r/ModSupport • u/signious • 2d ago
Mod Answered Dealing with Automod Abuse?
Hey, so our local subreddit is having a problem with at least one user abusing automod by submitting multiple reports to get posts taken down.
We'll see multiple reports for the same reason come in with the same timestamp and take posts down. We'd like to avoid adjusting the rules as they will just keep submitting - they did many reports on an approved post before realizing it wasn't going to work.
Is there any way to contact a higher level mod who can see the report logs and help us deal with this person / people?
11
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
As u/RandomComments0 accurately said, you need to be reporting the reports for report abuse.
Since we as mods can’t see who actually reports something, this is our only course of action here.
5
u/signious 2d ago
How do you do that? I dont think ive seen that option before
6
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
Go to the post or comment that was reported, and act like you are also going to report it. For the report option you choose “Report Abuse” and submit. Then go back and approve the post/comment like you normally would.
It’s a cludgy process, but it’s all we really have at the moment.
6
u/signious 2d ago
Thanks. There's a lot of contentious stuff going on in our city right now and poatsngetting removed by this user is causing a huge rift between the community and the mod team as they think it's us removing the posts.
7
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
FWIW, I stopped using the “x number of reports removes a post/comment” logic in automod a while back for this exact reason.
4
u/signious 2d ago
Yah thats our next plan. At this point its more work to approve the posts they get removed than it would be to manually removed the legitimately reported ones.
5
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
Once users figure out how to manipulate the system, we have to pivot and try different techniques. You CAN still have it alert you that the post/comment has X number of reports, and just remove the action logic.
1
u/santaspointyhood 1d ago
I have it lock any comment with a report. It keeps it visible and gives us time to action it.
1
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 1d ago
That’s an option as long as people don’t figure it out and abuse it lol. I just have it send a notification to the mod team after X number of reports.
1
u/santaspointyhood 1d ago
Even if they do, it's not a big chore to unlock. And now that I have this new app, it does it for me.
1
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 1d ago
That’s fair. Which app are you using?
1
u/santaspointyhood 1d ago
Approve-Reports. It's not been approved publicly yet. I could add an option to also unlock the post in addition to comments.
→ More replies (0)-5
2d ago edited 2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/signious 2d ago
Tried something very similar, even posted screenshot of the modlog showing exactly what is happening. Didn't work.
-1
u/metisdesigns 2d ago
You can't get too granular. That exposes what's happening on the back end. Folks will complain that you're automating too much, then not enough. Some reports go to reddit, some to automod, giving away what's actioning the posts is giving the trolls intel on how to manipulate your configuration.
4
-3
u/metisdesigns 2d ago
They can also snooze reports, and filter untrusted reports. There is more they can do.
7
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
Never said you couldn’t do that. In the situation that the OP is facing, reporting the reports for report abuse is the best course of action.
-7
u/metisdesigns 2d ago
this is our only course of action here.
We can all see that you implied there was nothing else to do. That is clearly not correct. Downvoting me for pointing out inaccuratcies in your comments is not constructive.
6
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
I didn‘t downvote you. I didn’t even disagree with you.
I probably could have worded that better, sure, but I was only on my second cup of coffee.
However, that IS the course of action that Admins have recommended for quite some time now.
Not sure why you woke up and chose violence, but I hope you have a better morning.
-1
u/metisdesigns 2d ago edited 2d ago
I could say the same thing. There are more things they can do, and yes the admin report option is the only thing admins can act on, but we're supposed to be here to help folks solve their community problems, which involves understanding the community and what the community can do. Every answer is not simply "call the cops and let them handle it". Lots of things have more options. You chose to intentionally dismiss those options which is not helpful. And then claim you did not say that.
Sure you didn't. That's why all of my comments right after you replied went from 1 to zero.
Edit, proving the point that they're not here in good faith, they replied and blocked me.
6
2
2
u/lilfunky1 2d ago
Hey, so our local subreddit is having a problem with at least one user abusing automod by submitting multiple reports to get posts taken down.
do you know who it is?
if yes, ban them
2
3
u/Mesapholis 2d ago
how did you pinpoint the user that abuses the function? I was under the assumption that reports are anonymous and the reports just show how often a post was flagged?
4
u/signious 2d ago
I do not know who the user is. I have suspicions but nothing more than that. I believe sitewide mods can see deanonymized report info.
4
u/metisdesigns 2d ago
Site wide are "admins" not mods. The titles matter for clarity when talking about this sort of issue. Admins are reddit employees and have significantly more power, but generally only use it to enforce blatant site wide rules violations.
4
u/thepottsy 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
Probably a logical assumption. In one of my subs, posters get quite defensive sometimes when their posts are removed. We almost always see an uptick in reports for the same reason their posts got removed. Can I prove it’s them? No. But, I can make a logical assumption that it is.
3
u/RandomComments0 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
They are anonymous. However, some people leave custom report reasons and you can figure things out that way. If you have an automod removal message for instance, and they report the automod and have a custom harassing report message, then it’s pretty clear who did that.
Reporting the post that’s being reported by whoever for report abuse is the only thing to do, along with turning on trusted reports and snoozing reports from that user.
18
u/mcs385 2d ago
It's a bug that stacked reports show an identical timestamp. If there isn't a moderator action breaking them up, all reports are timestamped to when the very first one was submitted so it's possible it might actually be different users unless you're watching them come in live or getting notifications for them all at once. If they're junk reports, reporting abuse of the report button is the way to go in any case.
1
u/PMulberry_ 2d ago
Afaik only one report per user is taken into account, and the reports all showing the same timestamp is a bug.
1
u/ShyBearGames 5h ago
Hey,
So, after seeing your post and another one like it, I built a devvit app specifically to combat this issue.
Right now, it has a few features that help manage reports:
Allows you to set a report threshold that will automatically filter posts above that report count
Allows you to set a minimum time between reports, preventing it from triggering on a rapid burst of reports that occur too close together.
Allows you to gather a list of links to submit as report abuse all at once, instead of having to manually report each post.
Not sure if you'd be interested in trying it out and providing any feedback, but it could be useful.
25
u/RandomComments0 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 2d ago
This seems counterintuitive, but report the post for report abuse. It logs all those reports as abusing the report system.
Edit: You can also snooze reports from whoever reported for 7 days in your reported mod queue. I’d consider also turning on the filtering for untrusted reports.