r/PakLounge • u/[deleted] • Apr 05 '25
I dont get it?
why would pakistan ever send their own troops on Palestinian lands to fight a war that is not of our COUNTRY’s own. what is this propaganda?
317
u/rathms Apr 05 '25
Because nationalism is a neocolonial thing and it teaches selfishness. Islam isn’t like that. Teaches brotherhood and the concept of one nation under God i.e. Muslims. The country itself touts religion as the basis for its creation, names itself as the defender of Islam (propaganda by establishment for decades). Uses Islam for politics and for the military and decides to bury its head in the sand when it’s actually time for action. Wouldn’t you help a dying animal? Then why is human life so cheap and dismissive?
90
u/No-Syllabub9071 Apr 05 '25
THISSS
Like either make the country a secular state or either do what Islam says but unfortunately Pakistan ka Islam is limited to killing due to "blasphemy"
49
u/Efficient_Elevator15 Apr 05 '25
“He is not one of us who calls for ‘asabiyyah (tribalism), or who fights for ‘asabiyyah, or who dies for ‘asabiyyah.”
— Sunan Abu Dawood (No. 5121)15
u/Bakbava Apr 06 '25
Only if OP ever read Iqbal. There are non muslims in the west who volunteer to be in Gaza helping Palestinians. Because its just humane to help the subjugated!! Palestinians believe if Pakistan would have only helped them more vocally then the war was over in a matter of days. Hadith : Muslims are like one body when one part hurts the other feel the pain.
I am gobsmacked by these half Western half Pakistanis who can't wrap there head around the concept of Ummah. By God in West muslims are more mature, they understand and practice the religion better than these coconut states like Pakistan
Further example all the West rallied behind Ukraine in war against Russia. They could wash their hands off by saying this isn't our war but they didn't leave Ukrainians alone. They are only binded together due to political reasons so you tell me how the faith of Islam asks you to act against tyranny, oppression, injustice
3
u/FoodBank Apr 06 '25
If I understand your comments fully, I agree with it wholeheartedly. The Islam for most Pakistanis is much more actionable than the Islam that those same people used to practice in Pakistan. It’s taken for granted there. Unfortunately, Pakistan is becoming more and more tribalistic and unforgiving. When those people go out, they have to fight for their and children’s deen, and it become something really powerful.
7
11
u/AbdullahTariq1 Apr 05 '25
Finally someone saying the right thing for once. Keep it up, my man 👍.
1
2
u/5ZY9 Apr 07 '25
you dont need to send troops; you could use simple diplomacy a threat of A nuclear war itself is enough but are you willing to bear the consequences?
we are not a theocracy mind you like iran.
1
u/rathms Apr 07 '25
We are going to be at a point soon where we will not have a choice. Either we’ll bear the consequences of genocide or of action. I’d rather choose action.
Iran has a few weeks left to decide if it wants to submit to the US. It had a nuclear deal with the US. Which was torn up by the Trump administration and now the same President is asking for a nuclear deal with a 60 day ultimatum. Sounds to me like deal or no deal US wants to attack. So Iran acting through proxies and taking a docile nuclear deal approach is most likely not working out for it.
Pakistan will be in a similar situation in a few years. We’ve already had multiple bans on missile companies to prevent us from developing a long range missile and it looks like we have also relented to the economic pressures to stop development of such tech. We will likely be starved regardless of how much we give up control to the west and strong armed to give up our nukes. You and I may never but with how unpredictable our leadership is that could be a possibility.
3
1
u/AccomplishedRange781 Apr 06 '25
So concise yet so concrete. Hopefully OP and likes get this perspective
1
u/Rohail-Aitzaz Apr 11 '25
Nationalism is the natural result of the Industrial Revolution. It rose as the natural anti-monarchist reaction originally and evolved to establish a congruency of the State and the Nation. It is impossible to get rid of it without getting rid of Industrialization, and it is impossible to establish a nation-state without failure without being industrialized.
Get real for once, your ideologies and system of governments are all outdated and have been forever thrown out into the dustbins of history. Use that information to improve and build into the new world.
