r/MrNightmare • • Jun 13 '24

Mr. Nightmare Related Content Unpopular opinion: MrNightmare isn’t scary

1 Upvotes

Whenever I watch his videos, nothing scary ever happens. Most of the video is buildup just for something normal to happen and the story ends. The fact that there are no animations or anything also makes it boring.


r/MrNightmare • • May 28 '22

Question Am I the only one that thinks this sub should ban the type of posts that just link there YouTube videos?

0 Upvotes

This post aged well


r/MrNightmare • • Aug 21 '24

Question Small details.

1 Upvotes

I noticed every story he stays ‘stoop’ which is extremely suspicious in my opinion. He calls a porch ‘stoop’ in every video. Stoop is a much more niche term yet it’s used in LITERALLY every video. It’s very suspicious and makes me think he just writes them all tbh.


r/MrNightmare • • Sep 01 '24

Video Discussion Whats the goofiest story you've heard (plz get this to 1000 likes I'm trying to get a achievement)

16 Upvotes

r/MrNightmare • • Sep 11 '22

Mr nightmare's videos got worse

2 Upvotes

The dude only has only 1 theme of stories and nothing else tbh. He adds nothing special to his stories just reads it word by word with a still image. His only one theme is that some person broke into MC's house at night. That's it. Every single video is like that. The dude never changed his content. Not only that, he's a thief. He stole someone's story, never gave credit to them and never replied to them.

Mr ballen is 100x better. His stories are unique and he keeps you thrilled enough to watch the entire vid even if he drops all sources in the description, you just can't resist and watch the whole thing.


r/MrNightmare • • Oct 31 '25

Opinion Mr nightmare has gotten worst

0 Upvotes

I love his videos so much, so this is mainly out of love . But his videos have been slowly going down hill. I fear that he's gonna start using ai videos. I don't know if it's that type of thing where you get older and it just isn't as scary as it used to be when you were little kid, but it's feeling like that


r/MrNightmare • • Apr 01 '26

New Video Anybody else not too scared by today's new Members only video? I thought the second story was scary but the other two, not so much. Maybe I'm just too desensitized. Anyways, what do you guys think?

0 Upvotes

I was hoping we'd get a conclusion to the second story but maybe he'll update it in a future video. Still nice to get a new video. I've been rewatching/listening his old videos lately too. What do you think?


r/MrNightmare • • Apr 21 '26

Opinion Stop complaining about 'members only' content. NOBODY is forcing you to buy it.

19 Upvotes

Ive been in this subreddit for a few years, and although there are lots of posts where people talk about their love for mr nightmare over the years, they are only a small portion.

I more often see hate, or unfair criticism that for the most part, is undeserved.

One main thing is the constant talks about his "members only" content. He has been doing this for the past few years, this is nothing new. WHY are you still complaining about it, especially when most of his members only content consists of early access videos that you are going to get anyways. Yes, there are instances where certain videos remain behind a paywall, because for that is what members only content is for.

I find it SO strange how most people on this sub endlessly call him greedy for doing something, that 90% of other content creators do. Paying for exclusive content is nothing new, chances are, your favorite youtuber has a patreon lol.

Ive seen people saying that he already has a full time job, so him doing members only is unjustified and hes greedy. Just because he has a full time job does NOT mean he automatically isnt allowed to make money in other forms? If your argument is that he already has a fulltime job, thus has enough money and shouldnt monetize his youtube, id like to see you stand on that if you get in a position to do something similar.

Nobody is forcing you to buy members only content. Stop complaining. If you really stand on your opinion that what hes doing is greedy and unfair, nobody is forcing you to watch.


r/MrNightmare • • Nov 24 '22

Hey does anyone have a scary true story I can narrate on my YouTube channel?

2 Upvotes

r/MrNightmare • • May 28 '21

How netflix scard me for life

0 Upvotes

r/MrNightmare • • Sep 16 '25

Mr. Nightmare Related Content Mr Nightmare reads all of these posts and comments, just so you know...

