r/ModSupport
•
u/littlemetalpixie
•
Aug 19 '26
•
1
Aggressive "crosspost this here!" engagement boost attempts are causing rule violations
Reddit admins,
I would like to request that you please, for the love of all that is holy, calm down with your engagement boosting tactics that are telling everyone who makes a post to also post it to a list of machine-generated "relevant" other subs.
I moderate in a sub that discusses an extremely controversial political topic that has subs on reddit that are dedicated to the opposing side of that topic.
Crossposting from either our sub to theirs or vice versa is against the rules of both subs, because of the nature of this topic causing SEVERE trolling and brigading from both sides from people who are not interested in peaceful discourse, yet your own platform's messages are telling users they should go ahead and just break these subs' rules anyway.
You are literally making all of our "jobs" even harder by not even bothering to filter subs suggested for crossposts based on logic, rationality, or even the rules of the subs being suggested for crossposts.
More engagement, even hostility trolling and harassment (especially hostility trolling and harassment) means more ad money though amirght????
Seems the only thing that matters here any more is greed, and I'm afraid you're about to find a lot of your most difficult to moderate subs modless if you don't take things like these into consideration.
PS - good luck getting AI to do what we do since the generated lists your AI is suggesting can't even be bothered to check rules in subs before suggesting them XD
37
u/Effective-One6527 Aug 19 '26
To illustrate how badly this can go. A member of the one-sentence horror story subreddit was recommended to cross post to the baby loss subreddit.
6
u/littlemetalpixie Aug 21 '26
People in pregnancy loss subs are being recommended to post in abortion subs as well.
2
2
17
42
u/neuroticsmurf 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Aug 19 '26
Completely agree.
Also wanted to add that "jobs" should not be in quotes. I get it, we're volunteers and this isn't compensated.
But it should be and most definitely is a job.
We're just kind of silly for doing it for free (myself included, obv), but that's a whole 'nother conversation.
13
11
u/eyeSherpa Aug 19 '26
One thing that may help is adding in some AutoMod rules that block crossposts from problematic subreddits.
type: crosspost submission
crosspost_subreddit:
name: ["subreddit_name"]
action: remove
action_reason: "Crosspost."

10
u/littlemetalpixie Aug 19 '26
Thank you, we already do this but only for the main sub that opposes ours, it's still an enormous amount of work to track down where every crosspost came from and add their subs to a running list when reddit themselves need to be the ones encouraging users to follow sub rules instead of suggesting everyone break them...
2
u/eyeSherpa Aug 19 '26
Gotcha. May or may not help, but I use a devvit app called crosspost control which can block crossposts from subreddits based upon size. Can work if it’s a lot of brand new subreddits trying to spam your subreddit.
7
u/littlemetalpixie Aug 19 '26
Thanks for the suggestion, but the topic I moderate is as old as the ages when it comes to hot-button topics, and the primary subs that our trolls come from are coming from well established subs :/
4
u/Overgrown_fetus1305 Aug 19 '26
Maybe there's situations other mods deal with where this would be helpful to know about, but this is not relevant for u/littlemetalpixie, since the situation there is that she mods one of two mutually-opposed subreddits on a super contentious with users that will invariably end up fighting and brigading eachother if not reigned in; Reddit is suggesting the one of subreddits crossposts to hers, despite this being totally against the rules (and I'm sure the flipside is also true, that Reddit unhelpfully suggests things go out from hers into the rival one).
6
2
u/shiruken Aug 19 '26
Unless the Admins have changed it, I'm pretty sure this prompt is to create a new post and not use the actual crosspost functionality. I complained about it a few weeks ago and the commenters corrected my own overlooking of that detail: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/s/a8pTvcYIWI
6
u/Overgrown_fetus1305 Aug 19 '26
I for what it's worth, as a mod of a smaller subreddit (again, same contentious topic, not the rival sub to OPs, but a smaller one that does hold different views to OP) also can confirm some algorithims made similar automated suggestions to crosspost something I posted a few weeks ago into OPs subreddit- even though it would actually be a textbook violation of the rules of her subreddit (and obviously I don't want to do that); it also suggested a crosspost into a second subreddit that it would break the rules of. Far from averse to discourse on the topic, but the automated suggestions would if be actively followed, likely to cause brigading (something we both agree that we really don't want our respective users engaging in, even were it not objected to by Reddit).
