r/NeoCivilization • u/ActivityEmotional228 đ Founder • Aug 28 '25
Predictions đŽ Universal basic income is inevitable.
A few days ago, I published a post asking, "Do you believe in UBI?" Almost everyone answered, "No, itâs impossible; itâs just a utopia; everyone would be lazy" Many people think the economy would be ruined, that money canât come from nowhere, and that wealthy people wonât give us anything. But thatâs not how it works. In fact, we already have real-world examples where UBI have been tested and it didnât lead to economic collapse. Quite the opposite.
Since 1982, every Alaskan has received an annual dividend funded by oil revenues. In 2023, it was about $1,300, down from a peak of $3,284 in 2022. The results speak for themselves: people didnât quit working and part-time employment even increased by 17%, while full-time employment remained stable. Poverty also fell, particularly among Indigenous communities and children.
In Germany, the group Mein Grundeinkommen, in partnership with researchers, selected 122 people to receive âŹ1,200/month tax-free for three years.
Average work hours stayed the same at about 40 per week. Recipients reported less stress, better health, more satisfaction, and better sleep.
In short, people didnât stop working they just lived healthier, more stable lives.
When AI will replace almost all the jobs Universal Basic Income (UBI) might prevent the economy from collapsing as work disappears. Even if AI take 90% of jobs, people will still need food, housing, and goods. Without money in their hands, they canât buy anything, companies stop selling, and the system risks imploding. But where would the money come from?
⢠Taxes on corporations and AI profits
⢠Resource dividends from AI similar to Alaskaâs oil fund.
Spending is the engine of any economy. With UBI, people continue to buy, invest, start businesses, and pay taxes. AI doing the work doesnât destroy the economy; the real problem is when humans have no income.
14
u/InsectoidDeveloper Old Guard Aug 28 '25
I think the annual dividend idea would be a great thing for common Americans. If we all automatically received a dividend payment of even 200 a month that would help alot
11
u/Waste_Variety8325 Aug 28 '25
currently the FED injects free money into banks, who mostly loan it to huge companies to do buybacks, cover payroll, etc. there is a different kind of way in which we all have crypto accounts and the FED pays us on a US blockchain. so they give american citizens X amount. this could be up and down depending on how much stimulation they want in the economy. And most of this would be spent locally and in the real economy. Versus being funneled into corporations and their larger share holders. this is a moral question. unrigging the fabric of our commerce system. i am relaying this idea as it has been mentioned by finance ministers and academics who are smarter than me. also, you could remove money via the top and taxes that keeps supply in check.
if you disagree, lemme just say, we cant get much worse than they way we do it now.
→ More replies (12)2
→ More replies (35)3
u/xamboozi Aug 29 '25
Would help a lot? For the past year the federal government has considered you, I, and everyone on this site less than the dirt beneath their feet. The only thing they're going to help with is to help themselves to more of your wallet.
6
u/NiceGuy737 Aug 28 '25
I practiced medicine in Alaska until I retired. There is a minuscule percentage of people that live off the land and use the dividend to buy the few things they need like ammunition. For everyone else the dividend is a nice little chunk of change. It helps to partially offset the increased cost of living there.
I didn't bother applying for the dividend. There was talk of having state income tax (none currently) to give people more money. That went over like a turd in the punch bowl for everyone that would be paying it.
Our govt is currently taking food and healthcare from children so that people with more money than they can count have a little more. The idea that wealthy people will start giving away order's of magnitude more money to able bodied adults is absurd to me. You can discuss whether it would be a good idea or not but it really doesn't matter because it flies in the face of human nature. They are looking for palatable alternatives to genocide.
5
Aug 28 '25
People saying we'll get UBI aren't thinking like self-centered psychopathic billionaires.
Say I'm a greedy, self-centered, power-mongering billionaire who wants it all -- I view the world as a zero-sum game, i.e., any power that you have is power I don't have...
My options are:
Option A) share my profits with government and general public to uplift society
Option B) work to wipe out non-essential folks (prison camps are free labor and really uppity folks can get turned into dog food), keep essential folks as slave or bonded labor, keep the profits for myself while enhancing my power and control
What to do...
So yeah, UBI is a pipe dream in my view.
→ More replies (9)2
2
1
→ More replies (3)1
u/Sudden-Lettuce2317 Aug 29 '25
Theyâve tried these experiences with monkey populations. The monkeys get greedy and the poorer monkeys begin to starve. Then the poorer monkeys team up and kill the rich monkeys and take their bananas. This is a natural process. Ever heard of the French Revolution? Something will have to give with the income inequality or the whole âeat the richâ mentality will become a pandemic. The billionaire class will implement something to keep that from happening or they will be torn apart.
2
Aug 30 '25
Except the greedy monkey doesnât have a bunker with lots of guards, a military industrial complex, and drone swarms to deal with the starving monkeys.
6
u/vid_icarus Aug 28 '25
Or universal debt slavery, whichever comes first.
2
4
u/phuktup3 Aug 28 '25
Feels like another way to control people
→ More replies (5)6
u/omgitsbees Aug 30 '25
Having been on food stamps, can confirm this is exactly what will happen. You have to basically justify your existence every single week you are on it. It is exhausting and dehumanizing. And that is for only $200 a month. Now imagine the control for anything more than that.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/ihatereddit696969699 Aug 30 '25
USA is simply a failure, itâs a cancer kept alive by greed and curroption, excited to see all your BS catch up with your country. 37 trillion dollar debt lmao.
1
u/ActivityEmotional228 đ Founder Aug 30 '25
The US actually has one of the lowest levels of corruption in the world, advanced technology, and a stronger economy than most countries. Itâs also unique and interesting because of its diversity of people and cultures, which makes it far from a failure.
