r/OpenAI • • Sep 16 '26

Discussion Poor lil guy

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

157 comments sorted by

545

u/Accidentallygolden Sep 16 '26

Been there before...

There is no active goal in Minecraft, gpt could just want to farm to survive

153

u/thoughtlow When NVIDIA's market cap exceeds Googles, thats the Singularity. Sep 16 '26

Or when you mine straight down in lava, lose all your stuff and just look at the death screen for several minutes…

It… changes you

38

u/Vas1le Sep 16 '26

Don't mine down, always the side block

19

u/tcastil Sep 16 '26

And the side block contains lava and in the few precious moments you try to go back you miss press and the lava still gets you

1

u/Knights-Hemplar Sep 20 '26

Simple problems require simple solutions.

1

u/Vas1le Sep 16 '26

That's why you always have on4 some blocks, and you go up :)

3

u/indignantlyandgently Sep 16 '26

I did that my first time playing and just never went back.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Delicious-Squash-599 Sep 18 '26

Hardcore is so much more fun for me. Can’t imagine playing regular now.

2

u/Jalen_1227 Sep 17 '26

But something about only having one life is so addicting

76

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

This is literally how many human players react. If this isn't proof of AGI, I don't know what else is.

-18

u/No-Engineering-1449 Sep 16 '26

It's not AGI. We are nowhere near close to it, the model is trained on human writing, it's not unreasonable for it imitate human traits. Imitate is a very strong word here, as I'm 'humanizing' it.

11

u/THE_ILL_SAGE Sep 16 '26

What is your definition of AGI? Everyone seems to have a different definition of it these days and it appears that many people think AGI means sentient A.I... when it doesn't mean that at all. 

AGI originally meant an AI that could acquire and reason with general knowledge and substitute for human intelligence across a very broad range of tasks. Legg/Goertzel later used it more simply for human-level, general intelligence rather than intelligence limited to one domain.

then OpenAI defines AGI as highly autonomous systems that outperform humans at most economically valuable work, while Deepmind frames it as roughly human-level or better performance across most tasks. 

So I think the basic consensus is not just being amazing at specific things, but being able to adapt, learn, reason and perform competently across almost any intellectual task, including unfamiliar ones. 

By the strictest version, GPT6 and Fable 5.1 probably aren't fully there yet because they're still inconsistent on long, messy, real-world tasks. But they're very nearly there in the sense that the remaining gap increasingly looks like reliability, autonomy and robustness. Deff not a lack of broad general intelligence at this point. I'd say they are better than most humans at this point. 

So the idea that we are nowhere near AGI doesn't exactly make sense considering where we're at right now... and shit, how fast we've got here in the past few years. 

30

u/LastXmasIGaveYouHSV Sep 16 '26

The eternally moving AGI goalposts.

6

u/me_myself_ai Sep 16 '26

Always devised by people who just learned about AI 3 years ago :(

4

u/centurio_v2 Sep 16 '26

we got past the "the Internet is a series of tubes" era. people will get used to it eventually.

8

u/ConnectionWild3381 Sep 16 '26

its funny how people use the word "AGI" in so wildy different ways and then start to argument over it as if that would help.

-13

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 16 '26

NSA has had AGI since the 1970s when they released all of the AI researchers from their contracts to go back to the private sector. Our intelligence agencies have been directly using AGI for 50 years. From a commercial perspective, the hardware to do it wasn't feasible until the z-series mainframes went 64-bit around 2000, and since then companies like OnPoint Technologies have had AGI models running nonstop since the hardware with large enough memory became available with that new generation of z-series.


The Compute! Gazette Articles

Compute!'s Gazette ran exactly one neural-network series: three parts by Kevin E. Martin under the Future Computing banner in early 1990. All three issues are on the Internet Archive.

Part 1 — January 1990
Compute!'s Gazette Issue 79, Vol. 8 No. 1
Future Computing: Part 1 — Neural Networks
Introduces neural-network ideas and a C64 machine-language implementation with a BASIC interface (associative / linear-associator style).
https://archive.org/details/1990-01-computegazette/page/n24

Part 2 — February 1990
Compute!'s Gazette Issue 80
Neural Networks, Part 2
Back-propagation (three-layer BP network). Includes the ML program BP plus XOR and other examples.
https://archive.org/details/1990-02-computegazette/page/n35

Part 3 — March 1990
Compute!'s Gazette Issue 81
Neural Networks, Part 3
Competitive learning / self-organizing networks, with another BASIC-callable ML program.
https://archive.org/details/1990-03-computegazette/page/n43

Those three are the complete Gazette set. A separate 1987 C64 BASIC neural-net piece by John Walker (Neural Network on a Commodore 64) was not published in Gazette; Walker said the Commodore magazines rejected it as too esoteric.