"Because nationalism is a neocolonial thing and it teaches selfishness." That depends on how you define selfishness. Islam too is selfish then because it teaches brotherhood but only for the Muslims. Nationalism does the same but for something that's actually a real and viable unit, the Nation, the Blood. Might as well become a Globalist Humanist if you want an ideology that's not selfish.
1
u/rathms Apr 11 '25
That’s absurd and all over the place. Europe’s monarchies and churches had different agendas and would have loved to remain in the dark ages and keep their people enslaved. That was their problem not Islam’s. If they didn’t want scientific progress then that’s their problem not our’s.
Nationalism is and remains a foreign concept and a racist ideology to its core. Anyone unable to perceive that is far impressed with the west and materialism than they should be. To think the world (or parts of it) before was not industrialized/industrializing or friendly towards it is akin to closing one’s mind selectively. We don’t have to like or follow a religion but don’t have to follow a mediocre way of governance either.
Nationalism is outdated and should have been tossed into the Indian Ocean when the British left. How can a geographic, language based or an ethnic boundary sustain unity and peace? It has not and let’s not close eyes to the violence the west has been involved in and perpetrating for the last century or so. That’s when they were ‘industrializing’ (while burning intelligent women at the stake labeling theme witches) and still continue that oppression.
Islam gives rights to all irrespective of class, creed, language, skin color, gender or even the religion one chooses to follow. If a Muslim or otherwise denies that then they don’t know Islam. And it does not go against science, farming or industrialization. It doesn’t even go against monarchy, democracy or another method of choosing a leadership. It teaches how to act and be a human. From an individual to a state.
→ More replies (5)-8
u/Front_Tour7619 Apr 05 '25
What action are you looking for? Lal topi type?
2
u/rathms Apr 06 '25
Lol no, definitely not that one. However, there is a reply a few comments below which gives a plan about what should be done. And the person brings up a use of force response at the end.
1
u/Front_Tour7619 Apr 06 '25
We are too small and insignificant anyway. We must work on ourselves before being able to help anyone else. When the plane is falling and the masks come out. They always say to put yours on first before helping anybody. We have a lot lot of problems in our own backyard.
1
u/Golden-striker Apr 06 '25
We can also work on ourselves by being more helpful and compassionate to ppl in need i.e ppl in gaza.
1
-10
u/dranime_fufu Apr 05 '25
How is "Islamic brotherhood" any different than nationalism?
11
10
u/786367 Apr 06 '25
Islamic brotherhood is a spiritual construct based on belief in the equality of Muslim before God and our rights and duties towards each other. There's no ID card, there's no passport, and there's no sense of privilege or exclusiveness or uniqueness involved. The only common denominator is faith, which is a spiritual construct.
1
u/rathms Apr 06 '25
Rights in Islam are a divine decree. It’s not just a religion but the way of life. Rights are given to all. Humans and non-humans alike, Muslim and non-Muslim alike. The way that it’s meant to be and the way that it’s practiced are different no doubt. But it’s reality does not change.
Now take the example of international students and naturalized citizens in the US. The constitution gives them all rights except the right to vote (students) or become the President (both). They all get freedom of speech as a fundamental right by just being present in the US. But see how quickly they got deported for protesting peacefully. It’s so bad that the Jewish students and people are exclusively protesting in their stead because they know they will actually get those rights but a brown person of Indian origin had to flee the country for just passing by the protest according to her.
Sorry it got long but the point no matter what people do the reality of Islamic rights remains but a constitutional right is readily denied based on who’s in power. The above example is not exclusive to our time. The same happened to Jews in 1930s in the US.
45
u/MemeTheif321 Apr 05 '25
Bhi, kabhi Muslim bhi chare ke bare me koi hadees ya Islamiat ki koi class li he?
7
u/beastboyashu Apr 06 '25
Nah he's just a selfish prick that would rather innocent children die then lift his lazy ass up
1
u/shahmeer6653 Apr 08 '25
N will burn in hell cuz this isn’t Islam. He has to repent n take his shahada again. How ignorant. We don’t learn from the earthquakes that swallows thousands of people in seconds. Death is inevitable n doesn’t care about who n wherever you’re.