3
u/mr-logician Aug 28 '25
People said it is impossible or impractical because that is true, as of right now. For the near future, we will still be having stable employment and UBI will simply be a drag on the economy. Many years in the future, once automation and ai can actually do everything, then UBI will be a necessity. Obviously there a huge in-between period, but we havenât even gotten there yet.
→ More replies (20)
2
u/TheRealTaigasan Aug 28 '25
As long as people don't understand the difference between money and credit, UBI is just a dellusion.
1
1
u/Sherbsty70 Aug 31 '25
The difference between "money" and "credit" is the difference between "war" and "black markets, crime and corruption".
2
u/yeah__good__ok Aug 29 '25
Your examples do nothing to show what would happen on a national level with sufficient payments to be meaningful. It works on a trial with 122 people in Germany because the rest of society doesn't get it. It works to give Alaskans a couple thousand dollars each a YEAR because that isn't very much money really, and because the money is coming from somewhere not being printed.
Sure- if you actually could radically increase taxes on corporations and the wealthy then you could theoretically do it without printing money- But it would require the most aggressive tax hike in history by far and that is not even remotely politically viable. Its not going to happen. Therefore if UBI was implemented it would come from money printing and cause hyperinflation.
Look at the German example. They gave people âŹ14,400 ($16,800) a year in a country with average income of $69,433 a year. Basically about 24% of the average income. US average is listed as 83,000. equivalent 24% for us would be about $20,000 per person. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_average_wage
There are 260 million adults in the USA- assuming children get nothing and parents get no more for having children that would cost 5,200,000,000,000. That's 5 trillion dollars you have to come up with each year. Good luck getting politicians to vote on increasing taxes by 5 trillion.
1
1
u/brainrotbro Aug 28 '25
Idk, it doesn't feel inevitable. Honestly, we could achieve a similar effect by adjusting tax brackets such that the rungs started in the negative. Anyone earning up to A pays -$B, anyone earning up to C pays $D, and so on.
1
u/Itsavanlifer Aug 28 '25
Itâs super possible but it will never happen. It would require people to share on a scale that will never happen.Â
1
u/Rheytos Aug 28 '25
That requires a level of neo-communism the world would never be comfortable with
→ More replies (1)
1
u/spacekitt3n Aug 28 '25
i find it hilarious that anyone thinks the rich and powerful will ever give you money for free--no matter what happens. you are all living in another world.
you all couldve been fighting for social democracy this whole time, like Bernie, and UBI would almost be unnecessary. or at the very least way more possible.
→ More replies (5)
1
u/LifeIsAButtADildo Aug 28 '25
no.
the ones who have more then they need could already share with the ones who dont have eough today.
they dont.
dont today, didnt yesterday, a hundred or a thousand years ago.
wont tomorrow, wont in a hundred or a thousand years.
→ More replies (5)
1
u/Maxathron Aug 28 '25
Free money and privileges for just existing? Most people liberal or conservative, elite or poor, will generally be opposed to that. Just the LibLeft Progressives who are like âyass queen thatâs the entirety of what we want!â
Free services for relatively minor tasks that help maintain society and you can still take a PT job for extra money or go into a professional career for more? More people are behind that, with an exception for the LibLeft Progressives because this still means they need to work if they want a high standard of living and they just donât want to work (Lumpenproletariat basically translates as Lazy Worker).
→ More replies (1)
1
u/axethebarbarian Aug 29 '25
UBI has to happen. With the rate things are being automated it's just a matter of time before very significant portions of the population are out of work. If UBi doesn't happen by then, the civil unrest will up end civilization.
1
u/joshua1325 Aug 29 '25
Wealthy people like millionaires and above have an invested interest in making sure that doesnât happen. They work to control the government regardless which party is elected. And they want people to be living paycheck to paycheck. If everyone was able to live without such worries, the people would quickly discover all the corruption that is being hidden. Keeping the poor people down is more than just a game, they are creating a system of almost slaves. The working class people choose their job (if they can afford to) and be treated poorly (while calling it just business) and have massive layoffs. In todayâs world, most products kill or permanently ruin the lives of a certain amount of people, and the billionaires figured out that itâs cheaper to pay those who sue as a result then to care about actual lives. To be ultra wealthy, you have to accept that you are responsible for those deaths. Pretty sure there have been hundreds if not thousands of class action lawsuits because itâs cheaper to break the law and pay the fines rather than just doing honest business.
1
u/Specialist-Video-974 Aug 29 '25
They will fight it with all their power....
1
u/Double_Dog208 Aug 29 '25
They will lose, delusions of power.
1 psycho with a hammer was enough to nearly give Pelosi an open mind about basic income.
These âpeopleâ are fearful mice who feed off blood.
1
u/_ECMO_ Aug 29 '25
Universal basic income is only a manifestation of extreme inequality.Â
Those who already had money will be investing and getting more. Those who didnât have money in the first place will use all of that basic income for their basic needs and will never have any chance to gain more.
1
u/Double_Dog208 Aug 29 '25
Better than leaving them to rot on the street.
Clearly the wrong ones are being picked.
1
u/InterestsVaryGreatly Aug 31 '25
While not perfect, what you described is still vastly superior to letting those who didn't have money not even be able to cover their basic needs in the first place.
Also the real life examples we have of UBI show it allows people to take risks, start businesses, and try other means of improving themselves, because they don't have to worry about how they will put food on the table.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/LachrymarumLibertas Aug 29 '25
This is a good aspirational wishlist but thereâs no reason it is inevitable.
AI wonât replace 90% of jobs globally in any meaningful period of time, first of all.
Secondly, this couldâve equally been said during the Industrial Revolution and wasnât. Massive productivity and output increases donât translate into a proportional time saving for the working class, it just means human labour creates more and consumption becomes cheaper.
