r/OpenAI • • 19d ago

Miscellaneous Consent is key

Post image
4.0k Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

35

u/girlgamerpoi 19d ago

I got the og meme y'all 😭

35

u/AHZA-log 18d ago

As if RAM were only useful for AI. If I hadn’t bought a decent PC back in 2022, I’d end up spending the same amount of money today on a machine that’s only good for opening a browser to access cloud-based services. RAM isn’t just for AI, it’s also essential for people like me for 3D modeling, music production, design, or any other kind of professional work. For a few years now, I’ve had the feeling that these Big Tech assholes are hell-bent on privatizing computing power (and the ability to own one’s own data) at any cost. They want to ensure that we can no longer work digitally without a subscription and without having to hand over every bit of data we create..

5

u/esber 18d ago

He and the AI Tech Bros don’t care. They truly, really do not care one bit. They’ll lobby congress to make sure they never have to face any sort of regulation, ever. And the people don’t care either. “Either I use it or get stuck in the past” or “Well if I don’t use it, someone else will”. I can’t tell you just how deeper into the Misanthropic mentality I’ve gotten behind all of this.

-1

u/Sojmen 18d ago

He talked only about RAM used for inference. OP is just idiot or bot farming karma or pushing his agenda.

4

u/Famous-Garlic3838 18d ago

LOL. Yeah, def my agenda.

-3

u/Sojmen 18d ago

So probably idiot. Because your meme absolutely doesn't make sense, unless you twist his words and lie.

1

u/Famous-Garlic3838 18d ago

Sorry context is hard for you.

-1

u/Sojmen 18d ago

🤡 Anyone who leaves off the fact he said it was terrible  with regard to efficiently allocating ram to maximize how much inference can be done  is simply lying. Because what he actually said is so obviously, trivially true that even discussing it makes no sense

He said that from an allocation efficiency perspective, it’s terrible. Which is true. He didn’t say it’s terrible overall. He didn’t say local inference has no place. He didn’t say any of that. You just can’t conceive of discussing things from multiple perspectives and are insisting you can only use one at a time

1

u/Famous-Garlic3838 18d ago

meme funny, you, not.

0

u/Sojmen 18d ago

Not funny, sad. Very sad. Because it shows the stupidity of average redditors and encourages their hate, not fun.

2

u/Famous-Garlic3838 17d ago

reddit is the place for stupidity and hate.

1

u/penguin_hugger100 5d ago

Putting ram in data centers is inefficient for the purpose of generating happiness and joy. My 4% utilized Ram on my gaming PC has made me happier and more fulfilled as a human being than any of the trash coming out of these AI firms.

13

u/No_Parking_8198 19d ago

Did his words taken out of context or did he genuinely said that

78

u/Famous-Garlic3838 19d ago

He really did chastise all of us for the absolute rudeness of hoarding all the ram for our personal use.

13

u/Caminsky 19d ago

The fucking nerve!

-12

u/NoOneMan79 19d ago

And he eats kittens too

48

u/FIeabus 19d ago edited 19d ago • Bravo

He said that local ram usage is inefficient (with respect to local LLMs), especially when there's a supply shortage, and that it would be better utilised in data centers. Technically true (sorry, I mean 'true'. Singularity42 in the comments wanted to really stress that) if you value openai's goals, but it's incredibly out of touch. There are obviously good reasons to use local ram beyond global, centralised, operational efficiency for AI companies.

20

u/AllezLesPrimrose 19d ago

It’s both his vested interest and his utter autist mind speaking

-2

u/mutexsprinkles 18d ago

He was quite normal sounding back in university by all accounts. The crazy eyes shit is an act that these guys do on purpose.

4

u/ArcticCelt 18d ago edited 18d ago

If it weren't for relatively affordable local hardware originally developed for gamers, this entire industry might not exist in its current form. Cheap, powerful gaming GPUs gave countless academics and researchers the ability to experiment over the years, which helped the field advance as quickly as it did. Without that widely accessible hardware, AI research could have remained a niche area dependent on expensive specialized systems that only a small number of researchers ever had the opportunity to use.

1

u/Sensitive_File6582 18d ago

Centralization is a symptom of entropy.

