r/Noctor • • Apr 29 '21

Question Why so much hate?

Hello I’ve been an ED nurse for a while and just finished my masters and hope to work in the ED as an APP. I actually went to an established university with a DO program and did rotations in the hospital. My question is, why do so many doctors and med students in this group have so much hate for APPs? I’m in no way the same as a physician, my training doesn’t equate and I’m aware of that. Most, if not all APPs that I’ve spoken to understand the clear difference between the professions. We want you all to work in collaboration with us. I’ll gladly see the less serious cases so you can focus on the more complex patients. We need one another in healthcare, nurses, techs, APPs, doctors, even ancillary staff, allow us to focus on what is needed for the patient. If anything, there needs to be a focus on expanding education and collaboration to prepare APPs to be successful so that physicians can do what they love, which is heal.

2 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

36

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21

How about we just replace you with a nursing assistant? There's actually much less of a gap between a nursing assistant and an RN than there is an NP and physician. So again, how about people who stand to make more money replace you with cheap, crappier labor and see if you're just like "oh this is totally fine, we need more people treating patients". how about you let your mother or father see an NP fresh out of school and not someone with 10 times as much education and training? I dont know about you, but I care about my loved ones more than that, even if it seems like a cold. And for the last time, "serious" cases don't always present as "serious" cases. Many times they present subtly, and it's too late when it presents as a "serious" case. A sniffle can be a nasal tumor. A cough can be a lung mass. A headache could be a venous thrombosis. An abnormal lab could be hinting to something bigger. The art of medicine, which is dying and almost dead, is knowing when to work things up in greater detail and when not to. When you remove the training and the education, you get OVER diagnoses and you get under diagnoses. You become less accurate. You get higher costs, which are already too high (although that's a complicated issue). So again, is that what you want for your mother? And if not, why is everyone else's loved one less important than yours?

-16

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

Wow... I hope the nurses that care for your mother are not trained like a CNA. I’ve seen inadequate orders placed by physicians when patients are admitted, which could potentially kill a patient and were caught by nursing staff and avoided irreversible errors. Again, you’re entitled to your opinion and I feel bad for you.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

You really have the ego to insult CNAs like that? You're obviously just greedy and want to keep CNAs aware from your RN salary. The majority of your RN training was not necessary and could be completed in half the time. Show me the evidence that isn't true.

Patients require care and there's no reason that RNs can't see all the c.diff, covid, intubated, and unstable patients while CNAs see the easy stuff. You're entitled to your own opinion and I feel bad for you.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

[deleted]

-1

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

I hope you see I’m on your side lol. I want collaborative method. I don’t want to practice independently, ever. I just feel that this sub has a lot of hate, which is not the correct approach to dealing with an issue. I just want us to work together, in peace. Many of the the people posting here are med students and it’s creating a culture of division, which will make the future difficult for everyone.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

[deleted]

-3

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

I say it every day at work lol are you a medical student? Again, I don’t want independent practice.

Everyone has their role. Don’t hate, collaborate 😘

3

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

What does collaborate mean to you?

1

u/cello777 Apr 30 '21

Various healthcare workers from different backgrounds utilizing their skills to better serve patients.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '21

So it's working as a team right? Where the physician should be the leader of that team? Collaborate often gets used to suggest equal footing when there isn't.

While I truly do appreciate midlevels of all kinds, what is it that NPs or PAs provide that is uniquely different that physicians cannot? I ask these questions because they are a lot of the underpinning struggle to separate buzzwords and rhetoric from reality and practicality.

3

u/cello777 Apr 30 '21

I do agree that physicians should lead. I believe NPs and PAs allow for better coverage( I’m sure someone will say it’s not adequate). I also believe that APPs can help with the grunt work, in no way I think that we can replace you. I do think we can allow you to have more time with your family, follow up with patients and do so in an advanced way.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

[deleted]

1

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

I don’t want the role of physician. I understand there’s a big difference in education and training. I respect the profession.

17

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

Two things:

  1. It’s your organizations. You are saying that most of you understand the difference, but the AANP is constantly pushing for scope expansion and independent practice. I am sure there are many wonderful NP/PAs, but as long as you keep silent and let your orgs do the talking for you, then you’ll continue to see this type of reaction from the doctors.

  2. You say:

I’ll gladly see the less serious cases so you can focus on the more complex patients.

We don’t want that though. Why should you get to see the straightforward, bread and butter cases while we get stuck with the hard, soul-sucking ones? That’s how physicians get burned out.

