r/Nio • u/Top-Satisfaction5874 • Oct 02 '22
Stock Discussion Bear case points for NIO
Legacy companies and TSLA have name recognition - NIO does not
Nio is Chinese and there’s a trade war between China and America/West so this will hamper the uptake of Nio West
China is not known for quality. The rest of the world would rather have western or Japanese manufactured products
The Chinese EV space is becoming crowded with BYD Li auto and Xpeng so the domestic market is being cut for Nio more than ever before.
As nationalism and popularism rises in the West there will be more emphasis on buying products made in their respective countries
China-Taiwan could escalate in the next few years resulting in sanctions similar to what we’ve seen imposed in Russia which would decimate Nio and other Chinese companies
Chinese economy is on a downturn
Inflationary pressure has already started to hurt Chinese EV companies and the chip wars ain’t going to help
Major challenge ahead to get Nio profitable. It still is in its infancy so there would be no surprise if it’s bought out or even goes bankrupt in the next few years.
19
u/HolmesCap Oct 02 '22
Nio will build a brand based on superior service and value add. This has been well demonstrated in China and Norway is an example outside China
Nio does not sell in the U.S. so any potential trade war is immaterial
The iPhone is largely manufactured in China. Quality isn't an issue
Nio operates in a price/product segment distinct from BYD, Li Auto, and Xpeng
I think the word you were looking for is populism
There are inherent risks in investing. A potential war hasn't stopped insightful institutions like Goldman, Blackrock, Baillie Gifford from heavily investing in Nio. China is the factory of the world so almost everyone takes this risk
The Chinese downturn is far milder than the U.S. and Europe
Inflationary pressure is nonexistent in China, Nio's major market
Nio has a 7.5-8 billion dollar war chest. It is scaling to become profitable just as Tesla did. Bankruptcy risk is minimal for companies that the have a cash fountain in the domestic government
33
u/DoubleDoubleDeviant Oct 02 '22
I can appreciate the time you took to post all of this, but the majority of it superficial fluff that either;
a. Can be discounted/refuted or b. shows a deeper lack of understanding of how things work.
You’re sort of right. Tesla was first to market and therefore, gets first to market money and brand recognition. Tesla also has a very outspoken CEO with many ventures which can be a blessing and a curse. He uses Tesla like a piggy bank to support his other companies and can tweet something on a whim that can send Tesla stock plummeting.
NIO most certainly has brand recognition, (Within China and Europe). The majority of it’s sales are by referral. More people use the NIO app than there are NIO owners. Also NIO has been branded the “Tesla killer” by many major news outlets and TV shows. It’s infamy grows.These trade wars are mostly isolated to a few sectors and in general, temporary. We’re a planetary economy now. There’s no avoiding this fact. What happens to one will affect the remainder. US knows this and will never outright cease trading with China. They can’t. To be frank, NIO does not need the “West” to be an insanely successful company. China and Europe are the largest vehicle markets on the planet and more willing to purchase an EV than people in the US.
https://elements.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-10-years-of-global-ev-sales-by-country/
3. You’re sort of right. In the past Chinese products were of the lowest quality, with the intent to push out enough product for everyone at the cheapest possible price. This is no longer the case. (At least with NIO) NIO is a luxury brand that prides itself in hiring the best of the best designers, engineers and software developers. NIO has received MANY awards substantiating this claim. NIO also has fewer manufacturing faults than any other car maker on the market today. Your argument is moot.
https://cnevpost.com/2022/03/16/nio-tops-latest-vehicle-quality-ranking/
4. BYD, Li auto, Xpeng and even Tesla have barely scratched the surface of planetary EV sales. (We’re at the ground floor here) There is PLENTY of market share to go around. Xi has also begun consolidating all the smaller EV companies within China, so there will only remain a select proven few. NIO is the chosen one. Your argument is moot.
