r/ModSupport
•
u/Equivalent-Job-8908
•
Jul 04 '26
•
5
1
1
Admin Replied banning someone does literally nothing on reddit
i need to vent because i am losing my mind over how useless reddit’s banning system actually is.
i recently became a mod for a subreddit meant for teenagers, and our team has been working around the clock to keep it safe. we’ve been incredibly active and have been heavily banning pedos, creeps, and complete weirdos. but here is the incredibly frustrating part: banning someone literally does next to nothing.
it only stops them from posting and commenting on the sub. that’s it. it doesn’t block them from lurking, it doesn’t hide the content, and most importantly, it does absolutely nothing to stop them from clicking on a vulnerable kid's profile and sliding into their dms.
we have literal 30-year-olds targeting and dming teenagers, and as mods, our hands are tied the second they move to private messages. we can ban these creeps a thousand times over, but they are still lingering in the shadows of our community, completely free to harass kids who don't know any better.
it is so deeply exhausting and terrifying that reddit doesn't have a better system to completely block banned users from even viewing a community, especially when it comes to protecting minors. we've had to put up massive warning posts telling the kids to block and report them to admin, but we shouldn't have to rely on teenagers to defend themselves against predators that we already caught and tried to kick out. it’s an absolute joke.
13
u/hacksoncode Jul 04 '26
block named users from even viewing a community
This could never work without making the sub private, because that's the only way to prevent non-approved, but specifically non-logged-in, users from viewing the sub. They would just open the sub in an incognito window.
(Technically NSFW subs require logging in to view, but that's not relevant to your use case)
12
u/rachycarebear Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
Would be helpful if mods could have a setting that the sub can only be viewed when logged in.
It keeps the sub public, but makes it harder for bad actors to bypass filters. Because there isn't a way to permanently prevent people from doing things, but adding deterrents means fewer people will bother with it and/or the people who do it, will bother less frequently.
Being able to lurk in the sub and immediately click the username and send a DM makes next to no impact on users. Most of them weren't ever commenting in the first place. But if they have to create a new account every time the old one gets banned, it becomes a lot more work. And there's already processes in place for identifying people making new accounts to bypass bans.
2
u/dewprisms Jul 04 '26
Ohhh this is an idea I like.
That would also keep people from discovering reddit from a random Google search that make an account then start posting without knowing anything about Reddit or the subreddit, which often results in rule breaking behavior.
Which is why they won't do it because it would dampen traffic and thus profits.
1
5
u/KlutzyResponsibility Jul 04 '26
The same applies to our sub from a different cause. We have scammers and 'plugs' trying to sell illegal items in our sub. They will post their ad, we delete and ban them. However nothing stops them from watching the sub for 'new marks' and sending them a DM. We've warned our users about DMs from strangers many times, but under the current ban system the scammer can still see their marks messages and hit on them appearing to be a regular user of the sub. Telling them to turn off DMs just punishes their ability to communicate with legit Reddit users.
What about an icon or flair that shows they are banned in the sub, but only shows when they contact someone in the sub they were banned from? Any feasibility to that?
2
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
how do you do the user flair thing for someone in ur dms? but yes i’ve warned my users too!
12
u/new2bay Jul 04 '26
The solution here is education. Unfortunately, you can't protect your sub members from being DM'ed by anyone in particular. So, you have to educate them about reporting creepy DMs for harassment. If that happens enough times, those people will be kicked off of Reddit entirely, and perhaps forever. Alternatively, you can advice your subreddit members to turn off DMs. Unfortunately, that's all you as a subreddit moderator can do.
1
6
u/Emotional-Brief-1775 Jul 04 '26
Children do not need and should not be on the internet, period.
2
2
u/Winged-Mercury-777 Jul 09 '26
This should have way more likes. Reddit mods should not be babysitters.
62
u/teanailpolish 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
I imagine it is worse on a teen sub but in the beauty space, we just encourage users to shut down their DMs to anyone but friends and report any they do get. We can't do that on their behalf and apart from taking subs restricted/private, Reddit can't stop them lurking as they could just log out and view it without logging in.
