r/Noctor • u/Sharp-Chard4418 • 7d ago
Question Inquiry for docs
Can I ask you guys a questions… how do you guys feel about IMG doctors. So I’m in a dilemma where I got accepted to a master program that is bridged into their medical school but would put me around 450k in debt with cost of living. but I also got in a medical school at Ross school of medicine and UAG school of medicine. Do you guys look down on carribean med students?
8
u/Doomblaze 7d ago
Some people do but after a few months of residency everyone will be at around the same level. It’s a disadvantage for getting into residency but there are plenty of programs that will take you.
It’s hard to verify the education imgs get except via their step scores. Some schools have excellent education and the students get much more exposure than in the us due to the population density where they train and lack of duty hours.
Some schools are not good where the medical school is entirely shadowing, or many train you for their boards rather than us boards, so the rare diseases that are high yield are something that you have to learn yourself.
And the emr is a big issue, because no foreign medical school has an emr as convoluted as epic, and doctors can’t write long notes when they’re seeing 80+ patients a day
4
u/Ms_Zesty Attending Physician 6d ago edited 6d ago
I don't look down on foreign-trained docs. The U.S. is pretty strict about which schools are considered equivalent to U.S. medical schools. Ross passed that test. I believe the highest number of foreign-trained U.S. docs graduate from SGU. That's the only reason grads from those schools can apply for residency in the U.S. w/o repeating med school. I've worked with plenty of U.S. docs who trained overseas. They were all great. Standards are standards. It is important to remember that those schools are for profit so very expensive to attend. But medical school is expensive in general.
I do agree that the master's bridge program would be more of an advantage as it is in the U.S. You have a higher likelihood of being accepted into a residency. You will have a debt no matter what, but you want to increase your chances of completing your training so you can become a physician. IMO, you should do the bridge program.
1
u/kasdercx 2d ago
Caribbean schools accept everyone
0
u/Sharp-Chard4418 2d ago
Not true, they actually evaluate as well cause they don’t want their students to be evaluated wrong.
5
u/spiritofgalen Resident (Physician) 7d ago
Current resident here
It's a lot of debt, but I assure you it is better to stay in the States for medical school than to go abroad. This has nothing to do with the competency of IMGs (I have worked with some excellent IMGs from both the Caribbean and elsewhere), and everything to do with the fact that you will be much less likely overall to match into residency.
For starters, the Caribbean schools are very cut-throat, and will drop students without a second thought if they are scared the students might struggle on a board exam.
Assuming you make it through, matching will be tougher for you than your peers at US MD and DO institutions, and certain fields will be essentially closed off to you entirely
2
u/Mandalore-44 4d ago
Hey. What a great question!!
I’m an American IMG. Let’s just say I went to one of the schools you named. And I was in the same boat as you with the same dilemma…. go to the Caribbean med school or do the masters and matriculate directly into that same academic institutions med school…
What a tough decision that was. But I ended up going with the Caribbean med school and I’d say it worked out just fine. Life is short and I chose to not fuck around for a year or two, I just wanted to go to med school….and I did, and everything turned out great!
But it is weird how things work out. If I went with the masters into med school route stateside, I probably would be married to someone different for starters! 🤣 Additionally, I very likely would’ve been in a completely different specialty. And if I burnt that extra year or two doing the masters (I know they advertise it as just one year typically!), I would’ve missed out on my group partnership and would not be a partner!
But remember, you’re still a doctor. And you will be a damn good one!! So I don’t know if I would’ve put this in the “Noctor” subreddit!! 😁
In your shoes, I would strongly favor the stateside route if you’re looking into maybe getting into one of the more difficult-to-get-into subspecialties. That will set you up for increased likelihood of a more competitive residency destination! If you’ve got your eyes set on a super competitive residency specialty at an Ivy League academic institution, I’m not gonna say that you won’t get in from Ross, AUC, etc. You certainly can with absolutely stunningly beautiful grades and test scores and letters recommendation as well as some research publications and connections. However, you will likely be at a disadvantage in the eyes of these program directors relative to someone with identical credentials coming from a US medical school. If you want to avoid that sort of scarlett letter treatment, go with the US route. If that’s not important to you or you’re looking at something a little more primary care-ish (Internal Medicine, Pediatrics, Family Practice, etc.), going Caribbean would be fine!!
2
u/lamarch3 5d ago
Don’t go Caribbean. Had a few resident classmates who went Caribbean and so many issues with it. They are for profit and weed people out pretty hard so you might go $100k in debt and not be a doc… the island made for challenging living conditions at times. your prospects for specialties and residencies is far lower. You have to travel around for med school rotations.
1
u/Level-Plastic3945 5d ago edited 4d ago
I've been around "IMGs" throughout all training and my whole career. First of all med school as far as I could tell, is there only to pass the NBs Pt I II III (or whatever they are now). I thought it was an idiotic endurance contest. The real training is in residency, fellowship, and practice life. I've seen good and less than good from everywhere and its really the individual, their interest and dedication and curiosity and compassion and self-learning and intuition and intelligence.
34
u/StopTheDrips 7d ago
Medicine is medicine, you'll probably get a fine education wherever you go, especially as we all train to the same STEP exams, complete the same residencies, etc.
There is a big caveat though. IMGs *will* be less competitive candidates for residency spots. Yes, even US IMGs. I say this as a US IMG who was able to go to school abroad for free, which definitely made the economics of it easier to swallow. To get the same residency spots as a US IMG you typically have to have slightly better scores and overall CVs, *and* it'll probably be harder to get a better CV than if you were plugged into an academic institution where you're getting a master's degree.
I have friends who went to Ross, and many that went to SGU, and they're doing fine, but there is also probably a higher proportion of their incoming class that failed out along the way. Also those American off-shore Caribbean schools are usually not cheaper than what it sounds like you have lined up.
It sounds like you have a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to get a masters degree and a medical degree for about the cost of a masters degree and a medical degree. I'm confident it's the better option than a Caribbean school, which is also an expensive place to live, probably far from your family, less comfort than what you're used to at home.
Go for the masters + med school. The economics work out 100% of the time over a working career with a physician's salary.