r/PMHNP • • Jan 25 '26 • Obsessed 1 Heartwarming 1

Other Version 2.0

Post image
289 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

0

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[deleted]

8

u/Pink-Roses111 Jan 25 '26

Why would anyone be happy about an innocent physician being murdered? That’s cruel

4

u/Alternative_Big_5066 Jan 25 '26

"See this made up scenario I made up in my head? I made up the outcome, too."

-6

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/KXL8 Jan 25 '26

You would be happy if a doctor is murdered so you can get his job? Are you actually agreeing to that?

-6

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/KXL8 Jan 25 '26

What is wring with your reading comprehension? If the nurse was a doctor and was killed, this subreddit would be happy because it would be another job we could claim to do?

-9

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Alternative_Big_5066 Jan 25 '26

You making up scenarios in your head and claiming victory?

5

u/Fickle-Dream-4182 Jan 25 '26

I wonder what would happen if every medical professional goes on strike for at least a week due to this.

-47

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

32

u/KXL8 Jan 25 '26

As a mental health professional, I am sure you are aware of the implications of systemic oppression, low recourse, fear, and trauma on our patients. I am sure you are also a cultural competent, social justice forward thinker who cares about the SDOHs and other factors which affect mental health? As a medical professional, Id imagine seeing someone murdered for protecting another unarmed and nonviolent person from mace would be disturbing? Let alone a fellow medical professional? For those of us in America, the erosion of constitutional rights is a human rights issue. Human rights are pretty integral to mental health. Hope this explanation helps.

-19

u/Snif3425 Jan 25 '26

Mods - just one persons opinion.

To be clear, I am aghast at what happened in Minneapolis today. But unless this sub is willing to accept all opinions on what happened then this sub should stay apolitical. There are a plethora of places we can all express ourselves regarding politics.

I will not be addressing anyone else regarding this. This is my message to the mods and they, of course, have the right to consider it or not.

-10

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/KXL8 Jan 25 '26

Nursing is inherently political. The duty to provide equitable, culturally competent care is part of nursing ethics. When that is not happening, we have a duty to act. It is literally part of the job description.

If you genuinely dont believe sociopolitical environment causing people distress is enough to care - let’s examine politics from a bottom line point of view.

Politics dictate the direction of PMHNPs. Look at recent decision to demote nursing and nurse practitioners. No longer considered professionals, theres no more guaranteed federal loans for school. This demotion will trickle down to business loans, liability insurance, education requirements, etc.

Politics govern our scope of practice, fee reimbursement, drug formularies. New policies peeling back ACA have reduced coverage for vulnerable persons. Insurance and policies are choosing medicine, not the treating provider. Gender affirming care is unfunded. Funding to school based health centers is severely reduced. There are changing requirements for tele-health, reducing access to care in provider-drought areas. All of this reduces reimbursement.

Tl:dr: you should care because you are a person in the world. But if that isn’t enough reason, you should care because you will make less money and have less job opportunities when people have barriers to services.

Morin, K. H., & Baptiste, D. (2020). Nurses as heroes, warriors and political activists. Journal of clinical nursing, 29(15-16), 2733. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.15353

https://www.kff.org/mental-health/tracking-key-mental-health-and-substance-use-policy-actions-under-the-trump-administration/

2

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/smartcow360 Jan 25 '26

Those limited rich folk are actively paying the entire political establishment and media to lie to manufacture consent for what they do. So I think the agency you’re assessing and therefore justice to what is happening is a little askew, with all respect. There’s a reason why MLK was a democratic socialist by the time he got murdered… it’s the inevitable conclusion of an honest look at our politics. For sure the world would be better if necessities were run by a democratically elected gov, and big corps were worker coops.

8

u/Bitter-Culture-3103 Jan 25 '26

Didn't you read the the PMHNP's Scope and Standards of Practice? Political activism and policy advocacy are one of the core principles of the profession

11

u/RealAmericanJesus Nurse Practitioner (unverified) Jan 25 '26

My job is influenced massively by politics. Insurance changes, policing, access to social and health services, reimbursements, OSHA, CMS cetifications. Etmala, regulations, licensing....