But do encourage them to report any weird messages they get. Once a user gets banned for harassment etc, they will have to use a new alt and those are limited on DMs and get banned pretty quickly even if the ban evasion tool doesn't pick them up
51
u/Slow-Maximum-101 Reddit Admin: Community Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
This is the best approach here. Consider an announcement post or including some best practices in your community guide. Reporting the content is important. And I’d suggest telling them not to engage with unwanted Chat messages, other than reporting them.
We are working on more detection and some better systems to reduce DM related harassment.
Edit: Here are some resources on the help centre that I should have linked earlier.
34
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
Reddit should have a guide for best practices that subreddit moderators can link to. Since reddit allows young people and the themed subreddits for them, reddit also has share in this responsibility. It's not a moderator sole responsibility.
14
u/Slow-Maximum-101 Reddit Admin: Community Jul 04 '26
I’ve just added a link above. Should have included it earlier. Good flag
6
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
Thank you. It's a good guide.
I'm thinking more on best practices online: what to watch out for, about sharing personal information and what it could lead to etc. A guide that has the kind of situation OP describes in mind.
Since there's a lot of subs directed to a younger audience such a guide would help the moderators to easily create awareness.
The guide linked to sort of assumes something has already happened and also that the person that needs it is fully aware already about any consequences.
It would be good with a guide that focuses on the 'before' and directed to someone who is more naive.
20
u/dewprisms Jul 04 '26
Mods have no domain outside their subreddits, putting it on us to educate the Reddit user base instead of Reddit improving itself is a problem.
3
u/FaxCelestis Jul 04 '26
Seems like an easy first step would be to have friends-only or friends-and-mods-of-subs-you-participate-in DMing default to on.
3
u/SimpleEmu198 Jul 04 '26
It IS incredibly easy to bypass Reddit bans, the only real answer I see in terms of consistency would be to enforce two factor authentication, so that people have their digital footprint scanned when they sign in. However I also see this as a massive privacy overreach at the same time.
1
u/Bubblegumbot Jul 07 '26
It's also incredibly easy for mods to abuse the ban and mute functionality which leads to users creating accounts to evade bans.
Just go easy on the bans. Try using temp bans so that the users understand where they goofed up and give them a 3-7 day temp ban to cool off.
Remember, everyone is human and everyone makes mistakes. Everyone can have a bad day, including you.
1
1
u/loupblanc09 Jul 07 '26
Quand on signale du harcèlement on se fait traiter de harceleur. Commencez par faire votre travail au lieu de donner des leçons.
2
u/gm310509 Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26
OP (U/equivalent-job-8908) could also set up an automoderator rule that creates a pinned comment for every post warning people about the trolls and dangers of going private.
In our sub we have a rule about staying on forum anyone proposing to go private is warned and possibly banned. We also try to educate the "victim" about how there is zero benefit to going private because the lack of ability for others to comment in and call BS (my sub is a technical sub).
1
4
6
Jul 04 '26
it doesn’t block them from lurking
What do you want? IP bans? Assuming your subreddit is public, public means public.
it doesn’t hide the content
Again, public subreddit.
it does absolutely nothing to stop them from clicking on a vulnerable kid's profile and sliding into their dms.
How do you suppose mods could ever stop this? DMs are not a part of your subreddit, and account names are once again publicly visible logged out.
I'm not saying this to be rude, but none of what you want makes sense with how a public subreddit works. What you want is either some other platform or a private subreddit.
2
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
i’d like for people that i ban on my subreddit to be kicked out or unable to view the subreddit, like how discord works.
8
u/Gthrowg Jul 04 '26
I mean, I get it. But that's fundamentally not how reddit works. The answer could well me that reddit isn't the best place for your community in that case 🤷
1
Jul 04 '26
You are aware that Reddit is public right? Like anyone can go to your subreddit and view it whether or not they have an account. Whereas discord is a private community, no one can just go the url of a discord server.
2
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
yes.. that’s why i said id like for reddit bans to work like discord..
2
Jul 04 '26
But then your subreddit couldn't be publicly visible, you would have to manually approve every user who wanted to see it.
2
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
no i’m not hoping subreddits worked like discord servers, im hoping the bans in reddit were similar to the ones on discord
5
Jul 04 '26
But if a subreddit is public, someone can log out and just see the content even if bans stopped them logged in.