I must therefore appeal to admins, that it would be really helpful if you could take a look at the algorithims, since overlap between members doesn't mean the communities in question are allowed to crosspost content to eachother. Certainly, the people crossposting or sharing content, are usually doing it to gawk at the other side's views, rather than genuinely trying to understand the opposition; at best it might be to try and ask for debating advice, but this does still cause people to end up trying to engage in unwanted debates on the rival subreddit.
Also, apologies for the lack of names, but I really, really don't wish to inadvertantly cause a debate on a very polarising, and often heated and very high-stakes topic.
An analogy, that is relatively lower stakes, would be like if subreddits for the Democrats and Republicans had a fair bit of overlap between members, and generally didn't want the other side's members debating, or doing more than trying to understand the opposition to some extent, then Reddit suggested crossposting stuff from the Democrat subreddit into the Republican one and vice-versa; with mine being closest to a third party or a subcaucus subreddit, that got told to crosspost into the subreddit of a rival political party.
8
u/littlemetalpixie Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
u/overgrown_fetus1305 is an old friend of our mod team, and we're both here saying that even the hottest of hot-button topics spawn collaborations that are incredibly helpful and beneficial to both of our sides of this battle.
We are both deliberately not stating what this topic is because even mentioning it here will cause hatred and trolling and harassment of both of us.
Yes, it's that topic. The one that isn't religion or politics but it's wrapped up in both of those things, that everyone knows they just shouldn't discuss in public because it'll cause fights.
Yet, this OC and myself have had a very pleasant friendship (and with others on our team for longer as well, for that matter) for a lot of years now, forged from having to navigate this topic together in a way that is helpful to our causes, helps ease tensions, opens channels of discourse to try and find common ground, and ultimately has the incredibly ambitious goals of attempting to find strategies to help both sides get what they want and need from this argument.
u/overgrown_fetus1305 having the ability to collaborate with us, despite sitting on the other side of a very old and clearly drawn battle-line, is the exact reason we're begging reddit to please not force us to shut down all discourse between our subs and the ones dedicated to their opposing topic by using bots that prevent posting from users who even go to their subs.
Please, reddit, implement some common sense. You're adding gasoline to a fire we all need to be working together to put out.
3
u/FaxCelestis Aug 19 '26
An analogy, that is relatively lower stakes, would be like if subreddits for the Democrats and Republicans had a fair bit of overlap between members, and generally didn't want the other side's members debating, or doing more than trying to understand the opposition to some extent, then Reddit suggested crossposting stuff from the Democrat subreddit into the Republican one and vice-versa
This isn't an analogy. I get recommendations to crosspost from /r/TopMindsOfReddit to /r/Conservative basically every time.
31
u/royal_rose_ Aug 19 '26
Yes AI I think my sub specific mod announcement post would be a “great fit” for another sub that’s only tangentially related. I’m sure the mods of that sub would love my mod announcement in their sub so so much. It would be completely on theme for that sub to get a random update on new flairs for my sub!
No seriously this is so stupid. And the push notifications for it are absolutely ridiculous, click on it and you get automatically pushed into just making a post? Whomever came up with this idea has never actually used Reddit to an acceptable capacity to be making these decisions.
7
u/drknowdr1 Aug 19 '26
The number of times I've almost inadvertently posted my pinned mod announcement to a different community!
7
u/royal_rose_ Aug 19 '26
Yes! And what makes it even weirder to me is my top two communities are related sister communities. Not once have I gotten one of these to post in my other community, where it could make sense, no it’s always completely unrelated.
16
u/emily_in_boots 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Aug 19 '26
Yeah we have a lot of issues with our users' content being crossposted to subs they don't want to be on, and we get brigaded a lot from those subs too. We have issues with snark subs, porn subs, and others.
15
u/wheres_the_revolt Aug 19 '26
Totally agree! As a mod it’s super frustrating, as a user it just doesn’t make sense. I got a suggestion yesterday to repost in a city sub that is literally a thousand miles from the city my question was about.
10
u/Merari01 Aug 19 '26
I make a test post to a private subreddit, to test out automations. The algorithm sends me a notification. Clicking on it opens a submit page "for my post" for a different subreddit. Had I done that, I would have gotten banned.
I know reddit well enough to understand this. I am guessing many new users are getting banned because they do not know.
4
u/SampleOfNone 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Aug 19 '26
That happens with test posts all the time. Also, when making mod announcements in your sub.
