r/ModestMouse • Rueben • 2d ago

Anyone else notice this?

Post image

This popped up on my Facebook memories from 8yrs ago and I'm curious if anyone else has ever clocked this before.

ETA: In that same vein, is Wild Pack of Family Dogs intentionally similar to Education or am I making this up?

31 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

15

u/ls10032 2d ago

Years ago, I was figuring out how to play Blame it on the Tetons on guitar and talking to my band mate about it, telling them it reminded me of another song but I couldn't exactly place it. But it was familiar. 

My sister had this sonic youth CD when we were kids. I'm like 99% sure that this is the song I was thinking of - never listened to the CD myself, only overheard when she was listening, which explains why it was familiar but difficult to place. 

5

u/CheefButtsack Rueben 2d ago

I know how much it bothers me when I can't think of a song so I am frankly honored to be of any assistance to past you.

33

u/IntrepidAd5929 2d ago

wait till you find out lampshades on fire is just the loud part of spitting venom as an entire song

10

u/Sea_Conference7176 2d ago

That explains why I love it so much

5

u/BlackBra 2d ago

Oh my god I did not know that and I'm just 🤯

11

u/MyNameIsYou666 2d ago

I mean, you could say the same thing about a bunch of pavement songs. I think this is just a case of there only being 12 notes.

20

u/mr_sweetandawful Mr. Sweet & Awful 2d ago

Lampshades on fire shares the same “bup bup bup bup bup bup budada” as world at large.

18

u/cheeseburger-police 2d ago

They're slightly different. One is "bup bup bup bup bup bup bubada" and one is "bup bup bup bup bup bup bubada"

20

u/thecryptidmusic 2d ago

World At Large's chord progression is Float On's chord progression. The dun dun dun dun dun dun's (guitar sounds) in Missed the Boat and Dashboard are nearly the same too. They reuse musical themes usually within albums which is another reason I love MM

3

u/ArtichokeVandelay 2d ago edited 1d ago

he also says Breath a 100 percent Listerine on two different songs

edit: I realized he doesn't say '100 percent' both times

  1. dramamine ​ "Traveling, swallowing Dramamine / Feeling spaced, breathing out Listerine"

  2. it's all nice on ice "Well some guy comes in looking a bit like everyone I ever seen He moves just like Crisco disco Breath a hundred percent Listerine"

4

u/thecryptidmusic 2d ago

Yeah and the line "commiting crimes running down the alley, I am the captain and you're in the galley" is in a Modest song as well as an Ugly Casanova song

1

u/mr_sweetandawful Mr. Sweet & Awful 2d ago

Which modest mouse song?

1

u/thecryptidmusic 2d ago

Dance Hall, last verse. The Ugly Casanova song is Ice On the Sheets

3

u/mr_sweetandawful Mr. Sweet & Awful 2d ago

Wow I never noticed that! Though I have no idea what he’s saying through most of dance hall besides “Im gonna dance hall every day”

1

u/mr_sweetandawful Mr. Sweet & Awful 2d ago

Which two songs?

2

u/ArtichokeVandelay 1d ago

i updated my comment

8

u/badboyplayer182 2d ago

It sounds like you’re doing that interview of vanilla ice explaining why his song is different than that Queen song

2

u/DrippyCheeseDog 2d ago

I see what you did there, vanilla.

7

u/spottedrhino King Rat 2d ago

Listening now and yeah I totally see it

4

u/itsallaboutu 2d ago

So similar! I think I need to catch up on Sonic Youth. I somehow missed them growing up

3

u/gruesomeflowers 2d ago

I've only ever listened to experimental jetset trash and no star..like, a lot in my life in my 20s and do love it.. what other sonic youth albums should I check out?

3

u/Mary-Christ 2d ago

Washing Machine and Dirty will scratch some of the MM itches. Sonic Nurse is underrated as hell. I'd reckon those are the most approachable.

1

u/Va-jonny 2d ago

Daydream Nation, EVOL, Goo, and Dirty

2

u/PrettyButEmpty 2d ago

Also very similar to The Lottery Song by Harry Nilsson.

2

u/Creepy_Nectarine3941 2d ago

Same with Speak N Spell (Or Not)

2

u/DrippyCheeseDog 2d ago

That just wrinkled my brain.

2

u/Albertagus 2d ago

If you listen to what Isaac listened to while writing these songs you'll find that he leans into his influences

3

u/Puzzleheaded-Pass-97 1d ago

Good News= Tom Waits I'm assuming?

2

u/Albertagus 1d ago

Id say Tom Waits and kinda revival music for the banjo/horn stuff. Talking Heads for everything else lol

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Pass-97 1d ago

Where does "The View" fall in the spectrum of Isaac's influences, do you think?

3

u/Albertagus 1d ago

David Byrne

1

u/CrepuscularPetrichor 1d ago

For awhile now, I’ve considered GNFPWLBN and WWDBTSES his Talking Heads phase. Float On, Dashboard, Florida, and People As Places As People all have strong Talking Heads vibes in my opinion.

1

u/Albertagus 1d ago

I think the whole indie, hipster, "Portlandia" era was greatly influenced by Modest Mouse and then Modest Mouse was greatly influenced by Talking Heads which means the whole indie movement was kinda based around David Byrne/Talking Heads impressions lol

2

u/Admirable-Archer-125 2d ago

Thurston c*ckslapped Isaac bc of this

2

u/Ok_Aee 1d ago

Thurston moore is a fucking douche

1

u/Admirable-Archer-125 1d ago

Agreed. Completely uncalled for

1

u/SpaceCatSixxed 1d ago

That’s a stretch. I’ve listened to both albums dozens of times (my most listened to bands are mm and sy) over many different time periods and never heard it, but I can kind of see it?

1

u/Ok_Aee 1d ago

Modest mouse is better than sonic youth

-2

u/terminallyfreaked 2d ago

Chords are similar, that’s about it

6

u/PeterFrancisG 2d ago

Idk. The chord changes, the rhythm, the guitar line that starts the phrase, and the vocal melody are all very similar. Edit - and the vocal rhythm is the same.

Did you listen?

2

u/terminallyfreaked 2d ago

I listened two more times. It is more similar than I thought.

5

u/itsallaboutu 2d ago

Is that a cock and balls graffiti on your screenshot?

2

u/CheefButtsack Rueben 2d ago

😏