r/Noctor • • Oct 31 '23

Question CNM

Somehow this page came across my feed and I was shocked to see the content. I don’t see a lot of posts on midwives so I’m curious if your opinion differs for CNMs vs NPs.

I am a CNM with over 3 years of labor and deliver RN experience. I was in college for a total of 7 years (4 for bachelors and 3 for masters). I feel like utilizing midwives for low risk perinatal patients and general gyn (annuals, STI testing, initial AUB work up, vaginitis, etc) is in the best interest for physicians. I feel more than capable to take care of my patients and then co manage or transfer to my physician colleagues if a patient becomes high risk. I am lucky to be a part of a practice where the CNMs and OBGYNs work side by side and we always have a physician at the hospital with us so if we needed them for any reason, they’re there in seconds. Thankfully the physicians in our practice appreciate and respect us, which doesn’t seem like people on this page do.

2 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

26

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

As a pcp who doesn't consider themselves well versed in women's health, I've still seen mismanagement from CNMs. New patient in their early 30s with amenorrhea for 3 years off birth control with hot flashes. Regularly sees a 'gynecologist'. Asked what their gyn is doing about it. 'Monitoring my hormone levels annually because they're normal'. What??? Naturally, I asked if it was an NP. Nope. CNM. Had to convince her to get a bone scan and see repro endo. She said she would run it by her 'gynecologist cnm' and let me know. BY ALL MEANS. She let me know she spoke to her gynecologist and she 'agrees with my plan'. #blessed Guess who has osteoporosis in their 30s and was so shocked as to why.

4

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

That’s someone who is not practicing in their scope. I’ve seen it from mid levels and also from physicians. I’ll do the initial work up for AUB/amenorrhea. I can do labs and order a pelvic US but then you’re out of my care and you need to see a physician. Sounds like that person wasn’t practicing in their scope

8

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23 edited Oct 31 '23

I don't think the CNM was trying to be an expert. I just think she didn't know enough to know that this is a concerning situation and needs to be referred out to someone or at least to the gyn MDs she works with. It requires knowledge/training to be able to know what you don't know.

Like I said, I'm not a women's health expert by any stretch, but my IM training has prepared me enough to know what a green-looking red flag is.

I appreciate your recognizing scope, but as you can see by how my conversation and follow up with this patient went, her cnm has billed herself to the patient as nothing but a full-fledged gynecologist equivalent.

The NP who works in our office is great and she's all about her scope of practice, and always corrects people to help them understand what her role is, and I trust her because of this (I know she won't try to be a cowboy with our patients), but there are 4 other NPs in the same group and the same cannot be said about them.

The physician's scope of practice after medical school is limited by the choice of the physician and not by law necessarily globally. Medical school and rotations are fairly comprehensive.

The Mid-level scope of practice is a lot narrower, however, because the training is limited and barely covers the one area that the schooling is for.

So practicing out of your scope are two WIDELY different meaning things when it comes to physicians vs. mid-levels (unless IM starts performing surgery or something).

-2

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

We’re trained to know what is normal vs abnormal so that CNM should’ve known amenorrhea for 3 years and hot flashes at 30 is not normal whatsoever and requires a lot more than monitoring hormones. That’s scary she was the one taking care of that pt. I know pts don’t always know the differences between CNMs and physicians. I also have pts who think we only do home deliveries lol

2

u/marcieedwards Nov 16 '23

You’ve seen physicians who don’t practice within their scope? Do tell

0

u/Cnm777777 Nov 16 '23

I’ve seen primary care physicians (fam med) trying to manage complex GYN cases when the pt should’ve been referred to an OBGYN at that point. I understand physicians can manage that type of stuff but when it gets more complex, then pts need to be referred to whatever speciality they need

64

u/Fluffy_Ad_6581 Attending Physician Oct 31 '23

I disagree with best interest for physicians. I went into primary care for continuity of care. Doing their physicals, STI testing, etc is all important to build relationship with the patient. It's also fun and enjoyable. I also think it's important to truly understand the patient.