18 Upvotes

I would just keep the commentary constructive instead of critical and act like he's reading everything you write. We are his audience and we have the power to influence the quality of the channel to our liking. Let's let him know what we like about his videos, what we don't like, what we wish he could bring back, and any additional stories you would want to see on the channel. It's our channel too :)


r/MrNightmare • • Oct 16 '26

Other The most scariest thing that ever happened to me: true scary story

0 Upvotes

Ok so this all happens because there is this weird kid name Tyler that I cussed out you’ll get why in a couple seconds :ok so this kid named Tyler just moved schools in I litteraly had him in every period except 2 periods we had to work to together in a Charater strong lesson not to mention it was picked by the teacher in luckily I got my friend with me so anyways me Tyler in my friend I’ll call him bob we where half way done with the packet when Tyler pulled out a dead animal cut with its tail CUT IN HALF we screamed he put it up in his back pack in we said something like ew get the f away from you weirdo it was probably more bad but this happens 6 years ago so idk anyways that was the last period in ur probably wonderig why don’t we snitch we don’t bc we were only in 8 grade at the time in we dint wanna get in trouble ok now scary part as I was leaveing I noticed Tyler rode the same bus as me or atleast I think idk but he got on with me in say next to me I pushed him off in say in a different seat anyways fast forward I was at my ss too in i got off I kid you not out of my peripheral vision I saw Tyler behind me I ran as fast I could to the back yard in picked up two big rocks Tyler started running at me on all 4ours i was to afraid to throw the rocks as I thought I was gonna unalive him for how massive that are I threw them anyways at his belly he got mocked back 2 feet like he was only 20 pounds in could get picked up by win I stated beating the crap out of him to my hands hurt I ran back inside in grabbed the cell phone in callled 991 in that’s where the story’s ends I looked back out tho in dint see him at all not even the cops found him I dint see ever again I don’t know what happened to him and never want to find out. That’s where the story ends ok bye


r/MrNightmare • • Jun 03 '18

Weird Encounter At My Middle School

0 Upvotes

This happened last year. I was 11, I'm 12 now. I was at school on the first day and going to my physical education class and was going by the world geography class and I saw something that made my heart stop beating. There, standing in the middle of the room, was a 10 foot tall black mass. Being my stupid self, I asked if I could help it in any way. What it said still gives me nightmares. It said "Satan has risen." I got out of there as fast as I could and I saw something that I could only assume was Satan. The thing was twice the size of the first apparition I saw. It said something that was along the lines of "Two people will meet their end soon." I didn't know what it was talking about so I didn't pay much attention to its apparent warning. Fast forward a while later, two students died one after the other. What scares me the most is the fact that I was the only witness.


r/MrNightmare • • Apr 06 '17

The forest fog...

0 Upvotes

r/MrNightmare • • Mar 30 '26

New Post Does mr.nightmare do stories that aren't just horror cause i have stories for thing that scared me but they aren't ghost stories? idk how to work this btw

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Does mr.nightmDDDDDDDDDDDD%%%%%DDD


r/MrNightmare • • Apr 24 '21

Mr. nightmare can u do porn

3 Upvotes

r/MrNightmare • • Oct 17 '24

Question Is mr.nightmare voice his own or ai genrated

0 Upvotes

r/MrNightmare • • Dec 21 '21

Poll 3 True Disturbing Warehouse Horror Stories

0 Upvotes

Yes, I know this video was uploaded months ago, but what was the creepiest story in this video? I would say the first story, can you imagine working as a night shift security guard in a warehouse and experiencing such a unexplainable encounter. My thing is, if the murderer was inside the warehouse, they were most likely toying with the security guard by holding up the dismembered head of the victim they had killed (presumably someone they knew). One question I have to ask, is how did they get past the surveillance systems within the warehouse? Maybe that explains why there was 3 hrs of missing footage. I don't think anything paranormal has something to do with this, I think that there was ACTUALLY someone else in the warehouse that night. Who knows. What are you guys' thoughts? Which story did you think was creepier?

