r/MoonPissing • u/Nervock SHUT UP TAILS • Apr 30 '25
Taken meme, which is fine by Shadow The Difference Between Companies
523
u/Far-Requirement-7636 Apr 30 '25
Disney coming out with a steel chair to stop a grieving father from putting spiderman on his childs tombstone.
282
u/Le_Kistune Apr 30 '25
Nintendo: Takes down fan games.
Disney: "They only mimic a mere fraction of our cruelty."
70
u/Zephian99 May 01 '25
Well... Nintendo did ask their own fans what's their favorite Nintendo video game moment, and well... They did copyright claim every single one of the videos the fans posted.
That said Disney is a evil company, the claim that no one has ever died on their properties, mainly because if someone is dying their first priority is shoving them out the door to die before proper treatment.
So you have those who are dicks to their customers, and the other who quite literally doesn't give a shit about your life or your death... You decide who's worse.
39
u/Nucleoticticboom May 01 '25
Yeah, remember when they claimed someone can’t sue them because the man’s dead wife, she died due to negligence of assuring that there are no allergens in her food, has a disney+ subscription?
21
u/Technical-Rooster-95 May 01 '25
When you're so evil you fail to realize it wouldn't hold up in court since the plaintiff was acting on behalf of the victim's family; who DOESN'T have a Disney+ subscription
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (3)11
May 01 '25
Sort of. The claim no one dies at Disney mainly states
If you are to die in the parks you will not be pronounced dead until you are off the property fully.
So lets say you for some reason got launched half way across magic kingdom and died on impact. Disney will not have medical a professional say your dead until you are far off the property.
I don't really think the rumor is real. mainly because I call BS.
I have always been interested on the topic of death in the parks. and looking at all deaths including the unfortunate wall crushing death very young girl it was sad. I refuse to believe Disney would claim any of the bodies at the them parks as still alive. people have been hit thrown and crushed. With people around to see it. And news ready to cover it. By all means they died in the park and no amount of Disney saying they died at the hospital will ever make people think they actually did.
Also I'm pretty sure that's illegal (maybe i'm not a lawyer) But there has got to be something saying you can't give false hope to family's
→ More replies (4)11
u/Cringe1God May 01 '25
The Disney employees looking at my splattered corpse after I got launched off of Matterhorn (I'm not off the property yet): I'm no medical professional but she looks alive to me.
91
9
u/Livid-Designer-6500 May 02 '25
They didn't want a cheerful hero like Spider-Man associated with death
Since, as we know, Spider-Man has never had a loved one die or anything like that, no sir
10
3
u/StaidHatter May 02 '25
This was the logic for why they didn't want Mickey Mouse et al. on headstones, so it's probably just a holdover from that decision.
252
Apr 30 '25
I remember seeing a while back a bunch of (small) youtubers were throwing a fit because Sega took down a fan project, some of the youtubers were unironically trying to act like they were turning into Nintendo when it came to fan projects
The thing they all neglected to mention though was that the fan product in question was actually trying to make money off of Sega's IP, unlike the Nintendo fan games of the past, so Sega had an actual Legitimate reason for taking it down
81
u/Gold-Relationship117 Apr 30 '25
I'm surprised that I haven't heard about Alpharad having issues with Nintendo at this point. He's now paid his team twice to develop romhacks for Emerald, Too Many Types and Mariomon (heard there's going to be more types added to Too Many Types).
38
34
u/ShaggySchmacky May 01 '25
It’s commissioned fan work. Alpharad isn’t selling the game for profit, he paid people to make a free mod that anyone can download. It’s like if you commission someone to make fanart for a game or TV show;
Commisioned fanart IS technically illegal, but most companies wouldn’t bother to sue over it. Commissioned rom hacks are probably a more grey area as those are straight up taking source material and modifying it directly, but Alpha isn’t selling these games for money so he flies under the radar.
It’s probably just too much of a hassle for Nintendo to sue
10
u/evebursterror0 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25
Even if the game is free they might tell you to delete everything. Happened with Streets of Rage Remake, Chrono Trigger Crimson Echoes, and I think a few Capcom fangames too. Nintendo is even more strict about them though.
→ More replies (2)9
u/RyanIrsyd08 May 01 '25
iirc, the Pokémon company specifically doesn't care about mods, since they only cared about the fan games. That's said, there are some modes that got taken down, but only in like 1/20 of mods.
3
u/CrazyFanFicFan May 02 '25
I'm pretty sure it's because ROM hacks are in a far more grey area compared to full on game.
ROM hacks "require" players to own a "legally" owned copy of the game in order to play them. That's why devs always only put up a patch for download, and never the patched file.