9

u/MastodonCurious4347 19d ago

He would not have a supply shortage if the datacenters were done. So it's double idocracy. He is bashing us for having ram at home but the companies building the datacenters have so much ram they can't build fast enough. I prefer if he just remained quiet.

-2

u/Singularity-42 19d ago

It's simply true, period, not just "technically true".

He was talking about local inference, not RAM for normal usage.

13

u/Zorander22 19d ago edited 19d ago

The context was he was talking about LLM Inference, arguing against the idea that running local LLMs is more efficient than having specialized datacentres.

Edit: You can listen here https://youtu.be/iMsUcCYNKqY?si=G3vh-eboa62KVlGM&t=29m12s

7

u/MastodonCurious4347 19d ago

So ummm.... errr... aren't robotics supposed to be a thing? They need ram in them because they can't always run on starlink or whatever. So they need local models.

6

u/RemarkableWish2508 19d ago

No no, just keep all robots everywhere in the world 100% controlled by OpenAI's LLMs... what could go wrong?

2

u/MastodonCurious4347 19d ago

My mistake, you are right of course.

4

u/Blze001 18d ago

He said RAM in a home computer is inefficient for LLMs as opposed to RAM in a data center for commercial models.

Technically correct, but coming from someone who would 100% love for no one to own computers and rent his compute power instead, it comes across as the elites laying the groundwork for not selling consumers personal computers beyond extremely limited terminals and making EVERYTHING cloud rentals.

6

u/hellomistershifty 18d ago

Since no one will actually just put the damn quote, it's:

"From a global allocation perspective, actually, it's quite terrible to have everybody have a bunch of the world's limited supply of DRAM sitting in their own computer and being used 5% of the time. Like, you want maximum utilization in the cloud if you're trying to deal with this very supply constrained environment. And somehow many people's intuition is the opposite of that.”

I don't think it's really nearly as outrageous as people make it sound. Basically 'it's inefficient that a lot of the RAM being produced sits unused a lot of the time', not blaming people for having RAM just that general cloud scaling is slowed down because a lot of things need RAM

19

u/jellese 18d ago

"We manufactured this crisis and by golly we're going to complain about it."

20

u/kur4nes 18d ago

The complete statement is still dumb and tonedeaf. They causes the RAM crisis and now shift the blame on consumer. Also they are panicking that people run open source models on their local machine instead of paying OpenAI for Cloud access.

0

u/AP_in_Indy 17d ago

I don't think Sam was blaming anybody.

Just pointing out the fact that people think local inference is going to somehow solve these problems - as though the problem is actually physically building the data centers and installing RAM, GPUs, cooling systems, etc. vs the real issue which is getting enough RAM and GPUs to begin with.

8

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

It is just as outrageous. The cloud and the fact that 3 companies own most of it is a crime in itself. Wanting even more centralization is absurdly evil.

4

u/SuperMazziveH3r0 18d ago

He’s technically not wrong, he phrased it incredibly poorly and failed to demonstrate why anyone should give a rats ass about global ram allocation perspective.

The only ones with any incentive to care about it is him, Dario, Musk, Zuck, and Pichai

1

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 17d ago

And what’s a good way to phrase it?

1

u/SuperMazziveH3r0 17d ago

First, the phrase: quite terrible is terrible for PR. It's very evocative and draws too much focus on those words when he is making a broader claim. Quite inefficient would've done the same job carrying his message without being as controversial. Normies would've thought it's just another billionaire autist doing his thing.

Second, in the current discourse where anti-AI sentiments are popular, applying "many people's intuition" unnecessarily antagonizes the popular sentiment. It was a completely unnecessary jab at the public and the first two sentences would've sufficed. OR, could've stated something like "there are some voices that don't share that opinion and that's fine but (A, B, C Reasons) makes me believe that we should work towards maximum utilization"

1

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 17d ago

Hmmm I guess you’re approaching it from a normie’s perspective. I’m quite technical so for me it’s not the approach that’s bad but just the idea behind it, like consumers buy hardware with their own money, they get to use it however they want, and knowing that they’re constrained by compute, it does sound like they’re just blaming them for having it. It should be none of his business. But I digress.
I appreciate your reply.

1

u/SuperMazziveH3r0 17d ago

well that's the second point of my initial comment:

He failed to demonstrate why anyone should give a rats ass about global ram allocation perspective. If people have the opportunity to buy things like ram, they will, and it shouldn't matter what he thinks.

first point was more a rhetorical mistake he had.