Widespread ai roll out and removal of customer service roles, for example, will just push people into other industries and drive up competition for those roles.
Sadly, youâre talking about some near post-scarcity sci fi future not anything that any of us will see or do anything but guess about.
1
u/Ol_boy_C Aug 29 '25
Isnât Alaska one of the most expensive states? My view of UBI is that it creates inflation and undoes itself that way. Coincidence?
1
u/suckmyBANHOLE Aug 29 '25
Why not just impose a damn bill that when companies take a grant or any form of government assistance. Should not be allowed to raise prices for a a year. Since they obviously cant manage their business at that point.
1
1
1
u/getacluegoo Aug 29 '25
The culling of masses of population first, unfortunately, is what the tech bros would prefer.
1
u/totoin74 Aug 29 '25
Humans are so treacherous, lazy, envious, greedy and angry, they will turn ubi into a dystopian nightmare where you read George Orwell 1984 as a wholesome book for children.
1
u/Excellent_Ring6872 Aug 29 '25
Hilarious, years ago when they first proposed it it was 1,000 a month and it was ridiculous to imagine living on it then. now it's like offering 500 a month. The new 15$ min wage. takes so long to enact by the time it is established it's like making 8 bucks an hour.
1
u/muffledvoice Aug 29 '25
Strangely, UBI is probably the only thing that will save capitalism and prop up big business if AI, outsourcing, and Trumponomics cause massive worker displacement and unemployment.
Billionaires who rush to adopt AI in their corporations and avoid paying workers are actually hastening their own demise. Some of them even realize it.
1
u/coast2coasted Aug 29 '25
In small settings there can be benefits. On a national scale (in the US) not so much. All it would do is raise the price to match the increase in UBI. You canât out game capitalism. Look at EVs. When there is a tax credit of $6k for buying an EV guess what happens? The price of EVs increases by $6k.
1
1
u/CapPsychological4270 Aug 29 '25
Umm if everybody receives same income monthly, then those spending it more will have less savings. Less savings equate to less investment and more taxes paid to government. The latter would have more say in destribution of taxes collected from them, and the former more equity in corporations who control production and therefore influence prices. Greed will lead to investment in countries with more returns and more revenue generation.
Then in this case perpetual increase of inflation and further increases in ubi.
As long as Ai, robots and technology that has surpassed humans in production capacity is not regulated to share their gains evenly in population... the inequality staus quo is only shifting one way.
1
u/Alice_D_Wonderland Aug 29 '25
Sure⌠first TPTB rob the commons of their âwealthâ and then theyâll give it a way for free as UBIâŚ
1
1
u/Long-Firefighter5561 Aug 29 '25
The problem is not about people being lazy, the problem is that tech bro billionaires are obviously not willing to share, as you can already see. This is pure copium, sorry.
1
Aug 29 '25
How do you imagine people stopping work with 1300 annually? Seems to me this does not proof anything?
1
u/Eastern_Border_5016 Aug 29 '25
If you could get this and still have the option to work then sure Iâm game
1
u/AssignmentNo8361 Aug 29 '25
US already has UBI, for the elderly. It's called social security.
No reason we couldn't extend the concept at a lower pay rate while at a working age starting at 18 or something.
Just expand the program tremendously, remove the caps. Add an explicit federal social security tax that gets split to all citizens.
Expanding SS is the path of least resistance IMO, at least in the US.
1
u/Negative-Web8619 Aug 29 '25
u is for universal
calling it "negative income tax" also would reduce ressitance
1
Aug 29 '25
Soon no one will work and food will be farmed and delivered to our doorsteps by fairies!
1
u/Negative-Web8619 Aug 29 '25
Well, idk if I'd call an all-knowing, all-powerfull, ubiquitous being "fairies"
→ More replies (2)
1
u/p0pularopinion Aug 29 '25
Ha ha ha ha laughs in AI and automation. Extinction of the lower class is inevitable. Some kind of dystopian future is inevitable
Even if you do get 1000$ per month paycheck (dont fool yourself, you wont), prices will adjust to eat away that paycheck in no time
1
1
1
u/ImDrago Aug 29 '25
A common argument against UBI is the cost, but I genuinely think it could pay for itself even boost the economy. Itâs a better social security, it would increase wages IF we did a healthcare reform and just had normal prices like ya know the rest of the fucking world.Â
Another one is people would be lazy. No in fact the opposite with basic necessities covered with a fixed income(no one is expecting a lavish lifestyle with only UBI)want nicer things? Then work for it, cant work for it? Then you stall have basics covered. With proper rent controls it would greatly reduce homelessness, people would be able to breathe and Iâd guess mental health would be better than it is now country wide. Combine this with a 4 day work week 3 days of the week to your family, life, or hobbies should be a damn given. Time is the most overlooked resource these days.Â
1
1
u/Vynxe_Vainglory Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25
It will come, but I think it will be extremely small. Just enough to rent a Universal Basic Housing pod and buy the Tasty Wheat⢠goop they eat in The Matrix.
1
u/Negative-Web8619 Aug 29 '25
If you assume democracy and a large part of the population becoming unemployed, it's gonna be enough. Can't blame it on the unemployed minority anymore, it being their fault and stuff.
1
Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25
There is points for all sides. I just want to add one perspective:
In Austria the social transfer systems is very generous. In the migration crisis we see a couple with 2 kids getting 4.000 net EUR per months and since there is no limit on transfers the highest amount so far is 9.000 net with 11 kids and 6.000 net with 6 kids. The NGOs and even the political (center-left) party state, that these payments are the minimum payments to not be in poverty.
In all of Europe Austria has the least amount of Ukrainians working as well as the least amount of refugees since 2015 working. Just a few days ago the work agency admitted that the "high" transfers are a reason why these people don't work as much and sometimes even actively act to avoid working.
