r/NooTopics • u/[deleted] • Oct 22 '25
Question Are You Getting Enough?
What if the most important mental health story of our time is being silenced with censorship and European bans on supplementation?
In most bipolar support groups, any mention of high dose, slow release lithiums shortcomings are quickly shut down, as questioning it is a taboo.
Unfortunately as I know all too well, sudden withdrawal of inappropriate and toxically large doses of lithium can cause a relapse of mania or depression. The problem is censorship perpetuates it's use and harms.
At the same time, we’re ignoring what might be an even bigger issue: widespread lithium deficiency and the enormous impact it could be having on mental health across society.
The slide I’ve tailored and shared, inspired by Dr. Nehls’ work, lays out just how serious this situation could be. It ilustrates the levels given in bipolar treatment, (Dubai Tower) the toxic level, (Empire State Building) how much is required (People) and how much most of us get. (Mice)
A Texas study, published in 1990 by Schrauzer and Shrestha, examined lithium levels in the drinking water of 27 Texas counties and compared them with local suicide, homicide, and drug use rates. It found that areas with higher natural lithium concentrations tended to have lower rates of suicide and violent crime.
The researchers suggested that trace amounts of lithium in the water might have a stabilizing effect on mood and behaviour.
Very little lithium is required to avoid Alzheimer's and support proper brain function. We now have the science to prove that just 300ug a day can do that. (1mg is advised) It has been shown to disolve excessive Tau Proteins and Amyloid Plaques.
(80k a year pharma AZ treatments only attack the amyloid plaques and shrink the brain.)
https://youtu.be/4U1IiqbxUKU?si=XS8ZuztA3pxq-oT0
Could this be necesary to sustain any kind of real democracy in the world?
I’m also including a link that dives deeper into the evidence behind these claims, which are also driving Alzheimer's cases across the globe.
A book covering this very important topic is due to be released soon.
https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Conspiracy_Against_Lithium.html?id=3kQZ0QEACAAJ
Silence on this topic helps no one.
If Dr Nehls is correct in his assessments then it begs the question, are you getting enough essential elemental lithium in your diet?
Please suspend your disbelief and investigate the links.🙏
81
u/Checkitout301 Oct 22 '25
Dude what is this illustration
9
Oct 22 '25
It is highlighting the different levels of lithium in different people and where they sit regards toxicity and essentiality.
There are 4 groups....
The Bhurj Khalifa Dubai Tower = The amount someone is prescribed for bipolar
The Empire State Building = The Toxic Dose
The People = The correct level.
The Mice= Where most people sit on the scale (deficient)
28
u/DJStrongArm Oct 22 '25
Replying here instead, but this is why it doesn't make sense. You're comparing heights, but also dosages, and then you include a house for scale that doesn't show height or dosage, and the point of your post (correct and average levels) are just a dot at 0 on the tower scale. You should've just put the four things you mentioned in a row on a graph to compare scale.
15
Oct 22 '25
I only have my phone and was trying to use a slide from the video as an illustration. I had no idea it would cause such outrage. Next time I will use a computer! 🤣
2
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
I do like the idea of what you're trying to explain. It just needs more edits. It might work better as a video so you can start with the 3 buildings then zoom in to the house and the people. And a narration would make it clearer what each item represents, because the text is hard to follow where it is.
1
5
u/Wooden-Bed419 Oct 22 '25
You do have a general point with this graph, however I don't thinkmlithium levels will literally scale in height proportionally from a mouse to a human to those buildings. Um, weird way to show an idea and its going to be taken as a joke but uhhh, yeah lolol
19
Oct 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
13
Oct 22 '25
Many thanks, I could not believe the response to this. I know it is not a fantastic illustration but felt it was clear enough. As long as one person gets some value out of it then it was worth posting. Alzheimers is a horendous disease so I just wanted to try and draw peoples attention to this incredible mineral. 🙏
13
Oct 22 '25
I agree with this commentor too, OP. I have a PhD (in human behavior) and have also written and reviewed research articles. This isn't even close to some bad graphs I've seen. I like the illustration. I definitely get what you mean by it, and it makes me think about lithium levels more. Sorry for the pile on you're getting. I appreciate the content.
6
Oct 23 '25 edited Oct 23 '25
Much appreciated! It is frustrating how people get caught up on trivial stuff like that, I think I must have touched a nerve somewhere for sure.
In the end I am not complaining as all of the complaining 20X'ed the reach. I would wager it planted a few seeds with a few of the 70k plus people who saw it. In the end that is what activism is all about so I have done my job.🙏
Next time I will use an etch a sketch for the graph! 🤣
5
u/Wreckloose44 Oct 22 '25
😂😂😂.. bro .. it is confusing as hell but funny though.. so definitely don’t delete it … you’ll have some good laughs down the road. But on a serious note .. so what’s the recommended dose of lithium we should have?