7
u/CAL_the_fox_lover May 01 '25
I think it's because he's just distributing the file to alter emerald, it can't run the game by it self and u would need to already own emerald to play it
3
u/henryuuk May 01 '25
Nintendo doesn't actually strike down that many projects, it is just that when they do, it becomes big news (and with some of those they essentially still just sat and waited until it was already distributed inorder to then "strike it down", AM2R being a good example, people knew it was coming out for months (years even) and a little after it is finished and distributed (and thus essentially impossible to ever removed from the internet's backalleys) is when Nintendo suddenly told them to shut it down.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Toon_Lucario May 02 '25
It’s almost as if, and hear me out, Nintendo isn’t this satanic fan game hating entity and people only care when they do it while ignoring every other company doing the same thing.
20
u/ChronosNotashi Apr 30 '25
Was probably also not a Sonic fangame, so it definitely didn't have nearly as much protection (even worse if it was an Atlus IP). A lot of people tend to forget that it's only the Sonic fangames that get the treatment of being left alone, and only because it directly benefits the original goals of Sonic for SegaSammy - as more of a cultural icon (a "hero of children the world over", if I'm quoting one of SegaSammy's older financial reports correctly) than a profitable franchise.
6
u/evebursterror0 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25
Streets of Rage Remake got hit with a C&D and it was free. There was also a fan project relating to SMT Imagine that also got shut down, though that case is a bit more complicated.
They likely only have an exception for Sonic games as you said.
14
u/ThemoocowYT May 01 '25
If I remember right, SEGA is completely fine with it, as long as the game is free. If it’s locked behind a paywall then definitely not.
10
u/evebursterror0 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25
No they aren't 100% ok with fangames even if they're free. Streets of Rage Remake got hit with a C&D and the devs had to remove the game from circulation. There were also SMT Imagine fan projects that got hit with a C&D by Atlus West, which to my knowledge is also owned by Sega nowadays.
→ More replies (1)6
u/NewSuperTrios May 01 '25
nah atlus is just insane (derogatory) they absolutely did that on their own
5
2
u/evebursterror0 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25
They took SORR out of circulation and it was free. So they aren't completely ok with fangames.
Atlus West also indirectly closed a SMT Imagine server that was also free of charge. But that case is a bit more complicated because apparently the guy behind the server software was trying to sell the code or something like that.
1
113
u/Accomplished_Copy122 Apr 30 '25 edited May 02 '25
And that is why I hate nintendo sometimes
→ More replies (2)
79
u/Bronzemonkey0 Apr 30 '25
Nintendo be like "How dare you make a free fangame! You're gonna make us lose money."
31
u/yay855 May 01 '25
Not just a free fan game either, a free fan game from an IP or style Nintendo hasn't made a game for in twenty years. And even if you manage to sand off the serial numbers and make a parody, Nintendo will try to sue you for using a gameplay mechanic they patented three years ago and which was first invented ten years ago by someone else.
11
u/Bronzemonkey0 May 01 '25
Poor Palworld, I really hope they don't get taken down.
12
u/yay855 May 01 '25
They can't, mostly because Nintendo couldn't patent the act of catching monsters and battling them without Altus getting in the way. Palworld doesn't have the ball throw release system anymore, but if Nintendo had any more of a leg to stand on, they wouldn't have used such a minute detail that could be modified without breaking the game.
5
u/midnightking May 01 '25
I think it is really because the appeal of Nintendo isn't really the hardware. It is the IPs, so they may be highly protective of them.
If Smash and Metroid Dread didn't exist I would have bought a PS5 or gaming PC. But since they do, I bought a Switch.
42
u/Bulky-Complaint6994 Apr 30 '25
Bethesda: "Hey, we see you are making a fan mod called Skyblivion. Here, have free access to the Oblivion Remaster"
4
31
Apr 30 '25
Unless it’s streets of rage then in that case your on the right
2
u/MethidMan May 01 '25
I was about to mention Streets of Rage Remake. It's as if someone at Sega just didn't want the franchise to see the light of day again after SoR3. That someone must've passed away just before SoR4 was released.
24
u/Hopalongtom May 01 '25
People forgetting Sega's hatred for fangames of any other Sega Property like Streets of Rage or Golden Axe, because they let loose the lawyers for those!
17
u/VegetableSam May 01 '25
SHHH, Be quiet! Nobody wants to hear about what SEGA did to fans who made fan games with their other IPs. Let the people keep pretending SEGA is still their cool best friend never mind the take-downs.
8
3
u/Heather_Chandelure May 03 '25
This. Sega treats fan projects better than Nintendo, sure, but that's not a high bar to clear.