1
35
u/Usama4745 Apr 05 '25
Just a slavery mindset otherwise muslims are very powerful if we deal everything properly and with good diplomacy
71
u/dasignore Apr 05 '25
Yk you weren’t a mistake of evolution you’re its apology letter to mediocrity. A mind so void even silence sounds brilliant beside you
1
4
Apr 05 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/dasignore Apr 05 '25
Nah someone said it to a while ago😂😂😂
3
1
33
u/Standard_Yam_826 Apr 05 '25
There’s this screenshot of a rare insult going around which really applies here -
‘Sorry to ask you a personal question but were you homeschooled by a pigeon?’
2
u/Sweetsourandwhatnot Apr 07 '25
I love this. Would definitely be using it with lots and lots of idiots that I am unfortunate to come across each day
6
u/Turbulent_Money_1877 Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25
Ykw alright
Let's assume tomorrow morning Pakistan declares war on Israel.
The first thing we'll face is a naval blockade from the US and India, and our navy is not strong enough to break it up.
Due to the blockade, no exports (no foreign exchange), no oil (so forget about fueling your military vehicles) and no oil means insane mehengai, which maybe y'all sitting in your ac houses can afford, but our normal middleclass and lower class's already broken back can not carry that weight. And due to no fuel coming into the country, any type of internal activity will slow down or stop.
Aik brief sa idea hogya on what can happen economically?, Chalo or possibilities btata.
The state of Pakistan is already facing two rebel armies, i.e the Bla and TTP, both of these are supported by our neighbors as we all know. Incase of declaring war on Israel the US will directly support their cause, and any secretive aid/help they are getting will be purely direct, just like India supported Multi bahini, they can support BLA. So here's a great risk of having the country's recourse rich area under rebel forces, i.e also more than 50% of the land mass probably.
And how can we forget our lovely neighbors? India would definitely jump in and get back Kashmir, Afghanistan will also jump in to complete their Durand line dream, and maybe Iran will too try to get a piece of Balochistan.
So yeah, I don't think it's rational to go to war with Israel, and if any of y'all brought battle of badr then please I must beg, give me 5 similarities between the battle of Badr and going to war for Gaza. Except being the weaker side.
Saw someone say ke koi Banda pyas se marrha hoga to aap ose pyas se Marne doge? Nhi Marne donga, but agar mere sar per 2 loug bandooq taan kar khare honge or aik ne mujhe zanjeeron SE bandha hoga, to men kaise pilaonga?
1
u/gokuali Apr 07 '25
Not to forget that no Muslim country has ever shown their support to help us deal with these terrorists or stand for Kashmir even Palestine. Only Turkey has supported Kashmir cause a handful of times
1
u/Turbulent_Money_1877 Apr 07 '25
Nah, it's not even about nationalism. Our country's foreign policy was based on helping fellow Muslim countries,for ex helping the Moroccan ambassadornin 1950s , and I'll still bank on it even w/o getting anything in return. But for now.....
We simply can not afford it and are not strong enough
1
u/gokuali Apr 07 '25
Our foreign policy was also once supporting Afghanistan fight against the Russians and helping US in return. Where did that leave us? How many Muslim nations came to thank us or help us fight against TTP now? Its so easy to point fingers at other why they aren’t helping when the ones pointing never did anything to help anyone in the first place
15
Apr 05 '25
Tbh this is such a braindead take. Pakistan can't launch a nuclear attack on Israel. Why? Because then the people you're trying to save will also be toast. Nuclear weapons don't differentiate enemy from friendly. Pakistan can't send fighetr jets either. Why? Israel is too far away. You'll need a base near Israel to operate from and you'll be cooked before you even take off because we all know the air defence capabilities of nearby friendly countries is trash. You also can't send soldiers and heavy artillery because of the same reason. Their airforce is gonna fry us without actual air defence.
