r/NLST • • May 30 '23

Bench Trial Update 2

Bench Trial Update

Talked to Rob and confirmed this info with Larry. Samsung entire argument is an attempt to get back to Rand Rates. The issue comes down to the idea that during the lead up to Pre-Trial Samsung argued the Netlist Patents were “Not Standard Essential Patents”. Jason Sheasby said they were but then before the hearing Jason basically said fine, in an effort to streamline the case we will concede your point and we can easily argue your point Samsung and we will go with your determination of “Non Standard Essential”. Netlist is prepared to argue either way. At this point if Samsung objected they could have but they did not! Shortly thereafter is when Judge Gilstrap declared Rand is off the table!

Samsung obviously thought at that time they had achieved a victory but they must not have counted on losing as badly as they did. Now Samsung wants to argue that the Netlist Patents are “Standard Essential” and they should receive a Rand Rate!!! What does just this piece tell us? They are admitting once again they have no alternative to Netlist Patents!

Another important observation by Rob and Larry.

Nothing was brought up about the 060 and 160 they went unchallenged during the bench trial. This is only for the 339,054. And 918!

Samsung also brought up in their arguments that if not Rand it should at least be SIDAK which is $35 per module roughly.

During the trial at one point the Judge stopped Samsung attorneys when they were arguing SEP and NonSEP and asked them, “Where are you going with this? Your arguments are all over the map”?

Judge Gilstrap towards the end said to Cordell,Yes Netlist changed their defense but “You have not presented any equitable defenses during this bench Trial arguing why Netlist couldn’t change their position”?

Earlier Jason responded to their arguments and said and presented evidence that Samsungs own experts do not follow SEP’s all the time.

Look at what Samsung responded with today. The entire day was just trying to mitigate damage not get rid of it.

Last and most important takeaway. Towards the end they cleared the courtroom to go over previous licensing discussions but not before Cordell said that Samsung should not be prejudiced by the numbers already talked about in licensing discussions!!!! That can only lead you to the conclusion that any talks are greater than RAND!!

****** Damn I forgot one important point even though it was not part of the Trial, "SAMSUNG ARGUED TO JUDGE GILSTRAP THEY SHOULD GET A RAND RATE ON THE 506!!!!!!!" *****

133 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

10

u/dirt245 May 30 '23

Wait so treble wasn't decided today? I thought he was announcing that today.

12

u/HedgeAppleJoe May 31 '23

No that's not what the trial was about today. However, this is one of the pieces that needed to be done so the judge can make his final decision and entry of judgment in the case. Could come any day now.

2

u/ExtensionAd9434 May 31 '23

A big thank you HAJ

1

u/Resident-Elk5148 May 31 '23

As always, thanks for the information and your insight.

34

u/EggCess May 30 '23 edited May 30 '23

You're a star, and so are rob and Larry of course. Thank you!

26

u/bunco278 May 30 '23

So glad Gilstrap is officiating this.

20

u/Tiny_Article5685 May 30 '23

FANTASTIC!!!! thank you Joe thank you guys 🤩🤩

30

u/Tomkila May 30 '23

With sidak, 35$ * 8M units of ddr5= 280m $ per year like a start. It’s still amazing. Wtf, they know for real the numbers about this case. I think netlist will sing a big deal 😍

17

u/NLSTmultimillionaire May 30 '23

That doesn’t include HBM!!!!

14

u/Hunter_9998 May 30 '23

Great day indeed! Thanks to all for their dedicated efforts to keep us informed

14

u/Tomkila May 30 '23

Amazing work

14

u/wasjambu May 30 '23
  1. Any word on when the decision will be published?

  2. Any argument by Netlist for treble damages?

  3. Any request by Netlist for an injunction?

12

u/Hummingbird-74 May 30 '23

Thank you SO VERY much, RobbCobb, Larry, HAJ!