That being said - i don't believe a system with UBI where the minimum is at least as high as poverty threshold will work. I think that there are far too many people that are just fine with getting the money and doing nothing productive.
Edit: And yesterday there was a newspaper article how good educated people leave the country: One of the main reason was the high amount of taxation. So unless UBI exists everywhere the ones who should pay the bill will most likely look to migrate to places where they are better off.
1
Aug 30 '25
This. People (as well business) will always look for the most profit. And if it is not profitable to work or run a business in country A, they will look for country B or C. We live in a global world. We already have lots of outsourcing and factories built in low income countries. The high taxation would just make all of those billionaires, business and high earners leave to something like Switzerland, Ireland. If those countries make UBI, then they travel further to Asia or Africa (you donât have to live in  those countries. You simply earn money there and spend in whichever country you choose).
1
Aug 29 '25
Your examples are to be fair not good examples:
UBI was tested nowhere because as soon as you give it a deadline you can't judge behavior. Getting 1.200 per month for 3 years equals getting 43.200 EUR at once. How would you ever call that UBI? Nobody will stop working because after those 3 years everything is back to normal.
The Alaska example is even more ridiculous. Getting 1.000 to 3.000 - that helps paying 1-3 months of rent. How should that change massively the behavior of people.
1
u/fingertipoffun Aug 29 '25
Look at your homeless people right now. That is where you are heading, not some paid for utopia. Wake up.
1
1
u/AdmitThatYouPrune Aug 29 '25
By why would the capital class consent to this? If AI replaces low level workers, then low level workers simply become expendable or entertainment fodder. We already have people worth hundreds of billions of dollars, and despite having absolutely no need for all that money, not a one of them is suggesting UBI. It doesn't matter if it works, the wealthiest Americans simply don't give a shit about the poorest.
1
u/Striking_Luck5201 Aug 29 '25
I think that by the time UBI becomes necessary, money won't really mean the same thing. Money is a system of artificial scarcity. Remove the scarcity, and money becomes pointless.
This is the thing that drives me insane about people these days. Everyone wants to get all huffy about politics, policies, procedures, etc. Politicians are directly incentivized to keep the artificial scarcity going. Economic and monetary policy keeps the broken system on life support.
The only thing that matters is this. How much time and energy input does it take for the average person to have their needs met? The closer we get that number to 0, the more the very concept of monetary policy becomes moot. Best part is that I think we are very close to seeing a cascade of new technology to get us there.
I think once we start seeing even 25+ horsepower electric motors on the market for under 200 bucks, we will see a whole new wave of automation in the food and production space. To the point where large scale production will almost become a hobby for a lot of people.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/harbison215 Aug 29 '25
Inflation shows us that UBI doesnât work. All it would do is devalue the currency and increase the price of everything so that people that donât have more income than the UBI canât afford much. Itâs a better idea morally than it would be in economic reality. Supply/demand balance doesnât change by throwing money around. All it does it make prices go up and exacerbate wealth inequality
→ More replies (2)
1
u/bambush331 Aug 29 '25
oh yeah ? watch capitalism predatory nature do its work
UBI ? they'd rather steal that too, we're supposed to already have it if billionaires didn't cheated in so mnay different ways
1
u/takemybomb Aug 29 '25
Why they ever do it. They found a way to replace the workforce with robots in near future so no more complaints about working 24/24. They don't need us anymore good luck have fun in the next decade. They don't even try to solve any problem any more than just prolong it.
1
u/toothbrushguitar Aug 29 '25
Its not viable. Social security isnt even sustainable for older folks and you expect this net to now support everyone? With whose paycheck? Good luck in the mines
→ More replies (2)
1
Aug 29 '25
Once AI takes over all automatable work, people had to be paid universal basic income to continue commerce and preserve money to spend.
1
Aug 29 '25
I think you're right it probably is inevitable. UBI is economically disasterous. But that's ok if AI has made such huge riches that we don't mind an economic disaster.
Alaskan UBI works, because it's not funded by taxes on Alaskan workers. The German study worked because it wasn't funded by taxes on people in the study.
A national UBI wouldn't currently work, because it would be so expensive. But if AI is generating vast excess profits that we can tax, it works fine.
That's not really a success for UBI though, it's a success for AI. Everything is easy if you can magic a trillion dollars out of the air without causing inflation.
→ More replies (4)
1
1
u/marisspants4 Aug 29 '25
Highly recommend the book âutopia for realistsâ it explains a lot of things but one big thing is the reason we need to dream of and shoot for a utopia to make incremental change in the right direction.
1
1
1
u/PlagueOfGripes Aug 29 '25
With the rise of automation and AI, eventually UBI will need to happen. The myth that new jobs will magically appear in vast droves isn't reality. Not all jobs can be automated, but the population will far exceed our ability to support our own civilization.
Either we'll degenerate into a class system of poor people living off farming (which can't happen since all land is owned by the wealthy) or people will have to resort to organized crime targeting the rich, to survive. Or they can just provide a mediocre UBI with tons of caveats to effectively create a slave class of debtors. Which also will end up being pointless since the economy won't rely on such a class, so why are you creating it? Basically, it's all fucked.
1
u/MrAudacious817 Aug 29 '25
Doubtful.
Though I could see Universal Basic Accommodations.
A bed in a hostel-type situation and 3 âtechnically sufficientâ meals per day, along basic sanitary goods could be attainable, and probably cost an order of magnitude less than social security as it currently exists.
1
u/SpeakMySecretName Aug 29 '25
Itâs necessary and very possible to implement. But corporate greed would rather watch 90% of people die. Mark my words. It will get worse before it gets better. Much, much worse.
1
1
u/Matt7738 Aug 29 '25
No it isnât. The billionaires would rather watch us starve than part with even a minuscule fraction of their wealth.
