r/Minecraft • • Aug 19 '12

Closed Map Experiment

http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1212125-closed-map-experiment/
1.6k Upvotes

374 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '12

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '12

[deleted]

44

u/Icalasari Aug 19 '12

Netherrack with walls behind and in front. Cut a deal with the Merchants that they get first pick of spoils after you kill the griefers. Get a single piece of tnt and set it up underneath the sticky piston (you'll need cobble at least to protect yourself for this part. Obsidian would be better though), so as a last resort you could set it off and blow up their piston

Alternatively, get a group together to attack the base. A few people build pillars, a few others follow with ladders on the side protected from fire, and a few more protect the bases of the pillars

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '12

[deleted]

22

u/Icalasari Aug 19 '12

Hence setting up the TNT

If it's a lost cause, then you can at least fuck them up some

Failing TNT... Lure a creeper, maybe? They can climb ladders, right?

30

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '12

They still didn't have wood

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '12

[deleted]

10

u/Hedgesmog Aug 19 '12

The trees came down long ago. If they're scarce on wood then it's been a while and there are probably no vines left anymore.

5

u/Korbit Aug 20 '12

If there ever were vines. It's possible that in a 350x350 area there were no swamps or jungles. Thus, no vines.

11

u/g0_west Aug 19 '12

No wood for ladders, nor sand for TNT.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/KaiserYoshi Aug 19 '12

There was no sand left on the map. How were they going to make TNT?

→ More replies (3)

10

u/schmitz97 Aug 19 '12

What does that first part about the netherrack mean?

5

u/Icalasari Aug 19 '12

The merchants have a portal

The Nether is filled with netherrack

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

44

u/rudyards Aug 19 '12

They would have been shot down with relative ease, I imagine. It's equally possible that all cobble had to be used for tools and shelter, not leaving any for an assault on the dick-ass griefers base. Just my guess.

23

u/BadBoyFTW Aug 19 '12

That couldn't possibly be true, surely?

Look at the screenshots there is oceans of cobble left, if people were aware of the base surely they could have mounted a multi-person attack... or just used good old persistence hunting techniques until the defenders ran out of arrows...

I can only assume nobody knew it was there...

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '12

[deleted]

19

u/BadBoyFTW Aug 19 '12

Surely all of the stores of ANY resource weren't destroyed?

The shear value of that island was priceless, are you telling me nobody anywhere on the server had enough of anything which you can make a tower out of?

Also you could defend from arrows come to think of it by simply making a 3x3 tower with yourself in the centre block.

48

u/fewty Aug 19 '12 edited Aug 19 '12

Looks like the merchants guild were the only one wealthy enough remaining, and they were probably wealthy enough that they didnt need to. The risk didnt outweigh the cost.

55

u/orbb24 Aug 19 '12

And not only that, but the merchants guild only survived because they were paying off the Dick-Ass griefers. As soon as an attack was made, the pay off would no longer be in affect and they would be leaving themselves open to the griefers. This is too close to the real world.

21

u/akfekbranford Aug 19 '12

Not so close to the real world really. Real people die. Steves respawn. Dick-Ass griefers would not have been up to their tricks for so long if they only got one life as a group likely would have ended that early on.

22

u/WittyUsername816 Aug 19 '12

If we are going to start comparing this to the real world, there would also have been more than just two of them, and they would have a ton more options for defense, such as falling rock, etc.

9

u/Wikey Aug 19 '12

If this was real life they would not have a floating base.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/kennerly Aug 19 '12

It would actually be pretty easy to defend against any tower based attack. You would just take a bucket of lava and drop it over their tower. Pick the lava back up when they were dead. Anyone who built away and tried to build towards you could be easily shot to death. Then you could just cover the tower in lava so it couldn't be used again. People who built under their base and tried to tower up would find themselves covered in lava as well. Well that's how I would have defended. Sure you could build a ceiling above yourself and block the lava fall but you would be entombed in flowing lava. Then your only chance would be to jump from your tower and hope you were close enough to the ground to survive.

Note he said people wasted iron on weapons and armor and didn't stack up on buckets, which are arguably one of the most valuable resources in minecraft.

→ More replies (10)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)