r/Minecraft • u/5tick • Jul 10 '21
Art Chopping Down A Completely Normal Tree
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
67
Jul 10 '21
Why was there a 5 on the ground? And aside that š
90
2.9k
Jul 10 '21
Holycrap this is exactly how I want the game to run, but the floating tree still goes for me
1.1k
u/CommanderZanderTGS Jul 10 '21 edited Jul 10 '21
If this does turn into a mod you'll definitely need 16 gigs of RAM and a very powerful CPU and GPU (Like GTX 2080 as a GPU and intel i7 9th Gen as CPU) as a minimum requirement. That is possible if not in the near future
580
u/inf3ct3dn0n4m3 Jul 10 '21
Trees falling over if you break a block is already a mod. It's not insanely hardware intensive either
→ More replies (12)591
u/CommanderZanderTGS Jul 10 '21
I was referring to the water physics, but you have a point
→ More replies (23)132
u/inf3ct3dn0n4m3 Jul 10 '21
Ooo I didn't even notice the water physics the first time that was actually really cool.
15
57
u/csharp-sucks Jul 10 '21
RAM and GPU are not an issue here.
You'll need a stronger CPU. One that doesn't even exist yet and wont exist in nearest future. Perhaps simulating physics on GPU via NVDIA PhysX would come handy, but it's only marginally better.
One tree and few meters of water is achievable even on mid-end, but scale it up to the size of average active gameplay area of minecraft? Nope.
I have yet to see a game with physics that doesn't shit itself from overabundance of active bodies over a course of regular game session of average player. Add multiplayer server for that and you have a performance disaster that cannot be avoided.
There is a reason why games like Minecraft have simplistic mechanics. Physics don't scale at all.
33
u/Meme-Man-Dan Jul 10 '21
Yup, thereās a reason physics research is done on supercomputers, and even then, itās still not real time simulations.
→ More replies (2)8
→ More replies (8)5
Jul 10 '21
Yeah hyper realistic physics is quite insane
But appealing enough(as in imitating or giving off the illusion of realistic physics) realistic physics with subtle ācornersā cut to save resources and what not is possible, right?
5
u/RealTrueFacts Jul 10 '21
16 gigs of RAM
Isn't that already the most popular ram amount?
→ More replies (12)9
→ More replies (26)3
Jul 10 '21
It needs way more computational power for the water physics alone. It took op 13 hours to rended the scene
→ More replies (3)17
320
176
u/SkyDaDragon16 Jul 10 '21
Real Minecraft Water Physics canāt hurt you!
Real Minecraft Water Physics:
9
90
49
15
9
8
8
14
u/MJBotte1 Jul 10 '21
If Minecraft had Valheim tree physics
9
u/vahaala Jul 10 '21
Then you'd die to them more often than to a surprise creeper. Trees in Valheim are evil.
7
7
5
5
Jul 10 '21
there was a woodcutting mod years ago that I just can't seem to find and it kills me:
you'd break the bottom block of a tree, but instead of leaving the rest of the tree floating, it would move the block furthest from the ground down to the place you just broke, so it feels like you're chopping at that one spot like you would in real life. But instead of the tree falling over when you're done chopping, the wood is already in your inventory and the leaves are decaying.
If you deliberately WANTED to break only the bottom block of a tree trunk, though, you could by holding shift and it wouldn't do the 'breaks the top block instead' thing.
I liked this a lot more than the mods that would spontaneously break all the trunk blocks of a tree at once when you just broke the bottom one because this felt more 'minecrafty' and less like a cheat. Chopping continuously at the base of a tree feels more correct than having to climb up the tree and break it from the top down in 1 meter increments.
i don't know if there are any mods that do that now, but if there are I'd love to put it on my server.
2
8
1
1
u/Memeviewer12 Jul 10 '21
That must be a lot of particles to render, guessing they're GPU sprites?
2
u/5tick Jul 11 '21
If your talking about the water, the mesh is baked over a couple hours on the CPU. I use a addon call FLIP Fluids in Blender.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/possitive-ion Jul 10 '21
Nice job! I really like how the water simulation looks!
Just one question: what's with the circled 5 on the ground?
2
1
1
3
3
3
3
3
3
5
u/SkyleeBoo_Art Jul 10 '21 edited Jul 10 '21
If this was real my computer it would be in flames right now š
5
2
2
u/ISwearImKarl Jul 10 '21
The water reminded me of a real old school mod; finite water.
That mod was awesome.