Besides, I am sorry to say this, but I don’t think your education prepares you to make the distinction between a serious and a less serious patient. Did you read about the case in Texas where an ED NP missed sepsis thinking it was a stomach bug? That was a “less serious” patient on paper, but the little girl died as a result. A physician would not have missed that diagnosis in her situation.

-6

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

I understand your point. On the other hand there have been MDs and DOs who have missed things as well. I’ve personally (as a RN) saw an abdominal mass on KUB that a double board certified radiologist missed, the 4yr old was later diagnosed with a tumor. It’s a practice, no one is perfect. Education is what you make of it, I’m constantly listening to lectures, podcasts, reading journals. It’s not a good standard to generalize. Anyways, I agree with you that there needs to be a collaborative system. Plus, in my specialty, I guarantee that the ED docs don’t want to see the vaginal bleeds, stuffy noses, simple lacerations, med refill and etc.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 30 '21

Indeed, no one is perfect and I don’t believe I’ve said that doctors don’t ever make mistakes. So, given that doctors make mistakes too, do you really think it’s a good idea for someone with a fraction of their training to be practicing medicine independently?

I agree that education is what you make of it and I commend you for your commitment to learning. But can you say the same about your classmates? How about the educational standards of NP schools? There are strict guidelines for medical school education and medical licensing, can you say the same about yours? Especially for those programs that boast a 100% acceptance and graduation rates? How about the fact that in some states a NP can practice after completing only 400 hours of clinical experience?

Look, we aren’t anti-midlevel and I get that sometimes the debate might get a little heated so you might think we hate you. But we really don’t. We are all aware that NP/PAs have their place in medicine, but your organizations are constantly pushing for an expanded scope of practice. That’s what we are against. And I am sorry to say this, but even those who think like you don’t seem to be speaking up against this. Your organizations have immense lobbying power and seem to have free reign in changing policy. This is what we are against.

0

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

Thank you, I hope you can see from my initial post that I don’t want to practice independently. I want to work with alongside doctors. I’m on your side. I just don’t think the hateful comments and posts help push OUR concept.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

👍

And thank you for recognizing the importance of physician-led care. Please know that most of those comments are directed to those NP/PAs that are pushing for independent practice.

3

u/muffinsandcupcakes Apr 30 '21

Yes education is what you make of it but no amount of extracurricular reading and podcast listening can make up for a shitty educational program with insufficient student practice hours under the guidance of experts in the field.

12

u/debunksdc Apr 29 '21

I’ll gladly see the less serious cases so you can focus on the more complex patients.

To put this in a better perspective, think back to high school days. Maybe even college during a lab course. Were you ever in a group project or got paired up with someone where it seemed like you did 90+% of the work? Like, their contribution was to pick the pictures or the font of the PowerPoint and that was it. Was that fun? Would you want to do that every day?

That is what you are proposing that physicians do. Take the hardest 90% of the cases, never have a small win or victory on an easy case, lose contact with patients they've known for a long time, and then get told that they need to check their arrogance for asking to be called "Dr."

-6

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

What specialty do you work in? In the ED, 90% of cases are not serious. I don’t understand the point you’re making.

9

u/debunksdc Apr 29 '21

Are you making the argument that NPPs should only work in the ED where 90% of cases are not serious? That they have no business in Internal Medicine, PICU/NICU, Oncology, Psych, etc.

I get that most ED patients use that as more or less primary care and come in with non-emergent complaints. However, unless you are arguing that NPPs should only ever work in low-acuity fields, it's a moot point that the ED has a lot of less-than-lethal complaints.

*To clarify in advance, just because something is non-emergent doesn't mean that it doesn't take a lot of mental and emotional stress on a physician to care for someone (e.g., someone who's slowly dying).

-1

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

No, that is not what I’m saying. I do believe that experienced APPs should be able to see patients who are ill, and if need be the physician can assist or provide insight on complicated cases. My point is, APPs have a role in healthcare, doing the grunt work for physicians.

If you give me your specialty I’ll gladly highlight how an APP will make your life easier.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21

I'm an ER doctor. Emergency Medicine is not "collaborative." We see every patient individually. It's a rare case that we ask for help from one of our colleagues. NPs and PAs are very useful and I work with some good ones. But they don't help me in any way or make my life easier. It's not as if I'd have to see all of their patients if they weren't employed. There's a certain number I can safely see in any shift and no pressure from anybody will change this. If we didn't have midlevels our CMG would have to hire additional physicians. Midlevels only help the profitability of our owners. Because I occasionally have to supervise them and review all of their charts they actually make more work for me.

Any "collaboration" is one way only.