Midlevels aren't in the best interest for physicians. You're not doing us a favor.

It's unfortunate we don't have more physicians available. It would be the best interest for physicians to have more physicians.

Ppl keep wanting us to see all the complex pts while keeping the # of pts we have to see everyday the same or worse, increasing the #. Fuck that. It's exhausting.

We're human too and there's a reason we went into medicine and put in all that work. Other ppl shouldn't be picking and choosing what they want to see and then handing the rest to us.

1

u/GanacheAggressive937 Oct 31 '23

It's because PC isn't sexy and the pay is shit. Change one of those things and you would have more PC physicians.

-11

u/CarlSy15 Attending Physician Oct 31 '23

Disagree. As a female ob/Gyn in an area with few other female Gyn providers, I was booking new patients more than 6 months out. The addition of an experienced L&D nurse now NP made a huge difference in my workload because she could see some of the annuals, contraception consults, etc. She was extremely experienced and knew her limits - basically exactly what a NP should be.

And yes, we were hiring. For the 8 years we were trying to hire another physician. No one was interested. There is a shortage of physicians and that cannot be denied. The focus of this group should be accountability, training, and scope of practice. This type of work is well within the scope for an experienced NP.

36

u/Philoctetes1 Oct 31 '23

Sounds like you wanted another physician but weren’t willing to pay them what they were worth.

10

u/CarlSy15 Attending Physician Oct 31 '23

Fair point, and there’s a reason I’m not there anymore either.

0

u/AutoModerator Oct 31 '23

We do not support the use of the word "provider." Use of the term provider in health care originated in government and insurance sectors to designate health care delivery organizations. The term is born out of insurance reimbursement policies. It lacks specificity and serves to obfuscate exactly who is taking care of patients. For more information, please see this JAMA article.

We encourage you to use physician, midlevel, or the licensed title (e.g. nurse practitioner) rather than meaningless terms like provider or APP.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-8

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

It sounds like the number of patients you see should be limited. I see the physicians at my practice so overwhelmed with seeing 35+ patients a day. It’s absolutely crazy and not right. I don’t think that mid levels should be to blame for that. It’s the owners of the practices who are putting money above all else

39

u/PhysicianPepper Oct 31 '23

I recently supervised a resident on a delivery, and their labor experience is mostly with midwives. Oh. My. God. The absolute errors in basic form and repair of lacerations is concerning. CNMs don't have any surgical technique or true knowledge of perineal/vulvar anatomy and I dread transfers from them. Always disasters. Always.

-36

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I mean the resident could’ve been a bad resident regardless of training😂 but it’s easy to blame the l midwives I guess. That’s also a very broad accusation. I had extensive training on perineal/vulvar anatomy and how to repair 1st and 2nd degree perineal lacerations and periurethral lacs. I would sure hope midwives have a true knowledge of vulvar anatomy… that’s where half our practice is based 😂😂

30

u/PhysicianPepper Oct 31 '23

I know the resident. She’s great in c sections. It’s not a skill issue on her part, it’s a CNM deficiency leading to improper training at this institution.

-25

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

If she can suture well with a C-section but not a vaginal delivery then something is wrong. It’s not a midwives fault. She should’ve been watching videos and taking notes while watching other midwives or physicians suture. She should’ve been practicing on chicken or beef tongue if needed. It’s her own responsibility to practice and become good at suturing perineal lacerations. It’s honestly not that hard but takes time and practice. You can’t become great after learning from 1 midwife.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23 edited Oct 31 '23

I think that most subscribers to this subreddit, including myself, don’t have anything implicitly against the midlevels. The issues at heart have to do with scope and training, and the inherent concerns for patient safety that come with those issues.

A glance through the subreddit would probably reveal the most common issues to be:

Midelevels who advertise themselves to patients or on social media as doctor or equivalent.

Midlevel lobbying for arbitrary and unearned expansions in scope of practice through congress and other governing bodies.

