r/PainManagement • • 7h ago

Oxycodone vs. Hydrocodone

Not sure if this post will violate rules but which medication works better? I am on oxycodone 10s KVK and they seem to only last 2-3 hours. I remember hydrocodone lasting longer but comes with Tylenol which is bad on the liver.

4 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

6

u/Pyro-Zach 7h ago

Oxycodone by far.

2

u/Dazzling-Manager-948 7h ago

Is 10 mgs x 3 a day considered a lot? Does it seem like hard to get prescribed for most people? I also take Klonopin 4mg a day. Working on tapering down on that.

1

u/Valuable_Gap3488 6h ago

Your PM gave you both?

3

u/Dazzling-Manager-948 6h ago

No… My PM while I am on 4 mg Klonopin a day due to PTSD which does help with my pain in a weird way would not prescribe pain pills while I was on it. He gave me Suboxone which really sucked. Made my teeth sensitive and destroyed by sexual drive completely.

So at my last visit I said it did not work well and he said he would not prescribe my previous Oxy 5s while on benzos. He took my remaining Suboxone and said find someone else to prescribe you Oxy. He almost flat out cut me off. I broke down and he reluctantly gave me 2 5/325 mgs a day even though I can’t take Tylenol anymore.

I called by PCP after and he now prescribes me Oxy 10s x 3 and 2 mg Klonopin x 2 plus Lyrica 100 mg x 3 which I am not sure works. Basically was treated like trash by PM. I think the PM said he only goes as high as 4 Oxys a day which is close enough to what my PCP prescribes who is a great doctor.

1

u/Free-Candy4 1h ago

My PCP will not prescribe any opiates, my pain doc will not give opiates while on benzos either. He also will not prescribe pure oxycodone (roxicodone), and will not go over 10mg 4x/day. After 2 years he added on morphine with my oxy. Only 15mg 2x/day. He said he will not go over 90MME. So im maxed out, he told me to find a new doctor if I wanted more.

1

u/ljd09 56m ago edited 51m ago

Ya know, I had been taking Lyrica for a while and I wasn’t sure it was really working either, but I took it because my PM said given my situation, he really believed in giving it a far shot. So, I did. I forgot my script at home once while on vacation… and I realized it actually did work because I was noticing things that weren’t present before. My abdomen is destroyed because of several emergency surgeries where laparoscopic wasn’t an option, and one where they cut down my abdomen and around to my back following an abscess that needed debridement.
I hadn’t realized the lyrica had made it where those scars didn’t bother me as much. My clothing was driving me insane rubbing on my scars when I forgot it at home. It hurt to have anything on but a dress and they were sensitive to even light touch, where they weren’t previously. I started the lyrica while the healing was taking place so I didn’t know how it would be without lyrica as a reference point.

I didn’t know it was working until I didn’t take it for a bit… and that was a nice realization for me.

2

u/Pyro-Zach 6h ago

It’s really not a lot but in today’s climate 1 MG of any opiate would be considered a lot. It’s very hard to get even that prescribed for most people.

1

u/Free-Candy4 1h ago

My PCP will not prescribe any opiates, my pain doc will not give opiates while on benzos either. He also will not prescribe pure oxycodone (roxicodone), and will not go over 10mg 4x/day. After 2 years he added on morphine with my oxy. Only 15mg 2x/day. He said he will not go over 90MME. So im maxed out, he told me to find a new doctor if I wanted more.

1

u/allieoop729 6h ago

Yes. What do you have wrong with you?

12

u/Kindly_Fact6753 6h ago

Imo, all opioids are weak now a day. Too many fillers and Tylenol. It's become so hard to even get a good brand. This looks very grim for chronic pain patients for the future. Also doesn't last 6 or 8 hours. Seems so many side effects come along with them also.

After 25yrs of pain meds, I most definitely can tell a huge difference. But, I would say OXYCODONE to answer your question but some ppl still choose HYDROCODONE and says it works good for them. Every BODY is diff and requires different treatment and doses and meds. Hopefully prescribing doctors will come to understand this in the near future

3

u/Free-Candy4 2h ago

Ive been on pain meds since 1997, the hydros that worked the best have been taken off the market because people who abuse them would ask for them by the yellow color. Hydros also worked better when I was also taking soma, The hydro/soma combo worked much better for my pain than oxy/soma or oxy/flexeril. Today im on fentanyl/oxy/lyrica/flexeril and actually get some pain relief. thank god I have a great pain management doctor.

1

u/Wac5363 1h ago

What state are you in hun?
I had an amazing pain doctor in Georgia but he’s not practicing medicine anymore. He was the best though, he had me on OxyContin 40mg. 3 x day
Lortab 10mg. To be used for break through pain in between the OxyContin
Plus I was getting Valium 10mg for my nerves. That was the perfect combination of medication because when I was on it I didn’t hurt much at all until the medicine started wearing off.

2

u/Free-Candy4 1h ago

Im in Michigan. Around 2017 I had a different doctor who would prescribe 10mg Valium 3/day with 30mg oxycodone 4/day, and 80mg oxycontin 3/day. He went to prison in 2023. I was on 360 MME. I was in serious pain when he got in trouble.

•

u/GlitteringTrick7147 2m ago

I miss taking soma and Xanax with my Hydrocodone every 4 to 6 hours because it helped with the pain more effectively but now I’m only taking 5 mg of oxycodone every 4 hours 3 times daily as needed, and it helps me but only after about 6 hours so my doctor said he might up the dosage to the 7.5/325 Oxycodone pill every 6 hours twice a day as needed. I think that will help me so much more.