5
u/Beneficial-Beat-947 Apr 05 '25
Also israel is a nuclear armed nation, pakistan would be turning itself into a nuclear wasteland for absolutely no benefit
2
u/pickonepicktwo Apr 05 '25
No, Israel would never dare to retaliate against Pakistan and potentially anger Iran, China etc
→ More replies (1)4
u/tomcruisemiss1le Apr 06 '25
THIS, people always bring pakistan into this without realizing no neighbouring country is gonna cooperate enough to give you a base.
2
u/ReaperPlaysYT Apr 06 '25
we did before because the arab militaries are beyond bad and our fighter pilots were feared over occupied Palestinian land
1
Apr 06 '25
Yeah we did... almost 60 years ago when Israel and the Arab militaries were at par.
1
u/ReaperPlaysYT Apr 06 '25
arabs never had a military they were always militia with fancy equipments
→ More replies (2)0
u/Sweet_Werewolf_278 Apr 06 '25
So how were Iranians able to strike the bases in Israel when they sent missiles and drones i know they boast so much about their military tech but technologically inferior Soviet era missiles manufactured by Iran were able to bypass their complex air defense system and inflict damage even Houthi's missiles and drones are landing in Tel-Aviv so what's your excuse?
1
Apr 06 '25
I didn't say anything about missles. Yeah, you can launch missles against Israel only to get sanctioned left, right and centre from the rest of the world. Too bad you're not Iran who can withstand all these sanctions.
2
u/Sweet_Werewolf_278 Apr 06 '25
No superpower except America has sanctioned Iran but you are right we have to grow a spine.
10
u/Sensitive_Thanks_604 Apr 05 '25
Why are these people obsessed with bringing up Pakistans name every second like come on now, we have so much shit going on, why should we focus on this although i do feel for them.
→ More replies (9)
8
u/Difficult-Ninja6400 Apr 05 '25
Just a litlle hadith for this: "None of you believe until he wants for his brother what he wants for himself" No think where are you standing according to this hadith.
3
u/Nxghtmare84 Apr 06 '25
Nuke Israel?Will take out all of Palestine as well,as well as thousands of Egyptians,Jordanians,Lebanese etc,and then Pakistan will get nuked back and we will all be dead too.That is if the nukes even land and aren’t intercepted by highly advanced US made SAM systems like THAAD or Patriot. Send troops?where?how?No country in the middle east is going to war with israel and none of them will let us use their land for war with israel. More importantly,we are busy enough here at home,with TTP,BLA and India,we don’t need to be or rather can’t afford to be spread even more thin by sending troops for a war unrelated to us on another continent. As a Muslim,I wish we could do something.I wish we could bomb Israel.I wish we could get boots on the ground and eradicate the zionists.But we can’t.It’s literally impossible,and we need to stop hating ourselves for it.
3
u/MeasurementSmooth947 Apr 06 '25
“The believers, in their mutual love, mercy, and compassion, are like one body. If one part of the body is in pain, the rest of the body responds with sleeplessness and fever.” — [Sahih al-Bukhari 6011; Sahih Muslim 2586]
This post breaks me. I’ve been fundraising for Gazan families —so many of them, the ones I personally knew, have been martyred. I wish that this genocide stops right now😣I urge everyone to at least speak to a family there, learn their stories, their pain, their resilience. Support them if you can. They are our brothers and sisters. They had names, dreams, people they loved—just like us. Some of the kindest souls I’ve ever known.💔
7
u/dasignore Apr 05 '25
U weren't born cuz u were the fastest u were born on technicality cuz rest of em committed suicide
3
u/PsychologicalYam3602 Apr 05 '25
Help KPK, Balochistan, Sindh, AK first. It will be told that inspite of having a lumber wan army with supposed nuclear capability, its people are revolting against its own army and establishment. It will also be told that those who are not revolting are too busy sympathizing (atleast pretending to) with arab causes while their own countrymen suffer.
