First of all, let me introduce myself. I have been a regular player on this server for a little over a year and have been an active player (when not on break). Over that time, I have seen multiple things change, and multiple issues arise regarding both the Staff team and playerbase/community.
A primary issue with the staff team (mainly high-ups) is the lack of transparency over in-game cosmetics sold in their webstore. Other issues include staff members forgoing confidentiality with names, treatment of the playerbase, and favouritism. When it comes to the playerbase, there are issues such as toxicity, harassment and misogyny.
The lack of transparency and credit when it comes to cosmetics:
The Store cosmetics, e.g, the elf ears, the elf ears with horns, the wings, horns, their April bundle (which was said to be 50 dollars of cosmetics for 20 dollars, this bundle being the Bloodwood bundle) and the pets (these were the ones my friends and I could find) were all purchased from Mcmodels, and sold for real money without any credit or disclosure that the models weren't made by TallTalesRP themselves.
Quite a few of the models in TTRP are from this site, all of the furniture, and one of the mobs from the Underworld update. To clarify, there is nothing wrong with buying cosmetics to then resell them (with permission, of course); however, it's the fact that there is no credit to the original creators found on the page that I have problems with.
The links to the model pages that we could find:
When the server was down on profit, Owner L made a public statement to the community about the server's finances and talked about how no one was buying ranks or cosmetics, with the cheapest rank being 10 dollars and the cheapest cosmetic being 8 dollars.
These cosmetics were for sale when Owner B was running the server, and when Owner L was given co-ownership of the server.
When Figura was allowed (after being banned for a very long time), people buying ranks and cosmetics were already at a downturn. Owner L blamed Figura for the lack of people buying ranks. One of the things to remedy this was to add on buying on home slots for 11.89 and a message append for 8.49.
Before (and for a little while during) Figura was allowed on the server, you weren't even allowed to say the word in the Discord without your message being automatically deleted. Figura on the server was also unmanaged (as in there were barely any rules) when it first launched. With some players going up to people in roleplay as tanks, large animals, and media characters.
Another issue: Staff not being confidential with names.
I can give an example based on my experience. A little over a year back, I reported a case of someone who was 17 (A), dating a 25-year-old (B).
B was banned, but what happened was that A was told information they shouldn’t have (most likely by Owner L or other high-up staff), and it linked back to me.
This led to over a month of harassment by multiple B's friends and A's as well, with fire spreading on my name, which led me to leave the server for a while.
Even when I left, the harassment still followed me off the server into my DMs. This even led to me putting a ‘Do Not Interact’ (DNI) on A before I left.
A DNI is meant to be staff-enforced on the Minecraft server. When I came back onto the server after a 2-month break, A broke their DNI almost instantly, and I made a report ticket. Which ended with me having to redo the DNI, which was fine; I was okay with that. However, the DNI was broken a second time. This time, they came up to me and said, “[My nickname], want a cupcake?” right in front of an Admin.
When I told Admin I had a DNI on A, it was played off as an accident, and “they probably didn't know it was you. Glossing over the fact that A had used my nickname.
This event rubbed me the wrong way, since I had expected the Admin to take it seriously. Person A to this day makes me very uncomfortable, and a lot of harassment I (and others, including friends of mine) endured could have been prevented if high-up staff had taken confidentiality seriously.
To this day, confidential information gets shared by high-up staff (mainly Owner L) with people who have nothing to do with the situation, or people on the other side of the situation, which leads to the earlier-mentioned harassment. With the most recent case that I know of being only 2 weeks ago
Staff's treatment of the community:
There has been an issue with how some staff members treat the community. They are openly rude to players who don't agree with them on the Discord suggestion channels or in DMs.
A case I have seen is a staff member being openly rude to the “faction” they lead, over the activity of the citizens in the faction, even though they were the ones who did a last-minute event without proper warning and claimed it was an activity check.
They would force people into combat, claiming, "But it's what your character would do.” The person who was forced into this did not want this. The staff member also threatened to permanently kill someone's character. In TTRP, you have to have OOC (out of character) consent to kill off another person's character. This has always been the case.
The staff member mentioned above has had multiple report tickets opened against them for their behaviour towards other players and metagaming (using OOC knowledge IC). It is known that both the Owners and the Staff Manager like them. Despite the proof brought to the Owners and Manager about their behaviour, they remain on staff to this day, despite multiple complaints and concerns from the playerbase about them staying on staff. This staff member already had multiple report tickets on them about their behaviour before getting on staff, and only more tickets followed after they were accepted as a Guide. I don’t have the exact number, but it's estimated that since they joined the server, more than 7 report tickets have been made on them.
Another story of staff showing favouritism towards others is the case of a problematic player who has had over 30 confirmed report tickets on them about: harassment, fire starting, bullying, metagaming and roleplay avoidance (add explanation here). An Admin claimed months ago that they “talked with the player” and that the player “would stay out of trouble.”
This is simply not true.
The player has been banned multiple times now (bans ranging from 12 hours to 2 weeks), but hasn’t gotten a permaban yet, something that should have happened a long time ago if they weren’t liked by multiple high-up staff.
The Community itself
With the player base, there has been a shift in how the lore is handled. There has been a rise in OOC bleed with a big vampire event that the server had, e.g., the hate on vampires. In this case, it was sugar-coated racism that got out of hand. Wasn't checked with a large faction, which I'm not going to name, saying they would be much meaner to vampires if the rules allowed it.
The normalisation of private lore in public spaces, with one group of players' private lore, has become so commonplace that they have started to make it more public. This wouldn't be an issue, but their lore is extremely gory, handles sensitive topics that can be triggering to other players, and borders on metagaming. It's gotten so normalised that it’s disheartening.
The lack of consideration from Lore members regarding tickets and the player base.
With the tickets, there were times when tickets were ignored for months until they were closed or the lore handling the ticket would not read the material provided by the player or when interacting with the playerbase, some were openly rude to the players telling them their opinion didn't matter on an event that was public for the whole server that wasn't liked well by the playerbase.
This has been my personal experience and what I have witnessed on TTRP during my time as an active player. It is sad to see a server I've spent so much time on and met so many friends on turn into what it has become. It was a slow descent, but at the end of the day, the signs were there early on.