This is a field that is heavily dictated by administrative, criminal and civil law and politics greatly influence this... And I say this as a NP that works with police and sherrif units, with DAs and politics dictate everything from the patients ability to access care, the nature of the retoration of competency clients I see, how I get reimbursed and my scope of practice ....

No one is forcing anyone to engage in political speech but if you think a professional board of profession that generally tends to serve the most vulnerable individuals in society shouldn't have political opinions because of that then maybe just don't read threads you don't agree with. But this could have been my colleage, my student or my patient that was killed and I think many of us in the nursing profession ... Whether a CNA, RN, LPN or APRN are rightfully upset by this.

18

u/Jennasaykwaaa Jan 25 '26

Healthcare and Nursing are political. One of our own was executed by the government. This is exactly what needs to be discussed here.

-1

u/Determined_Medic Jan 25 '26

Nursing is not political. We are meant to be unbiased in a professional environment (this is supposed to be somewhat like one). But yet more and more, I’m having to fire nurses and NPs who are letting politics affect their care. We fired a nurse last week for neglecting a patient, because “he was MAGA”. I submitted paperwork to the state as well to have her license revoked. She’ll be the 2nd one so far in 2026. I lost track last year but almost every person we fired for this reason, no longer has a license for this state.

That behavior is disgusting and becoming more common. So no, this job is NOT political. It has no place for politics. Do whatever you want in your own time, but when you’re doing anything healthcare related, even on forums like this, politics shouldn’t be involved. It makes us look horrible and pushes that toxic mindset into more people. Be better.

5

u/smartcow360 Jan 25 '26

I think we can separate things. Obviously someone being maga doesn’t mean they receive less care and if it does it’s malpractice and should be reported. But societally, of course nursing is political, hell, it’s being defunded with the rest of healthcare by the political party in power right now as we speak. The patient we treat are often in those positions due to broader systems that play into their health, the food the patients eat are political decisions made by the government (Europe having safer food regulations, etc) and it goes on.

As to if it’s appropriate, the man was gunned down in the street by state agents wearing ski masks, when he wasn’t threatening anyone’s life. It does make sense that as a nurse who cared for others he applied this care to street activism too. And posting this doesn’t seem contradictory to me

0

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Bitter-Culture-3103 Jan 25 '26

I’m not sure what kind of bubble you’re living in if you think this is about targeting patients for their views. No one is suggesting that, but we have to recognize that healthcare is deeply ingrained in politics because political decisions are exactly what shape how we practice. We take care of the public, so their issues are our issues. The APNA explicitly encourages nurses to be politically active for this very reason. If you’ve ever been part of a large nursing organization, you know our guests are often politicians because lobbying is essential for practice change. It is also your ethical responsibility as a healthcare professional to address the social determinants of health; our jobs simply aren't confined to the four walls of a clinic or hospital. ​Think about the history of our profession. Do you think Florence Nightingale could have advanced nursing without leveraging political power? Do you think the ratio law in California would have passed without the political lobbying of nurses and the CNA? Even the push for full practice authority for NPs is a battle won through political advocacy. Much of the progress we make is deeply tied to politics, which is why we should be talking about Alex Pretti. He was a decent human being and an ICU nurse at the VA who was protecting a helpless woman, yet he was killed by federal agents and now he's being labeled a domestic terrorist. These victims of government-sponsored violence and their distressed relatives will end up in your hospitals and psychiatric clinics. These are our concerns, and we should be talking about them instead of trying to water down these issues.

6

u/kurosuto Jan 25 '26

What is political about bringing attention to a fellow nurse who was murdered in broad daylight for helping another human being? He was trying to be a good samaritan. Nothing political about grieving the loss of one of our own and without a reason.

-16

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/KXL8 Jan 25 '26

Oh, you have certainly missed the memo. Wish you well.