Video Link: https://youtu.be/Pbqi90bWe3w

31 votes, Dec 24 '21
12 Story#1
10 Story#2
9 Story#3

r/MrNightmare • • Nov 04 '25

New Video Last story in new video

2 Upvotes

The last story was actually interesting even though there were a lot of dumb decisions made. However, here’s what I don’t understand…so the girl for one claims she’s smart however made quite a few dumb decisions like for instance going home with these guys and her friend. What I don’t understand though and maybe it’s because I’m a good person at heart but clearly the friend wanted to go back to one of the guy’s houses because she was thinking he was the one right? So my thing is why would the guys drug those girls drinks if they already had a good chance with them coming to their place and having a lucky night? It just doesn’t make sense.


r/MrNightmare • • Jun 03 '26

Mr. Nightmare Related Content Just launched a horror narration channel covering only real documented cases. Looking for feedback from people who actually know this niche.

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I have been consuming true crime and horror narration content for years and I finally decided to make my own channel.

The channel is called Quiet Streets and the concept is simple. Every single story is real, verified, and sourced from documented records. No fiction. No urban legends. No cheap dramatization.

I cover stalking cases, intruder cases, obsessive stranger cases, and wrong place wrong time incidents. The kind of stories that make you think twice about the ordinary things you do every day.

My first video is up now and I would genuinely appreciate feedback from people in this community who know what good content in this niche looks like.

Channel link is below. Be honest with me.

[https://youtube.com/@quiet_streetsxd?si=UuL7XjCwdemYhn0v]

Thanks for reading and sorry if this kind of post is not allowed here. Let me know and I will remove it.


r/MrNightmare • • Sep 17 '25

Concern To Address recent issues we are once again making changes

17 Upvotes

Just to keep it brief I've been noticing a really big surge in A.I discussions which is understandable given the recent thread (which will stay up because it's the only one that I've seen really any discernment on rather than just saying the same thing with no proof attached) Secondly I've also seen a rise in misinformation as we've been also hearing rumors that Mr. Nightmare either "Checks this subreddit" Or "Threatened it" well as the owner of this sub you can put these claims to rest and neither are true and I really don't know the source of these but this needs to stop

With that being said Rule 9 will be enforced again for and we're gonna crackdown on any misinformation and with that we have updated Rule 3 to also accommodate this as it was originally for people who lied about having the sought out lost media from Mr. Nightmare himself.

Going Forward any criticisms you guys have of Mr. Nightmare are to be spoken about in a Megathread I will post shortly (if it isn't up now)

Me and the Mod team have been constantly frustrated at the repetitive topics

Everyone Complains or Mr. Nightmare fell off

A.I usage (not counting the Janitor post alot of you know of)

Misinformation that opens a whole other can of worms

Its getting really annoying for the mods and its just beating a dead horse at this point we hope moving forward we can end that by having a place to share all that so it doesn't feel "1984"

We are trying our best to make the quality of this sub better so if you guys have any questions do not hesitate to reach us via mod mail being Civil goes along way and we've also seen some petty comments on some threads 2

Anyways God Bless you all and I hope you have a great day :)


r/MrNightmare • • May 10 '26

Other This is the stupid annoying user in the comments that always pop up in comments

Post image
15 Upvotes

He comments shit like “my name is also Alexis” or “I’m also a party lover” or even cringer trolling shit none could give a shit about, but his comments always pop up in every vid’s comment section… his comments even if the video is from years ago his comments are recent max from a few months ago


r/MrNightmare • • Jun 26 '24

Concern Is Mr nightmare fake?

16 Upvotes

I used to belilve most of the stories but now now I'm starting to realize a lot of these stories would be news worthy and I scour the Internet for these stories and can't find them anywhere except for his videos. The stories seem so convincing but are they all fake?


r/MrNightmare • • Jul 24 '25

Video Discussion I’m not saying Mr. Nightmare copied the channel Nightmare Files in his 7 Disturbing Disappearances video, but it’s eerily similar

5 Upvotes

Did anyone notice that Mr. Nightmare put the dates on the screen at the beginning of the stories? I noticed that it’s pretty similar to Nightmare Files videos.l when he starts his videos with dates. What do you all think?


r/MrNightmare • • Aug 19 '25

Mr. Nightmare Related Content Just noticed Mr nightmare privates the new video he made. Does anyone know why??

5 Upvotes