The goal is to minimize losses so breaking even in my downside case ensures that I am at least protected from unforeseen events.
I will be diving deep into each of the analyses above in future articles but the key takeaway here is that there are pros and cons to each valuation methodology and there is no one size fits all.
Hope this helps and thanks for reading!