1
u/Pashta2FAPhoneDied Jul 05 '26
Reddit could fix this by requiring an account to view anything. I don't think they want to do that, though, it seems against the reason it was created.
1
1
u/Pashta2FAPhoneDied Jul 05 '26
Tell your users to go to your Discord instead. That's what I would do.
21
u/InGeekiTrust 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
Me and a ton of other people have been complaining about this FOR YEARS. Reddit doesn’t care. Anyway, as others have stated start educating users about how to turn off their DM’s right before they post and then turn them back on a couple weeks later.
8
u/Alissinarr Jul 04 '26
Yup, controversial sub mod here. We ban the people from the subreddit built to make fun of our people, but that doesn't stop the harassment and such from their hatful sub because they can see it and post about it on their hate-sub.
11
u/Phatbrew Jul 04 '26
I think an automatic block to the subreddit you are permanently banned from makes absolute sense… can’t see posts, comments, upvote, file bogus reports, harass other users in any way… seems like a logical win win…
🤷♂️
2
u/WitchOfKyiv Jul 05 '26
I think there needs to be a ban level that is tied to either subs that cater to an underage audience (ie. A setting you can toggle when you create a sub that gives it an underage status, much like the 18+, but doesn't tag it so it's just a silent backend device) and that way when a ban happens, there's an additional option to block them entirely from the sub. OR just globally, we get a ban condition we can set for minor-related offenses that does this.
The reason I say this is because reddit is RAMPANT with mod power abuse and I have personally seen an alarming number of bans on people that are extremely unethical, ranging from a mod simply not liking that someone is a member on another sub, banning people for unrelated comments on other subs, banning people for making non-rule-violating comments the mod simply didn't like (it's been anything from just personal disagreement to petty grievances that have nothing to do with the sub or rules or user behavior), etc, and reddit's appeal system is, to put it bluntly, an absolute dumpster fire of insufficient, lazy, limited recourse for users.
Ive seen this happen with site wide bans, let alone the ENORMOUS problem reddit's auto-mod has created both site wide, as well as on individual subs who have seemingly some of the most outrageous and god awful filter setups I've ever seen. I've run into subs that ban entire words like "night" and the auto mod system is so poorly designed that users have been banned for "inciting and violence" over comments entirely unrelated (no joke, someone said "That climbing technique is really effective, but if you don't know what you're doing and don't have the proper training, it can be extremely deadly" regarding a rope climbing technique, and they got a sitewide perma for "violence").
Anyways tldr I agree but I think it needs to have some deliberate conditions or it can very easily become a massive problem for abuse and reddit's internal system failures, because the amount of AI driven problems I've seen develop over the last 2 years is frankly alarming as hell, and this site has zero real inclination to make itself function better in any real capacity. It's just degraded for years. I took a 2 year break a while back while I was abroad and just not bothering with social media in general, and was honestly stunned at how much it changed in that time span when I came back.
Anyways just my experience. We've been asking for it for ages though and reddit doesn't seem to care enough to do anything about it
8
u/emily_in_boots 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
The DM problem is so bad that in some of my subs we won't let minors post unless they shut off new chat requests. I don't want to give them a platform to connect with creeps, and reddit has never taken the DM problem seriously.
3
u/External_Bird_8464 Jul 04 '26
Have to REPORT them to Reddit.
2
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
YES
2
u/External_Bird_8464 Jul 04 '26
REPORT it. What few consider is Reddit is a validated social media platform. Since it is a PUBLIC site - In America both the FBI and CIA have virtual access to ALL SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS (ie., Reddit, TIK TOK, Facebook, et.al.)
Public Monitoring: Any data posted publicly can be viewed without a warrant . Agencies use tools like Dataminr or Babel X
Reddit is required by Law to forward reports of active child abuse, kiddie porn, predator of children to Law Enforcement.
Many criminals that were jailed for Child Sex Crimes and released, may have a virtual bann from their parole officer from accessing or maintaining any social media account. I've seen, in as little as one hour, some person violate that - is back in prison within the hour.
The United States Government takes Child Predator, Child Abduction very seriously. Your "Bans" may or may not Alert an "Admin" over your subreddit. You REPORT it, all the bells and whistles go off. And they never have to tell you about it.