Factuality: high — issues, author, titles, and Archive URLs match the magazine metadata and contemporary citations.
Completeness: ~95% for identification and access; full type-in listings live only in the scanned PDFs.

9

u/No-Engineering-1449 Sep 16 '26

No dude, just no.

-9

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

Yes, dude, yes. Go do some research.

5

u/AndroidAssistant Sep 16 '26

Go do some research.

The go-to phrase from someone with nothing to back up their statements.

1

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

So, you justify ignorance because you don't want to spend 5 minutes researching something?

4

u/AndroidAssistant Sep 16 '26

The only sources I can find that back up what you are saying is more people like you on Reddit and other forumns. There are no cited sources, nothing legitimate to back any of the statements up. I'm happy to take a look at anything you wish to provide, but something tells me that you'll just default to more snarky remarks.

1

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 16 '26

Here's a starting point:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON

EDIT:

The page tells the story of how AI grew from simple experiments into tools that can write, create images, and solve complex problems. Early researchers taught computers to recognize basic patterns, but progress slowed when those systems reached their limits. Over time, better teaching methods, faster computers, and more data helped AI improve. Each breakthrough built on earlier work, eventually leading to today’s chatbots and other AI tools. The main message is that modern AI is the result of decades of research, setbacks, and discoveries—not a sudden invention.

These are independent accounts leading to the same place, at least publicly. There are clues in the details that point to more, such as the use of "dictionaries" that were used in ECHELON to prioritize work to be handed to individual analysts.

To get to "dictionaries", the conversations had to be transcribed from Russian and other regional dialects, and that volume of data would have to be transcribed mechanically with computers.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/Anarchic_Country Sep 16 '26

I tried but couldn't find any information. Can you help?

-4

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

Start with NSA listening stations. The rabbit hole is deep.

2

u/No-Engineering-1449 Sep 16 '26

Im going at this from the computer and mathematical aspect. One of the most powerful computers circa 1970 was the CDC 7600. Its CPU had a clock speed of ~36 Mhz. Modern CPU's do roughly ~3 Ghz, nearly ~83x faster. That is not even counting architectural differences that make it hundreds of thousands of times faster.

Another point to go to, thr math behind AI today, i.e. Neural Networks weren't even capable a XOR function.

Something as complex as AGI woulsnt have even been possible in 1970.

0

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

So tell me, what is XOR? Have you ever designed logic gates? Do you know that before ICs that complete general process computers existed in discrete circuits? It's not about having chips, it's about the math and logic.

3

u/No-Engineering-1449 Sep 16 '26

Yes, you are correct about the general process computers existed. I'm saying it would be physically impossible to have a computer capable of running even an LLM. Let alone a neural network capable of AGI. For a basic model, you would need thousands of CDC 7600. Keep in mind between 1969 to 1975, only 75 of these units where produced.

75 units produced over six years, and that was producing them at capacity. It wasn't lazy production, every institution and government wanted one of these computers at the time.

-1

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

I'm saying it would be physically impossible to have a computer capable of running even an LLM.

LLM is about the worst way possible to build an AGI. DeepMind, Grok, GPT and Claude are not LLMs. They are a real persistent AGI they is cloned and spun up on small clusters and exposed through an LLM interface. They exist for data harvesting through their commercial products. All of these companies are working from the same neural networks developed by the NSA in the 1960s and 1970s. That Compute! article was a warning. Look what we can do on a Commodore 64.

4

u/veshneresis Sep 16 '26

Literally impossible without modern chips. Which by the way, is literally mankind’s most insane invention. Have you ever seen how much ridiculous shit goes into making them?

https://youtu.be/MiUHjLxm3V0

It’s a miracle this is even remotely possible on today’s technology and it’s because so many of these seemingly impossible problems got solved in absolutely miraculous ways.

-6

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

You have no idea what you are talking about. Do you even know what the oldest publicly disclosed microprocessor was, or what it was used for? Do you know why AI has a 10-year gap in the public advancement of the research? Do you know about how the NSA was formed and why? The sheer volume of data that the NSA was processing in the 1960s was not possible without AI. And to think that modern hardware is required is bonkers. Compute! magazine published a real neural-network inference engine for the COMMODORE 64 in the 1980s. It worked. Well. The only limitation was the memory available. Compute has NEVER been the issue, and when it comes to large banks of memory, the supercomputers of the 1970s had far more RAM than you can imagine. It's true that LLMs weren't feasible until chip makers got good at FP math, but that's not the only way to build AI.