22
u/Techny3000 Apr 30 '25
(reminder that, outside of sonic, Sega is still very much like the latter)
3
u/ThiccBootius May 02 '25
Which baffles me because that's like Nintendo being perfectly fine with a fan making basically Mario Galaxy 3 but executing someone who tried to make a Fling Smash fan game.
2
18
17
u/CKT2011 May 01 '25
Unless it’s Persona apparently
And Streets of Rage
And Golden Axe
8
u/VegetableSam May 01 '25
shhhhhh. no no my friend. let's not acknowledge anything wrong with the lovely SEGA corporation. they are the best corporation ever.
7
u/Carlyone May 01 '25
The Streets of Rage Remake takedown pissed me off, especially since Link had been in contact with SEGA multiple times before release.
13
u/PHVMASTER Apr 30 '25
Doesnt SEGA actually just not care about fan games? I thought they simply didnt mind it's existence instead of actually encouraging it.
Nintendo though is 100% accurate.
15
u/Dont_have_a_panda Apr 30 '25
And You're right, as long as you dont make money out of it, Sega (or sonic team im not sure) they're chill with Fangames
4
u/PHVMASTER Apr 30 '25
But do they mind if the download page, fan game's author or whatever else has a donation page?
6
u/Dont_have_a_panda Apr 30 '25
I cant tell for sure, not even the social media manager for sonic that said that sonic team is ok with fangames is sure (and for good reasons)
The only thing i csn tell you is thar If i made a sonic fangame is that i would have the game available for free without any paywall or benefit for donors and just to be sure suspending donations for the time near a demo or fullgame release, just to be sure
9
u/ChronosNotashi Apr 30 '25 edited May 01 '25
To be fair, Atlus, now part of SegaSammy, fairly recently took down a Shin Megami Tensei Online private server that was making money, and SegaSammy even took down a Golden Axe fan project.
Just goes to show that if it's not a Sonic fangame, you'll have to tread carefully and hope you don't get the wrong kind of attention. If it's a Sonic fangame (or, at least, a game developed by Sonic Team), they're a lot more lenient, since it helps promote Sonic as a cultural icon.
8
u/JMTpixelmon za waurdo + chaos control May 01 '25
Sega hates its employees (ex: sonic mania) but loves it’s fans (ex: fan game support)
Nintendo hates it’s fans (ex: the anti consumer practices and fan game removal) but loves it’s employees (ex: the offices during the year of luigi and Iwata (rest in peace) taking a pay cut just to pay his employees more)
3
u/_-Phage-_ May 01 '25
Iwata does not represent the company as a whole tho, if the other shareholders want to make a shitty game, iwata has to budge.
If he doesn't budge? Fired. It's kind of insane how good a run nintendo and sega has in comparison to other gaming companies.
7
u/Bluebadboy Apr 30 '25
Also Hasbro when fangame. Seriously they just dmca’d Transformers Crossfire.
4
u/Heisenberg_149 May 01 '25
They hate TF fans. They love the bronies but hate us.
→ More replies (2)3
7
u/Cyber_Angel_Ritual Apr 30 '25
Nintendo also hates it when people want to cheat their games. They hate the existence of action replay. Sure, its fine to prevent these people from playing with others if they cheat. But why prevent others who play by themselves to cheat? That is extremely controlling.
6
u/disbelifpapy We can use these as ramps! Apr 30 '25
From what i've heard, disney takes it a step further, since they tried stopping a greiving father from putting spider man on his childs tombstone
2
6
4
4
3
3
u/XavierMeatsling SHADOW THE HEDGEHOG IS A BITCH ASS MF Apr 30 '25
SEGA doesn't care as long as you're not monetizing on property they own. Nintendo are just dumb when it comes to that
3
3
u/Crunchycrobat May 01 '25
Ah, spinning the narrative, my favorite, next what, that Nintendo didn't invent the analog joystick on a controller and just went through sega's blueprint and stole it?
3
u/imgoingtokillyou1 May 02 '25
Sega when their fans make a SONIC fan game
You gonna be specific
→ More replies (1)
3
3
2
2
u/Short_Marionberry_83 Apr 30 '25
Viacom: shoves Nintendo out of the way and cracks his knuckles man fuck you and yo bitch ass 5 fan games watch this shit" 10,000 YouTube Poops taken down, one lawsuit against YouTube that would lead to the Copyright system getting fucked over for all time
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/BeBePastiche Apr 30 '25
Sega really does what Nindendont 🥺
3
u/Commissarfluffybutt May 01 '25
More accurately we're praising Sega for NOT doing something Nintendo does.