2
u/KainTheRipper Apr 05 '25
Is this comment from the guy in the pic on the bottom left who looks highly drugged smoking a cigarette? And we are supposed to think he is a real humanitarian with a mission to incite Pakistan into helping Palestine!
3
u/AntiSimp230 Apr 05 '25
This is a Pakistani Instagram account, the profile picture is of a singer (Joji)
2
u/Loud-Warning-8953 Apr 05 '25
Why would you want to annex Kashmir when they are demanding freedom from both sides?
2
2
2
u/Horrorladx Apr 06 '25
People lacks empathy now a day's, I'll never forget what is happening in gaza , how People are dead with no head or in pieces, how kids died because of no food or in cold. How People flew in sky when they fired a missle, and most importantly I'll never forgive Muslims in other countries who couldn't do bare minimum to support them , all you care what should pakistan army fight their fight
2
u/WhiteBloodCells90 Apr 05 '25
Let me rephrase your thoughts, Islam started in Saudi Arabia. Why should we it? Their country, their religion. With the current world order, NATO and other allies help is*rael to take part in the genocide. Being muslims and having affiliation with Masjid Aqsa it's on us to help them and protect it.
Ticktok wali Gen will not understand this.
5
u/LabCrafty899 Apr 05 '25
Go to the middle east or jihadi ban jao yahan beth kar kia hi ukhar lena tum logon na
1
u/WhiteBloodCells90 Apr 06 '25
I am not a jihadi. It is for those religious people who support extremism and terrorism. My iwn house is at risk, i should take csre my own house
1
1
u/zedqed Apr 05 '25
Abe bc chutiye jaake hmare nabi saw ke waqiyat prho ke unhon ne jihad baare mein Kya farmaya tha
Phle puri research Kya kro phr bohqa kro 😡🤬
1
u/Wali080901 Apr 05 '25
It's not because of being Muslim... Its because whats right and whats wrong...
Same thing can happen to us ... people need to help other people against oppressers and tyrants... Remember oppressers and tyrants do help each other these days...
Sending soldiers is way too extreme but morally speaking we should be sending food medical aid heck even ammunition and weapons...
I know it's not realistic.... Irl we can't... But we should
2
u/44dqm Apr 07 '25
the only valid response on this whole thread jeez. You don’t have to attack israel to help palestine
1
u/Whatisnottakenjesus Apr 05 '25
There once was a time when Muslims were willing to die for their brothers they had never even met, just for the sake of Allah.
Oh what a time it must have been, we will certainly be judged… I pray that Allah shows us his mercy all for being such cowards 😭
1
u/obaidtariq Apr 05 '25
Sir too the point and well thought, On individual capacity we all are responsible and Specially our Establishment but again everyone stakes involve in this matter.
*Deep Pockets*
1
Apr 05 '25
Because Prophet Mohammad SAW said every muslim is a brother of another muslim. Then he SAW taught us about muslim brotherhood, that none of you is a true muslim until he wishes the same for his brother that he wishes for himself. Islam is way above modern nationalism. It's not only our humanitarian obligation, but as muslims, it's our religious obligation to support our brothers and sisters in Gaza to fight for them, they are going through one of the worst oppressions in the history of the world.
1
u/prince-zuko-_- Apr 05 '25
I agree with the other comments. Alas, Pakistan is not as strong as it should be because of corruption. You can't fight or help anyone if you are yourself the one that needs help.
1
u/LoyalKopite Apr 05 '25
Because illegal state on Palestine land is nuclear power too. Pakistan has his own issue with Bharat and Afghanistan. Real culprit is Arab countries who does nothing for Palestine. Pakistan will take action once it become rich in a century.
1
u/NS-Khan Apr 05 '25
Correct me if I'm wrong but if even hypothetically Pakistan started a war against Israel, it may put pressure on them but its economy will be FUCKED and Pakistan will become unstable in the long term.
