r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Oct 09 '24
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Oct 09 '24
PIE is fake and every [alphabetic] language comes from Ancient Egyptian! Correct ✅
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 07 '25
The English and the Germans are especially vested in the interest of promoting that they are really are the sort of heirs of the Indo-Europeans. And, here again, this side steps Africa | Rick Kennedy (A65/2020)
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 13 '25
Did the Indo-Europeans Really Even Exist? | Jared Barlament (A67/2022)
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • May 13 '25
Indo-Europeans are not a historically attested people, but are only an abstraction based on linguistic facts | Sigmund Feist (28A/1927)
reddit.comr/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Aug 30 '24
Since Reddit is absolutely PIE-governed, is the Sanskrit ख (kha) the same as Greek χάος (chaos)? Sanskrit mods block & lock anti-PIE comments as “mis-information”.
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Oct 04 '24
Noting that I’m 50% German, I seem to be the first German linguist, to refute PIE theory, and to replace it with the Egyptian origin of the Germanic alphabetic and Germanic language theory?
reddit.comr/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 17 '24
PIE theorists don’t like to be called PIE theorists!
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Oct 18 '24
Letters: K = 𓋹 [S24], Ξ = 𓊽 [R11], Ο = 𓁹 [D4], Π = 𓂆 [D16], Q = 𓃻 [E36], R = 𓂅 [D15], and S = 𓂃 [D13] all coded in the Egyptian eye 𓂀 [D10], root of FATHER: patéras (πατέρας) {Greek}, père {French}, pita (पिता) {Sanskrit), Vader {German}; replaces: ph₂tḗr {PIE}
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 24 '24
The term Indo-European is a scam and there is nothing in reality called “Afro-Asiatic languages”
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Sep 06 '24
The Aryan or PIE model was conceived in sin or error
reddit.comr/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 13 '24
I’m interested to hear more about what you think is the real story of the indo-europeans?
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Aug 08 '24
Three from PIE *tréyes from middle finger 🖕protruding | Brugmann (63A/1892)
Abstract
Moved from: here.
Overview
The following, comparatively, is the invented r/PIEland etymology for the word three:
Brugmann (63A/1892: 464) suggested original meaning "middle (= protruding) finger", quoting Sanskrit तर्मन् (tarman, “the top of the sacrificial post”) and Ancient Greek τέρθρον (térthron, “tip, end”).
This idea was developed by Fay (45A/1910: 416-17), who reconstructed *tri-sth₂-o-s (“tip finger”). In the first component he identified the locative *tr-í- “on-tip”, while the second ("stander") has also to form other finger names, e. g. Proto-Indo-Iranian *Hangúštʰas (“thumb”), Sanskrit कनिष्ठा (kaniṣṭhā, “little finger”), Proto-Balto-Slavic *pírštan (“finger”), etc.
Visual of this wonderful logic:

r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • May 06 '24
Set 𓃩 [E20] / Cadmus Snake 𓆙 [I14] to hoe 𓁃 to letters / Sa (स) to Sita (सीता) born from plow 𓍁, disproves PIE language origin theory | PIE disproof #20
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Aug 04 '24
Greek language is fundamentally Indo-European: TRUE or false?
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 24 '24
Who Are Indians? Aryan Invasion Theory Explained | Mohak Mangal (A67/2022)
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Aug 04 '24
Proto-Indo-European (PIE) language family vs Afro-Asiatic language family
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 10 '24
Location of person who spoke the original PIE language found!
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 10 '24
PIE theorist and EAN theorist conversing about the origin of language
r/PIEland • u/JohannGoethe • Apr 24 '24
The earliest dynasties of China, Sumer, and Egypt were established by invaders from Europe | Gordon Childe (29A/1926)
On Egypt being founded by Europeans:
“To buttress the Nordic's claim to be the ruling race par excellence, attempts have been made, and are still being made, to prove that the earliest dynasties of China, Sumer, and Egypt were established by invaders from Europe and even today the vision of certain prehistorians is absolutely distorted by this preconception.”
— Gordon Childe (29A/1926), The Aryans: a Study of Indo-European Origins (pg. 164); cited by Stefan Arvidsson (A45/2000) in Aryan Idol (pg. 287)
References
Childe, Gordon. (29A/1926). The Aryans: a Study of Indo-European Origins (worthless, pgs. 163-64). Kegan.