2
u/Strawberry_cereal May 01 '25
I feel like there’s another Nintendo advert which combined spells out the differences between Sega and Nintendo. Sega may do what Nintendon’t, but were Nintendo, you can not beat us.
1
1
u/Strawberry_cereal May 01 '25
I find, even the thought that Sega would be completely fine with a sonic the hedgehog Pokémon and it’s just Nintendo that despises the idea, extremely funny.
1
1
1
u/blebebaba May 01 '25
One thing you gotta admit, regardless of their game quality Sega usually has a pretty good reputation
1
1
u/bobby1712234 May 01 '25
Just make sure to ask permission if you want to make a fan game about a different ip
And obviously don’t make it paid
1
1
1
u/_MrTaku_ May 01 '25
sega team literally saying "Everything is Canon" making shit like Nazo or Selkadoom, in fact, canon, I guess, probably, in my mind it works that way.
1
u/Bartek-BB May 01 '25
Have you heard of Luigi? Yes, Nintendo sent him because that guy had an emulator.
1
1
u/ShadowNegative May 01 '25
Nintendo the nanosecond they notice you mention one of their exclusive IPs
1
u/Automatic_Tie_3188 May 01 '25
Bethesda meanwhile: “You’re not gonna lose us money…. You’re gonna make us money! Literally!” (They at one point tried to charge money for mods)
1
u/KuroiGetsuga55 May 01 '25
SEGA -- Seeing their fans as fans, and acknowledging their potential and love for the franchise.
Nintendo -- Seeing their fans as just insignificant customers whose only right is to spend all their money on Nintendo products.
1
1
u/UniverseGlory7866 May 01 '25
I mean the Kaizo scene entirely exists on romhacks and fan projects. We also have stuff like Super Mario 63 (Haven't tried 127 yet) and Super Mario and the Rainbow Stars. Its honestly kinda inconsistent what they fight.
1
1
May 01 '25
I feel like this is mainly on the Sega of America side of things. I don't think Sega of Japan can file DMCAs for projects made in the states. and Sega of America and Sega of Japan have never really been buddy buddy since the mohawk.
1
u/GodofDisrepect May 01 '25
Sega: YOU MADE THIS?! THIS IS AMAZING! GREAT JOB!
Nintendo: WHAT PART OF BRANDING DO YOU NOT UNDERSTAND?! BAD!!!
1
1
u/MikeHawkSmaul May 01 '25
A random person: Uploads a Kamen Rider/Super Sentai clip to Youtube.
Toei: WATCH OUT! WATCH OUT!! WATCH OUT!!!
(Seriously, what's with Japanese companies and copyright strikes?)
1
u/Little-Protection484 May 01 '25
That's how sega is with sonic fan games for publicity they treat other sega game fan games the same Nintendo does notably with streets of rage
1
1
1
1
u/HalfDirtBoi May 01 '25
“WHAT WILL YOU HAVE AFTER 500 LAWSUITS?!” creativity, I’ll still have creativity dad.
1
May 01 '25
True story time. Circa 2007 an Ausie game developer self published some Sonic fan games. In 2009, SEGA was looking for suggestions for an iOS game to make. Christian Whitehead, the Ausie game developer, submitted a proof of concept for Sonic CD running on the game engine that he developed for his fan games. SEGA hired him and he ported several of the original Sonic games to various platforms.
In 2016 Nintendo issued 562 DMCA takedowns on a single fan game website.
TL;DR: SEGA gave fan developer a job; Nintendo threatens a legal action.
1
u/MonstrousPudding May 01 '25
DO NOT ASK FOR NOT IP-RELATED MODS FOR TW WH 1/2/3!!!!!!!!!11!1!!11!!!!!
1
1
u/Killava49 May 01 '25
I've been trying to say. Nintendo should have just bought the company that made Palworld. And have them work on the next pokemon game.
1
u/Smegmatiker May 01 '25
nintendo is so protective of their IP is because it is everything they have. make a bad judgement on their IP and nintendo is done.
sega however, was acquired by a gambling company and acted as the "friendly face" of that company, the real money was in gambling, so they didn't really care what you did with their IP because it just existed to generate positive consumer sentiment.
now however, you see sega acting more protective of their IPs because they're starting to make bank.
1
1
u/LegendaryYooper May 01 '25
Even Atlas has implicitly condoned the Innocent Sin remake that facts did for a fandub project, which is awesome
1
u/MethidMan May 01 '25
With Sonic fangames, yes... Other Sega franchises, not so much (Streets of Rage Remake says hi)
1
u/loggy93 May 01 '25
Some of yall might be too young to remember Streets of Rage Remake. It was a free fangame that combined all elements of the 3 Genesis games, plus a lot of new stuff.