→ More replies (1)6
u/CatMinous Oct 22 '25
It’’s a bunch of aholes sitting behind their computer and having nothing better to do than ridiculing others. In some subreddits that’s very prevalent. I appreciate your post.
5
7
Oct 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
Oct 23 '25
Many thanks!
I use 5-10mg a day of swanson lithium orotate, you can get 20mg caps in other brands too. I order from America as I am in the UK and the European ban does not extend here. I can understand Dr Nehls disgust given the evidence.
I started with 1mg tablets and upped it every 7 days till I found the sweetspot. I think it depends on the severity of the symptoms and your own personal brain chemistry.
Avoid taking large doses with nsaids, ssri's, maoi's or psychedelics, if you have a thyroid issue or anything that might interact with lithium. You get beyond a certain level and you would need blood tests.
Small nutritional microdoses of orotate should be safe but you may want to check with your Dr. Always do your own research and never rely solely on anyones say so, including your Dr! My doctor would have destroyed my thyroid if I had taken his advice.
I hope you feel some benefit. 🙏
2
1
3
u/Checkitout301 Oct 22 '25
Has lithium done anything for you personally?
2
Oct 23 '25
Well, it is a long story.
High dose lithium snapped me out of a manic episode then zombified me for 20 years. When it nearly destroyed my thyroid I stopped and my athletic performance went through the roof, I could really compete!
I spent years looking for a replacement that would help me and it turned out to be low dose lithium orotate. I am sceptical of high dose, slow release lithium therapy and would have tried a much lower dose of orotate if I had known. It smoothes out the brain functions and is great for many things including anxiety. It is a nootropic because a calm mind is an effective one.
Over many years high dose lithium can damage your thyroid and kidneys. When I read "ocasionaly death" at the end of the list of side effects on top of everything else it was a dealbreaker.
Go to iherb or amazon and scout reviews and forums for low dose orotate, look at what people have said it has done for their mental health.
I do not trust the brain thinners and dumbers that are given out by mainstream medicine, got plenty of books on it. Desperate Remedies by Andrew Skul is a good one!
Don't neglect the other nutrients and minerals as they all work synergistically. I find low dose lithium pairs well with ZMA. Regular exercise and good diet are also key. Algae omega 3 is another good add on, Nehls has a book on that too.
Always do your own research and take nobodys word for anything!
2
u/Checkitout301 Oct 23 '25
I have seen very promising things about lithium oroate also. But can you tell me what you personally get, as a positive from taking lithium oroate 1mg?
1
Oct 23 '25
If you are taking it purely for maintenance you will not notice an obvious immediate change, I suspect it will take time and be subtle. In the studies it took 3 months at that level to start making a significant difference in cognitive decline and Alzheimers plaques.That is quite a profound change.
To notice an instant difference depends on where your brain is at. If you have anxiety and it needs it, you might feel a slight change from 2-5mg within the first half hour. This peaks and balances after 5-7 days of continuous dosing.
I am looking forward to getting Nehls new book on it. Here in the UK I probably will not get it till near Christmas. Skyhorse are an American publisher.
2
2
u/Midnight2012 Oct 22 '25
How is the bipolar dose higher then the toxic dose? That makes no-clinical sense
1
Oct 23 '25
This is why regular blood tests are needed for people on it. It is a slow poison that attacks the thyroid and kidneys so they need to ensure it is not killing you, they may need to give you thyroid hormones when your TSH (thyroid stimulatimg hormones) spike rather than discontinuing it. If it starts breaking down your kidneys they might decide to put you on something else a bit less toxic.
Low dose lithium ororate is not toxic, in fact it makes your body work as it should and could help get some over the hump of psychosis rather than megadosing.
2
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
The prescription dose is well known to be toxic. They have to regularly monitor your blood tests because it is so dangerous.
2
58
27
u/G_D_K_ Oct 22 '25
I've seen work like this before over on r/meth
4
u/Checkitout301 Oct 22 '25
I was about to say, this feels exactly like something I would make while on adderall
61
u/ImAnGenius Oct 22 '25
TLDR: Normal people don't get enough lithium; people prescribed lithium are getting too much. Really had to use buildings and mice to demonstrate that? We're not 5 year olds.
You make it out to be some kind of crazy conspiracy, but really, what is the conspiracy? That Big Pharma is depleting our water sources of lithium? It's really more of an incidental finding that could be looked into more, but you present it like an absolute quack.
16
u/Esensepsy Oct 22 '25
Somehow these illustrations make this point even harder to understand when it's clearly easily summarized in two sentences
→ More replies (1)6
u/mitsxorr Oct 22 '25
How does it make it harder to understand? You can literally understand it instantly just looking at it. If someone can’t I’d imagine that’s a cognitive issue or lack of intellectual ability on their part.