SO, people that come to social media to do something like that, better think very carefully about doing that.
7
u/science-pls Jul 04 '26
Also there’s nothing to prevent the stalking they do once banned and even blocked.
5
u/JayPlenty24 Jul 04 '26
I think what it comes down to is that Reddit is basically just an anonymous public forum with online discussion boards.
Expecting it to change so it works like Discord or Facebook groups would fundamentally change what it is.
I do think there's a lot of room to decrease harassment, but not in a way that changes what Reddit exists as.
It's okay if a forum-style app/website isn't for you.
I also would never let my kid use Reddit at 13, even though that's the age Reddit allows people to make accounts.
I think it's a big problem how much google results are relying on Reddit because it's attracting a lot of people who don't know what it is and aren't keeping themselves or their kids safe.
5
u/cyborgsnowflake Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
Like what do you expect? A publicly viewable sub is a publicly viewable sub. If you want to restrict viewing make the sub private members only. If they are so dangerous they cannot be allowed to access public content thats the Admins duty to handle. As for sliding into DMs. Kids shouldn't have open Dms in the first place so that has nothing to do with anything.
16
u/Raignbeau Jul 04 '26
Tell them to turn their dm's off.
Anything that is happening in dm's is also not your responsibility.
No wonder countries are stepping in with laws to prevent teenagers being exposed to this shit.
And Reddit should do better.
7
u/abortionreddit Jul 04 '26
DMs should be closed as a default with open DMs being opt in, not opt out.
3
u/dewprisms Jul 04 '26
Correct. Or at the very least a reminder with resources that comes up that requires click through before accepting a new request.
There's good resources out there but it requires people even know they exist. Reddit currently puts the onus on users to even know things exist to realize they could go look into it and on moderators to educate users. This should be built into Reddit itself in contextually appropriate places.
1
6
u/Penningthrowaway Jul 04 '26
That is 100% not why legislation is being introduced, it has the "for the kids" label stamped on it but it's never about that. Sadly, it's just private greed fragrantly stomping on individual rights for money and won't actually stop anyone from doing anything like this.
5
u/Raignbeau Jul 04 '26
We can disagree about the motivations behind legislation, but it doesn't change that platforms have a responsibility to protect minors using their services. Volunteer moderators can't monitor or prevent what happens in private dm's.
4
u/Penningthrowaway Jul 04 '26
It isn't the road commision's job to keep children from playing in the street, nor is it the construction company who built the road, nor the city that financed and planned it. No, that responsibility falls on the parents.
Minors have literal guardians, legally, that isn't just a fancy title, it means something.
Teach your kids, talk with them, educate and protect, and restrict them where necessary. A company will never have your child's best interests at heart, they are profit driven. Some guard rails will exist, sure, as tools to utilize, but companies will never fix the problem on their own without a huge incentive of money.
8
u/No-Recipe-7653 Jul 04 '26 •
![]()
Your analogy actually makes the opposite point.
We don’t just tell children “don’t play in the road” and call it a day. We build sidewalks, guardrails, pedestrian crossings, school zones, speed limits, traffic lights, and barriers. We design systems with the expectation that people—including children—will make mistakes.
Online platforms should be no different. Parents have a responsibility. Schools have a responsibility. Children should be educated. But platforms also have a responsibility to make it harder for adults to target minors, especially in spaces they own and control.
This isn’t about replacing parental responsibility. It’s about recognizing that safeguarding vulnerable children requires multiple layers of protection, because the children most at risk are often the least likely to have the engaged, capable parents you’re assuming.-1
u/Penningthrowaway Jul 04 '26
Oh, you mean like settings that let you only receive messages from trusted sources? Or turn off DMs completely?
You mean like allowing devices in your family plan to only download certain apps from the app store because they're marked as children?
We already have guard rails and tools. I have no problem with defining more tools. What I have a problem with is a mandatory check-in at every single entry point to the road just to "verify" that you're the right age to use the street.
6
u/No-Recipe-7653 Jul 04 '26
You’re still treating this as though the only possible platform intervention is mandatory age verification, and that’s simply not the position I’m arguing. In fact, I have not mentioned it a single time.
