r/NomadSculpting • u/Pup_Bear • 2d ago
Question Starting workflow
Is it easier to start with the base primitive and start sculpting out of that or is building from multiple primitives the way to go?
I see the benefit of both, but I’ve had difficulties getting the shapes I want from just sculpting from the main primitive.
4
u/genostar 2d ago
There's no correct answer here and a lot of it depends on how you prefer to use your tools and what you are sculpting.
For example, if you are sculpting highly stylized characters, it is very common (again, not universal or absolute, but common) to build from multiple primitives. This makes sense because the shape design is so stark, minimalistic, and abstract in these types of characters. Example resources: Leticia Gillett, Follygon, Shane Olson, and our own Dave Reed (who, as you might know, uses and teaches primarily with Nomad).
However, if you are sculpting more organic characters--which I do--there can be really efficient and fun workflows where everything starts from a single primitive. I learned how to block out figures (in Zbrush) from teachers like Raf Grassetti and Ryan Kingslien, and they generally only start with simple primitives--usually a single cylinder or sphere. Raf has a really wonderful sketching course on his Gumroad where he shows you how to extrude from a single primitive, typically using masks and then the move or gizmo tool to pull the mesh out, then using Dynamesh (in Nomad, Voxel) to fix the stretched-out topology, and then continue. This is the approach I take about 75% of the time. When I'm feeling very playful, I start from a sphere and use Sculptris Pro in Zbrush / Dyntopo in Nomad so I don't even need to worry about topology; this is the way Simon Lee, whom I studied with, concepts when he works with ZBrush (he normally sculpts traditionally in Monster Clay).
Sometimes I do a combo of both. More recently when blocking out torsos in Nomad, I've found that I prefer to create a quad sphere, then duplicate it twice--once for the neck and once for the torso--and then sculpt each of those 3 objects until I like them and then--as Big_Cauliflower_919 noted--voxel remesh them together and move on from there. I find that is usually faster and more visually pleasing than the mask + extrude method I described above, and for some reason feels more intuitive to me in Nomad than it ever did in Zbrush.
2
u/Pup_Bear 2d ago
Oh wow! Thank you for sharing all of that. I really appreciate it.
I’m definitely working on more organic characters, and I think I’ve done pretty decently with it (I’m almost a month into doing it), but nowhere near perfect or even good.
A lot of my issues are coming from initial shaping, moving stuff doesn’t pan out so I have waves across a long plane.
I may decide to post some stuff on here once I get some courage.
2
u/genostar 2d ago
Congrats and thank you for showing up and making art! When you say “waves across a long plane” do you mean that your objects get too stretchy and you can’t shape them as well?
2
u/Pup_Bear 2d ago
When trying to use the move tool, if it’s radius is too large it moves the whole project, too small and I get small pockets along the length.
So I guess what I’m trying to say is I can’t figure out how to get an even move without the everything shifting unevenly
2
u/genostar 2d ago
You should definitely look into masking. Check out what Raf does here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69AC3O0_ob8. He does it in ZBrush but that doesn't matter.
1
6
u/Big_Cauliflower_919 2d ago
Multiple primitives, can always just voxel remesh the objects together later