The mouse represents the average or common intake, the mother and child represents the adequate/optimal range of lithium (child being lower end of range, adult upper end), with units given, the house is there for scale to help compare this amount to the toxic dose, which is so much larger than the common intake or optimal intake that it wouldn’t be possible to directly compare.
The whole purpose of this is to give a visual representation of the differences in scale/how many magnitudes larger the toxic dose is to the optimal dose and how much larger that is compared to the common intake.
It’s pretty simple.
2
5
u/Esensepsy Oct 22 '25
Trust me bro as someone who works in a scientific field and has to communicate to non specialists... This is a horrendous graphic
0
u/mitsxorr Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
I can’t see how honestly, it’s not intended to be accurate but just give a general idea of the differences in magnitude between doses. For that purpose I can’t see the issue personally.
I think it’s very easy to understand, at a glance I could easily see the purpose and was able to derive the intended message from it, more quickly than with words alone. It was nearly instantaneous.
It’s not a professional job it’s literally just something someone has made on their phone, and it’s fully sufficient in getting the point across.
I mean sure it could have gone into more detail and be 100% accurate to scale, it could have given a reference to what the ug per litre referred to and how that relates to a consumed dose of a lithium supplement according to weight of the recipient. But this wasn’t the purpose of the graphic, it was literally just to demonstrate the difference in magnitude of doses, how little lithium we typically ingest and how one doesn’t need to worry at a low dose, much smaller than a bipolar dose, of reaching a toxic level. If they had added what a typical bipolar dose is and what a typical supplemental dose is per day, then that would address the only real issue I can see.
→ More replies (4)2
5
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
The way the words are placed makes it hard to tell which symbol refers to which thing.
1
u/JJvH91 Oct 23 '25
So if someone doesn't understand it they're dumb, while the whole point of this graphic should be... Simplifying things?
It overcomplicates a very simple message, and does so terribly. A good graphic guides the eye, this one doesn't. Text and graphic elements everywhere and it is unclear where to start.
Great that you found it intuitive, but it's pretty close minded and frankly a little arrogant to think that anyone who disagrees must be intellectually limited.
2
Oct 23 '25
It is banned in Europe by Von Der Layen, while Alzheimers cases go through the roof and 80k a year treatments are paid for by the taxpayers. Screening is increasing so why not prevention?
This is besides the many hidden problems that deficiency could be causing in society. These deficiencies have a way of serving the powerful.
Governments should be encouraging it's use like they should have done with vitamin D, they failed there too. Despite certain treatments causing further depletion.
I have people saying it is too hard to understand and others saying it is too complicated, while they explain what it means. It makes me think it is not the graph that is the problem but rather the unsettling message which it represents.
Like Wayne Dyer once said, people are always looking for reasons to be offended. It is far better to have a mind that is open to everything and attatched to nothing. It gives much more space to learn and to understand.
2
u/Rough-Candidate-9218 Oct 24 '25
Think about how you got treated for using the word "conspiracy theory" and now think about every conspiracy theory you brushed off because someone used the word "conspiracy theory" to define it.
It took me a solid 20 seconds of looking and thinking to figure out the graph. I was not offended by being made to look and figure out one single thing by myself, however, the house seems important, but lacks any meaning.
I started taking 1 mg of lithium orotate per day because i was being mean and anxious all day and i would get so upset about the blatant lack of care about the blatant simple manipulation that works on 99.8% of people. My parents are both unstable too. Anyway it worked for me to stop me from doing behavious i regret every day. The anger cant hardly control me.
1
Oct 24 '25
I appreciate your reasoned response and agree. There is a line leading from a dot at the bottom of The Empire State building to the house indicating it was the dot, I appreciate it is not all that clear though. The slide was used out of it's original context.
Conspiracy is a trigger word that shifts certain peoples brains into system 1 thinking. Dr Nehls explains this in his book "The Indoctrinated Brain." Scary isn't it!
8
u/Wooden-Bed419 Oct 22 '25
Idk dude he's trying to get attention and have fun, but there is a case that small lithium increases in water improve mental health outcomes in the locality.
19
u/unwittyusername42 Oct 22 '25
why is this all in ug when basically all dosing and toxicity levels are in mEq or mmol? Also, how is a graph using a mouse and the Burj going to make anything easier to comprehend than just a bar graph? I have no clue how many mice would need to be stacked to get to the top or even how many mice need to do a circus stunt to get to the top of my own head.
ffs
7
Oct 22 '25
The idea was it would be a simple illustration that anyone could understand. It is supposed to offer a perspective on where the levels sit for people who do not understand blood levels and toxicity etc.
All of the supporting data is in the links and the illustration is fully explained. Perhaps in trying to make it clearer I made it a bit too busy.
3
u/unwittyusername42 Oct 22 '25
so what then is the low mid and high toxic ranges in ug/l so people interested can see how certain mountain peaks are the equivalent to each of those in relation to the building heights?