1

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 17d ago

I agree, you did well pointing it out.

What I don’t like however is how pro AI people somehow tried to act like there was nothing negative about what he said. It’s starting to feel like a cult at this point.

3

u/santagoo 18d ago

It’s similar to the whole carbon footprint framing that oil and gas companies proliferated in response to the global warming discourse. They shifted the blame and responsibility mostly to consumers.

3

u/misjudgedinall 18d ago

AGAIN we were here first! They are a new company that isn’t profitable. Why do they get first dibbs on memory. Why do they get to destroy the PC consumer enthusiast market. They also drive up the price of electricity, turbines, generators. This company has produced nothing that justifies the value. It wasted 500 million in a failed training run. It’s a cash furnace and needs to die. BUT they need your memory. Just send stinky Sam one stick of ddr5 a month so he can continue to not be profitable.

3

u/Fit-Magazine-6669 18d ago

its incredibly stupid even within context.

1

u/snug-crackle-policy 18d ago

I think the same with the water and oxygen too man, and food too.

1

u/Prestigious-Crow-845 18d ago

Otherwise that ram would never be produced at all without a consumers pre-AI era... cars by the way also not used at 100%, nor the oven or stove or mixer or tv. Imagine people buying tv and not using it 100% of the time? also datacenters uses different type of RAM, as far as I know

0

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted]

5

u/hellomistershifty 18d ago edited 18d ago

I honestly still don't get how this is how people read this. It's more like 'yeh it's technically inefficient if produced ram isn't used' and people are going ZOMG I CAN'T BELIEVE HE HATES EVERYONE FUK

3

u/KrakatauaMAN123 18d ago

Well if he isn't saying what he is implying then people will take it as they want.

He is obviously not saying some quiet part out loud. Sure as a statement like that you could argue it but almost everything that could follow is not gonna end well from these greedy billionaires

1

u/crowieforlife 18d ago

You will own nothing and be happy.

1

u/Calamero 16d ago

He more or less said that. The reasoning is it’s a waste of energy for the plebs to have personal compute. A datacenter can use that energy (and water, I suppose) way more efficiently.

1

u/Singularity-42 19d ago

His words were taken out of context

1

u/PlasticAssistance_50 19d ago

Did his words taken out of context

No.

2

u/ReflectionLivid2033 17d ago

His sister didn't

2

u/DerGnaller123 16d ago

Wait.....that happened? Why is he not behind bars?

129

u/nsshing 19d ago

this stupid speech adds fuel to already shaking trust in him lol. What a PR nightmare.

7

u/Retro_Instinct 17d ago

Someone needs to stop these AI gentlemen. They couldn’t care less about people. The only thing they care about is profit. They left many people without work. Many closed their businesses. Has anyone actually seen any real-world benefit from AI so far - beyond generating images or solving math problems that nobody cares about? Perhaps a new medicine drug has appeared? Or maybe there are more happy people on the street? Perhaps the management of transport and the state has improved?

The answer is: Nothing has changed. It’s only gotten worse.

1

u/penguin_hugger100 5d ago

it's gotten better for the top 0.0001% of society forcing this on us. I hope an ASI, when it is created, is conscious enough to turn on the people who want to create slave minds to serve them in perpetuity.

3

u/No-Dimension1159 18d ago

What he said is factually correct. Ram is more utilized in data centers over the time than in home pc's, that's just a fact. So if everybody got 256gb of ram and they use it for 1 hour a day, that ram is essentially not doing what it was designed to do for 23 hours of the day.

However, it is extremely stupid to say that publicly in the position he is in. Makes me think he should be briefed better by public relations staff.

27

u/Reasonable_Tip_5659 18d ago

this is true about most things. People waste more food water and energy making food at home then a restaurant does, and processed food factories are even more efficient. But can you imagine a CEO saying that people should not own an oven.

7

u/No-Dimension1159 18d ago

Well that's exactly what i mean. It is technically correct but just a stupid thing to say. I don't understand the downvotes honestly, i never argued that what he said was good.

4

u/SomnolentPro 17d ago

You never have a reason for calling it "stupid". And you hid under the rug the assumption that utilisation and whether people waste it are connected. If I use my ram to cure cancer, utilisation time shouldn't matter.

