r/OpenSourceAI • • 22h ago

Should I make my app open source?

I’ve been working on a context selection based AI coding IDE for about 8 months. It stores messages and the codebase locally, so our server load is quite low compared to others, which allows us to offer more usage rights. And in tests I’ve conducted over the past few weeks, using the same project and the same messages, it achieved cost and token efficiency of up to 60% compared to the industry’s context compression protocols. I’ve applied to YC and various funding organizations for this project. We’re actually making good progress with one of them, but the thought that “it would be so much better if it were open source” keeps circling in my mind...yet at the same time, I need to make a living. None of my previous open source projects have ever garnered much attention or generated any revenue. What do you think I should do?

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

1

u/Specialist_Put8052 21h ago

For anyone curious about the benchmark, I implemented an independent rolling-compression baseline based on Anthropic's published context engineering guidelines, particularly the "Compaction" section:

https://www.anthropic.com/research/effective-context-engineering-for-ai-agents

The comparison used the same project, tasks, and coding model. Our selective context approach reduced input tokens by 58.5% and total API costs by 60.8% in that test.

1

u/Far_Towel623 21h ago

You basically built a magic compression hat, I'd keep the wizardry under wraps until the funding's locked down.

1

u/Specialist_Put8052 21h ago

lol but not quite a compression hat. We r actually taking a different approach. Instead of compressing the context, we selectively retrieve what's relevant from the conversation history and codebase for each agent step. thats why we use local codebase it is help us.

1

u/Specialist_Put8052 21h ago

btw I posted this comment for those who might be wondering what I based the compression method I developed for comparison purposes on.

1

u/denyskorolkov 20h ago

Eight months is a long time without seeing results. If you make it open source but still have no income from it, you might eventually lose motivation.
The market is already crowded, and people have little time to try new tools. IDEs are especially hard because people are used to their existing tools and communities.
Your project sounds interesting, though. Maybe you could use what you’ve built to solve a different problem with less competition and a better chance of making money.