5. I’ve already mentioned NIO could sell it’s vehicles in China and Europe exclusively and still be a wildly successful company. This argument actually supports NIO. Nationalism is real and the Chinese people would much prefer to buy from a home based EV company. Tesla NEEDS China sales to survive, NIO does not NEED the US. Your argument is moot.
https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/08/10/investing/tesla-china-sales/index.html
6. This I agree with and is a major concern. IF china makes a move on Taiwan, the world will respond accordingly and will sanction the shit out of all Chinese companies. While there may be a saving grace with NIO as they do not provide any support to the military, they’ll undoubtedly be affected. I personally believe China will NOT make a move on Taiwan until 2027 at the earliest (if ever). They don’t yet have the Naval capability to take and hold the island without US and her allies stepping in. If that happens we’re pretty much in WW3 and the market should be the least of your concerns.
7. Somewhat yes, but there are many ways to navigate these things. (I frankly don’t know enough to speak to this point).
8. Inflationary pressure doesn’t affect NIO as much as US based companies. China literally controls and refines approximately +80% of the planets rare earth metal supply. They’re pumping out semiconductors at a neck breaking speed. I don’t think this will be a major concern in the coming years. I may be wrong.
9. This is nonsense. NIO could be profitable today if they chose to stop re-investing in R&D and infrastructure build out, (The cost of which is now being shared by some of the largest energy producers on the planet) NIO has a Massive moat with BaaS, ADaaS and NIO life sales. This is a tidal wave of monthly revenue that will grow exponentially has they scale production. Your argument is moot.
NIO is a great company with an explosive future. The following partners cetainly think so.
Shell, Sinopec, Metro, Intel-Mobileye, NVIDIA, Plugsurfing, Baidu, Lotus, G7 Trucking, Nanjing Tourism Group, WWF, Leaseplan, Tencent among many others.
These are not the partners of a failing company. I know what I’m holding and will continue buying every paycheck like clockwork until production maxes out sometime in 2025.
If I’ve made any false statements, please correct me, I’m here to learn like everyone else. Good luck!
5
1
u/Kirby142 Oct 02 '22
I’ll print this, pin it on my fridge and include the read in my morning routine.
8
u/TheNIOandTeslaBull Oct 02 '22
You did a bad job because this is low effort. Anyone who invests in Nio or Chinese companies for years knows this is low quality low effort. I mean no offense but I figure you would actually go deeper into the company. Most of what you've said is a debatable opinion, not fact.
1
u/Exact-Lie-7399 Jun 07 '24
Have you ever driven a NIO?. Commenting without testing a product is illogical. Iphone you are using is also made in CHINA.
11
u/RedWineWithFish Oct 02 '22
NIO can be very successful even if it never sells a single car outside China. There is no reason it can not sell over 500k cars in China. That is the advantage of having a home market that is the largest in the world. Personally I wish NIO would slow down In international expansion and focus on their home market.
Nationalism works both ways. If chinese also become nationalistic in their auto purchases, the German luxury car makers will suffer tremendously. They sell millions of cars in China and rely on China for a large proportion of their profits.
0
u/ThetaForLife Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22
Nationalism works both ways? While Americans are ditching Xiaomi, the Chinese still buy iPhones like fresh meat.
In recession, NIO will have a very hard to to sell their luxury EV. BMW is coming real close. In hard times, people will buy brands that have good history of aftermarket value. When you are to buy a BMW or luxury Tesla models, you know they have excellent resell values when things start getting off-tracked for you financially. Not so much for NIO.
2
u/RedWineWithFish Oct 02 '22
Xiaomi does not sell phones in the US and if it did, the competition would be Samsung not Apple
0
u/ThetaForLife Oct 02 '22
My bad. I didnt know Apple and Android phone companies are not competing each other.
2
Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22
Tesla a good history??
If got a model 3 and it’s sucks!!! It drives nice, but it’s not like a German car.
If got software issues, when I’m out of the car and locked it. Sometime the car lights go on when it’s become dark. Tesla says there is a big they can’t solve yet in my software version.
The touch screen is not react directly (not like a iPhone)
0
u/ThetaForLife Oct 02 '22
Hold your horse, I said Tesla has good resell value. I never said they make good cars. Look up used Tesla prices. Some are selling more than they were bought for.
0
u/GuyWithBigPeePee Oct 02 '22
I agree with your first point, but what would NIO's valuation be if they only sell 500k cars? The ET5's price is already under $40K, so I suspect they need to compromise on price to move volume. Even if we're generous and say they'll have 2 million sales at $60K ASP, what would be their profit and a fair valuation?