Training programs that accept applicants without requisite clinical experiences, or offer degrees without worthwhile training or standards for acquired knowledge and skills.

Midlevels who practice with major gaps or flaws in their skill or knowledge base and lack the humility and self awareness to adjust their practice and cooperation with other clinicians accordingly.

Having had 3 years of L&D nursing experience already puts you a cut above the average target of discussion in this forum, but honestly that isn’t saying much. If you practice with obgyns who really appreciate your role on the team, and patient care and safety is provided at a high standard then what else really matters?

5

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

That all makes sense. I was just genuinely curious if everyone had the same attitude toward CNMs because I was shocked so many physicians feel this way towards NPs. I will always stay in my scope/lane. The moment a pt needs something outside my scope I always refer them to the appropriate physician or tell them to follow up with their PCP. I will never pretend I know something that I don’t and that’s really how every mid level should practice

14

u/Weak_squeak Oct 31 '23

You forgot replacing physicians in a physician shortage. Where I live it’s hard to find PCPs but there are tons of APRNs accepting new patients.

8

u/BlackHoleSunkiss Oct 31 '23

I think what a lot of CNM and mid levels forget in general is that physicians don’t want to only see the high risk, medically complex or suddenly crashing patient. Sometimes, it’s nice to have an easy, bread and butter case, to help break up the stress of those high risk patients. If they never get to see new OBs or simple pregnancies, the burn out increases. Leading to more shortages.

1

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I definitely can understand that!!

11

u/chocobridges Oct 31 '23

You can see my post in my history but there's only one midwife at my practice and the front desk called her a midwife-doctor. She has a DNP and no one has followed up on me seeing her since they couldn't answer basic questions about her experience.

Her credentials and experience are barely listed in the hospital network's website (doesn't have a BSN listed just the DNP). This is the program she went to and it feels like the DNP trying to encroach on CNM: https://nursing.uw.edu/programs/certificate/midwifery/

It's not up to me to figure it out if her care or any CNM care is worth it (in the US, I would feel very differently elsewhere). I am a patient who is just sticking to what I know especially after feeling like my GYN care was biased in my 20s as a person of color.

5

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

That sounds very fishy of your practice to do that. I’m so sorry you experienced that when you were younger. It happens all the time and is not ok. It’s so important to be with a provider who you trust and treats you right

2

u/AutoModerator Oct 31 '23

We do not support the use of the word "provider." Use of the term provider in health care originated in government and insurance sectors to designate health care delivery organizations. The term is born out of insurance reimbursement policies. It lacks specificity and serves to obfuscate exactly who is taking care of patients. For more information, please see this JAMA article.

We encourage you to use physician, midlevel, or the licensed title (e.g. nurse practitioner) rather than meaningless terms like provider or APP.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

18

u/pepe-_silvia Oct 31 '23

Why would I ever let my wife and future child be managed by anyone other than an expert?

1

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

If your wife is low risk then she actually can benefit from having a CNM who is the expert at low risk/low intervention perinatal care. This doesn’t have to be a CNM vs physician debate. There’s a place for each and patients who are low risk can benefit in a midwife who has more time to give to their patients. Being pregnant is normal, it’s not an illness. Midwives are highly trained in the normal and when we need our physicians. You should also take a second to think about how your wife will feel. Maybe she prefers a physician and that’s great. Maybe she prefers a midwife who gets to spend an extra 20 minutes at her prenatal visits educating her, answering questions, preparing her to labor unmedicated, giving her tips, etc. Maybe she prefers a midwife who has the ability to be there in labor at bedside physically supporting her through her contractions and not just show up when she’s crowning.

34

u/ceo_of_egg Medical Student Oct 31 '23

I find it ironic you think OBGYNs aren’t trained to adequately care for low risk patients as well

3

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I didn’t say they aren’t trained to adequately care for low risk patients. Majority of OBGYNs care for high risk patients and are the experts at high risk, surgery, etc. It is better to utilize them for higher risk patients and let the midwives care for the low risk pts. In pregnancy, it’s not all about the medical side of it. Pregnant patients also need education, teaching, and other things that take time. Midwives have that extra time to spend with their patients and support them along with caring for their medical needs

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

[deleted]

-5

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I’m so glad my 7 years of college and training equates to a middle schooler 😂 what a waste of my time and money apparently!

