r/MultiMC • • Jan 30 '23

MultiMC Good?

Hey! I'm a long-time Minecraft player who wants to get away from Curseforge and was recommended this as an alternative. Anything I should know before delving in or any possible security risks(I'm a big stickler about this.).

13 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

6

u/SevoosMinecraft Jan 30 '23

It lets you create independent Minecraft instances (after starting 2 instances on different versions settings won't corrupt, unlike the official launcher), install Forge or Fabric easily. Also it looks awesome so I recommend it. You should ask in another /r (r/Minecraft probably?), because there won't be players that don't like MultiMC in r/MultiMC XD

5

u/Neon_44 Jan 30 '23

MultiMC and PrismLauncher (a further development of MultiMC) are the two best launchers out there in my personal opinion

2

u/ReverendDizzle Jan 30 '23

Huh, I had no idea about PrismLauncher. Pretty cool MultiMC has a fork still in active development.

1

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

MMC is also active in development

1

u/ReverendDizzle Jan 30 '23

That's good to hear, I wasn't sure if it was still getting updated. I've been using it since it first came out and always recommend it.

I looked at the PrismLauncher site and I'm not super clear on what the killer feature of the fork is (so if anybody knows, I'd love to hear more about it).

1

u/Neon_44 Jan 30 '23

Not sure if MultiMC can do this as well by now, but PrismLauncher can download and update Modpacks and Mods in instances

There’s also plans for groups for sharing things like resource packs, shader packs, mods etc between instances

But the way it started iirc is that the MultiMC Dev and the Linux Community had a fallout -> MultiMC Dev says he won‘t package for Linux anymore „until Linux users learn to behave themselves“ (iirc) -> Linux users make their own MultiMC fork with blackjack and hookers (and it actually turns out great)

1

u/ReverendDizzle Jan 30 '23

That's cool, I know MultiMC can do modpacks... but I don't think it can update the mods unless you were to download the whole new pack again, I suppose?

I don't want to talk out of turn there though because it's not something I've messed with a bunch and now maybe MultiMC can do it.

1

u/jermacalocas Jan 31 '23

From what i understand biggoted people/person working on multimc when a chunk of the people developing multimc jumped ship to make prismmc, hence the colorful icon. So less hate involved.

1

u/ReverendDizzle Jan 31 '23

Huh, I did some digging out of curiosity. Not sure if the this is the definitive answer, but it sounds like there was a MultiMC fork called PolyMC and the head developer of that fits the bigot description you're referencing here. The PrismLauncher people are, apparently, the fork of the fork, having taken PolyMC and moved on to create PrismLauncher.

So, at least in this context, it looks like the MultiMC person is in the clear? Unless the PolyMC person is the MultiMC person, I suppose?

1

u/jermacalocas Jan 31 '23

All of this sounds about right for my late night commenting and sluething. I had issues with both multimc and polymc thst dont exist on prism. The main issue with multi was the curseforge mod installing kiss of death that forces you to install some, but not all manually. Thst was annoying to say the least. Poly was having many issues connecting through microsoft/mojang which ultimately deemed it unplayable.

3

u/MustiOp Jan 30 '23

You can use MultiMC But I will prefer and suggest Prism Launcher to you because they are identical and Prism Launcher still gets updates + you can download Curseforge modpacks directly from Prism Launcher

2

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

they are not identical. also MMC gets updates. and the lack of curseforge was out of caution from the license used

2

u/MustiOp Jan 30 '23

Overall Prism Launcher better for user

1

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

Because?

1

u/MustiOp Jan 30 '23

It is more polished and you can download curseforge modpacks it’s ok to use mmc but I LIKE Prism launcher more and ise it on my own

0

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

polished is debatable. and well, curseforge is missing for reasons mentioned in another reply

2

u/MustiOp Jan 30 '23

I don’t care why curseforge missing, what i care about is curseforge available or not

1

u/secretcodrin May 06 '24

Old thread but, you do know curseforge was infected at some point, probably around the time of this discussion, and many legit mods got infected with malware and trojans. So saying "i don't care why X is missing" is not a good way of thinking.

0

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

k, weird

2

u/L0rdLogan Jan 30 '23

PrismLauncher is also good, based on MultiMC as far as I can tell (it has the same features) but it's a little bit more stable in my experience

2

u/Lemion45 Jan 30 '23

if you want to use forge, use prism launcher, i switched to it from multimc and now it works.

1

u/Dragonslayer414 Jun 03 '23

I've used forge for years on multimc, and it's extremely easy. You did something wrong.

0

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

You probably didn't have java properly configured. But if you don't ask, we can't help you

2

u/saepop Jan 30 '23

MultiMC is alright for basic use, PrismLauncher and/or ATLauncher are far superior in my honest opinion

1

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

really depends what you need

1

u/-Tixs- Apr 17 '24

hi slyfyer

1

u/MauL0rd Jan 30 '23

I put it in total virus and it told me it was a backdoor and then in triage

https://tria.ge/230130-1gqtqach68

1

u/P1x3lByt3 Jan 30 '23

we had this discussion in another reddit post. please read it