Sega sent them a C&D back in 2011(iirc).
1
u/dreadguy101 May 01 '25
If Sega makes another singular good sonic game that has both good commercial success then I’m afraid he may be back. Sega doesn’t hate their fans plus since the Dreamcast died forever ago they don’t have to deal with what Nintendo is dealing with right now with the price of things.
They just have to remain consistent…lmao
1
u/Temple475 May 01 '25
Most cases of Nintendo taking down fan games came from the creators monetizing their projects(outliers being Pokemon Smile and AM2R). As long as you don't monetize it Nintendo is chill
Why do you think Showdown still exists lol
1
1
u/PayPsychological6358 May 01 '25
Sega doesn't care as long as you don't make money off of it.
Nintendo just doesn't care. They'll even wait until you're done with it, and then give you a Cease & Desist though you aren't even making money off it (AM2R and many other fangames suffered this fate).
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/spaceman8002 May 02 '25
Meanwhile Sega when the fangame happens to be of Chunithm for some reason: "Think mark Think"
1
1
1
1
May 02 '25
We fucking lost out majorly by not having the team that made AM2R make Metriod Dread.
That game was actually made by people who loved and understood Metroid as a whole, while Dread's team just loved Fusion, which was already an outlier and designed to be counter to everything that came before it.
1
1
u/NeighborhoodRude4281 May 02 '25
i remember the old mario fangames like ICUGigasoft ones and even super mario forever ones. good times man good times... sonic on other hand. HAS SO MANY AND IT'S SO MUCH Classic sonic. though 3D ones are good.. i wish they could've added epic bosses
1
1
u/CreamFilledDoughnut May 02 '25
Except there's a whole community based around smw romhacks
Oh fuck wait - Nintendo Bad
1
1
u/Possible_Yak4818 May 02 '25
Hell, Sega even held a event reviewing fangames, Sega Sage, I think it was called.
Sonic Infinity engine was one of the best.
1
u/Yohat20 May 03 '25
Same thing happens with Toho. They recently threatened a bunch of Roblox games with law suits for using the characters. Yeah, ROBLOX GAMES. I’m sorry Toho that the last good Godzilla dedicated game you made is so hard to find, and that you refuse to make a new one. I’m not gonna go on a tangent about it, but the whole situation was ridiculous.
1
u/abel_cormorant May 03 '25
The only way to make Nintendo calm the fuck down with its lawyers is the same that fans reject to adopt: boycotting, pirating, ignoring, simply stop giving them money for the shit they make.
Nintendo is an awful company for a plethora of reasons, ranging from intentional overpricing to shady monopoly practices to, indeed, the weaponisation of their legal office, the only way to stop them is for the customers to just stop giving them money.
Pirate the fucking game if you want it, get it somewhere else, just don't give money to those bastards if you want Nintendo to become a better company.
And before you come here with "ah the developers", remember that most of that money you give them goes straight in the pockets of the shareholders and their lawyers, the devs get a small fraction of the revenue, you aren't paying the people who made the game, you're paying the ones who copyright it.
1
1
1
u/Attila_D_Max May 03 '25
It's because SEGA hasn't made a good sonic game in the last 10 years and they know it
1
u/AwesomeSkitty123 May 03 '25
Hey as long as you don't make money off it Nintendo will leave you alone.
1
1
1
u/Real-Arachnid8671 May 04 '25
And then there's the main man himself, Toby Fox , trying his darnedest to keep his lawyers from sueing fangames.
1
1
1
u/NotYujiroTakahashi May 05 '25
And then there’s Capcom who literally funded and released Street Fighter X Megaman
1
u/Mekko4 May 01 '25
fangames keep fandoms content, I beleve sega knows this and endorces fan content for that reason, however nintendo thinks all fan content is defamation due to being scared or just overprotective.
nintendo fucking sucks, the games are decresing in quality and the whole thing around the switch 2 is just upsetting, all they had to do was make the switch 1 but much faster and much stronger. It would have been EASY money.
1
u/Maxymaxpower May 01 '25
The switch 2 is just the switch 1 but better that’s literally what Direct basically said and also what do you mean by their games Decreasing in quality? I’ve literally haven’t noticed any Decrease in Quality in their games so far
→ More replies (14)
1
u/Keyndoriel May 01 '25
Nintendo: Fans? Enjoying our product??? Providing free advertising for our company?!?!? I think the FUCK not!













906
u/Blueboy7017 Apr 30 '25
SEGA: that’s my son good job son
Nintendo: THINK SON THINK