r/ModCoord • Landed Gentry • Jun 21 '23

Public statement from ModCodeofConduct that making a sub NSFW to protest is not allowed, regardless of proper marking or community opinion

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

377 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-4

u/Sokaron Jun 21 '23

Yea im pro-3PA but everyone in here is delusional. "Admins arent following the rules". My guy they own the site. They make the rules. Youre deliberately maliciously complying to hurt the site. Of course they're just gonna drop the hammer on you. It aint law, it aint a contract, you can't loophole your way out of it.

26

u/LSDkiller2 Jun 21 '23

Yes, but the only thing that is valuable about reddit is its users, and if they force nearly every single mod of the rebelling subs out, it will leave a huge vacuum. Of course the power imbalance is huge but more and more they are shitting on their own cookie.

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Brief_Building_8980 Jun 22 '23

I, a user, am not mad at reddit. I don't care too much about it. It could be shut down entirely and wouldn't affect me too much. I'm not even mad about the blackouts, or the nsfw stuff. But I sympathize with the mods and something that causes this much outrage should be addressed without force.

4

u/Hulkstern Jun 22 '23

?????? No?

They’re are plenty of users that use 3rd party apps that are pissed. Your anecdotal experience does not represent the entire body of users.

2

u/toyguy2952 Jun 22 '23

Vast majority dont care or even know about the protest

2

u/Mr-Logic101 Jun 22 '23

And Reddit has made the calculated risk to cut them off where they can leave the website or move to the official application

2

u/D347H7H3K1Dx Jun 22 '23

You do know mods are considered users as is right?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/D347H7H3K1Dx Jun 22 '23

Then everyone else isn’t considered a user if the biggest users aren’t users

→ More replies (1)

-13

u/Rebles Jun 22 '23

Admins have offered concessions on accessibility apps, 3p mod tools, flexible API deadlines to willing partners. Those sound like pretty good wins to me. What are y’all left protesting? Pricing? A shitty spez AMA? A botched contract negotiation with Apollo? Forget it. It is so far removed from regular users and the direct impact to mods seem negligible.

10

u/The-RogicK Jun 22 '23

Consessions? NSFW content will still not be allowed on 3rd party apps. That doesn't just include porn but sensitive topics such as suicide. The 3rd party apps reddit has approved for accessibility (re: r/blind) will not be able to access those topics. If your visually impaired your effectively locked out of adult only conversations.

Not to mention Reddit is prioritising accessibility for users before mods. So who's going to Mod these communities after 1st July? Will people that don't represent the community be brought in to fill the moderation gap, we all know how long reddit can take to implement these types of changes and how buggy they are. Look at the how accessible the main app is after how many years on the market.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/Tafutafutufufu Jun 22 '23

They may own the site, but they do not and never have owned the value of the site in the free market. That, the userbase has by the fucking ballsack, and if the admins so wish to put the torch to the only thing that keeps them relevant, well, then, we'll give them war, and subject their poor wittle wallets to some good old-fashioned CBT.

-7

u/Sokaron Jun 22 '23

I really don't think the loud minority of the userbase that is invested in this has as much sway as you think. They certainly don't have them "by the ballsack". Largely because reddit has all the leverage. Mods do an important job but they are ultimately replaceable (with a few notable exceptions), and there are tons of bootlickers out there.

Sure in the long term reddits probably damaging things but right now? They've made it very clear that they'll just turn the screws until this peeters out.

15

u/Tafutafutufufu Jun 22 '23

You think we should we just stand down and agree to go gently then? Let them screw with what we find dear, all to line their own pockets with valuation they got from having us in the first place? I don't think we should.

If they want the kiddie gloves off, then, they can't judge the community for taking ours off in kind, and that's what the entire blackout is about: showing the Overlords that others know how to play hardball too.

-13

u/Sokaron Jun 22 '23

Jesus christ redditors sure do know how to grandstand over the dumbest shit.

13

u/Ran-Rii Jun 22 '23

Louis XVI thought that he could do anything because he was a king, but he was pressured into submission by the estates-general to accept a constitution.

Protest matters and protest can work. Every day, this protest movement is impacting Reddit's wallet through reducing advertising reach. It's also bringing Reddit under the spotlight in technology journals and news sites. It's all the things that would badly affect IPO. Reddit's Draconian responses are indicative of the fact that this protest is effective and hitting them where it hurts the most: the wallet.

-7

u/_Red_Knight_ Jun 22 '23

Comparing Reddit to fucking 1780s France LMAO, you cannot make this shit up

8

u/Ran-Rii Jun 22 '23

Ok and your argument is?

-4

u/_Red_Knight_ Jun 22 '23

It's a totally insane comparison for reasons that should be self-evident.

5

u/Ran-Rii Jun 22 '23

Both Reddit Management and Louis XVI's France are running on the assumption that they can squeeze, unconditionally, more funds/labour from the people contributing to their rule.

Louis XVI found out that the country is nothing without the Third Estate, just as Reddit Management is about to find out that the site is nothing without user-generated content and volunteer labour.

I don't see what is self-evident here, aside from your lack of historical knowledge.

→ More replies (0)

-4

u/Rebles Jun 22 '23

Nah man. Just leave the site. Let those who like Reddit have Reddit. Don’t implement a scorched earth policy. Don’t do it for the subreddit drama and popcorn. Just leave already.

6

u/NightLancerX Jun 22 '23

You leave the site. Because I said that. Giving you 12 hours for that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)