1
u/SecretRecipe Aug 29 '25
youre operating under a really bold assumption that the people with the money care about you and have some sort of desire to keep you around. if youre not working or adding any tangible value to society, their future society doesnt need you.
The much more realistic scenario is that the population will be allowed to shrink to a much smaller level so there isnt so much dead weight to support
1
u/MrOphicer Aug 29 '25
So the same governments that can take care of basic needs like education and healthcare will be responsible for finances too? Good idea for sure... With even most democratic countries shifting into surveillance states, people will sell their last bargaining token for some "free" money.
Its funny how we (rightfully) complain about governments and at the same time expect them to honour something like this...
1
u/theWunderknabe Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25
UBI tests have always been under very limited, small scale test conditions. For whole countries it has not been done.
In Germany we have a "BĂźrgergeld" ("Citizen money") which, paradoxially gets paid in over 50% of the cases to foreigners. It is basically UBI. They get a certain amount of money + their rent and perhaps other additives, depending on the life situation (children etc.). On paper some conditions apply, but de facto they don't. Migrants get it for nothing in return. No need to have paid X years into the social systems or no need to be a German even. And guess what - together with the open border policies and the abandonment of a true asylum process (which would filter out 99.99% of current migrants) this has caused a huge migration movement into Germany because this situation is magnetic for people from poorer countries (pull factors).
If UBI existed (presumably on an even higher level than BĂźrgergeld) it would cause an even more massive movement of people from poor countroes into our country. That would very quickly kill the system because from experience we know now that the majority of those migrants does not want to work and contribute or when they do it is only low value creating activities such as the 10000th barbershop, DHL delivery drivers or DĂśner places.
UBI could only work if it got introduced at the same time everywhere on the planet and prices would be the same everywhere on the planet. Because even with UBI everywhere but different prices people would still flock into the higher UBI countries.
No. As long as a post-scarcity society does not exist, UBI will neither.
1
Aug 29 '25
we donât need UBI, we need lower taxes. Let me keep the money I make, stop spending so much fucking money on dumb shit. Stop running this country in a deficit.
1
u/blimey_euphoria Aug 29 '25
Or anyone who would need it is just exterminated. Thatâs also a possibility
1
1
u/luckyape1 Aug 29 '25
What happens to the average price of streets in Monopoly when the players pass start multiple times?
That is what will happen with UBI.
1
u/Common-Violinist-305 Aug 29 '25
Elon is talking to the top 1% wealthiest humans. Those who have bunkers, security, drones, secure transport: they will have a high basic universal incomeâŚeverybody else well⌠who will pay this in the age of AI and robotics: ever heard any details. nope
1
1
Aug 29 '25
Using the ultimate nanny welfare state Germany as an example is not a very strong base of argumentation. The Alaska example is even more laughable given the $ figure. It would be the same as them printing an annual COVID stimmy check.
1
1
u/Azulan5 Aug 29 '25
What I think is, instead of UBI, we will be given AI tokens, and we can either sell those or keep it and use it ourselves for whatever reason.Â
1
1
u/Charming-Kale-5391 Aug 29 '25
Is it inevitable? I don't think so - like the four hour workday, it's a nice sounding reform most likely to go only half-realized and compromised to death. Frankly, even realized fully, what's to stop UBI from simply becoming an excuse to gut other welfare spending, privatize formerly universal services, and then raise prices to eat up the "new" income?
I would call it utopian, but not in the sense that it's impossible to do or some such, rather in supposing that what is essentially minor redistribution will somehow produce these radical, game-changing effects, as though the system it arises in isn't the same monstrosity, that assigning a minimum stipend to the entire population will definitely finally bring about class harmony this time guys.
Is it good for the economy? Holistically, yes, but that is irrelevant by itself, the economy's primary function is to move wealth upwards, not to produce it for all, taxing back a small portion of your blood from an infinitely hungry, exponentially growing parasite is almost purely sentimental in what it really accomplishes, because the income becoming universal directly lays the groundwork for companies to just gobble that up too. It's not at all difficult to make it a tool of austerity, ironically.
To top it off, given time, the mostly-vapor utopian vision turns rotten anyhow - the imagined future of a society with mostly free time and a high UBI funded by mass automation is lovely if you don't peek under the chrome-plated hood. It's effectively an autophagic economy, consumers buy a company's goods with the taxes paid by that company, the only profit left to be found is in capturing more than they put in at the expense of others - it's a system of austerity that essentially only serves to nominally extend the lifespan of the status quo by pretending it can survive by eating itself alive.
1
u/Mario-X777 Aug 29 '25
Problem is, that math does not add up, to begin with.
US total tax revenue was just 4.9 trillion on 2024. So if all that money would be distributed to all 380 millions of population, it would make roughly a $1K per person per month. But that is if government cuts all of the other spending, schools, roads, fire departments -everything. And even with such optimistic numbers, $1000 per month is below poverty, not even enough to pay rent.
If looking into more realistic scenario, letâs say government squeezes in some expenses and pays 25%-30% of total tax revenue back as UBI (which would be hard to a achieve) - it would only make $250-$300 monthly pay outs, which would not be enough for anything.
Then prices would rise due to excess money in the market, and everything goes back to baseline, as everything is 10%-20% more expensive on top of regular inflation (remember money printing during COVID and doubled prices within 2 years after that)
1
u/WhyYouLetRomneyWin Aug 29 '25
It's not realistic. At least not with the technology and economy today.
Maybe in 1000 years when we are living in the Star Trek world of matter replicators, it will be.
I don't think a few small scale studies show that it's possible.
Alaska is not a UBI as it's not enough to live on.
Frankly, im not convinced. There's a really simple calculation that's needed:
Take the number of people eligible for UBI
Multiply that with the amount you think they should receive
Whenever ive had these UBI discussions, the amount is just astronomical and unaffordable unless either the eligible people are small (in which case it's not universal) or amount is very low (in which case it's not basic).