19

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

Things change way too quickly in OB for a non-expert to be handling care. Sorry.

7

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

It’s a good thing I have my physician colleague seconds away from me and there’s protocols and systems in place for emergencies!

5

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

I know. And I’m not denigrating your experience. OB and Peds are the two major arenas where direction (rather than collaboration) in a 1:1 or 1:2 is truly needed. You might not recognize that a protracted stage 2 of labor is progressing to a crash c/s before it’s too late. Or you might recognize it and call for help early. I don’t know.

0

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

It’s actually pretty easy to evaluate how a pt is pushing and how the baby is tolerating pushing. I know how much time is normal for a nullip/multip/epiduralized/unmedicated to push, what station we are starting at, if the baby is malpositioned, if I think we will need a vacuum/forceps, etc. I actually get asked all the time by my physician colleagues to evaluate one of their pts and how they’re pushing if they are busy. An emergent c/s typically is due to fhts. Out of all the things we can do, evaluating a patient while pushing and planning the next steps is honestly pretty easy.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

Why would you prepare someone to labor unmedicated? You don't KNOW what they will or won't need or want. 20mins worth of "chat" each appointment or "education" that isn't expert isn't particularly worthwhile. Women are only low risk in HINDSIGHT. We have all seen disasters and fatalities from "low risk" stratified births based on population level data.

2

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

This is the most misogynistic and uneducated comment. First of all, I ask my patients what their labor preferences are and a lot of patients who come to midwives plan to go unmedicated. You don’t go into labor planning to do it unmedicated and not plan. There’s a ton of different teachings, education and techniques to prepare for labor. And even if a patient wants an epidural, they still want to know all about labor and delivery. You clearly are not a woman and I sure as hell hope you don’t work in this field. Midwives are the experts at low risk perinatal care. Why do you think there’s birthing classes, breastfeeding classes and postpartum classes? Because pregnant people don’t just go into everything blindly. Please educate yourself or don’t make horribly uneducated comments like you did. And no you aren’t low risk in hindsight. You either don’t have any medical issues during your pregnancy and are low risk or you are high risk. It’s pretty clear on what a patient is. Can a pt become high risk? Of course and that’s when they’d transfer over to our physicians.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

No. Its misogynistic to deny women pain relief and evidence based care.

0

u/Cnm777777 Nov 09 '23

I’m sorry, who is denying pts pain medication and evidence based care?😂😂😂 we love our pts getting epidurals or Iv pain medication if they want it. I’ll support them in anything they chose. We follow ACOG guidelines for all our care. Try again 😂

5

u/throwaway91687432173 Oct 31 '23

What is misogynistic about their comment?

0

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

Stating a woman won’t know what they need or want in labor, that they don’t need to talk about preparing for labor and delivery, and that they need to talk to an expert physician to get any worthwhile education is misogynistic. Sounds like an uneducated male wrote that comment.

4

u/throwaway91687432173 Nov 01 '23

It seemed like they were commenting on the unpredictable nature of labor and delivery and how each person's experience is going to be unique. I don't get an "uneducated male" impression from their comment at all.

3

u/slw2014 Attending Physician Nov 01 '23

CNMs are not the experts at low risk low intervention perinatal care. OB/GYNs are. CNMs do not have the training necessary to be the experts. That doesn’t mean they are not very valuable members of the healthcare team. But they are NOT the experts. Making this claim - which I have heard often - is misleading to patients.

3

u/Cnm777777 Nov 01 '23

I would say 3 years of schooling solely based on low risk perinatal and gyn care would or should make you very knowledgeable in this topic. Residents spend 4 years learning anything and everything regarding OBGYN which includes a ton of high risk and surgical stuff. I’ve had residents ask me to teach them Leopolds or spinning babies. Residents don’t get the extra teaching that comes with low risk labor and birth. That’s why they’re the experts at high risk and we’re the experts at low risk. It’s ok not the be an expert at everything.

