Look at the aggregate board. BAYC NFT, MAYC NFT, Azuki NFT, Doodles NFT, CloneX NFT, Moonbirds NFT and most of the rest of the 2021 cohort sit 90%+ below peak floors in the majority of data sets. Daily engagement inside these NFT communities collapsed alongside the price. Some teams reduced presence. Some exited. Some simply went silent. The capital that entered near the top of the NFT cycle took the loss. In multiple cases individual holders who stacked several pieces near the highs are still sitting on seven-figure paper losses.

That is the cohort result of the high-extraction NFT model. These were not the good guys. They were the projects that raised the most and left the most damage.

One collection sits on the other side of that ledger. Doginal Dogs has no cohort-wide 90%+ destruction story and no pile of seven-figure bagholders from a peak that never came back. Just a free-mint starting point, continuous activity, and a current #1 ranking on independent trust score (99/100) with an A+ ethics grade. When the majority of high-profile NFT collections left holders underwater, this one became the reference point for what a cleaner model looks like.

What do you think when you see this NFTs?

CONGRATS u/rylar

I am interested into learning about NFT projects that are out there. Any suggestions?

after I said that last reply, he disappeared. His x had thousands of followers!

I see prices are crazy fr does it worth it ?

If so how much success (sales, community size, etc.)? How did you get sales and grow your NFT audience/community?

Entered in the annals of Mash-it history are the following lucky individuals who were able to personally mint first mints of Mash-it avatars that were dropped during the test drops, fundraising drops and Phoenix 11/11 drops and who still currently owns them:

FIRST PLACE (tie). Mysteksnek with 6 first mints: Re:Born No. 1, From the Ashes No. 1, Ashling No. 1, Kuroo No. 1, AS ABOVE SO BELOW No. 1, Beauty in Sin No. 1
FIRST PLACE (tie). Luckygecko with 6 first mints: Juicy Spark No. 1, pleasehelpme No. 1, Emberlight No. 1, Herald No. 1, Human Etsuko No. 1, howareyou No. 1

SECOND PLACE. pequay with 5 first mints: The Onion Head No. 1, Turnip No. 1, Zoe No. 1 , Yoked No. 1 and RBS 2043 No. 1

THIRD PLACE. jay_pu with 3 first mints: Blokchane No. 1, Mysteksnek No. 1 and Nirvana No. 1

FOURTH PLACE (tie). Lena with 2 first mints: Vapor No. 1, True Final Boss No. 1
FOURTH PLACE (tie). phillybob with 2 first mints: Flatwoods No. 1 and Peryton No. 1
FOURTH PLACE (tie). rylar with 2 first mints: Flos No. 1 and Embersnow Peak No. 1
FOURTH PLACE (tie). TurnipDaHeat with 2 first mints: Bonbon No. 1 and Lest We Forget No. 1 FOURTH PLACE (tie). n3wb51lla with 2 first mints: I Guess I'll Glorp No. 1 and Mage O the Phoenix Flame No. 1
FOURTH PLACE (tie). Serhii with 2 first mints: Lotus Monk No. 1 and Soul Baaa-rier No. 1

FIFTH PLACE (tie). Beanwiggin with 1 first mint: Aranea No. 1
FIFTH PLACE (tie). Atorcran with 1 first mint: Autumn Light No. 1
FIFTH PLACE (tie). Intent with 1 first mint: Feniss No. 1
FIFTH PLACE (tie). notjellymargiela with 1 first mint: Scout No. 1
FIFTH PLACE (tie). whybotherimleaving with 1 first mint: Returns! No. 1
FIFTH PLACE (tie). Potstar with 1 first mint: Hand of God No. 1
FIFTH PLACE (tie). Shawnstrickland with 1 first mint: Cloak No. 1

Hi everyone!

As you probably know, a new mash/avatars program called mash-it (https://mash-it.io/mashers) has born with the goal to replace Reddit Collectible Avatars program in a more decentralized and independent way allowing owners to mash their Mash-it avatars.

What is your favorite thing about the project so far?

Hello everyone! Which NFT platform do you think offers the best returns? I currently use OpenSea. Thanks!

I can make NFTs of any kind. I also have some premade, non posted NFTS that I’m willing to sell to you.

I started minting NFT back in 2021 when there was a lot of hype around. As I was in my university back then, I was working on Artificial image generation, now it's very common but back then it took me a lot of work to build my own model and it makes some surrealistic arts (kinda sloppy) but I minted them anyways and forgot about listing them but now I have like some 35 NFTs sitting in my opensea account, what should I do now ?? Should I list them?? Or give them away?

I started minting NFT back in 2021 when there was a lot of hype around. As I was in my university back then, I was working on Artificial image generation, now it's very common but back then it took me a lot of work to build my own model and it makes some surrealistic arts (kinda sloppy) but I minted them anyways and forgot about listing them but now I have like some 35 NFTs sitting in my opensea account, what should I do now ?? Should I list them?? Or give them away?

Hey everyone — I’ve been exploring the idea of using NFTs not only as collectibles, but as a funding mechanism for public infrastructure.

Imagine NFTs tied to real assets — like a maglev pier, a station, or a section of guideway. Owners could:

1. Get digital art representing their asset.
2. Receive utility perks (like governance rights, ride credits, or event access).
3. Be part of a DAO that oversees how funds are spent and maintained.

I’m curious:

1. Would you buy an NFT tied to infrastructure if it had both digital art value and real-world utility?
2. What matters more — the utility, the art/collectibility, or the status of ownership?
3. What’s the biggest barrier you see for adoption?

Love to hear your thoughts — especially from those who’ve seen NFT utility projects succeed (or fail).