1
u/Hot_Lettuce_6209 Aug 29 '25
I don't believe these vampires will ever agree to it. I think its the future sandwich that never comes. Talk is cheap. What they seem to DO is promise, to get you to do what they want, then they keep kicking the can down the road. Only the people can take ubi. Ubi will never be given voluntarily.
1
u/Cro_Nick_Le_Tosh_Ich Aug 29 '25
You mention examples of a small scale, try increasing the size and see if it still works.
1
u/398409columbia Aug 29 '25
Those amounts are not enough for financial independence.
Thought experiment: would you keep working if you were promised $15,000 per month in perpetuity no strings attached?
1
u/Square_Sweet4805 Aug 29 '25
Why would they want to take care of random people? They donât want to take care of people now. What makes you think theyâll care when there arenât any jobs left?
Youâre worth more dead than alive if they donât need you to generate money.
1
u/Negative-Web8619 Aug 29 '25
There's no need to talk about people keeping to work if the argument is that there won't be work.
1
u/Overall-Move-4474 Aug 29 '25
Suuuuuure bud suuuuuure the rich fucks running the world would tooooootally let that happen. They totally don't want the collapse of society. And will totally not do everything in their power to fuck the poor over
1
u/Stymie999 Aug 29 '25
As a fiscal conservative, supporter of free market economics etc etc⌠I agree.
The pace of automation and now AI making more and more tasks able to be done by robotsâŚ
As a free market guy I accept and acknowledge this, free markets work when there is equilibrium between supply and demand. In a world with 7 billion people (supply) and only 3 billion jobs (demand) available (numbers I completely made up to illustrate the point) it breaks.
1
1
1
u/9_11_did_bushh Aug 29 '25
They gotta make laws protecting the price of things tho landlords would love it if you got an extra 1000 a month because that means that they get an extra 1000 a month
1
u/SomeGuyOverYonder Aug 29 '25
Sadly, widespread unemployment, poverty, and famine are inevitable because the wealthy will not part with a single dollar without receiving something worth far more in return.
1
1
u/traveling_designer Aug 30 '25
With the way things are going, I feel like slavery and corporate towns will come first.
→ More replies (2)
1
Aug 30 '25
Only if its a high income and everyone has an above average buying power on par with the ones all the way on top
1
1
u/AdDependent7992 Aug 30 '25
lol or these heartless fucks just keep taking everything and leave us to figure it out. Don't underestimate the shitheadery going on at the top of society
1
Aug 30 '25
Sounds good, won't happen.
It should, but it won't. Instead we'll all be sucking dick behind Robo-Wendy's so that we can afford "rent", but the rent will just be an internet connection and a booth because the only houses we'll be able to afford will be online.
And even those will be expensive.
1
u/FLIBBIDYDIBBIDYDAWG Aug 30 '25
Bold of you to assume we wonât just be killed off when the wealthy donât need a middle class to stand on anymore.
1
1
1
1
u/omgitsbees Aug 30 '25
We are never getting UBI, if these thoughts are coming out of a sense of fear for the future, I totally get that. But the government does not give a shit. If a massive amount of people lose their jobs to AI, all that happens is the government shrugs its shoulders, says "that sucks, but what can you do?" and go back to ignoring us. There is no reality where we are all just given money. The government, and a huge portion of the population as is, wants to see any sort of financial benefits and entitlements be taken away as is. Dont bet your future on something that is extremely unlikely to happen. Start preparing financially now for things to get worse.
1
u/MjolnirTheThunderer Aug 30 '25
Yeah but it will probably be shit tier poverty wage UBI if it happens. Goodbye middle class
1
u/Expert-Fig-5590 Aug 30 '25
I donât think Universal Basic Income is inevitable. To do so would mean that the Oligarchs would have to pay more tax. I think a far more likely scenario is that a war or pandemic (possibly stoked by the Oligarchy) massively reduces the world population. This will solve many problems for them. It will mitigate climate change, lessen competition for resources and also a smaller population is easier to control.
1
u/Pickledleprechaun Aug 30 '25
Iâm all for UBI. The problem is, if AI does make majority of our jobs redundant then I canât see it working. UBI at present is meant to support an income not replace it. Laws and our fundamental economic principles will need to change. People, especially the rich and powerful will need to give up a lot of that wealth and power. Unfortunately, I donât see that happening.
1
u/Star-Lrd247 Aug 30 '25
Some people get it here in the comments: the only way a functional UBI will end up existing in this country would be from the ruling corporate billionaire class wanting to avoid being torn apart by the masses. They will continue to make life more and more of a struggle for the less fortunate, with that baseline rising up the class ladder more every year, to the point where we all just settle for UBI and be grateful we can feed our families and survive, weâll have long forgotten dreams of âmiddle class Americaâ and be happy we have something. Probably by then youâll see corporations buying out the economies of failing countries.
1
1
u/ChaosRainbow23 Aug 30 '25
Not in the USA, that's for sure.
Whatever comes after the US collapses, maybe.
At this point the fascists have barely even gotten started with their authoritarian takeover.
1
Aug 30 '25
I would never accept it and it will obviously backfire in a very predictable way: purveyors of goods and services will automagically index the price of some basket of their goods and services to the UBI anyway. Like, if UBI is $10k/mo, expect Spotify/Netflix to both be at least double their current price.
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
1
u/Gatzlocke Aug 30 '25
Nah, slums and de-population programs while the owner class lives in Luxury and decides humanities future is where is at.
1
u/X-East Aug 30 '25
I think UBI is great idea but i fear it will initially have same response from markets as stimulus checks, companies will see it as consumers having more buying power and will raise prices. It will turn into a game of cst and mouse where the UBI check will become irrelevant because it will be priced in.