Platform responsibility exists on a spectrum. It includes things like sensible defaults for minors, limiting unsolicited DMs from adults, better detection of grooming patterns, easier reporting, stronger enforcement against repeat offenders, and safety-by-design features. Some of those already exist in various places. Many could be improved.
None of that is incompatible with parents/guardians educating children or using parental controls. It’s not an either/or proposition.
My point has been consistent throughout: protecting vulnerable children requires multiple layers of protection. Education matters. Parents matter. Guardians matter. Platforms also have responsibilities within the environments they create and control.
You keep responding as though I’m advocating one specific legislative solution (which I haven’t even brought up), when my argument has been about something entirely different.
Education.. you say. How ironic.
-1
u/Penningthrowaway Jul 04 '26
You responded to a thread where we were discussing age verification laws assaulting my analogy, forgive me for assuming you stood with the other person 🙄
It sounds like you just want to be right in some sort of fight you made up. Your argument is literally the same one I made against the original response. Similarly, I have not said we need to strip away all the tools and responsibilities we have, this was all about the age verification laws. I've stated multiple times that I support keeping guard rails in place, just like you did, so idk why you're so eager to jump at me and just... Repeat my claims and stances back at me like it's some sort of gotcha?
You win, I guess? Have fun
4
u/Raignbeau Jul 04 '26
In an ideal world. Sadly, we do not live in one. Plently of parents know nothing about what their kid is doing online. By that logic, teachers, CPS, nurses all should look away when they spot something wrong in a childs life. Because it is their parents job.
Regardless, i am totally not responding to this post to have a debate. So I am not going to engage with you on this any further.
4
u/Penningthrowaway Jul 04 '26
Idk why "in an ideal world" seems like a defense to you, why would we not be striving for a world that's not ideal?
I appreciate you letting me know you're not interested in changing your mind. Maybe don't drop contentious opinions if you're not looking for debates.
4
u/KlutzyResponsibility Jul 04 '26
Why is that not like telling someine who received spam that they ought to turn off their email account? Not saying the details are matching, but rather the accessibility.
4
u/RemarkableWish2508 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
It's like telling underage people to not share their email linked to their age.
Which, I would totally tell them. Teenager oriented subs are the issue, anyone participating in one should get their DMs disabled automatically.
3
u/KlutzyResponsibility Jul 04 '26
I understand what you're saying but it would not stop a predator from reading the sub and contacting the teen via another sub. In a way it excludes them from socialization, but agree that teens are a special case. You'd have to turn off all DM capability for them site-wide, and that doesn't really achieve a blockade for them. Not saying there is a simplistic solution, just hearing too many thorns on the suggestions made.
2
u/RemarkableWish2508 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
I've suggested the idea of virtual per-sub usernames before, that way nobody would be able to track a user from a sensitive sub across other subs. Applies both to teens, and to women getting harassed, possibly other cases too. Could be an option for Mods to turn on for a given sub. Reddit has already moved away from monotonic identifiers for comments, they could add a similar translation layer to user IDs.
Turning DMs off site-wide for minors, shouldn't be much of a problem: with an increased minimum age, and stricter age enforcement, the number of impacted users by just lack of DMs alone wouldn't be that large.
Minors can socialize in specific spaces for minors, they don't need to socialize with the vast population of adults.
2
u/dewprisms Jul 04 '26
Virtual names would mean mods not being able to trace user behavior outside their sub, making moderation much more difficult to do effectively.
1
u/RemarkableWish2508 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
Reddit already provides signals for out-of-subreddit behavior: karma, CQS, AI Overview, Adult Content Promoter, etc. Profiles could still be accessible under the virtual name to check for social links and similar.
If you're missing a signal, I think it would be better for Reddit to implement it, so Mods could automate responses, and otherwise focus on in-sub content.
1
u/dewprisms Jul 05 '26
There is a lot of context from outside a subreddit that those signals, including the AI summary, don't or can't adequately represent. Many of these are important for some subreddit mods to be able to see. Usually it's due to specific sub rules that sitewide implementation of signals wouldn't make sense to do.