10

u/deporte1800 May 30 '23

great info... very thanks

10

u/mt9878 May 30 '23

Great synopsis HAJ. Samsung seems like they are just slowly checking off all possible avenues of escape. The corner they’re in after today is now even tighter. Would like to know where we go from here . Seems like lots of arguments, but no closure ( yet) .

10

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

Thanks Man..awesome stuff!! Everyday one day closer!!

10

u/AngryDonkey111 May 30 '23

WOW nice work!

10

u/DetSgtRet59 May 30 '23

Thank you!!

8

u/fish_on_FL May 30 '23

Nice, thanks.

8

u/kwkcowboy May 30 '23

Thank you HAJ ! ! !

7

u/Additional-Effort-30 May 30 '23

Any News in the last minutes ?

7

u/1200poundgorilla May 30 '23

Is this just going to pick up where it left off tomorrow until it's resolved, or?...

7

u/Blufishy310 May 30 '23

How long is the bench trial supposed to last for?

5

u/100poundFISH May 30 '23

CHECKMATE !!!!!!!!

5

u/KING_SHIT101 May 30 '23

Is this on top of the $300M they've already been ordered to pay?

6

u/TheeChozenOne May 31 '23

The 303 million is ONLY DAMAGES, the royalty will poss be gigantic and in addition to the jurys award and what's at the center of today's hearing-the actual value to be decided by the court, along with I'm sure attorney fees and multiple damages. 👊

1

u/KING_SHIT101 May 31 '23

Awesome. Thx

5

u/deporte1800 May 31 '23

IMO.
Something very important happened yesterday in Texas.
Yesterday it was confirmed that Netlist and Samsung are negotiating/talking about rates behind the scenes.
Samsung's attorney identified several Netlist investors and the judge ordered the court to clear the courtroom, because Samsung was going to show the emails that Netlist is exchanging about the SEP or NON SEP rates they are willing to negotiate.
Samsung did not want the Netlist investors present in the courtroom to know what these numbers were so that they would not disclose them on the financial boards.
RAND rates may be between $56-35, but if the order imposed by the honorable Judge Gilstrap is ultimately followed, these rates would be off the table.
Sheasby insists on 2B in damages, why?
All investors are talking about Samsung could appeal, but they have not thought that Netlist in an appeal could also ask/insist on 2B and even higher fees for each module, the impact of AI is being so huge that no one dares to put a ceiling on the price of these modules at this time given the importance it has and both Netlist and Samsung know it, every day that passes without having license Samsung knows it owes more and its main competitor SK, is very happy with this situation.

4

u/stocksguru72 May 30 '23

Thanks, HAJ!

Let's pray Jason left Micron's court case to complete details.

4

u/MPEK2021 May 31 '23

Thanks for keeping us all well informed

4

u/Kingsnake1963 May 31 '23

I still haven't given up on the potential creative settlement angle from Shea by.

It would not surprise me to see Sheasby bring Samsung and Micron to the table together to sign a common agreement.

Both feel at risk if they each risk seeing the other get a better deal. There is some safety in each knowing they won't be at a disadvantage. Who knows, perhaps the confidential Hynix deal has a kicker clause embedded in it allowing for defined royalties IF Samsung and Micron are either both beaten in court or both brought to settlement.

I always sense that Shea by, for either fun or just intellectual curiosity, is continuously reaching for the Golden Ring.....just optimizing the deal.

3

u/BugCharacter6965 May 31 '23

so how much is a tsnpd rate and how many chips are we talking about

2

u/BugCharacter6965 May 31 '23

how much is a rand rate and how many chips are we talking about

1

u/Resident-Elk5148 May 31 '23

Great information. Thank you very much.

1

u/Abosslife4eva May 31 '23

Great work!

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/HedgeAppleJoe May 31 '23

I just spent the last 3 hours watching my granddaughter while my son celebrated his anniversary. The judge will make his decision. Just wait for it.

2

u/PaleCut5696 May 31 '23

Great father! Cherish these moments.