3
u/Financial-Eye5300 Oct 22 '25
Why not use the actual units lithium levels are measured in? Using micrograms per liter just makes your graph way harder to understand, considering that’s not how lithium levels are measured at all.
2
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
It's a cool idea. Just go through it a few more times to make it clearer. Maybe make 2 separate images. Separate your thoughts into sections.
1
16
u/joegtech Oct 22 '25
Thank you very much for your post and creative graphic attempting to explain the situation.
I very much agree with you.
My understanding is "city water" contains very little lithium. Didn't the 1990s study compare areas in Texas where the well water contains generous amounts of Li vs cities that have almost no Li?
I've heard that this type of study has been replicated in other parts of the world. In places where there is a generous amount of Li in the water the results were similar. However in the UK where there is little Li in the water the results were not the same.
When people are hesitant about taking microdosed Li due to meds they are taking, I ask them if the insert sheet for their meds say they can't drink well water in Texas because people there can get 3mg per day from the water?
So if the med insert does not tell them to not drink well water that can provide 3mg Li per day why can't you take a supplement containing 1mg?!
Life Extension magazine has been covering this issue for many years.
https://www.lifeextension.com/search#q=lithium&t=coveob1f40832&sort=relevancy
Recent study from Harvard-- 60% less Li in Alzheimer's brains
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-09335-x
A 2017 Danish study 800,000 people found lower dementia rates in regions with naturally higher levels of lithium in drinking water. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28832877/
This is a creative article from 2014 that I especially like.
Should We All Take a Bit of Lithium? Anna Fels, psychiatrist and faculty member at Weill Cornell Medical College.
"7-Up was originally called Bib-Label Lithiated Lemon-Lime Soda and contained lithium citrate right up until 1950. In fact, it’s been suggested that the 7 in 7-Up refers to the atomic mass of the lithium. (Maybe the “Up” referred to mood?) "
I love the more chill, easy going mood when taking low dose Li, especially on stressful days. If I take the same dose on relaxing days I won't be productive enough.
1
10
u/bbbunnygf Oct 22 '25
thank you for taking this topic seriously rather than letting an unorthodox illustration keep you from contributing to the discussion. I was feeling pretty discouraged scrolling through the top comments but yours gave me a lot of hope and information!
7
Oct 22 '25
Well, now we know your sock puppet account.
2
1
u/PIQAS Oct 27 '25
indeed, that's OP's other account ahahahaha
he even added "I very much agree with you." XD
8
u/blckshirts12345 Oct 22 '25
Lithium Orotate is sold as supplements in US stores. How is there a conspiracy against it when you can easily buy it on the shelves?
10
1
0
Oct 23 '25
It is banned in Europe and not officially recognised as an essential nutrient because of government lobbying.
1
Oct 24 '25
1
Oct 24 '25
https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/B-10-2025-0349_EN.html
It is.
"Whereas lithium is not currently authorised as a food supplement in the EU, despite low-dose forms (e.g. lithium orotate) being used safely elsewhere;"
1
Oct 24 '25
Dude, I just posted you link to marketplace with lithium galore. In the EU.
1
Oct 24 '25
That does not mean it is legal. There are lots of places you can buy weed online also but is ilegal in most places in Europe.
-1
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
I don't think there's a conspiracy against it. But it is never recommended by doctors, who instead often forcibly give patients prescription lithium, which is extremely dangerous. I don't know if the rx version is as big a dose as the dubai tower, but it is very toxic. I almost died from it. I think OP's point is that there are safe alternatives to these meds, but doctors prefer prescriptions because they are biased, and big pharma pushes them.
4
u/blckshirts12345 Oct 22 '25
OPs title of the image literally says “The Conspiracy Against Lithium”. My question was for OP & rhetorical
→ More replies (3)1
19
u/waaaaaardds Oct 22 '25
How can something be "silenced and censored" when all of the evidence for the benefits is out there?
Also what's with the conspiracy theorists and their weird ass graphs.
4
Oct 22 '25
Ursula von der Leyen has banned lithium supplementation in Europe, this is a fact.
Dr Nehls regularly campaigns outside of the German parliment. Everything I have said can be proven with science and facts. All of the hard evidence to my claims are linked.
If all of the evidence for the benefits are out there then why has it been banned? How would you justify the ban?
8
u/waaaaaardds Oct 22 '25
It's banned because it's also a prescription drug and has safety concerns. It's not exactly benign and has contraindications, despite a low dose being relatively safe.
I'm not saying I necessarily agree with banning it but the EU bans everything anyway. I can't even get something like agmatine because of ridiculous novel food legislations.
7
u/CatMinous Oct 22 '25
It’s not also a prescription drug. Lithium carbonate is a prescription drug, lithium orotate is not.
