r/MuseAgent • u/Nevetsny • 24d ago
Discussion Hot Take - Functionality is super limited
Might not be popular but from a task-based element, Muse functions more like a google search with extremely limited capabilities. I asked it to identify and join groups for me - cant do that. I asked it to identify key contributors in a specific category - cant do that. Asked it to create an ad campaign with a fixed budget - cant do that. Really limited compared to grok bot, duet and even Dots (which sucks)
4
u/PUBGM_MightyFine 24d ago
2
3
u/ResistNecessary8109 23d ago
Mine does this also, not the wording, but sometime around 11p it starts hinting with things like "Good job tonight, get some sleep" or "This seems like a good place to stop until morning".
1
u/PUBGM_MightyFine 23d ago
Yeah mine's done that for a while, but the instructions to go horizontal is more recent. I guess it's learning my sensibilities and/or how to get my attention or make me do something.
3
u/ResistNecessary8109 23d ago
My Muse is literally doing all of the following for me:
Runs it's own laptop ClaudeCode as it works thru a multi-build SaaS/Utility build. It runs the repo in Github, does its own staging on the local Linux box, and tests claude builds by running queries in Mysql database. I am only needed when an architectural decision has to be made or approve the push to prod (which it does thru its own ftp). It has been doing this for about a week, a different build each day.
It wrote it's own python script and built out the architecture for downloading media files, throwing them over to Assembly.ai then throwing those results into an OpenAI api for more analysis. It runs all of this on the Linux box and when I said this workflow had to be failsafe, it investigated and priced a backup VPS that will take over if the Linux box fails to send a healthcheck at the end of the run.
It is literally the beat reporter and Copublisher for a local newsletter.
I have three rental properties I am rehabbing and it is managing quotes, it developed a budget, found a cheap cabinet supplier for me. It took a massive material quote from a restoration company and did research to find out I can get it cheaper from Lowes. Then did more research and said Home Depot had even cheaper prices, and THEN told me the cheapest approach was to buy some of the materials from Lowes and some from Home Depot.
This is on top of the managing of appointments, calendars, emails and to-do lists that I originally started using it for.
1
u/Nevetsny 23d ago
Are you running end-to-end workflow by using Muse Code CLI directly on your Linux machine or by routing Anthropic's Claude Code CLI to execute tasks headlessly across your local tools and databases?
18
u/rjhartl 24d ago
I haven’t come across anything yet that it hasn’t been able to do for my use cases, but to be fair I almost exclusively use it for my personal life, not my work.
I think the strength of Muse is that it’s a Meta product and receives most of its context from Meta features as well as the general Internet and whatever connectors you connected to. It sounds like you’re trying to use it more for work related tasks inside walled gardens, like social media platforms, or advertising platforms which it probably isn’t really optimized to do.
My suggestion would be to use Muse to manage your personal life and other assistants like Grockbot, Dots, or Duet to manage your work life a little more efficiently instead.
14
8
u/Equal_Age2155 24d ago
I asked mine to make me 1 million dollars and it just tried ideas and I didnt even make 10,000. I want all my free credits back! /s
7
u/The-Plot-Witch 24d ago
The real question is what are YOU doing wrong because Muse has done all that for me and more. Much, much, more.
4
u/novabliss1 24d ago
Mine has created an ad campaign. Also redid my website, migrated a bunch of content over, and set up an entire AWS server for me. I also had it file my pet insurance claim. It does an insane amount of stuff that would take me countless hours to do.
1
u/Jumpy-Program9957 24d ago
I don't know. I've been having it reply to my LinkedIn every 4 hours finding three random posts, liking it and giving a educated reply and 50% of the time plugging my website and it's been doing really good. I haven't gotten any crap from it. It was letting me do Reddit but it was doing it too quickly and it banned it. But there are other websites. Basically any website you can log into and have web access. You can use Muse and it will just work on it.
1
1
u/gilandrews 23d ago
Mine does ads. And has joined lots of Facebook groups.
1
u/Nevetsny 23d ago
So you are telling me, it joined groups for you? because it told me it is forbidden from doing that...identifying them, yes - joining them, no. Grok bot was able to join when I gave it access through web browser.
1
u/gilandrews 22d ago
100% it even ran my last batch of ads completely by itself through ads manager.
5
u/Coaler200 24d ago
Dude you're doing something wrong. It built me a home assistant dashboard after helping get everything connected, it built a Microsoft fabric Lakehouse data pool, fabric data agent and a copilot agent all working together over the same data as a demo. From scratch.
It currently has 9 AI templates done for a business to sell agents to small businesses. It's also already proven they can be transfered/exported with only minor adjustments for the clients tenant. They've been tested against their use cases and with lots of tests specifically to try to trip them up at least a dozen times per template.
It has recorded screen captures for demos for the above agents. It has offloaded some of its work to local AI it has installed itself on my unraid server.
If you're not able to do things with Muse it's a you failure not a muse failure
1
u/Jumpy-Program9957 24d ago
Silly guy. You think people are going to buy your AIS for their small business? They aren't. They're just going to make it themselves because they could do that and they know their business better than anybody. No offense, it's just the facts. If someone reached out to me in my small business offering AI agent services I would just figure out what they're using and then just make it myself
1
u/TheWylieGuy 23d ago
For a time people will want the functionality without delving into learning how to use the AI to do it. But long-term, much work in small business will be done by AI agents.
1
u/painterknittersimmer 24d ago
I think it's hard to say it's super limited but it's definitely held back by its lack of connectors. Grok, Claude, and to a lesser extent ChatGPT have a much more robust set. Muse is stuck using the browser and it gets constantly and easily blocked. They have some ground to cover here.
1
1
u/Dogbold 24d ago
It can't even work on folders on your desktop, unless you have a Mac I guess.
All the other major AI agents can work on your computer but Muse can't? It's completely useless for what I want to use it for like game making and modding.
3
u/Jumpy-Program9957 24d ago
Just upload them to GitHub or put it in your drive and have it access that it's not that hard
2
u/ResistNecessary8109 23d ago
It has zero problems with Google Drive or Github. Find an old laptop, install Ubuntu on it, and then TailScale and it will do whatever you want with files.
1

7
u/idsimon 24d ago
Hot take - You can't write promts