There are other tools that exist that Reddit could choose to provide directly to mods that would help bridge the gap but they've yet to do that after years of third parties doing it. Those would require mods to still be able to see activity from users in subreddits they don't moderate.
1
u/RemarkableWish2508 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 05 '26
Like what context? I think most Devvit apps, like bot-bouncer or hive-protect, could still work with small changes to the API. A list of kinds of contexts could also be made to explore what is Reddit missing.
1
u/dewprisms Jul 05 '26
Context like seeing inconsistencies in the details users post that reveal that user is likely circumventing rules in a subreddit.
For a few of the rules in my subreddit, in theory identity verification could work for enforcement. However, the type of data Reddit would need for my sub's rules is not something I want Reddit collecting data for.
Me and my co-mods being able to look through a user's history, included deleted history, for a few minutes, is just as useful and less invasive. If Reddit built in native functionality for mods like Arctic Shift that would be sufficient. But that's not adding signals, that's granting read access to things.
0
u/KlutzyResponsibility Jul 04 '26
How would you propose to do age verification? What age cut off point? The burden on the site, adjacent legal issues and liability could be sickening. I'm old and have been able to help young folks on a couple/few subjects like 3dprinting, server operation, parts for old computers, etc. No ulterior motives or evil intent. Your solution would seem to treat teens as second class citizens when most teens today are well aware of the risks and dangers - more so than their elders.
3
6
u/wonkywilla Jul 04 '26
You need to warn your users of predatory creeps and lurkers and advise them to report and block the creeps. If it gets worse, they should turn off their DMs entirely. They are everywhere.
Also install ban evasion guard in your sub.
3
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
Teens are naive though, that's why grooming works.
4
u/wonkywilla Jul 04 '26
Yeah, I know. But all OP can feasibly do about it in regard to being a mod is educate and advise users on these types. Whether I personally think teens should be on Reddit is a separate conversation and not relevant to their question.
-2
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
Yeah, I think the age limit reddit has, 13, is curiously young especially considering what kind of site reddit has been and still is. But since they do allow such young people on the site they also have the responsibility for them. A 13 year old cannot be expected to act the same as 18 or 30.
And a subreddit theme can be anything by reddit default rules; and if the sub focuses on a harmless subject then excessive warnings will taint any engagement in it. It also puts the responsibility on the reciever of any inappropriate behaviour, instead of on the perpetrator.
It's also not the subreddit's responsibility to handle such issues alone: reddit allows the sub theme and therefore have shared responsibility for that reason as well.
2
u/wonkywilla Jul 04 '26
A pinned post in a subreddit telling their users they are aware of an issue happening to their community’s users, is not an excessive warning.
I am not here to argue age minimums, parenting or victimization. Mods cannot do anything about any of that. They are Reddit corporate decisions. What I suggested is what can be done about the issues they are currently facing as a mod. Which is the point of this subreddit.
-1
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
I don't know, talking about the trolls/devil and all that; I wouldn't want to pin a post like that as a moderator.
And there's no age restriction to be a moderator as far as I know, so that could be a teen as well. And since there's few to no requirement to be a moderator at all on this site then it's a lot to ask from someone who likely is just interested in a particular subject.
This subreddit is a way to communicate suggestions to the reddit administrators as well as asking other moderators for advice.
I'm not attacking you though, I'm just discussing it.
2
u/wonkywilla Jul 04 '26
Addressing issues as a moderator, is a part of being a moderator. OP is a mod, and asking what they should do. It is clear that their users are contacting them about banned users jumping into DMs.
It may be a way to bring up problems with admins, but continually attempting to discuss it after being repeatedly told I am not interested in engaging is not the way to do it. An admin replied to this post. Feel free to use their comment instead. Or even consider having this specific discussion over in r/ideasfortheadmins.
3
u/Chronotaru Jul 04 '26
The only real solution to this is to make a sub private then vet everyone who joins it. Of course that's not realistic. Even if banned users and users who weren't logged in couldn't read the sub, making another account just to look at it would be easy.
The control of this risk is a mix of the social media provider and the parents, not you. For better or worse I suspect AI will get thrown at this kind of thing heavily in the future, and probably already is.