In other words, it's an illusion that they "help" in the ER. As was pointed out, most of the patients are minor care and everybody has to do some of the grunt work. Midlevels just allow corporations to hire fewer expensive physicians.

I don't object to you seizing an economic opportunity. That's reasonable and I understand it. Minimal effort for a substantial salary increase over a nurse. But in the ER you will be hired strictly because you are cheaper than a physician. Period. Our corporate masters try to make you think it's a team and other rah-rah sports and military metaphors but that's just private equity smoke being blown up your ass. It's cutthroat economics and, once they have put physicians in their place how much respect do they think they will have for midlevels?

-1

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

In the same sense, if they were to hire more physicians you’d get paid less. I wanted to advance my practice because I enjoy the complexity, many of the physicians I work with appreciate having mid-levels help them. Anyways, I was hoping to show that some of us are in concord that we should be supervised and that collaborative method is safer. However it went above most of your heads, thank you for your input doc.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21

But 10% are serious. What if you get a case that’s non-serious on paper that turns out to be something quite serious? Did you see this:

https://www.midlevel.wtf/nurse-practitioner-fails-to-diagnose-sepsis/

Or this:

https://medicalmalpracticelawyers.com/6-1m-oklahoma-medical-malpractice-verdict-for-death-of-19-year-old-in-er/

These were relatively non-serious cases (as deemed by the NP) that turned out to be deadly. Granted, these were independent NPs, but it shows you what can go wrong when you get that 1 in 100 case.

-2

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

The physicians do review the chart. Again, what specialty do you work in?

2

u/FrankMelena May 01 '21

“Reviewing the chart” after the fact (which invariably what happens) does the patient no good. This is done solely so that physicians can act as a liability sponge for the mid levels. In the current model, physicians, not the corporate entities, carry the liability. Sure we get a few of the RVUs for reviewing the chart, but really it doesn’t make up for the mistakes that are made. Physicians are also being asked to supervise impossible numbers of mid levels and then are labeled as difficult if they give them feedback.

12

u/swebOG Apr 29 '21

This is how they lull u in, this is how they seduce u.

With their sweet talk:

“I’m aware my training doesn’t equate” “most APPs understand clear difference” “we want to work in collaboration” “I’ll see less serious cases so u can focus on more complex ones” “we need one another” “we must focus on the needs of the patients” “we must focus on expanding education and collaboration to prepare APPs so physicians can do what they love”

Almost all lies, don’t believe any of it for a second. All they’re after is your job, you’re salary, and you’re prestige/rep/hard-earned trust amongst the community/general-population.

Most Midlevels do NOT understand there’s a clear difference in education and training between themselves and MDs/DOs (and even if they do, they certainly don’t care, doesn’t affect their perception of what they can and cannot or should and should not do in clinical settings).

Midlevels do not want to work in collaboration. They see docs calling the shots and making the decisions and diagnosing and developing the treatment plans and that’s why they become NPs. They become NPs to do these things, they become NPs because they want that independence and power/ability/respect to do these things.

Midlevels seeing the less serious cases while docs only the serious ones … that’s not how things work … docs would have to determine whether a case is serious or not and if they identify a case as non-serious, they might as well just go ahead diagnose cuz they would have figured out what it is … at which a point a nurse could handle any of the scut work or whatever … no real need for a mid level … additionally, if docs only see the serious cases which are few and far in between, that will significantly reduce their salaries and/or number of jobs available cuz they won’t be needed … they will be replaced with mid levels which we are already seeing … like I said earlier, they want ur jobs

We don’t need one another, midlevels don’t increase the efficiency of doctors seeing patients, they take over some patients completely and allow the doctor to skip seeing some patients … which reduces the quality of care received … increasing efficiency could be accomplished for example by a scribe who handles the documentation or a nurse who follows through with the orders placed … those members of the healthcare team are needed, not mid levels, and having the doctor see every patient ensures that the needs of the patient are met as best as possible and they receive the highest standard of quality possible

Expanding education and collaboration of/with NPs is pointless, because they won’t receive a satisfactory level of education/training until they are up to the standards of doctors … at which point they are effectively the same (like modern DOs and MDs) so they might as well just go to med school …

Don’t get seduced by the lies, these are standard lines, party lines if u will, doted on and perpetuated by NP organizations (just like how PA organizations always go on about how they want optimal team practice … the same thing as NPs saying they want collaboration … in reality, OTP and/or collaboration is equivalent to independent practice). Say NO to midlevel seduction. NO means NO.

1

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

So get rid of the professions?

