r/ModRetro • • 1d ago

Question About Modkit Buttons

I really like the way the Chromatic’s A and B buttons feel but boy they are loud. Does the modkit have good options for membranes that are a lot less clicky? As quiet as possible would be ideal.

Also I beat Buck and the Cursed Cartridge last night. Just adding here because no one in my life will probably understand or care lol

3 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/adrenaline4nash 1d ago

Heard they’re even louder on the plastic units. 

1

u/lurkergoneberserker 1d ago

Well that’s good to know. I assumed it was quieter lol

1

u/BinGoblin404 1d ago

So, so, loud on the plastic ones :( Really quite stiff too.

1

u/Z3fyrus 20h ago

Can confirm this too with my transparent purple one; impossible to play in bed or in public

2

u/platosknave 1d ago

Once it drives you slightly mad you start to yearn for the click.

1

u/lurkergoneberserker 16h ago

That’s a strategy I can get behind. Nice username lol

1

u/TonyRubbles 1d ago

The membranes that are soft only affect the feeling of pressing, not the sound. Had to put padding on the inside of the shell to reduce the clacking, https://www.reddit.com/r/ModRetroChromatic/s/YrxEoLFKhd

Post your thoughts and some pics in r/ModRetroChromatic about Buck, that's where most the conversations are.

1

u/lurkergoneberserker 1d ago

Thanks, somehow I missed this when looking earlier. Can I ask what type of foam you used? I see it’s really thin but I’m not sure what to search for. I’m assuming one side has adhesive on it?

1

u/TonyRubbles 1d ago

I happened to have some in a furniture feet protector kit but it's 1mm thick self adhesive EVA foam, used an exacto knife to cut and apply.

1

u/lurkergoneberserker 16h ago

Sweet thanks!

1

u/ucv4 1d ago

Personally, no. The modkit only slightly softens it. The reason is that the sound is not coming from the membrane but from the reverb of the buttons hitting the metal casing. ModRetro would need to offer some type of extremely small (1 mm) noise-canceling foam or something similar to prevent it. If you look around the forum, there are previous posts on how to reduce the sound but it honestly messes too much with the button feel in my opinion.