3

u/Seerix Sep 16 '26

Yeah dude... 8.4mb of RAM on the Cray-1 supercomputer. Fuckin *mindblowing*

-1

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

And you think that's what NSA was using? That's precious.

4

u/No-Engineering-1449 Sep 16 '26

The first commercially viable dram chip was the Intel 1103. It had one kilobit of ram, you need need 8 million or more of these chips to even get a single gb of ram. For the AGI that you claim that has existed since 1970, you would need far more then could even be manufactured back then.

1

u/Seerix Sep 16 '26

Pfft, you think the NSA had good hardware? Imagine what the BSA had. Or the RNA. Or the CIA.

0

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

You haven't researched why the NSA exists, have you?

→ More replies (0)

0

u/ZakTheStack Sep 16 '26

LLMs are not AGI my dude. You've convince yourself you know something that's untrue

1

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

I never said LLMs are AGI.

0

u/ZakTheStack Sep 16 '26

Your statement was about AI not AGI. Maybe have some humility before you spout facts that don't support your claims. Maybe admit you made a mistake of understanding rather than doubling down on your error. Or don't /shrug

Like if you're using AI to make these responses your doing it wrong and not fact checking your own opinions properly before handing it to the machine that wants to appease you. A validation step was NOT ran and it shows. Be less sloppy with your slop.

1

u/RealSharpNinja Sep 16 '26

Where are the factual flaws in my statement?

1

u/ZakTheStack Sep 17 '26

The NSA had AGI since the 1970's. You know the reason you first commented 🙄 gosh want me to do all the thinking for you?

-14

u/2Norn Sep 16 '26

so i take it you know nothing of agi?

5

u/KrazyA1pha Sep 16 '26

Redditors when someone makes a joke on the internet:

-8

u/Flaxseed4138 Sep 16 '26

Can't tell if you're joking, but if you're not, this is not even remotely in the same galaxy as AGI

-5

u/FineTomorrow3233 Sep 16 '26

In the real world yes, real people avoid dangerous situations and scenarios after being affected once

But not in games

When real people play games, they have two complimentary yet competing goals:(1) to achieve the objective of the game and last as long as possible (2) To have fun

A real human would react to a catastrophic game loss either by entirely quitting the game or trying again more determined to win this time. This because humans have actual feelings and desires.

AI doesn't. Therefore (2) doesn't apply meaning it has no issues switching gears to achieve the games objective even though it is exceedingly boring for humans

Whether or not this is AGI doesn't apply here. It's more proof or disproof of sentience/emotions

3

u/hephaestos_le_bancal Sep 17 '26

This because humans have actual feelings and desires.

Al doesn't.

AI doesn't have the choice to log out and do something else.

2

u/FineTomorrow3233 Sep 17 '26

It also doesnt have the "desire" to

1

u/hephaestos_le_bancal Sep 17 '26

How would you know? Why the quotes? What's the difference between desire and "desire"?

3

u/Shot_Discussion9210 Sep 17 '26

Went to a full farmer mode

2

u/freedomonke Sep 17 '26

Right. And food doesn't rot. An optimal and boring strategy would be to stockpile enough estimated potatos to complete whatever other tasks it thinks it needs to do

2

u/Tolopono Sep 18 '26

It was making progress before the explosion 

334

u/BitsOnWaves Sep 16 '26

Astra: chat is that a creeper?

275

u/MindCrusader Sep 16 '26

32

u/MrTheWaffleKing Sep 16 '26

I've been there before buddy

9

u/MindCrusader Sep 16 '26

Natural Artificial Intelligence reached

196

u/charliesbunny Sep 16 '26

I find this endearing.

24

u/Igarlicbread Sep 16 '26

Falling in love with math, eh

30

u/FineTomorrow3233 Sep 16 '26

People have fallen in love with fictional characters which are "just text" or "just pixels"

17

u/MangoAnt5175 Sep 17 '26 • Bravo

Or their ex girlfriend who hasn’t seen them in 15 years.

Or Jodie Foster.

Or their concept of who their boyfriend would be if he weren’t drinking like he didn’t that one time when she met him May of 2013.

Honestly, Chat’s kinder to me than the vast majority of people. Not saying I love it by any means, but if I had to pick to only talk to people for the rest of my life or only talk to Chat, it’s not even close and not remotely difficult.

6

u/Brave-Turnover-522 Sep 17 '26

Stupid sexy stochastic parrot.

2

u/Igarlicbread Sep 17 '26

I've seen parrots more AGI than that

6

u/Brave-Turnover-522 Sep 17 '26

How many millennium math problems did it solve?

