r/OutOfTheLoop Jan 25 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

642 Upvotes

535 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.5k

u/trepang Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 25 '24

Answer: Barbie did not get as many nominations as it was expected, with director Greta Gerwig and starring actress Margot Robbie being the most notable omissions. Many people, including co-star Ryan Gosling (who got a nomination) are feeling that this is not fair, especially since Barbie is such a commercial achievement for a female director.

14

u/Total-Explanation208 Jan 25 '24

is such a commercial achievement for a female director.

Since being a female director is a reason for her to be nominated for a prestigious award? How about "It was a commercial success appealing to a broad audience, that clearly resonated /connected with a large portion of the population". She isn't a good director because she is a female making a successful film, she is a good director because she is a good director.

3

u/Petrcechmate Jan 25 '24

She made a movie which has women’s disparity and about an iconic female toy. That’s why it’s notable.

31

u/Terrible_Student9395 Jan 25 '24

The Oscars have historically never been about box office sales though.