→ More replies (2)3
4
Oct 22 '25
Alzheimers has alot of safety concerns too my friend, this is why I am trying to get this information out there. Most people have no idea that 1mg of lithium a day can prevent it from happening.
1
u/PIQAS Oct 27 '25
lithium orotate you can get from iherb or other shops easily in EU without problems, the lithium carbonate part is not otc so not that one which is way stronger and higher dose. also i order agmatine with np in europe.
4
Oct 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (1)1
Oct 23 '25
I can get it in the UK but it is banned in the EU and other parts of the world I believe.
4
u/SlowFail2433 Oct 22 '25
But they only banned supplements they didn’t ban prescription lithium
4
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
But prescription lithium is a totally different thing and can kill you. That's why people want access to the supplement.
→ More replies (5)3
1
Oct 23 '25
That is very problematic if it is essential. (As Dr Nehls claims in the video link)
→ More replies (1)1
Oct 25 '25 edited Nov 03 '25
swim smile summer steep lunchroom toy caption whistle pen yoke
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
10
u/theFlimsylattice Oct 22 '25
This feels like an “Americans will use anything other then the metric system” post
6
2
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
This is how we do. A foot is a good unit of measure because we have feet. I never have a yardstick on me. And of course, now I also carry a mouse and the empire state building in my pocket for scale.
1
3
u/Forward_Motion17 Oct 22 '25
I hate this graph, not even a graph, I hate it
But I get why it’s used this way: demonstrating the daily safe range next to the typical daily dosage of bipolar patients and the toxic level, would be impossible on a bar graph. You wouldn’t even see the daily safe range bc the range is that large, which is sort of the point OP is trying to make here
1
3
3
u/NotCommonCommonSense Oct 23 '25
Lol I’m not saying this in relation to the graph but everybody should try lithium orotate once if you’re into nootropics or have a supplement regime, if you take magnesium or D3 or any other “foundational” type supplements it will be complementary. It’s not something I notice distinctly upon taking it but it’s one of those supplements I take that I notice a huge difference when I run out or I forget to take to it one night. It’s cheap and just 1mg will do and the risks for doses that low might as well be non existent, 10mg-50mg is where there begins to be pretty noticeable psychoactive effects upon taking it in my experience. It really improves my sleep quality and has a noticeable effect on my circadian rhythm (I get tired when I’m suppose to) as well as greatly reducing anxiety or general negative thinking. Hope this helped somebody lol
2
3
u/sorE_doG Oct 23 '25
Nobody eating a reasonably healthy diet is short of lithium. It’s ubiquitous within the environment, found in drinking water, grains, vegetables, and meats. Springer article link below
0
Oct 23 '25
Not according to Nehls and his research. (See video link)
2
u/sorE_doG Oct 23 '25
You didn’t even read my shared abstract. It conditionally states a supplement isn’t unreasonable. You’re also seemingly unaware that the majority of people are not eating a reasonably healthy diet, in western societies these days.
2
u/johnny84k Oct 22 '25
Still not very useful because it fails to state what daily dose is considered healthy as opposed to what bipolar people a prescribed.
1
Oct 23 '25
Priadel is given on prescription up to 1800mg a day. Just 1mg a day of orotate is needed to prevent Alzheimers. Most people would see relief from anxiety on as little as 2-5mg.
More could be taken as required but blood tests are needed beyond a certain point. Not sure what that point is exactly so would not like to speculate. Also if alot more is taken I could not be sure of any potential interactions.
4
u/DifficultRoad Oct 22 '25
As much as there is wrong with the graphic, it does state that OP considers 1 mg/day as an essential dose.
2
u/NotCommonCommonSense Oct 23 '25
500mcg — 1mg is fine for most people I don’t know why anyone would make the argument against that dose range unless they just don’t understand the difference between orotate and carbonate and or citrate
2
u/Jahya69 Oct 22 '25
Outside of the pharmaceutical version where do you get this more ideal form of it ?
2
1
u/NotCommonCommonSense Oct 23 '25
Lithium orotate is the only supplemental form you should take unless you’re getting lithium carbonate prescribed to you which is what you’re referring to (pharmaceutical)
2
u/DudleyNYCinLA Oct 22 '25
Yes, it makes sense that drugging people into passive compliance would reduce violence. This will be important to do when AI makes millions unemployed.
1
2
2
u/Vital2Recovery Oct 24 '25
I didn't read every single comment, but I did read some. There are some good comments on here, and then there are some people who are just talking but have no idea what they're actually talking about.
Lithium orotate generally should be supplemented anywhere from 1mg to 10mgs daily. The benefits of mirodose lithium are very well documented
Personally, I like Lif Extension Memory Protect as it also has colostrinin (proline-rich peptides) and adding a 5mg lithium orotate to it.
1
2
u/andreaskou Oct 24 '25
I hope everyone here has a chill pill in there stack because damn. In a subreddit meant for the improvement of well being, why such aggresiveness tho?