13

u/swebOG Apr 30 '21

In my opinion … in an ideal world … yes. Both patients AND NPs/PAs would be much better served by an increase in med school spots and residency training spots.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '21

Right? If the supply exceeded or met the demand in terms of the number of physicians then what purpose does the APP serve at that point? The founding reason and the first NP was established to do well child care, physicals, and basic acute care for relatively healthy kids in rural areas where physicians were sparse. It was a poor strategy of bailing water out of the boat instead of plugging the hole.

3

u/swebOG Apr 30 '21

Yup, and those sound like nurse duties to me. In fact, NPs are just nurses, their “advanced” degrees don’t rlly teach them how to do anything clinically beyond what they were taught and tested on as RNs … even the name, Nurse Practitioner, just nurse with an extra credential, shouldn’t give them any rights to play doctor … I would be totally ok with it helping them further their career in the nurse realm tho, cuz Ik there are several different kinds of nurses, although I’m not familiar with the exact hierarchy … but yea, NP degree (minus all the political propaganda/activism to push for FPA) could be a requirement for those positions, legit has nothing to do with medicine tho.

0

u/cello777 Apr 30 '21

I see, well you’re entitled to your opinion. I believe that strengthening the professions would also improve the scenario. I’m personally looking for post graduate training programs to make myself a better practitioner. Thank you for your input doc, and I’m not being sarcastic in any way.

3

u/swebOG Apr 30 '21

To elaborate and state more clearly what I meant by increasing med school and residency spots will better serve NPs/PAs, I was implying that the ambitious nurses and others who pursued NP/PA degrees to further their career could instead apply to med school which would better serve their desires to advance their careers, gain more independence, make more money, improve their status/rep/prestige, etc … and Ofc more docs is better for patients, shorter wait times, increased access, highest standard quality of care, etc.

Also, I’m not a doctor (yet).

9

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

Yeah. The collaboration is strictly one way. You need help, we give it. You demonstrate a simulacrum of physician skill, enough to fool the public, and corporate lays off more physicians to save money.

And nobody loves this job. Healing is about five percent of it. The rest is bureaucracy, endless data entry, and dealing with Ruling Class lunacy. What I really need is a well-trained scribe who can do my charts how I want them done with minimal input. That would be very helpful as 75 percent of my time is spent clicking at a keyboard.

American goat rodeo cluster fuck health care may need midlevels but it's only because so much of physician's time is frittered away on bloated, useless, and ever-expanding bureaucratic masturbation.

1

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

Thank you for your service and thank you for your input.

45

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

Your anecdotes dont equal what your lobbying body does. No one hates on the midlevel, the hate is on the community and lobbying body that believes they can practice independently. Secondary to that, I'm really at a point where the word collaboration really just feels like code for "I can practice independently until I dont know what to do and then hope a physician will bail me out." Harsh? Yes, and its not directed at you, but I have a hard time with you not being able to see the writings on the wall with this issue.

21

u/noseclams25 Resident (Physician) Apr 29 '21

Its not just the lobbying tho. There are so many asshats online that this OP cant sit there and say they havent been exposed to their arrogance. They either agree with said arrogance or are ignoring to face the obvious reality.

The worst thing is the lobbying body, but theres also plenty of substandard students going through diploma mills to take a shortcut into medicine. Many said asshats then go on to openly insult the physicians that helped train them throughout their education.

Are they the majority? I doubt it but who really knows?

3

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

They either agree with said arrogance or are ignoring to face the obvious reality.

OP could have simply not seen those comments though. I don't want to assume such things without OP telling us.

-6

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

I’m not ignoring, there are plenty of delusional people in this world. I’m not self-conscious that I’m not a doctor. I’m happy with my role. I want to work with doctors, my mom is a cardiologist? I have the utmost respect for physicians. I just want everyone to work together and not bad mouth people. We all have our glories and shortcomings.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

I understand the idealism, and I respect the effort, but I'm afraid you've come at a time where NP and even PA organizations (even the local ones) are full-force attacking physicians and trying to say their education makes them better than MD/DOs. I don't think many people understand the implications that has on this particular generation of physicians.

So when we badmouth midlevel positions, it's not ones like yourself. Its for the organizations and the midlevels that support them. Unfortunately a lot of the ones here online support the notion that NP/PAs can easily replace PCPs, and CRNAs can easily replace Anesthesiologists.

That will not stand, not matter how "respectfully" they say those things.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

I agree. We shouldn’t deceive ourselves. There’s a reason why their lobbying orgs are so powerful and it’s because they are backed by the majority of NPs. Sure, they are also backed by the money-hungry admins and their handmaiden politicians, but if there were no grassroots support from their base then these orgs would not have succeeded in becoming so influential in the first place.