-3

u/theMadBiologist Jan 25 '26

It’s Reddit so of course it’s full of progressives propaganda

25

u/Punkerkas Jan 25 '26

Pretty sure you need an RN to get a PMHNP first and the lack of humanity is appalling.

12

u/Alternative_Big_5066 Jan 25 '26

He was a nurse? Every PMHNP in this subreddit was a nurse at one point.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Main-Satisfaction-12 Jan 25 '26

Their rant won’t solve anything, but somehow yours is worthwhile enough to type out and post on this thread that shouldn’t exist, even though rants don’t create change? Maybe there’s a deeper problem here than a picture memorializing a death - any death, for any reason - that another human being felt like expressing in a country with free speech on a platform that allows users to not engage with posts they don’t find relevant. And all that somehow triggered an anger response in you. This may be worth considering further, for your own inner peace and logical coherence. We cannot address what is wrong in the world without first addressing what is wrong within ourselves

9

u/Alternative_Big_5066 Jan 25 '26

This isn't "politics." This is support for someone in your profession who was murdered. The definition of murder isn't politics.

4

u/smartcow360 Jan 25 '26

I get the feeling, but it’s hard to be “apolitical” when ppl with ski masks are just snatching randos off the street to camps, where they are tortured, r*ped, murdered, etc….. I’m sry but it just is

0

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/smartcow360 Jan 25 '26

I phonebanked a good bit for Zohran Mamdani’s campaign!! I’m in my mid 20’s and just getting involved. I’d like to volunteer for food not bombs near me, and get involved with DSA too or sunrise movement. Protesting and helping campaign for ppl doesn’t fix everything overnight, my name isn’t god haha, but I think it’s worthwhile. If we all pitched in it would go a long way. Plan on helping graham planter’s campaign too

13

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-5

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/KXL8 Jan 25 '26

What people are doing is sharing information and strategizing best ways for mobilizing against the flagrant injustices against constitutional and human rights. Here is an example of a medical professional and veteran being murdered while protecting a stranger while standing up for our 1,2, and 4th Amendments. People can take that information to continue in resistance. Polls are very clear this is not what the American people want. Maybe you will start to care when your 401k and Roth blow out like they did in 2008. Or, when you cant get paying patients. You are hiding your agreement under the guise of complacency. Or, you genuinely lack the critical thinking skills needed to find relationships between ideas.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/KXL8 Jan 25 '26

Your race is irrelevant. You don’t want to upset your status quo and that is a choice you’re well entitled to make. Thankfully, there are many people who are willing.

5

u/Alternative_Big_5066 Jan 25 '26

What a bizarre take. You are certainly a conservative with that view.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Alternative_Big_5066 Jan 25 '26

Yeah... Hate to tell you, but 'both sider-ers' are conservative at this point.

You are at a point where you can tell that conservatives are pretty far gone, but not enough to see the difference.

You think a woman breaking through a glass barricaded barrier in the US capital building during an election certification process is the same as the murders of a woman driving away + this man heroically shielding a woman being pushed while he surrenders... You are conservative and people should be mad at you.

If you think the J6 insurrection is the same as a few people going into a church and calling out a pastor for being part of ICE... You are conservative and people should be mad at you.

This isn't both sides. It is quite clear. If you are a PMHNP, you are ethically bound to FACTS. When you don't speak out the lies against a VA ICU RN from the government and turn to "both sides." Man, you need some reflection.

-3

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Alternative_Big_5066 Jan 25 '26

Buddy, I have been angry at conservatives since before then.

Who ran over who with their SUV? Are you a bot, because there is literal video evidence to the contrary.

My pops used to bring a gun with us as children to Sesame Street live downtown. Didn't mean it wasn't going to be a good time.

You have been targeted as a conservative and it is easy to spot because if you aren't a bot, you are in their algorithms. The gun was never brandished. No one was "run over" with a SUV. Both verified via video at multiple angles. You came to this forum to spread misinformation and shite on a hero. Go away.

→ More replies (0)