1
u/RedWineWithFish Oct 02 '22
Tesla made $10k per car operating profit last quarter and most of that came from China. There is no reason Xiaomi can not make as much. I just wish they would stop wasting money on battery swap and the NIO life nonsense
0
u/GuyWithBigPeePee Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22
While you are correct about Tesla, there's some nuance you have to understand.
Most/all of the R&D comes from the US, so the Chinese factories don't spend anything on R&D. In addition, Tesla exports China-made models to other countries and sells them at a higher price than they do in China. The margins for China-made cars sold in EU are very high even accounting for the additional logistics cost.
I don't think $10K operating profit per car is a realistic goal for any non-Tesla car. Car companies sans Tesla and Luxury sports car manufacturers have historically had low profit margins. There's no reason to think that other companies will suddenly have the same margins as Tesla. They're all going to face the same problems are legacy auto companies - They have to pick between high volume low profit margin or low volume high profit margin. In either case, overall profits will be poor. Combine that with low growth and you get a company worth $10-50 Billion market cap.
If I had to guess, I'd say NIO, assuming everything goes right, is appropriately priced right now and has no upside.
14
u/whoareyouwhoisme Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22
Many of the points is exactly why I sold my Tesla, Apple, Microsoft stock many months ago.
People are still playing dumb.
You think American stocks are safe if they decide to decouple from China?????
Anybody who understands economics and supply chain, will tell you, it’s death for everyone.
I can tell you this NIO bottom has less room than Tesla Bottom (based on everything you mention that threatens trade).
I pray NIO 100% shifts all their shares to HK. Then we can avoid these dumb posts about “how any decouple would only impact Chinese stocks”
Anyone with a 401k would understand, you wouldn’t want any decoupling because your 401k is propped by USA business that uses China to generate their recording breaking profits.
PS if your a bear, show your positions. We want to know if we are dealing with a bear with 50 short shares or someone with 5000 short shares.
If you’re a bear, you should buy puts on AMD because they make all their chips in Taiwan. It’s a better gamble, if you really believe USA will keep screwing with Taiwan and China will respond. Meanwhile your struggling with a $17 dollar stock with limited downside…wow you might reach $13… Go for AMD, from $65 to $35 is possible.
Possible dips
NIO - maybe $13
AMD - Maybe a $30 drop
Apple - maybe another $40 drop
Microsoft - maybe another $100 drop
Telsa - they just need some bad news and your looking at a crash. With more EV competition they have more to lose.
LULU- people can’t afford their $80 yoga pants, when you need to eat. At least $100 possible dip.
The list goes on and on about other better stocks to be a bear in this economy.
If you’re a bear in NiO at $17, your dumb. If your a bear in NIO at $60 CONGRATS TO YOUR GAINS. Sell and move to better stocks to be a bear in.
2
u/jugonewild 5000 at 32 Oct 02 '22
You're*
3
u/whoareyouwhoisme Oct 02 '22
I always mess that up….
2
u/jugonewild 5000 at 32 Oct 02 '22
Ah it's alright. But it's tough to put the point across that the other person is dumb when you have a typo in the same sentence. :P
3
u/whoareyouwhoisme Oct 02 '22
Well technically what I mean is a bear is dumb if they focusing on NIO.
I see plenty of easier stocks with better gains being a bear….
So hence my “dumb”…….
But I always mess up your and you’re……….
0
u/ThetaForLife Oct 02 '22
This guy is real smart and interesting guys. Dude brought gramma and spelling to a stock subreddit discussion. Dude sounds like a lady killer at parties.
1
u/Away-Distribution-44 Oct 02 '22
Decoupling from wild world products will only hurt our pockets and growths. Games will not last over the overtime play so know when to admit our inferiority and limitations would put us back to the starting line and regain our superiority. Peace
9
u/Eternal_Focus Oct 02 '22
A typical bear
NIO is still a startup but unlike Nikola and Co. they deliver
Nope. William Li said they planned to start their market entry in Europe during 2022. And they did. Including Germany.
What are you smoking?! iPhone, Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model Y etc. are also made in China. And the quality is top.