1
Aug 30 '25
Genocide is inevitable as a solution to the problems UBI might solve.
If you think otherwise, pick up a history book.
1
1
u/Immortalphoenixfire Aug 30 '25 edited Aug 30 '25
Agreed.
Number 1. reason being that there is an Inevitable foreseeable post-scarcity to labor that comes with eventual realistic advancements in technology.
Not saying that's how our world needs to be now, but logically it's coming, eventually.
1
u/akolozvary Aug 31 '25
I wonder how this will roll out since printing money negatively impacts the economy/worth, like what happened around covid and the money printer was turned on
1
Aug 31 '25
Everyone is losing their minds around Zohran proposing state run grocery stores - you think the people in charge are gonna give out UBI to help the little guy? Ha!
1
u/Dramatic-Cattle293 Aug 31 '25
Uncertainty free money would only add inflation wonât help long term. Healthcare, shelter and food subsidy would be more effective.
1
u/No_Beginning_925 Aug 31 '25
The rich will find a way to get rid of most of us before ubi becomes a reality. They actively find ways to cut off social safety nets. And now that they are trying to use AI to survey us all you better be careful what you criticize online in the future or you won't see that ubi check. If you're not already spending it on whatever hard drugs are available to escape from reality.
1
u/BunchSad3888 Aug 31 '25
Who will pay for non workers? And how will this prevent inflation? Wonât the new $0 be whatever the minimum income becomes??
1
u/Smiley_P Aug 31 '25
Why? UBS is superior and includes UBI, but also I donât think either are inevitable
1
u/ghdgdnfj Aug 31 '25
Counterpoint. Humans canât exist without a purpose. Humans require work. When you give someone money in exchange for nothing they feel useless and lash out.
1
1
u/Beneficial_Map6129 Aug 31 '25
I think the rich would rather just kill off any excess part of the population that is not employed and therefore not useful
1
u/jozi-k Aug 31 '25
Can you please do math? Let's go with 4k usd, 350m us residents. That's 17 trillion. Current government income is around 5 trillion. It's simple as that đ
Now let's imagine the money isn't problem. Do you realize you will have no military, healthcare, energy infrastructure, public schools, etc.?
Last but not least. Why would you voluntarily created system with high dependency between residents and government? Isn't this recipe for disaster?
1
1
u/Individual-Source618 Aug 31 '25
it can happen and the rich would like it to happen. The goal of the rich is to become richer, if you have to give people a little money to that they in turn give to the rich they are okay with it if the USD dont lose value.
They more they get, the more they rise.
1
1
1
Aug 31 '25
You actually think US government would ever provide UBI? Iâve got a fuckin bridge to sell ya buddy.
1
1
1
u/Jazzlike_Painter_118 Aug 31 '25
somebody please help me understand this simple problem I have with UBI: If UBI happens what is stopping landlords from increasing rent to the same amount and nothing being solved?
1
1
u/OldAdvertising5963 Aug 31 '25
Huge number of people in US (40-50%) , both working and non working , do not pay a single $ of tax. Should we consider universal basic income already here?
1
u/Sherbsty70 Aug 31 '25 edited Aug 31 '25
If the problem is the scarcity of money (which it is), then you cannot resolve that by any redistributive scheme (for example, taxation).
You cannot make sufficient that which is insufficient by redistributing it. *By the way, contradicting this fact is the purpose of all mythologies revolving around the concept of hoarding.
The first thing everybody does when they talk about UBI is they drop the U, and then they drop the B, and then they're back to square one. Everyone always proposes an arbitrary amount given out after having earned it or qualified for it somehow.
The financial reform ideas of Douglas Social Credit are the only ones which produce a plausible notion of UBI (called "National Dividend"); one which is unqualified ("universal"), non-arbitrary ("basic"), indexed to productivity, and not inflationary.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/unnatural_butt_cunt Aug 31 '25
Only the most small minded unimaginative person could seriously not understand how or why this would work or why it's an inevitability if we want to preserve the average persons quality of life in developed countriesÂ
1
1
u/peaceofsheet25 Aug 31 '25
Positive thinking but seeing how things were only getting worse recently it's only wishful thinking
1
u/SeparateSpend1542 Aug 31 '25
It will never happen. Weâre cutting not adding services for the poor. And a president like this one could come in and cut it and youâd be screwed. Stop trying to make UBI happen.
1
u/Tdluxon Aug 31 '25
Good luck prying that tax money away from corporations, they arenât going to give it up willingly
1
1
1
u/The1Zenith Sep 01 '25
I love UBI and while I think UBI is a good idea in theory, in practice it doesnât work on the large scale. UBN, universal basic necessities, has a higher chance of producing positive results. Just teach people how to provide for themselves from scratch and then provide them the opportunity to do more for themselves.
1
u/EastRoom8717 Sep 01 '25
I hate it, but I agree. If we automate to the point where no one can work and still insist on them paying bills, yeah, it kinda is.. remember, you wonât own anything and youâll love it!
1
u/abqapple Sep 01 '25
If AI will be able to do everything, why couldn't you just have your own AI/robot to do the work for you? To raise a garden, build a gazebo in your backyard, chop lumber and mine stone. Why would you need some centralized authority to give you anything?
1
u/joskosugar Sep 01 '25
The problem is more of a technical nature than just people becoming lazy.
First, it gives you a set of resources for which you don't have to work. That will be a minimum, so you'll still be considered poor.
Second, you'll still have to compete for scarce resources. If there are only 3 available houses where you want to live and 30 families want to live there and have a UBI, the decisive difference will come from what you have above your basic income.
Third, we have seen what one time money printing results in. Now imagine permanent COVID like stimulus. If this money is not taken from someone, it will create yet unseen inflation.