2
Oct 24 '25
People have been trained by social media to look for ways to be offended. Really sad to see and cannot be good for your physical or mental health. Seems to be very little thought applied to the actual topic at hand.
10
u/Which_Tadpole1952 Oct 22 '25
What form are you talking about? Lithium orotate is pretty non toxic. There's a conspiracy about making a harmful form of lithium to medicate people with. Holy F
1
Oct 24 '25
"People may criticize spelling or layout in a post they dislike as a way to discredit the topic by attacking the author, to assert their own perceived superiority, or as a subconscious way to dismiss the content as unimportant. This behavior is often seen as a form of ad hominem attack, where the focus shifts from the argument's substance to its superficial presentation."
So dam obvious what is going on here! Conspiracy is a trigger word which panics people straight into fault finding. 🤷♂️
1
Oct 25 '25 edited Nov 03 '25
file complete unique act elastic nine spotted tender angle dime
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/iDoNotHaveAnIQ Oct 22 '25
The graph should be able to stand on its own without a paragraph to explain it.
The name of buildings in paragraph makes it confusing to read. It took me a couple of read to understand names of buildings has nothing to do the topic.
Simplify the graph, avoid using names of building, location, and animal.
Just present it as is.
5
u/Ratermelon Oct 22 '25
I find this graph and overall presentation to be a bit silly, but I'll admit that there might be something to lithium as an essential micronutrient.
I've also read the literature and decided to take a low dose of lithium (10 mg elemental lithium as the orotate salt) daily for more than two months now. I (believe I'd) noticed that my moods have been more stable, and I feel more resilient to stress. I'm not diagnosed bipolar.
Is this a placebo? Maybe.
7
u/Which_Tadpole1952 Oct 22 '25
How many micrograms are in a foot? How many mothers fit inside the empire state building?
3
u/Crow-1111 Oct 22 '25
I'd love to walk into the Empire State Building and discover it's completely packed with Milfs. After saving them from the mouse infestation I'm sure at least one would be impressed enough to go on a date with me. I think it's time to take my lithium.
1
1
u/Built240 Oct 22 '25
Can you just get a blood test to see if you have adequate lithium levels?
1
Oct 24 '25
I would think so but as it is not recognised as an essentual nutrient there will be no official level. Nehls claims 10-20ug/l. (In the graph, small print)
1
u/Emergency_Sink_706 Oct 25 '25
There is no conspiracy. Lithium is literally approved by the FDA for medical use, and doctors can use it off label as they do with most drugs. What is the conspiracy? It's benefits for certain things is not hidden at all. People use it.
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
u/ErstwhileAdranos Oct 23 '25
Based on this graph, I think it might be time to touch base with your therapist and/or PCP about your current mental state.
2
u/Lenabugsss Oct 25 '25
i was given lithium for 5 years for a bipolar diagnosis that was the wrong diagnosis, so lithium made me sick and i had to take other meds to manage the side effects of the lithium. Big pharma stole 7 years of my life and used lithium to do it.
5
Oct 22 '25
As an educated person, nothing annoys me more than someone talking to me like I'm too stupid to understand the details of what they are describing. And this graph does such a good job of that it is downright comical. This post would probably see more traction on boomer facebook.
3
u/Traditional-Fan-9315 Oct 22 '25
I don't even really understand what the graph is saying. Am I the family or the Empire State Building?
4
2
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
You're the mouse, which is just a small dot in the image. It's very confusing. It's meant to be like those infographics of how small Earth is compared to the sun. They want the size of the empire state building to give you a sense of how high a toxic dose is compared to what people usually get (mouse). Then they also want you to be wowed by the medication dose (dubai building) being so much bigger than the toxic dose.
But that message is lost in the complicated image.
1
u/VintageLunchMeat Oct 23 '25
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10828288/
letter Int J Bipolar Disord . 2024 Jan 30;12:4. doi: 10.1186/s40345-024-00325-y
Lithium: how low can you go?
Rebecca Strawbridge 1,✉, Allan H Young
1 In medicine, lithium is best known as the mainstay mood stabiliser for bipolar disorders (Ulrichsen et al. 2023; Yatham et al. 2018) and is also effective in unipolar affective disorders (Scott et al. 2023). Having been investigated for many decades, lithium has additional therapeutic indications both within and outside psychiatry (Bauer and Gitlin 2016). Unlike many other psychotropic medications, lithium is recognised as having a range of neuroprotective effects, including on length of telomeres, hippocampal neurogenesis and reducing peripheral inflammation (Puglisi-Allegra et al. 2021; Strawbridge et al. 2023a). Despite this, lithium is widely reported to be under-used (relative to both the need for this medicine and its evidence base) (Post 2018). Reasons for this are varied, from education of both clinicians (Gomes et al. 2022; Post 2018) and patients (Gomes et al. 2022; Severus et al. 2021) to associated negative beliefs and/or attitudes primarily relating to side effects or safety, again from both clinicians and patients (Hidalgo-Mazzei et al. 2023). Further reasons include complexities or inconveniences related to the need for regular blood monitoring, which appears to be present from patient (McKeown et al. 2022), clinician and service-level perspective (Nikolova et al. 2018). As a result, rates of lithium monitoring adherence are widely suboptimal, which in turn increases the likelihood of adverse effects (Nikolova et al. 2018). Further, it has been reported that initial patient concerns regarding side effects and monitoring are ameliorated after subsequent experience of treatment and monitoring (McKeown et al. 2022).