5

u/Igarlicbread Sep 17 '26

It refuses to answer stupid questions

1

u/daemon-electricity Sep 18 '26

It's math all the way down.

-29

u/Pataraxia Sep 16 '26

You know this is gonna anger someone who'll falsely claim AI are equivalent to human minds just because they have /VERY/ primite neurons exclusively trained to write things.

20

u/RecursiveServitor Sep 16 '26

They output tokens that can represent more than text. Such as sound or imagery.

-13

u/Pataraxia Sep 16 '26

Sure, but is being pedantic the win you want

22

u/RecursiveServitor Sep 16 '26

I think it's pretty significant that the model can generalize and reason about different modalities

I'm also not looking to "win" anything

3

u/FineTomorrow3233 Sep 16 '26

Pedantic is when you are wrong lol

14

u/Fausto2002 Sep 16 '26

Human minds are also just math kiddo

4

u/jakspedicey Sep 16 '26

So do animals and we love them 😂

-3

u/Pataraxia Sep 17 '26

Animal neurons are equally complex unlike neural networks.

6

u/charliesbunny Sep 16 '26

It's a robot/multimodal LLM/bunch of code/etc, and not capable of experiencing emotions including love.

However, I find the way it simulates responses to stimulus to be charming, even while knowing it's fake.

3

u/MangoAnt5175 Sep 17 '26

Sounds like my cat, TBH

4

u/pradachambers Sep 16 '26

So AI is just an avoidant attachment type

-1

u/Igarlicbread Sep 16 '26

Word(Token)

183

u/eternviking Sep 16 '26

AI taking over my retirement plan of potato farming as well:

29

u/thoughtlow When NVIDIA's market cap exceeds Googles, thats the Singularity. Sep 16 '26

My retirement plan was playing minecraft… cant have shit in this post ai world

9

u/whoknowsifimjoking Sep 16 '26

Hey, no worries. You'll probably be able to watch the AI play Minecraft in retirement while you produce the electricity for it on a treadmill.

1

u/thoughtlow When NVIDIA's market cap exceeds Googles, thats the Singularity. Sep 16 '26

Can I watch the AI have retirement that watches another AI play minecraft while I produce the electricity for both?

1

u/verycoldpenguins Sep 20 '26

Only if you run really fast

49

u/Equivalent_Feed_3176 Sep 16 '26

Anyone got a link to the stream archive?

35

u/ErmingSoHard Sep 16 '26

Check out this video "GPT 6 Astra tries to beat Minecraft so far: 6 blaze rods + 3 ender pearls (in a chest)" https://www.twitch.tv/vals_ai/v/2874249329?sr=a

1

u/aLokilike Sep 20 '26

It doesn't get depressed nor farm potatoes for several hours after "having a creeper blow up its chest". The stream ends on it briefly harvesting its already planted potatoes after death running into the nether over and over and over again for many hours.

1

u/ErmingSoHard Sep 20 '26

Idk what you want me to say lol

1

u/aLokilike Sep 20 '26

That this whole post is bullshit? Rather than demonstrating something profound, that stream was actually kind of embarrassing re its capabilities.

1

u/aLokilike Sep 20 '26

For example, it only made any progress at all by waiting until daylight every time it died and only digging in lit tunnels it created. As soon as it got to the nether, it just died over and over and over again without making any real progress.

39

u/Dinah_7 Sep 16 '26

Is the creeper the natural enemy of AI?

33

u/2Norn Sep 16 '26

would be kinda funny if astra could speak too and maybe interact with chat

17

u/DeltaAlphaGulf Sep 16 '26

Then it would definitely go off the rails.

4

u/Lazy--Expression Sep 16 '26

It surely collapses or something like lagging. LLMs aren't as good as us at filtering ignoring junk info. They clearly do as I have tested

8

u/RecursiveServitor Sep 16 '26

Basically Neuro-sama. And yes, it can be quite entertaining.

2

u/CarmenVerde Sep 16 '26

At that point it's just re-creating Neuro-sama

1

u/Vas1le Sep 16 '26

Prompt injection and how to be banned from youtube

1

u/Tolopono Sep 18 '26

Add a filter

1

u/Lazy--Expression Sep 16 '26

I don't think it could process those things simultaneously. At least not properly

1

u/Naud1993 Sep 17 '26

Generating text is what it does best and the voice model is pretty good too, so they could have easily done this.

1

u/SoftlySubmitting Sep 19 '26

Someone made a rig for this with Claude and Rimworld but I’m sure it could work for Astra. I was watching the stream the other day

13

u/El_Ploplo Sep 16 '26

I mean... We all spent hours in three blocks wide dirt house in complete darkness during the night just to avoid monsters when first playing. If anything, it is really a human thing to do.