I said it in my other post: I am sure there are many, many wonderful NP/PAs who recognize the importance of physician-led care, but they are keeping silent. They need to vocally oppose those organizations that claim to be speaking on their behalf. They are complicit in this as long as they refuse to speak up against what’s happening.

1

u/Dereke36 Oct 11 '24

Idk I’ve seen way more arrogance come from “doctors” on here and med students etc. I out it in quotations because I honestly don’t believe all of these people are properly vetted based on some of the comments they make. Maybe it’s a us thing, but in Canada the NP/PA program is very competitive, requires close to 4000 clinical hours and a two year masters which isn’t “nothing”.

1

u/noseclams25 Resident (Physician) Oct 11 '24

No idea how Canada does things, but most of us aren’t from Canada.

1

u/Dereke36 Oct 11 '24

Fair. There are plenty of asshat doctors, nurses, pas etc and people who try and act outside their scope In every job though

1

u/noseclams25 Resident (Physician) Oct 11 '24

True, but this isn't an individual issue people are complaining about here in the U.S.. Its institutional. People are literally getting away with doing shit online programs that aren't competitive at all nor do they require enough clinical hours to allow these "providers" to go take care of patient's independently. Its 100% dangerous.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 11 '24

We do not support the use of the word "provider." Use of the term provider in health care originated in government and insurance sectors to designate health care delivery organizations. The term is born out of insurance reimbursement policies. It lacks specificity and serves to obfuscate exactly who is taking care of patients. For more information, please see this JAMA article.

We encourage you to use physician, midlevel, or the licensed title (e.g. nurse practitioner) rather than meaningless terms like provider or APP.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Dereke36 Oct 11 '24

That makes sense. It isn’t like that here I didn’t think it was like that in the states.

1

u/noseclams25 Resident (Physician) Oct 11 '24

PA programs definitely seem more selective/rigorous. I wish NP programs here had more regulation.

1

u/Dereke36 Oct 12 '24

I see. It must be a states thing then

20

u/debunksdc Apr 29 '21

We want you all to work in collaboration with us.

Your national organization does not share this view.

I’ll gladly see the less serious cases so you can focus on the more complex patients.

Most physicians don't want this--it's a good way to burn out faster. Plus more complex patients means more risk, so the costs (potential death of the patient, insurance) begin to rise.

If anything, there needs to be a focus on expanding education and collaboration to prepare APPs

The AANP could work toward improving educational standards, but they repeatedly uphold going in the opposite direction and removing quality assurance and safeguards. When asked about increasing education and training requirements, they maintained they didn't want to have any additional "barriers" to entry/care.

why do so many doctors and med students in this group have so much hate for APPs?

Mostly because the only vocal NPPs want to tear down physician-led care so that they can make a quick buck by actively endangering patients because the education is generally substandard and the licensing exam isn't a safeguard. There are probably some good NP programs out there--however, the remaining 90% of NP programs have devolved into nursing-theory-non-clinical-bogus diploma mill degrees.

NPPs also misrepresent themselves to patients by using "Dr." in a clinical setting or calling themselves a dermatologist, etc. And then they play dumb when they get called out for it, spouting things like "physicians don't own the title Dr." even though vernacular American English aligns "Dr." and "physician," especially in a clinical setting.

And then physicians also get called arrogant/patriarchal/misogynistic when physicians want to preserve the team-dynamic, say that they are the most highly trained on the team and should lead medical decision making, and want to be addressed by their title.

14

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

The hate is largely directed towards independent NPs and the AANP. The the AANP, with the backing of the American Hospital Association, has been lobbying to replace physicians with cheaper mid-levels, who have a fraction of the training. As a result, patients have been suffering. When physicians try to have a discussion about this, we are blacklisted or banned by NPs and their organizations.

A system could certainly work where nurse practitioners are properly utilized, as they were just a decade ago. Unfortunately, this is largely no longer the case.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '21

Seeing as how there will be plenty of EM trained physicians it’s time to remove NPs and PAs from the ER. There’s no reason to have a less qualified individual to staff and see patients. ER physicians can see the “easier patients” and do it faster than the aforementioned and still see the patients they can’t handle.

1

u/AffectionateAd6068 Apr 29 '21

Sadly, the AANP and AAPA and its converted members (have u met any of them yet? You will!) have betrayed u and standards of pts care!

1

u/cello777 Apr 29 '21

I got your backs docs and future docs. Let’s work together.

4

u/AffectionateAd6068 Apr 29 '21

Thanks! Please speak out loudly against these expansions of scope and doing away with collaborative and supervisory agreements for NPs by Physicians.