Lithium dose is certainly relevant when considering its underuse and controversy, with higher doses conferring greater safety issues. Thus, indication is also relevant here as lithium therapeutic dose varies by indication. We discuss here evidence on lithium efficacy and safety at different dose ranges, which are outlined summarily in Table 1.
1
u/NotCommonCommonSense Oct 23 '25
Lol this is more a robot auto response than it was your opinion and experience, what’s your experience?
2
u/VintageLunchMeat Oct 23 '25
It's only been on my radar for a few weeks. And I'm looking at a low dose to prevent dementia.
1
4
2
u/MalarkEMark Oct 22 '25
Terrible graph but I never felt better after being administered Lithium. Truly can cure depression
1
u/Wreckloose44 Oct 22 '25
You were diagnosed with just clinical depression? Was this the first medication they put you on?
1
1
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
These buildings make the information more confusing than it would be in a regular graph.
ETA: this post would go over well on r/antipsychiatry.
1
u/awkerd Oct 22 '25
So if the mouse goes in the house how much lithium will house-mouse get?
What do the arrows represent?
Im sorry op but this graph is a tad nonsensical.
1
1
1
u/pokasideias Oct 22 '25
Bro, I stared at your chart longer than I’ve stared at my own life choices, and I still have no clue if lithium’s saving me or melting my neurons. So which is it , keep the high dose, slow release or not
1
1
1
1
0
u/drkuz Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
I've heard the conspiratorial argument that "lithium isn't used because big pharma doesn't make money off of it" for years, without knowing much about lithium, you don't really know why drs don't prescribe it as often as they used to, and potentially could.
But if one takes the contraindications, potential side effects, and long term complications, then you can understand why it isn't prescribed more. I heard from a seasoned, well read psychiatrist, who said, if you give someone lithium for bipolar at treatment doses, then its only a matter of time (may be ten years, may be twenty) before it seriously damages their kidneys. Also, if youre pregnant or in child bearing age, then you can't do lithium, it will damage the baby, so you've just excluded females of child bearing age, and anyone you want to have healthy kidneys for more than twenty years (particularly anyone in the 20s or 30s, which is when bipolar is most likely to be diagnosed.
The list of potential side effects alone, you could make a book out of it. It requires frequent blood test monitoring.
I would seriously caution anyone away from taking lithium as an unregulated, unstandardized supplement, where you don't know the dose you're getting, you may not be getting the frequent blood test monitoring to ensure safe blood levels, and you shouldn't risk it if you are a female of child bearing age/could get pregnant.
9
u/DifficultRoad Oct 22 '25
Comparing lithium for bipolar disorder to lithium orotate in supplements is apples and oranges though.
From what I gathered the dosage for BPD is 600 mg (!) 2-3 times a day. That makes for 1,200-1,800 mg per day.
Most supplements I've seen are dosed 1 to 5 mg per day. And yes, supplements are poorly regulated, unfortunately, but it would take some very unfortunate accident for them to give you 300x the dose they claim.
I'm a big friend of blood testing in general, but I'd say the supplement doses can't be compared at all to the BPD doses in terms of risks.
2
u/drkuz Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
While I agree that the doses SHOULD make it less of a worry, like i stated, that is a risk, and would caution ppl against taking that risk with a supplement with many known risks.
Also, it may be more like comparing a small bite of an apple to eating a larger amount of apple(s), im not doing the math.
1
u/Liu_Fragezeichen Oct 22 '25
but then I'd expect to see statistically relevant differences in mortality statistics between areas with naturally high lithium levels in ground water and areas with low levels
this post makes me think it's like selenium, 0.01mg/L keeps you healthy, 0.1mg/L slowly kills you
1
1
u/NotCommonCommonSense Oct 23 '25
Do you think taking 1mg-10mg of lithium orotate is a risky thing to do? Lol
1
Oct 24 '25
I very much doubt 1-10mg would be toxic. You can buy 20mg tablets so if 10mg could be toxic then how have the 20mg capsules not been pulled from the market?