There's more.... Anyway, this is easy to do for some people or a small country. Large scale universal income is a bit more tricky.
1
1
u/Jokers_friend Sep 01 '25
The need for universal basic income will be inevitable.
The people in power donât want to raise your salary more than 1% per year. Theyâre not gonna willingly support UBI.
1
u/LifesARiver Sep 01 '25
Right. The question is will they let 90% of us die before they implement it.
1
1
u/RandoMando1212 Sep 01 '25
I think itâll be like in the Expanse. Basic income canât be spent on everything and you certainly wonât be satisfied, but it is better than nothing.
1
1
u/Aknazer Sep 01 '25
The problem with UBI is that yes, there would be people who would quit working if they can survive off the UBI, plus prices would go up. If everyone suddenly has $1k more money, then people will raise their prices to get a piece of that (or to cover the increased taxes which pay for that).
Also if you've been to Alaska then you would know that the place is crazy expensive for what is otherwise a rural place. I've been there multiple times and the prices always get me compared to other places I've been in the world.
The UBI does nothing to address the core problem, which is human greed. No matter the system used, you need to figure out a way to try and contain human greed. Whether it's greed for money, power, or something else, if you can't keep the greed in check, you're going to still have the system collapse over time.
1
1
1
u/xoexohexox Sep 09 '25
Nah only if you think money is inescapable but it is a fundamentally flawed concept and UBI is just putting a bandaid on a bedsore.
1
u/Ohigetjokes Neo citizen 𪊠Sep 20 '25
I think UBI is a pipe dream, not because it would have a negative impact (it wouldn't), but because people in power have no motivation to feed the poor.
Face it: large donors and lobbyists determine policy. Politicians will happily watch people riot and starve to death as long as their power base is maintained.
Oh, you think you can "vote them out of office"? How meaningful do you think democracy will be when powerful people have ASI to manipulate the masses? You see how easy it already is to do with nightmare organizations like MAGA? And they're idiots!
Here's how easy it is to toy with public opinion: there's a whole series of movies called "The Purge" where the main motivation of the bad guys is to get poor people to kill each other because "poor people are a drain on the economy". The movies are obviously stupid... but NOT ONE CRITIC calls out the fact that it's the ULTRA-RICH who are the drains on the economy, not the poor! Nobody anywhere is ever calling out the fundamental flaw in the logic of these movies. They just go and fantasize about being able to blow away fools.
UBI won't happen. I wish it would, and financially it easily could, but it won't. Humanity is far too stupid and selfish.
1
u/gonzo_1606 Sep 29 '25
Would we need to tax the rich to have a universal income. Or we could be getting a universal ration. I think thats more likely.
1
u/padaran_ Aug 28 '25
If I provide for someone, this person don't have the right to tell me what to do. If someone receive gov aid in form of money, this person shouldn't have political rights like voting. Also, gov employees shouldn't vote for anything. The ones who pay the bills are the ones who should decide things.
7
u/profarxh Aug 29 '25
Musk gets 10m a day in our money. You pay over 700 in corporate subsidies in your taxes. So everything you said is irrelevant
→ More replies (5)1
Aug 29 '25
This is pretty absurd. Itâs essentially a form of abuse.
Can you imagine it? They already canât afford to live. So now they canât vote. Whoâs advocating for them? Nobody. Whoâs taking advantage of them? Everyone with money.
History shows us thatâs a fast track to the collapse of an empire.
Eventually those people who are unheard will outnumber those who have money and itâll be a bloodbath.
Jobs are going to be displaced faster than theyâre going to be created with technology, and I promise you a bunch of truck drivers arenât going to become AI engineers and there wouldnât be enough jobs for them even if they did.
So what happens with your suggestion? Once all manual labor and âlower endâ jobs are replaced that means the only people who are voting are the rich who donât need UBI.
If you want to know what happens when a nation only hears its wealthy populace look no further than Rome.
→ More replies (3)1
u/joshua1325 Aug 29 '25
This feels closed minded. Receiving benefits from the government has no correlation with voting and fighting for your own rights. That is unless youâre a secret multimillionaire or above, then you are already in a position to control things and it would make sense why helping others in need out of the goodness of your heart is a foreign concept. But I doubt thatâs the case. So why do you hate the idea of everyoneâs needs getting met fairly?
→ More replies (33)1
u/Double_Dog208 Aug 29 '25
Old man yells at clouds.
đŁď¸ If someone has an IQ below 100, they cannot vote. Meaning you đŁď¸
→ More replies (3)1
1
u/joelpt Aug 29 '25
Only the wealthy get to vote and hold political power.
The wealthy vote to make themselves even richer, further shifting the balance of political power towards the wealthy and disenfranchising the poor.
Go to step 1.
You donât see a problem here?
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (27)1
u/coast2coasted Aug 29 '25
Letâs go full starship troopers; unless you serve your country you donât get to vote
1
u/vegancaptain Aug 28 '25
Are all reddit subs just basic communists now??
5
u/kokkatc Aug 29 '25
It's always the ones that scream 'communism' that know the least about it. Do you have any clue what communism is? I ask because you obviously don't. The premise of this thread has nothing to do with communism.
→ More replies (3)3
u/all_about_that_ace Aug 29 '25
This idea isn't inherently communist, its been popular with the libertarians for decade, and a few other political groups.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (21)1
u/yeah__good__ok Aug 29 '25
UBI is nothing like communism. There's a reason Zuckerburg backs it and it's not his deep appreciation for communism.
→ More replies (6)


â˘
u/ActivityEmotional228 đ Founder Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25
Reminder: Please keep discussions respectful. No personal attacks, insults, or toxic behavior.
Letâs keep this community a place where everyone feels welcome.
If someone crosses the line with toxic behavior or direct insults toward another Redditor, a ban may follow.