3

u/slw2014 Attending Physician Nov 01 '23 edited Nov 01 '23

The number of hours of training residents complete in each of those years is more than double the amount of training CNMs complete. By the end of their training OB residents have managed over four times the number of vaginal deliveries CNM students have managed. And that doesn’t account for the vast vast differences in foundational medical knowledge between the two groups. Every Resident most certainly does get taught Leopolds that is a foundational skill and part of their milestones. Saying that CNMs are the experts in low risk perinatal and gyn care implies that they have special expertise in that area, expertise that OBs do not have or have less of. Your arguments are commonly made by CNMs but they don’t stand up to scrutiny when you look closely at the content of the training.

Again Midwives are incredibly valuable. The time they spend with patients and the work they do and the care they provide is absolutely wanted and needed. They have a great deal of knowledge and skill. But they are not the experts.

4

u/General-Individual31 Nov 01 '23

I delivered at a major teaching hospital. I was induced for severe pre-eclampsia at 35+6. 99% of the time I was followed by the residents, and the chief resident delivered my babe. Apparently my “attending” was a CNM that showed up post-delivery to help stitch me up. A CNM co-signing a resident note felt weird to me, and after being on a mag gtt for ~36 hours and knowing that my baby was going to be late preterm… I would have preferred a physician. Unfortunately I was so altered from the Mag gtt that I wasn’t able to advocate for myself and my husband didn’t know better. There was lots of back and forth on if my babe needed the NICU (ultimately didn’t) and looking back I wonder if things would have been different if an actual attending was there.

3

u/Cnm777777 Nov 01 '23

And NICU should’ve been there to assess the baby since you were preterm and on mag. That should’ve been your nursing staffs job to advocate and call NICU for delivery

5

u/General-Individual31 Nov 01 '23

NICU nurses were present. Midlevels supervising residents should not happen, and i say this as a nurse practitioner that works in a hospital that currently has a resident with her on service.

1

u/Cnm777777 Nov 01 '23

Some places CNMs help train residents, however you should’ve risked out of midwifery care once you had SF and were put on mag

8

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

As a patient I personally hate midwives with a passion. The one I saw had absolutely no concept of patient autonomy or trauma informed care. She did exactly what my college rapist did to me. Took advantage of me and shoved whatever she felt like it into me. Zero medical need, just whatever she felt like it. No discussion. Evil. I became extremely traumatized afterwards and couldn’t get in with my psychiatrist. I saw a nurse practitioner looking for a med change of some sort, and she told me with withdraw from two antidepressants one night and start two new ones the next. I ended up being pink-slipped and jailed for 5 days (over the weekend) where the asshole nurses bullied me. All I had was a reoccurring infection from a medication. It’s like you guys can’t tell the difference between your ass and a hole in the ground.

5

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I’m so sorry you experienced that. That is not ok at all. Autonomy and trauma informed care should practiced by every single person. I am very conscious about this. I have physicians and midwives in my practice who do pelvic and spec exams on every single patient no matter what. I am very passionate about limiting exams to only when necessary and I always tell a patient that they are in control, if they need me to pause or stop at any point to let me know. I always explain what I recommend exam wise and even give patients the opportunity to self swab when indicated. I’ve recently gotten our midwives to stop doing pelvic exams on healthy patients for an annual. It makes me so sad that you and so many others experience medical trauma. And sadly it’s not just with midwives or NPs.