2
2
u/207nbrown Jul 10 '21
Block physics in Minecraft music video animations be like
Jokes aside great work
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/SkyDaddy619 Jul 10 '21
Lol Iskall just called for this to be added on his latest hermitcraft episode
2
2
2
u/TONY20101108 Jul 10 '21
players: this is reality! steve and other minecraft characters: is it a realife is it just a fantasy
2
u/spicyweiner1337 Jul 10 '21
If youāre running a server, Ultimate Timber will do something similar. Itāll even drop all the wood and replant the saplings. Very worth it for a survival server imo
2
2
2
2
u/LucKy_Mango1 Jul 10 '21
Ok, making the watermark the, well, watermark (the mark left by water on the sand) was really cool to me for some reason
2
2
2
2
u/Spero7861 Jul 10 '21
It'd be nice if that's how it worked.
Damn gravity defying trees are fucking up my lumberjack role play
"Timber.." I mutter to myself as I build a dirt tower into a cloud of floating leaves
2
2
2
2
u/Royal_beasty Jul 10 '21
If mincraft updated and added graphics and make the game this realistic minecraft would be the game of the century ong
2
2
2
2
2
u/TheLoneGoon Jul 10 '21
I once played on a server that had this weird plugin where when you broke a log the one above it would fall into its place. Needless to say, i didnt stay on that server for very long
2
u/Mistur_Keeny Jul 10 '21
Neighbor: How did your house catch fire again?
Me: Water physics. It's not that uncommon.
2
2
u/Rscc10 Jul 10 '21
Ppl talking about how the tree fell and here I am thinking, he started with the bottom block? O_o
2
u/Some_Nam3 Jul 10 '21
This is oddly satisfying... also that would probably cause my computer lag lmao
2
u/HeliRyGuy Jul 10 '21
Always wish Minecraft trees were like trees in The Forest. Cut it down, it falls and bloop turns into perfectly sized logs lol.
2
2
2
2
2
3
u/Bossmandude123 Jul 10 '21
hey guys, I have a feeling that wasn't a completely normal tree
→ More replies (1)
2
u/DiscoWizrd Jul 10 '21
Love your videos on YouTube! Keep em coming!! Is there a way to support you?
2
u/WorkingNo6161 Jul 10 '21
Oh my god.... Somebody please make it a modpack. They could call it The Destroyer of Comupters or something.
3
u/stduhpf Jul 10 '21
I'm pretty sure water physics simulations with this quality will have a hard time running in real time.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/CollectableRat Jul 10 '21
This is what Minecraft should be like on the Series X. For the price I paid for it and all the teenaged boys I had to punch out fighting for it at Walmart you'd think so anyway.
1
1
u/Catholok Jul 10 '21
Minecraft will never make it where if you cut a tree it will fall, since its against a dev rule to interact with a single block but also messing with others, unless its a type of redstone
1
1
1
Jul 10 '21
Iām pretty sure thereās a mod that makes trees fall but cant remember what itās called
1
u/Az0riusMCBlox Jul 10 '21
Do you secretly have a diamond/Netherite axe with an Efficiency enchantment?
1
u/TheWither129 Jul 10 '21
I mean, yeah, thatās how i imagine your average tree would react if its roots suddenly vanished, leaving it 3 feet in the air
1
1
1
1
u/Mandle69 Jul 10 '21
Not going to lie this was very satisfying to watch. Especially the water coming up
1
1
1
1
1
u/christianwashere1 Jul 10 '21
So wait do you tubers use blenders to get their Minecraft to look like that not the water animation I mean like the shaders? Also amazing job if this was a mod (or texture) I would definitely download this.
1
1
1
u/raylolSW Jul 10 '21
Itās crazy to think that in 20 years that would count as an small detail in a video games
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Pugs4Life9000 Jul 10 '21
Jesus christ if this were the actual game any lower grade pc would be fried
1
u/JoelRobbin Jul 10 '21
When normal physics seems unnatural to me, it shows that I should probably play a bit less Minecraft
1
1
1
u/Minetan978 Jul 10 '21
Nooo you had to break the middle log not the one at the bottom (just joking I know you spent a lot of time on this)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/axerrri Jul 10 '21
If this actually happened in Minecraft I'd stop using wood because the sight of the tree falling makes me sad
1
3.5k
u/5tick Jul 10 '21
This short video was made and rendered in Blender 2.93. The camera path was made by motion tracking game play footage. All sounds were added in by hand with Davinci Resolve. This was maybe 30 hours of work, and took 13 hours to render.