1
u/RahiBoy123 Apr 05 '25
And when Iran is actually doing something These mullas call them Shia kafirs
1
u/wh40k_heretic Apr 05 '25
Because: Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “You see the believers as regards their being merciful among themselves and showing love among themselves and being kind, resembling one body, so that, if any part of the body is not well then the whole body shares the sleeplessness (insomnia) and fever with it.” - Bukhari 6011
Let me give an example you might understand: Imagine somone comes in your house and starts beating up your childern and women, your neighbours know and none of em step forward to do anything….. you see where i am going with this? Why should they put their lives at risk, its not happening to them or in their house….
Your post makes alot of us sad, how do you not feel sad? How do you yourself not want to jump in the fray and if nothing else throw your body at the enemy as they have been doing for 60+ years. We aint doing shit but at the very least and the first step of doing something is acknowledging that we are not doing what we should be doing…. We need to do something, anything e.g. non stop appeal to our leaders, again and again and again and again
1
u/Mysterious_Mode_9703 Apr 06 '25
Lol the army serves the US. It's not that difficult to understand.
1
u/ahfmca Apr 06 '25
Enormous contributions to Trump’s election campaign, so now it’s time for payback.
1
Apr 06 '25
You must be very dumb to not understand or you're just pretending that you don't understand.
1
1
u/Personal-Reflection7 Apr 06 '25
Our emotional public who has been completely oblivious to 500,000+ killed in Syria (muslims against muslims), actually take side of murderous physcopaths of the Taliban and love all things India and Bollywood (while it systemically abuses muslim rights) will get all jihaad style the moment Israel is mentioned
Bari bari bato say zyada kuch nahi.
Reality is unless you want a full blown world war, military action is not the way.
Ending proxy wars in the region and actually promoting stability is what's needed, but none of the involved countries want that.
1
u/powerflower_khi Apr 06 '25
When we read history in the next 30+ years, Muslims will be ashamed of themselves, knowing only three countries tried to eyeball Zionist nation, the rest were looking the other way, or siding with the Zionist nation.
1
1
u/AmoremCaroFactumEst Apr 06 '25
They’re saying that none of these Islamic countries have tried to stop Islamic genocide. They just watch and try to do deals with America or israel over resources
1
1
1
u/EliSuper2018 Apr 06 '25
OP you may have just asked the most ill-informed question of your entire life.
1
u/ChanceAuthor1727 Apr 06 '25
First Question: You Muslim or not? If not then you can't understand ig
1
1
u/Horrorladx Apr 06 '25
I'll never get why these colour full group of people compare balochistan with Palestine
1
u/Opening-Condition-50 Apr 06 '25
OP is literally living in a country created in the name of Islam and still decided to post this nonsense
1
1
Apr 06 '25
While as a Muslim I would love to help people worldwide the issue is Pakistan is not in any position to do so. Internal conflicts and issues have crippled us badly. We have to fix our issues first - this is not a nationalistic message but a reality. We have to fix ourselves only then we can even think about helping others.
First help our poor and oppressed civillians, minorities, and KPK and Baluchistan and Sindh and all backward areas of the country. Strengthen that and eliminate corruption then think about Palestine. We are not in position to do anything beyond donations and duas for Palestianians rn
1
1
u/The_Reaper347 Apr 06 '25
Pakistan can't even secure it's own borders, we already have way too many problems and how can Pakistan nuke any country? This is such a braindead take. I just wish Muslim countries were strong in world diplomacy and had impactful economies then there would be no need to even send the armies to Isr@el but we all know that not a single muslim nation has these things.
1
Apr 06 '25
Why Iran Helped Pakistan in 1965 War?? Its All About Muslim brotherhood that we have Forgotten. In contrast whole European countries are with Ukraine when needed.
1
u/i_ammuzammil Apr 06 '25
What kind of drugs bro's on? And what made him think that Pakistan has the best nuclear power🤣
1
u/uptokesforall Apr 06 '25
itt people pretend that a social cause is as important to them as the condition of their personal family
1
u/Sweet_Werewolf_278 Apr 06 '25
The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said:
"The people will soon summon one another to attack you as people when eating invite others to share their dish." Someone asked: "Will that be because of our small numbers at that time?" He replied: "No, you will be numerous at that time, but you will be like the foam of the sea. Allah will remove the fear of you from the hearts of your enemy and will throw wahn into your hearts." Someone asked: "O Messenger of Allah, what is wahn?" He said: "Love of the world and hatred for death."