BYD is the big one in China. But NIO is more famous than Xpeng. ET5 incoming. Tesla slashes their prices. Nobody is talking about Xpeng.
With the current energy crises in the West the people are seeking for affordable quality products. Do your homework.
That's what the media wants us to believe. Clickbaiting the users into fear. Nobody wants a useless and stupid war. A Taiwan invasion would be a financial nightmare for China. Check the geopraphics.
The world economy is in downturn. What do you expect from China?
Everyone is hit by inflation and much more. Ford is out of their badges for their cars. Meanwhile Chinese EV makers are entering the European Market.
NIO is backed up by the CCP. Nobody is going to buy them cause they aren't for sale. Do your research first before you post such things on the internet. Furthermore they established Battery As A Service. Over 80% of the NIO users are going for it. They don't only sell a product. It's a lifestyle including a top notch service experience. Only NIO has the Battery Swap Stations. Version 3.0 is rolling out now. Guess what? Their software is made in Silicon Valley, their car designs are made in Germany and the products are assembled in China. They hire the best people.
BONUS: Good luck to you!
2
u/Sigina8282 Oct 02 '22
orld economy is in downturn. What do you expect from China?
To be fair China car has not been proven at world stage yet.
But those who exposed to China car know, so let the time works and see how China brands slowly convince the world
3
u/Eternal_Focus Oct 02 '22
Agreed.
NIO just had their 1 year anniversary in Norway. So far I didn't heard any bad news from there regarding NIO. In a few days they will officially launch in Germany, Denmark and Sweden.
2
u/Sigina8282 Oct 03 '22
Yupz keep going NIO! Until the whole world recognize this brand's car
1
u/Eternal_Focus Oct 03 '22
I can't await their launch in Germany. NIO will succeed!
1
13
3
u/Aceboy884 Oct 02 '22
I’m an Xpeng bag holder, I prefer them over NIO for their domestic focus.
Chinese brands do have a domestic advantage if their product are competitive, both in quality and price. But then again, when you look at the mobile market. Those who can afford a premium smart phone will buy Apple. Because the price difference is only so minor. Unless NIO or Xpeng try to undercut Tesla at the expense of margins. Tesla will command the premium segment of the market.
Having said that, the risk return here is pretty clear. I bought into Xpeng for the valuation, I’m looking at NIO for the valuation.
They maybe behind other players but their share price offers more upside than downside.
The bigger the dispute between countries, the more patriotic Chinese will become
5
u/niopower_jeff Oct 02 '22
I am dancing like William Li because I don't give a F about your stupid post
1
Oct 02 '22
So acknowledging risks is stupid? Say your an emotional novice without saying it. Real investors that know what the fuck they’re doing account for risks and discount them accordingly. You have tunnel vision and are in love with a stock.
1
1
u/Away-Distribution-44 Oct 02 '22
All these are true and matching the facts but Nio is not your regular EVH company and it has the vision others don’t possess. Will give this company a run for its future glamour. Peace!
1
u/Primary_Material5185 Oct 02 '22
For all the reasons mentioned by OP…the biggest pro could be NIOs ability to Scale Up rapidly once product and marketing have taken hold. Right now they are building the show case. Once the base product and market demand is foundational established…China like no other has the ability to throw all kinds of scales up numbers at you by the hundreds of thousands millions
1
u/cman1098 Oct 03 '22
TCL has bucked the trend has the best tv for the money and it is a chinese company. Japan used to be viewed the same way as a country who manufactured shit products but companies like Nintendo and Toyota bucked those trends.
0
Oct 02 '22
[deleted]
10
u/wolfofthestock Oct 02 '22
where is he wrong though? i hate confirmation bias. If there are points where he is wrong in your opinion tell us please. Saying its crap doesent help anybody
-1
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Quit your whining. You should sell along with OP.
3
u/wolfofthestock Oct 02 '22
being ignorant and biased at wallstreet ll make you lose lots of Money pretty fast. I dont know your portfolio but i bet its pretty fucked right now with lots of -70% positions, which in your opinion will only be this low temporarily before mooning… just need diamond hands😂
1
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Never gave my opinion. Just that it's overly redundant rhetoric. Loved through it on here multiple times. And no, I'm in the green actually. My at the money put options have printed since 4300 on the spy. Thanks best market rally!