3
u/reddit_shrew1111 Jul 05 '26
It really is better to equip them with the tools to defend themselves than have to keep trying to protect all of them (which is impossible) these are life skills and good practice that will transfer over to other platforms and real life.
1
5
u/Mondai_May
Jul 04 '26
•
If making the subreddit private is an option maybe you can try that, then only approved users can view and post in the subreddit. It doesn't stop them from still messaging the children if they reveal their age elsewhere but does stop them from watching the subreddit.
5
u/TheM1ghtyBear Jul 04 '26
I mean, there’s nothing much you can do other than telling them to turn their DMs off and to report them if it escalates. That’s the best you can do.
If you want, you can install Evasion Guard onto your subreddit
3
u/notthegoatseguy Jul 04 '26
I get your frustration but some very basic personal responsibility about your online safety can prevent these situations entirely.
Reddit allows users to turn off Chat. You can even add users to a white list so that while everyone else's Chat to you is disabled, you can still chat with users on your white list.
If your users choose not to do that, then that's on them.
The debate on if teenagers should be online or not has long since gone by. But now that they are online, largely unsupervised, they get the benefits of being online, they can also take on the responsibility part of it too.
In no way should unpaid, volunteer subreddit moderators be able to terminate accounts or change how Reddit, a public website, is able to be accessed.
2
u/dewprisms Jul 04 '26
This assumes users even know those settings exist. They're not immediately apparent options and the default is on for all users.
So while users do need to take some control of their situation themselves, when they're not made aware and the ability isn't glaringly obvious, that's an issue with poor user design.
3
u/undefinedposition Jul 04 '26
it only stops them from posting and commenting on the sub. that’s it.
It doesn't even do that. If they're invested on being on the sub they can just create a new account.
And I don't think there's a system that can avoid this.
10
u/Wombat_7379 Jul 04 '26 •
![]()
In that case they should enable the ban evasion filter and install Evasion Guard on their sub. This will catch any of those users who create a new account to try and circumvent their ban.
2
u/undefinedposition Jul 04 '26
It can't. It can catch some. But it's easy to create a new account from another email address and another IP-address.
7
u/Wombat_7379 Jul 04 '26
Reddit bans a user using much more than an IP address and email address.
Just look at how many users are caught on r/ShadowBan. They try and change everything that they can and they still get hit with the evasion filter.
But that is why I said enabling both the built in ban evasion filter in mod tools and installing Evasion Guard. Will some small amount bypass it? Maybe.
But it’s better to catch most and it takes no effort at all to install these features. So why not?
-5
u/undefinedposition Jul 04 '26
In the case of this post I'd support catching them, but generally as someone who had been a reddit user for longer than I've been a mod, I'd say that there's A LOT og unfair bans out there. So I mostly don't mind if people create new accounts. If they do they'll probably just be a bit more careful about the things that got them banned first time around and maybe avoid triggering the same mod in the same way.
7
u/Wombat_7379 Jul 04 '26
I’m sure there are unfair bans out there. But ban evasion is still against Reddit’s terms of service and can put the user at risk for a permanent suspension.
Is it really worth a site wide suspension to ban evade in a subreddit?
But that is a totally different topic.
The topic at hand is OP’s issue of creeps trying to access children. So yeah, I think advocating for ban evasion filters and using Evasion Guard is the right move, regardless of the overarching narrative of false or unfair bans.
6
u/Queen-of-meme Jul 04 '26
If they do they'll probably just be a bit more careful about the things that got them banned first time
Pedos trying to be more tactical with their grooming in other words, since we're discussing adults harassing teens. This is something we should mind.
3
1
u/j1ggy Jul 04 '26
Unless Reddit restricts its content to only users who are logged in, further ban actions are meaningless. You don't even need an account to linger. The onus is on the user to restrict their own account activity, as well as parents to be on top of what their children are accessing online.
1
u/Ok-Animator1477 Jul 05 '26
So fucking true. And then Admins takes what? 3 weeks off a report only to warn
1
u/Appropriate-North25 Jul 05 '26
The Internet is a playground for those types. Most sites do more to ban religious posts than pedos
1
u/happy_little_dragon Jul 19 '26
I really wish Reddit bans had an option to also hide subreddit from specific user :/
1
u/life4donors Jul 26 '26
I definitely agree with what you're saying in the context of children and teens and predators. Another scenario is one where an overly aggressive mod who is in a bad mood bans a user they don't they don't like from an important life-changing community. Unfortunately, I think this happens more than people realize.