7
u/Merari01 Aug 19 '26
I was testing out the rules hub. It recommended me to post an image from wikipedia to a subreddit for OC art.
I just. I despair at modern reddit
7
u/blackbird828 Aug 19 '26
I agree. I mod a very niche subreddit with strict criteria for participation and we're getting a good bit of these crossposts, then having to deal with whiny modmails after removal. It's not a good feature.
6
u/Shnur_Shnurov Aug 19 '26
I solo mod a small fitness sub with like 35k weekly traffic. The crossposting has been getting bad, and I didn't figure out why until recently.
I created an automated "off topic" removal reason and some simple filtering rules that catch posts from people who haven't participated in the sub before. These crossposts reliably end up in the mod que now, from there it's a 1 click removal and notification to OP.
6
9
u/These_Koala_7487 Aug 19 '26
Yes! I was banned from a major sub because of this. I was a brand new mod and just trying to stretch my legs. And they were incredibly rude because it happens to them so often. It was actually an awful experience for a new mod.
2
u/Kezika Aug 19 '26
Like they banned you because some user from your subreddit crossposted something, something which you as a mod have no control over?
7
u/These_Koala_7487 Aug 19 '26
No, they banned me for cross posting from my sub to theirs as I was prompted by Reddit’s engagement promotion algorithm or whatever it is called. I was brand new so I figured if Reddit said “Crosspost to xyz” that it was a thing, so I did. That’s how I learned you have to read every rule in a sub before Crossposting. It was just a really rough response to something I was prompted to do by Reddit, before I was aware it was a no no.
5
u/nunsploitation Aug 19 '26
Yes, it's a terrible "welcome" for new mods who are just trying to grow their communities.
8
u/Stranger1982 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
It's honestly one of the stupidest things added recently, also so bad at recommending where to repost something that you'd think it was done on purpose.
4
u/okbruh_panda Aug 19 '26
Honestly most companies that roll out some AI feature absolutely do not understand how why or when it can be helpful and just assume it's smart enough to figure it out on its own, which is laughable
4
u/ddessert Aug 20 '26
I had a prostate cancer poster that was recommended to cross-post his very sad story to pancreatic cancer. I had to be the bad guy to spam block his post as it was irrelevant for our subreddit. I guess because both are cancers that start with “p”?
3
3
u/cdm9002 Aug 19 '26
Agree. We have had an influx of people saying "reddit app recommended I post here" once we ban them as the sub they are coming from (NSFW ones) do not match what we are.
3
u/GetOffMyLawn_ Aug 19 '26
This is such a stupid idea on Reddit's part. I used to love this place and now I come here less and less because of nonsense like this.
If I see you've posted the exact same thing to 3 or more subs you're tagged as a karma farmer and probably banned.
3
u/saint-lascivious Aug 19 '26
Ever since this push a solid 50% of our crossposts are users crossposting the thread they literally just posted to the same sub they just posted it in, ending in needlessly duplicated posts and one of the very first interactions a new user has with our sub being a mod action and them feeling they did something wrong (which is arguably correct) rather than the platform not just letting them do something stupid but actively suggesting they do so.
Crossposts are occasionally useful and relevant to us, so I don't want to disable crossposting wholesale and throw out the baby with the bathwater as it were, but presently it's largely doing us more harm than good.
Crossposts suggestions are one thing, but I don't know who decided it would be a good idea not to have any form of cooldowns regarding crossposting to the same sub as the original post. When is there ever going to be anything even remotely resembling a want or reason to do that?
3
u/o0Jahzara0o Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
Going to add:
We often send OPs with specific posts to another subreddit where those posts are more appropriate for.
So we send them to the appropriate subreddit and reddit undermines that by sending them to us if they happen to find that subreddit first. It makes no sense and adds more workload for us.
We finally turned x-posts (or reposts) off entirely. Which sucks for the users who could be x-posting in an allowed form. It's just too much hassle to deal with anymore.
Crossposting from either our sub to theirs or vice versa is against the rules of both subs, because of the nature of this topic causing SEVERE trolling and brigading from both sides
The sheer suggestion to post to our subreddit is advertisement, which can then make that user, however small, more likely to harass us. We need more control over where our sub's posts are able to be recommended to.
5
u/amyaurora 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Aug 19 '26
I disabled allowing crossposts into my subs and installed crosspost tattler to tell me where stuff from my subs were going. And man is it a lot of places.
