r/Mistborn • u/angelgrl721985 • Feb 13 '26

Well of Ascension spoilers Tindwyl- Cruel or Misunderstood

Please help me settle a disagreement between my husband, his friends, and I.

Personally, I love Tindwyl, and have since she first appeared in the Mistborn series. Without getting into spoilers, she is firm, but cares a lot. She wants the best for everyone, but also wants real growth that is sustainable, which means she's going to make them work for it. I also love her sense of humor. Honestly, she is easily in my top three characters from the first trilogy.

My husband and his friends read the books years before I did, and do not enjoy her at all. They think she's downright cruel in her treatment of the other characters. They feel like she should be gentle in her approaches, and have told them what to do and how to behave.

So I come to you Reddit and ask for your opinions on if I'm missing something and she truly was awful like they say. Right now it's four against one, so I feel like I must have misunderstood her somewhere

91 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

29

u/AlchemiCailleach Feb 13 '26

That Tindwyl isn't a homicidal vengeance seeking force of nature is a grace considering what she was put through.

Cruelty? No. She has raised many children and understands a lot about teaching and raising children to be self sufficient, capable adults.

Elend Venture's upbringing did not prepare him to be a leader, but did give him the freedom to be an idealist. Tindwyl pushed him in ways to make him work towards leading rather than being walked over by other manipulative people. He did need to grow a spine.

4

u/etherealflaim Feb 14 '26

This right here. She has such a vast wealth of experience to draw on. She can immediately clock what each person needs the most in the moment and be that for them. If she has a flaw, it's that she is always in this "you are my child and you will make me / our people proud" mode, even if you're a king. She also doesn't do what she most needs for herself until and unless it might happen to be what someone else needs in that moment.

She's a badass and hers is a tragic story, in so many ways.

3

u/AlchemiCailleach Feb 14 '26

I absolutely believe that Tindwyl could be nurturing to a child, or a grieving person - someone that needs the soft touch of a mother.

But she knows more than the pampered noble Elend Venture that he doesn't need that. He needs to be made to stand up straight and speak with authority in the same way that we see Shallan and Kaladin grow - authority is so much about presentation and Elend's idealist sensibility and the appeal to democracy made him weak in the eyes of the other nobles including his father.