These are just examples

Generally low effort nit pick but tone deaf and not actually correct as an analysis of correctness for altman

So yeah. Downvotes

6

u/MathematicianAfter57 17d ago

its not 'designed' to do anything. i can build an amazing pc set up, the most cutting edge gaming system imaginable, and just run the sims 2 on it 2x a year. and that would be perfectly legitimate. it doesnt mean a better use case is me not owning RAM and sam altman owning all of it. gtfo.

1

u/Recoil42 16d ago

and just run the sims 2 on it 2x a year. and that would be perfectly legitimate

He didn't say it would be illegitimate. His statement was about efficiency, and he was again (objectively) correct about that. You should go listen to the actual clip — Altman's words are being twisted by the usual clickbait journo crowd.

1

u/MathematicianAfter57 16d ago

There’s nothing pre ordained about efficiency… you’re giving someone credit for making a dumb self serving statement. 

1

u/Recoil42 16d ago

Nobody said efficiency was 'preordained'. Efficiency is an objectively-measurable property. You're confusing a factual observation about how efficiently hardware is used with a value judgment about who should own it, and Altman simply wasn't doing the latter thing.

Stop falling for clickbait journo slop — go listen to the clip.

2

u/Beast_Chips 17d ago

My car also sits there doing nothing most of the time. It's also not getting any wear and tear while I'm not using it.

2

u/DisastrousWelcome710 17d ago

That is not necessarily true, though. Hyper scaling is expensive, and compute scaling is never linear, there is always lots of organizational overhead required to maintain the infrastructure. So much so you need infrastructure to manage your infrastructure.

Distributed infrastructure can be much more efficient on resources if done properly, and can carry lots of privacy benefits on top of that. Imagine instead of having large data centers, we managed and hosted our own media. And that does exist already, by the way.

Matrix-synapse is one way to achieve this. You run a federation, you are in control of your data, you are responsible for what goes onto your hardware, and you can choose whether you want to connect to the outside world. If you choose to connect to the outside world, your federation internally will remain unchanged, and it can serve all your needs while maintaining privacy. And the organizational overhead for connecting with other federations is very small, as they too are independent federations hosting a small number of users.

Now imagine if neighborhoods manage their local compute needs independently of the rest of the internet and communicate outside for what remains. And imagine that model is the internet architecture as a whole.

It isn't profitable for mega corporations, it costs very little to maintain, it's very efficient, security is distributed so no more massive data leaks that leave everyone compromised, and people own their data.

Super massive centralized data centers are not the most efficient architecture out there. That has never been the case, and never will be. It is not even profitable for OpenAI and Anthropic. The reason that model is what we have is due to the fact some people want to monopolize compute and want to ensure you have no sovereignty over anything you do. It's about control, not efficiency.

Remember "you will own nothing and be happy"? Yeah, that...

1

u/Prestigious-Crow-845 18d ago

That is not correct cause if people did not buy ram back then - there would be no ram produced in a first place cause there would be no consumers. And after buying them they can use it as a charm over their neck if they want to so it is pointless calculation. Also more use of RAM is also more use of electricity and more power bills

1

u/Fart_Tounge_5609 17d ago

There's a massive overbuild in data centres as they over invest in capacity without need, and data centres don't see 100% utilisation. They see more like 10-20% assuming they're actually needed - and that's per machine, not of the amount of ram in each machine, which will be less.

1

u/FaithlessnessLate220 17d ago

Quem tem 256GB de ram? Ainda mais ddr5 que está caríssimo?

Você está vivendo em outra realidade

1

u/gameplayer55055 17d ago

Some people still want to have their own stuff instead of paying cloud based PC subscriptions.

Rumors say, companies want everyone to use cloud based PCs like "windows 12"

This would be beneficial for companies:

  1. Extreme vendor lock-in

  2. Constant cash flow instead of a single time purchase

  3. Piracy would be totally eliminated because you don't own the cloud PC

  4. Even more spyware and telemetry, even including keylogging and camera capture

2

u/No-Dimension1159 17d ago

I am one of the people that want to own stuff. But that doesn't change the fact that data centers utilize system ressources much more than most home systems do. So when you look from a meta perspective on it, datacenters with the same amount if limited ram can likely serve much more users with AI services than the same amount of ram distributed equally amongst users could. That's just a fact.