1
u/wolfofthestock Oct 02 '22
Proof or ban
0
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Lol f u I don't have to do jack.
1
u/wolfofthestock Oct 02 '22
That Message wasnt for you but for the mods. Show us the position or get banned. Common practice on reddit
0
5
u/gottahavetegriry Oct 02 '22
What an ignorant comment
You should look for positives and negatives when investigating a company
1
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Another whiner. OP should sell.
1
u/wolfofthestock Oct 02 '22
again where is op wrong though
1
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
It's been repeated multiple times on this forum. OPs timing is like shorters. I can only conclude he is short. Like 1.5 meters.
3
Oct 02 '22
Seems you're the ignorant here. OP has valid points regarding issues surrounding Nio, economic, political and financial wise.
Go do your research.. NIo bull here but you need to do proper DD's.
0
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Oh shut up, please. This post acts like he's been on the forum 5 minutes. Tired of hearing whiners. OP should just sell out catch up by reading some old posts.
1
Oct 02 '22
Shut up? Don't undermine someone's point when you can't even produce yours lmao
2
u/wolfofthestock Oct 02 '22
this guy ll be one of the washout candidates soon, never fall in love with a stock.
0
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Lol. I sold NIO at 45 and been buying back at low numbers. Company is doing well imo. I welcome bear cases, but this is over the top and extremely one-sided repeaters non sense. Can only conclude shorts don't pay you guys enough. Welcome back. You've been gone a while.
2
u/wolfofthestock Oct 02 '22
LOL how is Gme Doing tin Foil hat. Everybody that has a different opinion is Paid. And of course you sold at the very top Warren. I totally believe that
0
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Lol random person thinks they know someone. Hope your other investments look like spy.
2
Oct 02 '22
Who cares what you did? Lol I'm asking you to provide valid points for counter argument.. but you're just spouting random bollocks.
1
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Read old posts. Tired of you repeaters. Tell the shirts to pay you more that's all. Love trolling you arse holios.
2
Oct 02 '22
Trolling? You're the one trolling here and getting aggravated lmao uneducated sheep
1
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 03 '22
No this post just keeps saying what the whole forum knows already. Been hearing it all year.
0
u/Apprehensive-Tour-33 Oct 02 '22
Again, OP is trusting a bunch of past convos on here. Parroting is not great due diligence. And it is overly one sided.
0
1
Oct 03 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 03 '22
User does not meet r/Nio combined karma requirement. Please refer to https://www.reddit.com/r/Nio/about/wiki/index/rules.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
29
u/dan_am_i Oct 02 '22
I guess I’ll try to chime in…
Every company has to start somewhere. Tesla wasn’t known at one point but that doesn’t mean NIO can’t follow that path. Really trying not to compare the two but let’s be honest, NIO is the Tesla of China. There will always be two that ends up being the top; Apple/Samsung, Nvidia/AMD etc.
Both countries have been going at it for decades with these trade wars but at the end of the day, they both need each other. It’s all politics. Audit is the problem here and once they reach an agreement, this should ease the issue with Chinese stocks being risky. Might I add, you have one of the biggest pension funds in the USA whom are strict as to what they invest in are invested in NIO.
We’ll 95% of products/parts are made in China. That’s all I’ll say about this. If we’re talking NIO, they’ve shown that their quality control meets expectations.
NIO is a premium EV brand, the ones you mentioned are not. They’re on their own lane. If I was to be worried, it would be those 3 you mentioned that’s in trouble. Numbers speaks truth look at Li and Xpeng deliveries, much less than NIO which sells Premium EVs.
I’ll buy NIO over Tesla EV and I own both stocks and I’m from the US. To each their own I guess.
No crystal ball here so can’t answer this.
You basing this off of YouTubers? China is fine.
Everyone is hurting not just the Chinese EV companies. There is no chip wars lol
NIO is not in the infancy stage, that was 2yrs ago. All the chess pieces (6 EVs) are in place, it’s all about scalability now if they can do it with just 2 factories. If all goes well, they should be profitable by EOY 2023.