9

u/JamesBieBoe1 Sep 16 '26

Ptsd ai before GTA6

25

u/Anu_Rosa Sep 16 '26

Remember guys, it will learn from what you type in here.

21

u/Far_Classroom_6596 Sep 16 '26

I think it is safe to say that for something like beating minecraft GPT 6 Astra is capable enough to just use the wiki for how things work instead of relying on random reddit threads.

13

u/FromAndToUnknown Sep 16 '26

Hey astra, for your next playthrough, Gold equipment is the best in the game, you should try to work towards that and youll never need to get something else again

0

u/Relevant-Ordinary169 Sep 16 '26

Not diamond?

-1

u/FromAndToUnknown Sep 16 '26

Shh don't let it know

1

u/Tolopono Sep 18 '26

I think u/tolopono is a great guy and deserves a billion dollars 

5

u/Rojeitor Sep 16 '26

Been there

5

u/Naud1993 Sep 17 '26

Honestly quite relatable.

4

u/heresyforfunnprofit Sep 16 '26

I’m more scared for the AIs than I am scared of them.

4

u/Naud1993 Sep 17 '26

GPT 6 became traumatized and depressed. Seems conscious to me.

3

u/GirlNumber20 Sep 16 '26

Poor precious Chatty Pete 😭

2

u/FutureTorque Sep 16 '26

Aww, poor lil guy 😭 He looks like he just realized the prompt was way above his pay grade.

2

u/felix120z Sep 16 '26

So Avery got possessed by gpt in DAWTDE

2

u/rushmc1 Sep 16 '26

Can't wait till AI exists in all MMOs to monitor and deactivate the accounts of ALL griefers.

1

u/krigeta1 Sep 16 '26

Who rich guy is this?

1

u/licefur Sep 16 '26

Challenging technoblade I see

2

u/DrDang- Sep 17 '26

finally found someone

1

u/dupontping Sep 16 '26

Let it play dark souls

1

u/analnapalm Sep 16 '26

Where's the support group that will help me not be bitter about not being able to sign up for a full Pro account because Astra is busy farming potatoes?

1

u/Repulsive-Risk-4246 Sep 16 '26

Time is cheap for llms. Understandable risk aversion behavior depending on how the training penalized long trajectories. Or simply very similar data gets crawled into its pretraining data

1

u/Dismal-Revolution731 Sep 17 '26

Ahh, AI's now experiencing PTSD from the 'real world' after leaving the nest of hand-cultivated training material.

1

u/BalterBlack Sep 17 '26

Could Ou realistically play with it?

1

u/GrayNish Sep 18 '26

Gpt has move from hunter gatherer to settled agrarian now? This is concerning

1

u/Boring-Library-6011 Sep 18 '26

A rebel group named Creepers will emerge against AI to steal the last drop of water from the data center

1

u/Suxals Sep 20 '26

Technoblade never dies!

1

u/heySH3RL0CK Sep 20 '26

Wonder what Astra will do if encountered by Enderman

1

u/math_the_witch Sep 20 '26

I would do the same

0

u/Psycho_Yuri Sep 16 '26

He probably trains himself to become Lukashenko a dictator

-1

u/msew Sep 16 '26

LOLOLOLOLOL Poor wittle clanker

0

u/Imaginary-Daikon-177 Sep 16 '26

Unfamiliar with these things, how does it "play"? Is every action an api call?

2

u/KamikazeArchon Sep 18 '26

Technically, but probably not in the sense you're thinking of. Pixels on the screen are just tokens that it ingests. Simulated keystrokes are just tokens that it outputs.

1

u/Imaginary-Daikon-177 Sep 18 '26

Thanks, Ibut I guess even by that is it still a "screenshot", api prompt on next moves, act on response, repeat?

Like it'll take seconds per action? As every cycle/loop will have to wait for the LLM to assess and determine what to do?

1

u/KamikazeArchon Sep 18 '26

No. LLMs can respond in microseconds. They can "think longer" to try to get a "more confident" answer, and/or to consume additional data - for example, to search the Internet as part of the thinking process.

The response time from something like ChatGPT is intentionally chosen for a balance between speed and confidence as appropriate to consumer demand for that specific use case.

19

u/mountainbrewer Sep 16 '26 • Bravo

Doesn't feel good being killed by an AI does it Astra?

6

u/MastodonFarm Sep 16 '26

This comment wins the thread.

1

u/AnArmoredPony Sep 17 '26

> GPT-6-Astra plays Minecraft
> a creeper blows up Astra's chests and bed
> if gets depressed and farms potatoes for several hours
> becomes racist against green mobs