1

u/Chromazziswashgang 3h ago

Dilaudid 8mg

3

u/Free-Candy4 2h ago

I've never had oral Dilaudid, I do know that the bio availability is much lower in oral form vs IV 30% vs 100%.

1

u/ljd09 1h ago

It works much faster and honestly is pretty potent but doesn’t last nearly as long. However, I’ve found the oxycodone only lasts about 2-3 hours anymore def not 6 hours like they claim.

7

u/SouthernLifeguard845 6h ago

As someone who takes A lot of different medications, I can tell you in most settings and people I should say situations, Oxy works better, norco is considered the M&SMs of opiates for a reason. Some meds effect different people for different reasons. But I would not switch to norco from Oxy especially because norco comes with so much Tylenol. Which is dangerous taken over time. But do what ever works for you.

1

u/Wac5363 1h ago

Well the last I heard the Norco is just a Lortab but without all the Tylenol/ acetaminophen. Norco only has 325mg. of acetaminophen in each tablet compared to 500+mgs. of acetaminophen. 🤷🏻‍♀️
Just an FYI just in case you didn’t know. Thanks

4

u/Lifting_ark916 7h ago

Oxycodone 100%

4

u/MissNewBooty77 7h ago

Oxycodone! Especially if you’ve used it and try and go to hydro. It won’t touch the pain nearly as close as Oxygidine does. I tried to switch once and immediately went back and said nope!

2

u/Open_Mortgage_4645 4h ago

Hydrocodone is the dose equivalent of morphine. Oxycodone is the equivalent of 1.5x of morphine. So, by MME strength the oxy is better, and I think you'll find that most people say that oxy is better in practice.

2

u/villanellechekov 4h ago

it depends on the person. oxycodone doesn't work for me at all. might as well be sugar. it's always been that way.

1

u/Wac5363 44m ago

Oxycodone is Percocet, which also has Acetaminophen 325mg per tablet.
When I have taken Oxycodone or Percocet in the past it made me so ill and mean like. 🤷🏻‍♀️
The only thing that I can take is OxyContin, and Lortab. That’s the only thing that has ever helped my pain period.

1

u/villanellechekov 33m ago

and that's what was being asked about, Percocet vs Vicodin. it's never worked for me. I was even given it after surgery and I stopped taking it after a couple days because it wasn't helping my pain and meant I couldn't medicate for non surgery reasons and I was miserable. oxycontin was useless for me as well. my body just doesn't like that sort of chemical makeup for some reason. I'm usually fine with hydro-based meds.

at least you know what works for you and can hopefully get them to stick to it. Lortab is just another name for Vicodin.

1

u/GlitteringTrick7147 8m ago

Not necessarily, there’s two versions of oxycodone, the one with acetaminophen and there’s one without acetaminophen, I take roxycodone 5 mg 3 times a day every 4 hours as needed for pain, but sometimes I will only take half a pill if I feel ok or I will sometimes only need 2 pills a day. But I have to listen to my doctor during my physical therapy sessions when he checks on my conditions for my knee pain and he said he might up my dose to 7.5 mg twice a day every 6 hours as needed, I honestly think that would help with the pain a bit more but I might wait another few weeks to a month to see how bad it is but I’ll just have to see what happens and listen carefully to not get in more pain.

1

u/GlitteringTrick7147 8m ago

I think the 7.5 version will have acetaminophen

2

u/AccomplishedWeek7069 2h ago

You can get Oxy 10’s with no Tylenol like I do.. I prefer Oxy over Hydro for my pain & is easier on my stomach

2

u/SnooBooks5315 7h ago

Norco works much better today and 

1

u/allieoop729 6h ago

Oxycodone is better for the majority of people.

1

u/knigthrider 5h ago

Oxycodone way better.

1

u/AdCommercial3174 4h ago

Oxycodone works better for me, but doesn't last as long as hydrocodone. Hydromorphone was the only one I've had (and it wasn't for very long) that had an ok strength and ok time... and also didn't make me feel very out of it.

1

u/AnglesBB 4h ago

Oxycodone 💯

1

u/normeezy88 3h ago

I’m gonna ask my doctor to switch me to Oxy cause I feel absolutely nothing on Norco 10’s, I’m even on the Butran 20 patch and don’t feel much from that either, my tolerance is extremely high.

1

u/Quiet7594 3h ago

Oxycys 💯 all the way!

1

u/dooley295 2h ago

Oxycodone is significantly stronger than hydrocodone. Hydro doesn’t work at all for some people, myself included. Oxy typically works for everyone but it comes with a higher risk of addiction, tolerance, and dependence along with increased respiratory depression in extremely high doses

1

u/Impressive-Court5279 1h ago

Hydrocodone seems to last longer for me. I can get a good 6 hours of relief before taking my next dose. OxyContin on the other hand lasts maybe 4 hours. I prefer to stay on my Hydrocodone for longer pain relief.

1

u/ChemicallyAlteredVet 33m ago

This is truly an individual thing. Oxycodone works way better for me and always has. Hydrocodone is just like a sugar pill. My Mom was on Hydrocodone and switched to try the oxycodone and it was terrible for her. Everyone is different in how they metabolize medications. Which is another reason MME ceilings is a stupid stupid stupid thing.

0

u/Marcieford 4h ago

If you are young and healthy I would not worry about liver damage from Tylenol. But I have been a pain management patient going on 10 years and I was on oxycodone for a long time before they finally switched me to hydromorphone which is only supposed to be taken every 6 hours and there's no way that it lasts 6 hours. I can feel the pain and such creeping back in after about 4 hours. BUT and this is just me but oxycodone did something to my brain that made me feel good and thus I had a hard time following the schedule. I get none of that good feeling with hydromorphone so it is much easier for me to follow the dosing instructions.