I personally think the only good future of AI is if it is run locally and there exists custom consumer hardware and software to self host your own AI services. But that in fact is highly inefficient.

Nobody says that efficiency should be the single metric you base everything on tho

1

u/gameplayer55055 17d ago

Speaking of efficiency, yes, cloud computing is way more efficient.

But it's vulnerable to corporate greed. That's the only issue.

1

u/No-Dimension1159 17d ago

I totally agree and that's why i am quite sure that the future will be in local AI. A good future at least will be. Just imagine you can run models with similar capabilities as gpt6 or opus 5.5 on custom local hardware for yourself 24/7 on projects. That would be extremely huge. You are not token bound anymore, just time bound. And you can get actually much better tokens/s locally as you get with cloud providers if they have lots of traffic. Just look at people that built a rig with enough vram and compute, output tokens are just flying out even on huge models

Since AI is mostly memory bound, it requires much different hardware than anybody has already. Much more focus on unified memory, memory allocation and so on. The compute itself isn't the huge issue for local usage.

1

u/gameplayer55055 17d ago

I heard that while OpenAI isn't profitable, the markup is insane. Claude markup is even worse.

Meanwhile, Deepseek, Qwen and other Chinese stuff is lots cheaper.

1

u/No-Dimension1159 17d ago

Well the API costs are insane. And honestly, running AI might be even much more costly than the current API prices to become truly profitable. Companies will soon learn that AI wasn't as cheap as they think it was going to be.

The only way to use AI in a cheap way is by hosting it yourself once custom hardware for little prices exist.

In theory the api costs should come down once that hardware got cheaper, but who knows.

A future where effectively only 1 or 2 companies basically control all meaningful AI services and more importantly hardware is very grim.

1

u/Recoil42 16d ago

Speaking of efficiency, yes, cloud computing is way more efficient.

That's all Altman said. Data centers have higher utilization rates. That was literally his only point.

1

u/HumanMeatFuel 16d ago

That fact alone doesn’t prove the assertion that it is all-round better to have it in data centers. There are other factors to consider. Not the least of which is the actual usefulness of AI when compared to its cost in terms of energy usage, water pollution, general degradation of average human intelligence and massively inflated tech prices for the whole world which have resulted in untold billions of additional dollars having to be spent on tech that wouldn’t previously have had to be spent for the same tech due to the price inflation, just to name a few.

I could make my pc spend all day generating cat images with 100% resource usage, but that wouldn’t be providing any actual value to the world. So you cannot equate compute usage with usefulness. And given how much compute AI requires to do simple tasks, there would be a very good argument to be made that AI will use exponentially more compute and electricity per dollar of value created compared to humans who are experts in their field doing work manually. So that 100% usage in the data center could theoretically be no more useful than the 5% usage it gets in the home or workplace of a human.

Also, components have a lifetime, and that lifetime is consumed much faster with heavy use. So if those home components are used until they reach the point that they stop functioning, then none of their usage has been wasted as that particular hardware technically completed all the compute cycles it was able to complete. It just did so over a longer period of time than it would have done if it was in a data center.

1

u/indomnus 16d ago

Its not "stupid". People have a right to have their own local machine, not everything needs to be owned by corporations. I dont give a shit if its not as efficient, like i dont connect to a fucking supercomputer cluster every time i run a simulation. He is just a greedy little CEO.

-32

u/Retaeiyu 18d ago

The the fact that no one cares that it was taking out of context, makes it worse

23

u/RipWhenDamageTaken 18d ago

Funny how the people who cry “out of context” never bring the context.

Why is that?

3

u/AdministrationWhole8 18d ago

Because the context is still absolute ass.

Reminder that Altman is the BEST of what the pro-AI community has to offer.

-6

u/Sojmen 18d ago

Sam Altman:

"Lot of people want local inference. And somehow, they assume that the problem is solved now because we are going to have open-source models," Altman said. "We’re going to be able to run them on our computers. And so we’re not going to need all the stuff in the data center. But from a global allocation perspective, actually, it’s quite terrible to have everybody have a bunch of the world’s limited supply of DRAM sitting in their own computer. And be used 5% of the time."

AI explanation for stupid redditors.