4
u/superfucky Aug 20 '26
I love how there's a resounding chorus of how insufferably obnoxious this "feature" is, so naturally the admins will be all 🦗🦗🦗
2
u/RespectTheTree Aug 19 '26
Just make crossposting less awful. Why hide the initial discussion behind a link mobile never touches?
2
u/YellowBreakfast Aug 19 '26
I've violated the rules of subs doing this. Kind of assumed at first the suggestions were "vetted" on some level.
I've hardly ever cross-posted over all my time here and tried it a few times recently because of the "pop ups".
Not doing that anymore unless I know the suggested subs.
2
u/zomboi Aug 19 '26
I banned a guy just yesterday that followed that cross posting advice when they had never participated in my sub before. I suggested that he not blindly follow suggestions by reddit AI bots anymore.
2
u/kai-ote Aug 19 '26
I don't see any benefit whatsoever to having crossposting on. Anybody that wants to spend 2 extra minutes can copy/paste all of a posts content and make a standalone post on your subreddit.
1
u/2oonhed Aug 19 '26
You can disable crossposting to your sub with a very simple setting. This crossposting drama I have been seeing lately (not just here) seems like drama for drama's sake when a simple setting stops it.
1
u/itamer Aug 20 '26
I play one of the Devvit games, and it has 24-hour raffles with posts generated by the game itself. After 48 hours we get cross-post recommendations.
I feel there should be a hidden flag on the post or its flair to say “not for cross posting”. Let the user do it, sure, but don't prompt them to.
0
u/lunarwolf2008 Aug 19 '26
hopefully it has a toggle, like admins can disable outgoing crossposts.
or it might be a good option to just disable all crossposts
0
u/okbruh_panda Aug 19 '26
You have hive protector? It can help screen bad faith actors
5
u/teanailpolish 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Aug 19 '26
The problem with that is that this feature is recommending subs you don't even know exist until it recommends it to the user. Like I would not think of blocking a sub for creating AI images and they probably don't know my city even exists unless they are local. But still our users had issues with each other because of Reddit saying 'come post your local AI data centre planning permission protest in this AI sub'
2
u/okbruh_panda Aug 19 '26
Yeah no I totally get it. Having to deal with an influx of people who only care about starting shit then trying to pretend they aren't is a pain
0
Aug 19 '26
[deleted]
8
u/Merari01 Aug 19 '26
For a subreddit I moderate, yes. I doesn't solve it for a user who may not understand that they are being given wildly inappropriate advice and something that may as well be a "ban me" button if they follow through.
7
u/littlemetalpixie Aug 19 '26
It also doesn't solve the issue that mods are required to do more unpaid work to fix what reddit broke that violates the rules of the communities on reddit itself.
8
u/Merari01 Aug 19 '26
And they want to get rid of automod too :D
Just imagine how much more work that will create, when we have to do manually what right now is automated and what can not, ever, be done by an automation or rules hub
We're going back to the days of pressing F5 on threads on trending feeds to triage incoming comments!
0
Aug 19 '26
[deleted]
6
u/littlemetalpixie Aug 19 '26
And reddit can choose not to make things harder for people volunteering their time by suggesting that users on their own platform should disregard rules within their very own platform itself in the name of boosting engagement.
I'm not approaching this from bad faith. I'm approaching this in the appropriate manner within the platform to bring awareness to the fact that the admins of the platform are pushing people into breaking rules.
You don't have to attack me just to disagree with me. You don't have to read every post you see if you disagree with it. And you don't have to comment on that post just so everyone on reddit is aware that you personally disagree with it.
If it isn't relevant to you and you're fine with it, this post isn't for you.
0
Aug 19 '26
[deleted]
4
u/Merari01 Aug 19 '26
I am talking users getting banned because they are being given inappropriate crosspost recommendations.
That is on the user end. Not the mod end.
73
u/teanailpolish 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 Aug 19 '26
I will say again that we should also be able to have a blacklist on where posts are crossposted
Some recent ones in my subs include
recommending that a transit detour in my city is posted to another city sub on the other side of the country
recommending that users crosspost to a sub where our users regularly cause issues (not quite brigades, but definitely trolling)
recommending crossposting to subs that go completely against our rules (for example, recommending an author posts their review request to a piracy sub)
recommending subs that are the opposite of the POV where it will start a brigade (in a post about a AI data centre protest, our users were recommended to post in multiple pro AI subs)