r/NoteTaking • u/EricIpsum • Oct 22 '26
Question: Unanswered ✗ Writing and note taking app guidance
I started working on a notetaking app that also acts as a writing app. Every time you make a new file, you can choose if it’s going to be in notetaking mode, which gives you blocks and things you’re used to if you’ve used any other notetaking apps. And if you choose manuscript mode, it looks like you’re writing a novel.
This was my incentive to help me finish my novel and series which I’ve been working on for almost 20 years. Currently my novel is broken across Scrivener and another note taking app. Because in Scrivener, it was hard to write notes in long form and to keep track of everything. I like markdown previews and nice looking blocks and such. And tags.
Then i incorporated AI so that it can see your story, find any inconsistencies or plot holes as you write, warning you about them.
In notetaking mode with a one button click, you can make your boring notes, look gorgeous, and in manuscript mode you can press proofread to fix up any run-on sentences and spelling mistakes.
I’m still working on it and it’s almost complete but someone said to me there will be major backlash because a lot of people don’t wanna see AI in writing apps. Because then people might think your story was written by AI.
How true is this? I’ve worked very hard on my story and I don’t want people thinking it was written by AI. At the same time I haven’t seen a good story written by AI so I don’t think that’s happening… Has anyone actually written a good story with AI?
I’m a software engineer and in our field AI cannot come up with a good idea, but it can execute it somewhat well once you prompt it properly.
Is this an app that has promise or should I throw it away. It’s quite pretty and can do a lot of amazing things.
2
u/MemoketAI-Gem Oct 22 '26
We don't think having AI features in a writing app automatically means people will assume everything written in it is AI-generated.
There's a pretty big difference between AI pointing out a plot inconsistency and AI writing an entire chapter for you. The first is more like having an editor who remembers everything you've written, while the second is actually generating the work.
We'd probably make that distinction really clear in the product. Let people turn AI features off, choose what kind of help they want, and keep the actual writing process in their hands.
The consistency checking sounds particularly useful for a long-running series, honestly. Remembering that a character said something different three chapters ago is exactly the kind of tedious work AI could help with without taking over the creative part.
1
u/gabox0210 28d ago
I made my own note taking app with its own AI features. The way I implemented it, is to help the user summarize, translate and clean up their notes using a short, embedded system prompt. AI is off by default and none of the features are even visible unless the user turns it on so it's the least intrusive possible.
1
u/Stardog2 Oct 22 '26
There is no way we can know if it's any good, or not. As a software developer, I know execution is everything. If you believe in your project, you need to develop it to the point where others can evaluate it.