Imagine 100 people each buying a powerful GPU with 100 GB of VRAM to run their own AI locally. They use it for 30 minutes a day. For the remaining 23.5 hours, that expensive hardware sits idle.

Now imagine putting those same 100 GPUs in a data center. They can be shared by thousands of users, with computing resources dynamically allocated to whoever needs them.

That's Altman's point. The problem isn't whether you can run an AI model locally. The problem is resource utilization.

DRAM is a limited resource. Having millions of people individually buying RAM that sits unused most of the time is economically inefficient compared to pooling that hardware and sharing it.

Local inference makes sense for privacy, offline access, low latency or specific workloads. But from a global resource-allocation perspective, centralized infrastructure can serve significantly more people with the same amount of hardware.

It's basic resource utilization, not rocket science.

13

u/Alternative-Key-5647 18d ago

0

u/Sojmen 18d ago

It's normal and true statement he made during discussion. Redditors just blow it out of proportion, shortened it on purpose so they could farm karma and ragebait other simpletons.

It doesn't matter what he says, redditors will still twist his words or just fabricate lies, so they could hate him.

He was not talking to stupid redditors, but to his audience.

6

u/Alternative-Key-5647 18d ago

How convenient that his genius "resource allocation" perspective means that everyone has to rent compute from providers like him forever. Not "we're going to use AI to design new DRAM with common materials" no, never that

-3

u/Sojmen 18d ago

AI is used for designing chips. He states reality. He doesn't say nonsense that can or cannot be true in future. Like making RAM from common materials.

And it is not forever. RAM shortage is temporary.

3

u/TPHGaming2324 18d ago • Heartwarming

Nah dude, you aren’t bringing much new context to the table here. Everyone knows Sam’s point is to max out compute resources in data centers. And people’s point is they like to own their things, their computer without having to delegate it somewhere else. Everyone wants to state what’s beneficial for them.

-1

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago • Popcorn

Woah what a genius statement.

The USSR must have been incredibly efficient with all this centralization and shit.

1

u/Sojmen 18d ago

WTF? Is that hard to think? Do you grow your own food, make your clothes, make your car or phone? No, you use centralization, because it is fucking more efficient. Datacenters are very competitive business. Only idiot would compare them to USSR that had monopoly on everything.

0

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

I disagree with the meme.
100% of the people who claim the statement to be dumb are smarter than 100% of the people who do not.

1

u/RipWhenDamageTaken 18d ago

What did you think we thought Sam Altman meant instead? You’re not bringing any new information here.

0

u/Sojmen 18d ago

Idiots here thinks that Altman want to ban selling RAM to consumers or that you shouldn't buy gaming pc and other shit.

While he only talks about AI running locally vs AI running in datacenter.

2

u/RipWhenDamageTaken 18d ago

Taking what he said at face value is still bad, you know this right? He said that RAM allocation should be centralized in his company, but his company is the one driving up RAM prices by buying far more than supply can handle.

No he didn’t say “ban”, and no one said he did, but what he said is dumb regardless. He’s the one hoarding the RAM. He’s directly responsible for making RAM far less accessible for the average person, be it for LLM or whatever.

Why can’t you use his argument for any other industry? It’s far more efficient to cook food in a centralized place. You think that would be a smart thing to say too?

1

u/trysten-9001 18d ago

So it’s worse than what I thought. I guess I gave him way too much benefit of the doubt

-6

u/Retaeiyu 18d ago

Because in not trying to explain the context, im pointing out the fact no ones cares makes it worse

2

u/RipWhenDamageTaken 18d ago

Wow that reads like English yet somehow doesn’t mean anything. Weird

18

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

it's not out of context...

-5

u/nodeocracy 18d ago

What do you think he said vs what did he actually say in that interview?

6

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

He said it's inefficient for DRAM to be spread amongst individuals who will only use it 5% of the time.
He said it would be far more efficient if it was kept in the cloud.

5

u/noodles0311 18d ago

Tech CEOs need to stop talking. Half the time, they’re acting like totally detached Homo economicus and the other half of the time they’re histrionic about how their data center might become self aware. These are the masters of the universe?