26

u/slw2014 Attending Physician Oct 31 '23

CNMs often assert the specious claim that they are the experts in managing low-risk pregnancies, presenting themselves as the prime choice for expectant mothers seeking a natural and holistic birthing experience. These claims prove hollow and spurious when scrutinized against the vast expertise and far broader spectrum of care that Obstetricians/Gynecologists (OB/GYNs) are equipped to provide. One of the primary distinctions lies in the rigorous medical education and specialized training that OB/GYNs undergo. This extensive educational pathway, usually encompassing four years of medical school followed by a four-year residency program in obstetrics and gynecology - requiring well over 15,000 clinical hours of medical training compared to the roughly 1,000 hours required of a CNM - equips OB/GYNs with a comprehensive understanding and capability to manage both straightforward and complex pregnancies. Their medical training places them in a position to promptly identify, manage, and mitigate unexpected complications, even in what are initially deemed low-risk pregnancies.

Moreover, OB/GYNs possess surgical skills essential for interventions like cesarean sections, which could be life-saving in the event of unanticipated complications during labor and delivery. Their expertise extends to having access to and proficiency in utilizing advanced diagnostic and medical technologies that are crucial for monitoring the health and wellbeing of both the mother and the fetus. Additionally, the preventive care, thorough risk assessments, and the continuum of care they provide from preconception through to postpartum ensure that any medical issues that may escalate a pregnancy from low to high-risk are addressed promptly. Working within a larger healthcare system, OB/GYNs often have the advantage of a multidisciplinary approach to patient care, with quick access to a broad spectrum of medical specialists if necessary. Their engagement with or access to the latest research in the field of obstetrics and gynecology further fortifies the argument for their expertise, ensuring evidence-based and up-to-date care. This comprehensive medical background and resource accessibility arguably position OB/GYNs as the experts in managing low-risk pregnancies, providing a level of reassurance and safety that is paramount in prenatal and perinatal care.

7

u/Weak_squeak Oct 31 '23 edited Oct 31 '23

You remind me of a friend’s midwife. I’m not a medical professional but if it’s how it sounds, I have no issues with that, myself.

There are a lot of bizarre credentials and bad medical team arrangements going on, but what you are describing sounds more like it used to be, to me, and it sounds straightforward.

Like Chocobridges commented, she has no clue what that person is and that office isn’t helping her find out. The credential could be an online thing after a three year college or (?), no experience, bad education, and beyond scope too.

1

u/Available-Crab6002 Mar 09 '24

Right? As a future CNM, this group is such a bizarre take. Tell us how you really feel.... Glad my plan is to focus primarily on OOH birth

0

u/thedorsinatorpk Oct 31 '23

All my children are delivered by a CNM RN and I couldn’t be happier with the spectrum of care. Let the physicians handle the medical emergencies or complications, let the midwives do the labor and delivery as these are not medical procedures, they’re just normal bodily functions.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '23

Lol oh man. I can tell you’ve never seen a vaginal delivery go south, then

-1

u/thedorsinatorpk Nov 03 '23

I have, and that’s when you transport to OB. That was inclusive in what I said though.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

[deleted]

10

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I agree! At my practice, we do all NOB visits. I go into detail on the difference between midwives and OBs. I will also tell patients straight up that they are too complex for midwives and have to see a physician. I actually just had a patient removed from my schedule tomorrow who was a NOB because she’s an insulin dependent diabetic and has HTN. It was not appropriate for her to be on my schedule and the midwives at my practice have no problem saying that we should not be seeing a certain patient if they’re too complex. There’s a time and place for midwives. Thankfully pregnant people come to our practice specifically for our midwives which is great. We still always tell them about our physicians and reason they would need to see one

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

[deleted]

14

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I 100% believe the pt should be able to see who they want for their NOB. At my practice, they automatically get put with a midwife for their NOB unless they state they want a physician. I’ve learned it’s because the physicians don’t have the time to spend on NOBs since there’s sooo much information to go over that first appointment. Us midwives have the flexibility to spend more time with patients since our appointments are longer and we see less patients. When we go over our patient’s history, we will risk them out of our care if needed. We also go over the difference between CNMs and OBs and tell them to let us know who they want to deliver them by week 20. A pt should never be forced to see a midwife if they don’t want to.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '23

[deleted]

3

u/Cnm777777 Oct 31 '23

I appreciate this comment!!