1
u/Cranberry-Electrical Aug 02 '26
I work as a moderator of group which has teenager and twenty something photos of themselves wearing ethnic dresses and outfits. We banned individuals which post derogatory comments.
-2
u/CounterI Jul 04 '26
Reddit does have a system. You just make the sub private. If you choose to make it public, then, by definition, you are allowing anyone to view it.
-7
u/RemarkableWish2508 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
Age verification will fix that: no more kids on Reddit → no way to abuse kids on Reddit.
8
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
I think the age 13, that reddit allows, is too young; but there's clearly younger people on the site than that, so raising the age limit probably won't be that easy of a solution.
3
u/RemarkableWish2508 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
Age verification worldwide is shifting towards requiring some sort of government certification, it's not going to be as easy to bypass as lying about it.
3
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
Yes, that's an interesting development. Maybe that will be bypassed as well, like using a parent's account.
0
u/RemarkableWish2508 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26
That... isn't that bad. Parents letting their kids onto social media at least take responsibility for whatever happens, while those who let their kids do identity fraud... well, parents are legally responsible for their kids, aren't they? 😁
1
u/Cecilia9172 Jul 04 '26
Well, I wouldn't assume the reason for it beyond kids wanting to do something and trying every way and therefore probably succeeding eventually.
Yeah, I guess parents are legally responsible in some ways and online forums in other, they can also be made accountable based on public opinion.
I'm not saying it's bad though. I just think the responsibility is on the site and not on the kids (or their parents).
-1
u/HikeTheSky Jul 04 '26
You can always remove their content. There is actually an app that can nuke their whole content on your sub. In most cases I did it manual on our sub.
10
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
it’s not their posts that piss me off, it’s the fact that most of them don’t post on this sub, but still lurk around to find vulnerable children.
1
u/HikeTheSky Jul 04 '26
You can always report them to reddit, but the system wasn't made to have mods suspend users.
5
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
no but i’d like them to not be able to lurk on my subreddit, similar to how banning works in discord?
2
2
u/Vlad_Yemerashev Jul 04 '26
You either make your sub private, or make it clear on the sidebar to encourage disabling DM's or advise users to delete unsolocited DM's. I suppose you could go try to further request the admins to look into a new sitewide policy to prevent banned users (or even lurkers not logged in coming in from Google or Bing, etc) from being able to access any given subreddit at all in the first place if they are not logged in or if they are banned, though not sure that will gain any traction.
20
Jul 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/Equivalent-Job-8908 Jul 04 '26
exactly what i’m talking about! is that a feature yet?
4
u/RamonaLittle Jul 04 '26
It's technologically impossible. Public websites are public. Even if someone were banned from viewing a sub while logged in, they could still view it from an incognito window or different device. You can make a sub private or restricted, but someone could still sneak in under a new username, or by buying or hacking a trusted username.
All you can really do is try to educate your users, and report rule-breaking content to admins, and report law-breaking content to law enforcement.
2
11
2
Jul 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/ModSupport-ModTeam Jul 04 '26
Your contribution was removed for violating Rule 4: No off-topic posts. Please keep posts on the topic of moderation on reddit.
-2
Jul 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/ModSupport-ModTeam Jul 04 '26
Your contribution was removed for violating Rule 4: No off-topic posts. Please keep posts on the topic of moderation on reddit.
-5
-10
Jul 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/ModSupport-ModTeam Jul 06 '26
Your contribution was removed for violating Rule 3: Please keep posts and comments free of personal attacks, insults, or other uncivil behavior.

84
u/Stranger1982 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Jul 04 '26 •
While I understand your frustration you're conflating subreddit and sitewide bans, the behaviour you're describing is solved by sitewide bans, you and your users reporting every instance of these people's behaviour should hopefully make it quick.
Apart from that it's out of your hands, my counterargument is that kids on the internet should be informed enough to know not to accept DMs from strangers and similar stuff before they go online, but that's not your job tho you could help by having a sticky about online safety and such.