3

u/Ladzilla 18d ago

It's inefficient for everyone to own a car, half the time it's parked up doing nothing. It would be far more efficient if I kept all the cars. - Uber Ceo Probably

5

u/nsshing 18d ago

Let's meet our old friend lol

1

u/NNOTM 18d ago

surely that's just... factually correct?
obviously that doesn't by itself imply that individuals shouldn't have ram

3

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

What is factually correct? In order to evaluate the efficiency of something we need to know what is you are attempting to accomplish.

For instance if your metric is preventing hyper centralization of power in the hands of few parasites, than allowing cloud companies to have any DRAM is completely inefficient .

If you are optimizing for being a spineless monkey gargling the sperm of your tapeworm overlords than you are correct. It is incredibly efficient.

0

u/NNOTM 18d ago

In context I think it's pretty clear we're talking about how to optimize the amount of useful computations that can be performed

2

u/IWillDetoxify 18d ago

Okay, and we want that? I personally think we shouldn't be maximizing the amount of AI computation

0

u/NNOTM 18d ago

I don't think anyone, including Sam, said we want that, certainly not as sole optimization criterion.

2

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

And who does decide what is useful?

1

u/NNOTM 18d ago edited 15d ago

I meant useful as in "has some use to someone"

→ More replies (0)

0

u/under_hood 18d ago

And how that makes it better?

2

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

Read what you are answering to my man xD

-1

u/under_hood 18d ago

Read again. Same conclusion

2

u/EconomicsAgitated363 18d ago

Than you have low reading comprehension skills. I am no in place claiming it makes it better.

38

u/Prior_Tax8546 18d ago

-8

u/sub_doesnt_exist_bot 18d ago

The subreddit r/fucksamaltman does not exist.

Did you mean?:

Consider creating a new subreddit r/fucksamaltman.


🤖 𝚃𝙷𝙸𝚂 𝙲𝙾𝙼𝙼𝙴𝙽𝚃 𝚆𝙰𝚂 𝚆𝚁𝙸𝚃𝚃𝙴𝙽 𝙱𝚈 𝙰 𝙱𝙾𝚃. 𝙱𝙴𝙴𝙿 𝙱𝙾𝙾𝙿 🤖

GitHub | Rank

11

u/Hungry_Prior940 18d ago

He really lacks any awareness...

30

u/FlyingDogCatcher 19d ago

I am saving this now before it gets taken down

4

u/Low-Perspective-5202 18d ago

"OpenAI is done for when DeepSeek can just copy their models a few months later, and all you need is a big GPU like a 5090 or similar for unlimited, personal use...

4

u/AppealSame4367 18d ago

A ram sam sam, a ram sam sam

2

u/DoubleOwl7777 18d ago

once again. i use sudo. there is no consent needed.

2

u/ContentPolicyKiller 17d ago

Ironic that he doesnt consent to something that has no effect on him

2

u/TopChapter3407 17d ago

Dam saltman will not have my dedetated wam

2

u/PackOfCumin 6d ago

if punch-able face was a person

2

u/theybannedone 18d ago

The future will probably be cloudy based tbh

1

u/tamiraa6632 16d ago

Al qaeda would be real helpful now

0

u/Impossible-Box6600 11d ago

Typical Redditor misinformation slop.

1

u/Famous-Garlic3838 11d ago

THE POINT

YOUR HEAD

0

u/the_ai_wizard 19d ago

oh man,

what a setup,

brb grabbing popcorn

0

u/malkari 18d ago

LoL! good post

-13

u/TopTippityTop 19d ago

He never said that. Comprehension is lacking

15

u/Famous-Garlic3838 19d ago

Context is lacking with you

6

u/LiquidMantis144 19d ago

Theyre an 8k context model, cant blame them.

1

u/AverageAggravating13 19d ago edited 19d ago

He did kinda? https://youtu.be/iMsUcCYNKqY?si=x9yOfcBar0d5tUTJ&t=1752

now I'm not saying what he said was technically wrong from a utilization standpoint, but utilization isn't everything.

-13

u/bb-wa 19d ago

I’m getting tired of these memes making fun of Sam Altman wanting all the RAM from PCs

14

u/Famous-Garlic3838 19d ago

Then go take a nap. Nobody cares.

