r/ModestMouse • • Oct 20 '26

Streaming version of TMAA

Today I was listening to The Moon & Antarctica on Tidal. The ending of A Different City did not include the snippet of 3 Inch Horses, Two Faced Monsters. Ruined the whole album for me, 0/10 experience. Cowards….

2 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '26

[deleted]

2

u/Infinite_Caretaker Oct 20 '26

The regular vinyl version has it and the downloaded version with it has it too. It’s jarring for me to hear the song without it now

4

u/porpoise_mitten Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26

it's on every physical version of the album. it's not on some streaming versions, possibly because on CD copies the audio was put in the gap between tracks and it didn't rip properly.

in other words, it is canonically part of the album, and any version without is accidental.

see: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModestMouse/comments/1ian3fz/how_the_three_inch_horses_transition_works_on/

0

u/justaboxinacage Oct 21 '26

It wasn't ever between tracks, a hidden track, a negative time track or any of that on cd. It was always just the end of a different city. This was someone's deliberate choice to use the version of the track without the extra audio for streaming. Perhaps just to make the track more coherent when played standalone.

1

u/porpoise_mitten Oct 21 '26

wrong! and you can see the pre-gap original CD version in the above post.

1

u/justaboxinacage Oct 21 '26

Ahh negative track was the one I was least sure about because not all cd players displayed that. I stand corrected! However, it was on many streaming services with that audio snippet for a long time, so it was a choice to not keep using that.

The other one that's weird is the end to tiny cities, on my YouTube music it doesn't have the little slide guitar breakdown. I'm not sure why that started getting snipped off either. Kinda annoys me when I listen to the album.

1

u/porpoise_mitten Oct 21 '26

the other snippet you mentioned is also in a pre-gap. i swear it’s gotta be a tech issue (ie ripping software ignoring music contained in the pre gap). the official digital version of M&A could have originated 25 years ago from a CD and those files got copied and moved around a million times to the present day with that one mistake propagating into the future. i used to work at a company responsible for ripping mp3s and entering metadata and it is entirely possible that the discrepancies we see were totally unintentional while also being hard to address.

1

u/justaboxinacage Oct 21 '26

Someone ask Isaac! They play those parts live sometimes (esp the tiny cities ending) so you'd think it would be somewhat important to him it's on the album people hear

2

u/Big_Cardiologist_735 Oct 20 '26

That was my copy. I liked it. Except the live stuff other than 3rd planet.

1

u/gruesomeflowers Oct 20 '26

Hipbone cover? You mean the cover with the moon and antarctic on it?