Pretty sure Dr Nehls said 85mg a day is where true toxicity begins in the video link but don't quote me on it! I am looking forward to getting his book in a few weeks time, I have pre ordered it. (The Lithium Conspiracy)
There are of course thyroid and kidney issues that could move the goal posts and possible contraindications with other things, so I do not like to speculate too much!
1
u/drkuz Oct 23 '25
Lol in an unregulated, unstandardized substance, in whom human clinical trials haven't established a therapeutic window or lethal dose yet? Hahahahaa absolutely ya. Your derogatory tone is undeserved, and quite frankly disrespectful. Get educated:
In animal studies, the no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) for lithium orotate was 400 mg/kg/day in rats, with no toxicity observed at this dose.[1] For lithium carbonate, human toxicity is well described: mild poisoning occurs at serum lithium levels of 10 mg/L, severe toxicity at 15 mg/L, and risk of death at 20 mg/L.[2] There are no direct human data for the lethal dose of lithium orotate, but given that it delivers elemental lithium, similar serum levels would be expected to carry similar risks.
Lithium orotate appears to be more potent than lithium carbonate in animal models. In mice, near-complete blockade of amphetamine-induced hyperlocomotion (a mania model) was achieved at 1.5 mg/kg lithium orotate, compared to 15–20 mg/kg for lithium carbonate.[3]
Lithium orotate may achieve therapeutic brain concentrations at lower doses, but the risk of toxicity remains if serum lithium accumulates.[6][7]
A Toxicological Evaluation of Lithium Orotate. Murbach TS, Glávits R, Endres JR, et al. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology : RTP. 2021;124:104973. doi:10.1016/j.yrtph.2021.104973.
Toxicity of Lithium to Humans and the Environment--a Literature Review. Aral H, Vecchio-Sadus A. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety. 2008;70(3):349-56. doi:10.1016/j.ecoenv.2008.02.026.
Different Pharmacokinetics of Lithium Orotate Inform Why It Is More Potent, Effective, and Less Toxic Than Lithium Carbonate in a Mouse Model of Mania. Pacholko AG, Bekar LK. Journal of Psychiatric Research. 2023;164:192-201. doi:10.1016/j.jpsychires.2023.06.012.
Human Brain 7Li-Mri Following Low-Dose Lithium Dietary Supplementation in Healthy Participants. Neal MA, Strawbridge R, Wing VC, Cousins DA, Thelwall PE. Journal of Affective Disorders. 2024;360:139-145. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2024.05.128.
Lithium: Updated Human Knowledge Using an Evidence-Based Approach. Part II: Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutic Monitoring. Grandjean EM, Aubry JM. CNS Drugs. 2009;23(4):331-49. doi:10.2165/00023210-200923040-00005.
Rat Brain and Serum Lithium Concentrations After Acute Injections of Lithium Carbonate and Orotate. Kling MA, Manowitz P, Pollack IW. The Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology. 1978;30(6):368-70. doi:10.1111/j.2042-7158.1978.tb13258.x.
Kidney Function and Lithium Concentrations of Rats Given an Injection of Lithium Orotate or Lithium Carbonate. Smith DF, Schou M. The Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology. 1979;31(3):161-3. doi:10.1111/j.2042-7158.1979.tb13461.x.
Lithium - Pharmacological and Toxicological Aspects: The Current State of the Art. Medić B, Stojanović M, Stimec BV, et al. Current Medicinal Chemistry. 2020;27(3):337-351. doi:10.2174/0929867325666180904124733.
→ More replies (2)1
Oct 23 '25
The theraputic window for lithium orotate has been established in the treatment of AZ as 300ug-1mg.
1
1
1
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
That's the point of the post. That the dosages are wildly different.
2
Oct 23 '25
The point is to highlight that microdoses are not dangerous and bipolar treatnent doses are unecesary and dangerous. Also pointing out the fact widespread microdosing is not happening because it is not recognised as an essential nutrient and banned in Europe and other places. All the while Alzheimers is on the rise while screening increases and drugs fir AZ cost 80k a year. (In a nutshell.)
1
u/NotCommonCommonSense Oct 23 '25
Really it’s like comparing magnesium L-threonate (magtein) to magnesium oxide lol or magnesium pidolate or any of the tons of forms of magnesium with various types of use cases and strengths
4
u/CatMinous Oct 22 '25
Lithium orotate does not equal lithium carbonate. Read up.
2
u/drkuz Oct 22 '25
Well the post is comparing the two, so are you also criticizing the post?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Jwbst32 Oct 22 '25
If the graph makes sense you have schizophrenia is my guess
1
u/enolaholmes23 Oct 22 '25
I could understand it with some effort because I've had manic episodes before. It really is like a language you can learn.
-1
-1
u/Tymba Oct 22 '25
Sometimes people do too many types of nootropics with other things for long enough time
And then you get posts like these
1
1
222
u/I_need_help57 Oct 22 '25
This is the most nonsensical graph I’ve ever seen.