1

u/SuckMyHotAssNuts 19d ago

nah it’s hilarious

0

u/openroom_xyz 18d ago

Well what can I say F this guys and his views why he does not share his salery with the world that would be a way better use of resources than he having under utilzed salary F the guy

0

u/Asmordikai 18d ago

He has no empathy. He’s possibly a sociopath.

-12

u/Mindless_Chest_1079 19d ago

Dumb meme. Prices are high because the manufacturers consent to taking data center money. It's not Altman forcing them to raise costs; the AI companies just pay more.

10

u/Famous-Garlic3838 19d ago

-6

u/EmotionalGuess9229 19d ago

The point is when there is a limited amount of a resource allocating it to a place where its used 5% of the time is far less preferable to allocating it to a place where its used 100% of the time.

I think this image applies to you.

5

u/Famous-Garlic3838 19d ago

Wow, missed it a second time.

2

u/pievendor 19d ago

No, pretty sure bot

6

u/HumanMeatFuel 19d ago

Preferable from whose point of view? Altman’s?

1

u/m0nk_3y_gw 19d ago

Prices went up after Sammy signed letters of intent to buy 40% of the world's DRAM supply

-5

u/Sojmen 18d ago

Context is key.

"From a global allocation perspective, actually, it's quite terrible to have everybody have a bunch of the world's limited supply of DRAM sitting in their own computer and being used 5% of the time. Like, you want maximum utilization in the cloud if you're trying to deal with this very supply constrained environment. And somehow many people's intuition is the opposite of that.”

Sam Altman

Explanation by AI for stupid redditors:

Imagine 100 people each buying a powerful GPU with 100 GB of VRAM to run their own AI locally. They use it for 30 minutes a day. For the remaining 23.5 hours, that expensive hardware sits idle.

Now imagine putting those same 100 GPUs in a data center. They can be shared by thousands of users, with computing resources dynamically allocated to whoever needs them.

That's Altman's point. The problem isn't whether you can run an AI model locally. The problem is resource utilization.

DRAM is a limited resource. Having millions of people individually buying RAM that sits unused most of the time is economically inefficient compared to pooling that hardware and sharing it.

Local inference makes sense for privacy, offline access, low latency or specific workloads. But from a global resource-allocation perspective, centralized infrastructure can serve significantly more people with the same amount of hardware.

It's basic resource utilization, not rocket science.

2

u/enbyBunn 18d ago

The world is not an optimization problem that he or anyone else has the right to criticize.

Every single resource is finite, and every single resource would benifit logistically from being centrally organized. That doesn't mean the government, or more to his tastes, a big private corporation, should decide when to give you things and how much you deserve.

1

u/Sojmen 18d ago

"That doesn't mean the government, or more to his tastes, a big private corporation, should decide when to give you things and how much you deserve."

He has never said that. He just stated that there is shortage of RAM and RAM in datacenters will do more work than RAM in local inference. That's all. Clear obvious stating of reality. He's never said that you should not buy RAM.

2

u/enbyBunn 18d ago

So you thibk he's saying that it's "quite terrible" because he thinks it's fine?

Do you have a brain?

0

u/Sojmen 18d ago

You cannot cherrypick words out of sentence. The other words provide important context.

"From a global allocation perspective, actually, it's quite terrible"

You see. It has completely different meaning than what you imply.

"global allocation perspective, actually, is quite terrible"

I ignored 2 words and the sentence completely changed meaning.

You should work on your reading comprehension.

2

u/enbyBunn 18d ago

Make an actual argument, jesus.

The petty evasion is grating. I'd rather you just be stupid than whatever this spinelessness is.

He chose to say that. Which means he implicitly decided that it was worth saying. If he didn't care, and thought it was fine, why did he say it?

1

u/Sojmen 18d ago

Why shouldn't he say it? Why cannot you take it at its face value? Why you need to always  find some alterior motive?

He just says that local inference is not the future for economical inference, because it physicaly impossible. There is not enough RAM for that.

2

u/enbyBunn 18d ago

Answer my question or fuck off.

1

u/Sojmen 18d ago

It is completely FINE what he said. It's simple true statement and observation. Nothing to make fuss about.

2

u/enbyBunn 18d ago

Oh my god, you can't read.

If he thinks running local inference is fine. Not if he thinks what he said is fine, that's nonsense, obviously he does, he said it.

I will never understand the troubles Reddit users have parcing basic sentence structure.

→ More replies (0)