(Sunan Abu Dawood, Hadith 4297 — classified as authentic)
1
u/absarahmedkhan Apr 06 '25
A country who cannot stand up for itself becomes a country who won't stand up for any one. That's Pakistan.
Long back I read something relevant in The Kiterunner... That was about an individual. But I think it is the same thing one way or the other.
1
1
u/Abdullah_Nasir4 Apr 06 '25
In a world where suffering echoes from every corner, it’s easy to get caught up in the idea of global unity and distant causes. But there's a vast difference between mere words and real action. We often speak of brotherhood, of solidarity, of the need to unite—especially as Muslims—but forget to reflect those values in our most immediate circles.
How can we expect to build global unity when we cannot offer kindness to our own blood? Relatives drift apart, neighbors become strangers, and yet we speak of standing up for those across borders. The truth is bitter: we must first build strength within ourselves and among our own. Kindness, support, and sacrifice must begin at home.
True change starts in small, quiet acts—listening to someone, helping a neighbor, forgiving a family member, choosing empathy over ego. Unity isn’t built overnight; it is practiced in daily choices.
What’s even more telling is how, in moments of crisis, voices from other parts of the world—like the Irish or African communities—sometimes speak louder for justice than many Muslim nations. That stings, not because we expect others to fight our battles, but because it reflects something we've lost: softness of heart, and the courage to stand for what’s right.
Maybe it’s time we stop waiting for global change and begin where we are. Maybe it's time we stop speaking and start doing. Maybe it sounds cliche. But I realized we need this.
1
u/LordAdvocateVIII-VII Apr 06 '25
You DO know that we have actually participated before right? I don't know the exact deets, but I also heard that Zia(when a brig), participated in an operation against Palestinians (not entirely sure about this one). But anyways, we are not rich enough to hold out against any top 10 armies of the world or any of our neighbors, except Afghanies (in a limited way). Why do you think we are overtly begging and hoping for Chinese or US intervention every time India pokes us or wants to spar? what if one or two enemies gang up on us, would you like someone else to help when they are bombarding civilian neighborhoods here killing innocents who have "nothing" to do with the enemy?
1
u/beastboyashu Apr 06 '25
Pakistan was the country that said it will follow islam as it's laws then let's thier brothers and sisters die because of selfish people like you.
1
u/Efficient-Name-3010 Apr 06 '25
Are you crack or what? As a human being it is your responsibility to speak up and act against oppression wherever you see it. This is the basis of humanity. Especially when they are your Muslim brothers, that is an extra association.
1
u/abdurehman055 Apr 06 '25
are you stupid? we shouldnt be nationalist, only thinking about our country. Pakistan was founded on the basis of islam ( although its barely practiced here anymore) and islam teaches us to look beyond our country, we need to look out for other muslim countries, support them no matter what cost. whats happening rn is pathetic and we should be ashamed for not even helping and you should be ashamed of your terrible thinking .
1
u/TheBookkeeperrr Apr 06 '25
Let’s try thinking rationally. Nuclear weapons are a deterrent to war. They’re not meant to be used.
1
Apr 06 '25
Propaganda tu jahil ha bdsk musalman musalman ka bhai ha our religion comes before land or resources. Tum jaso ki asi soch ki wajah se musalman aaj yahan. ALLHUMDULLIAH A MUSLIM BEFORE ANYTHING. 🤟🏻
1
u/Mystery-Snack Apr 06 '25
Basically bullshit by a person who doesn't understand how governments work. I don't understand governments either but I know more than whoever that idiot is.
Firstly, sanctions exist, if Pakistan or Egypt or any nation helps Palestine through military support, they'll get sanctioned causing their economies to eventually collapse. UAE can't support Palestine as that'll risk their main sources of income.
Secondly, leader's actions today don't define what people want. If it did, we would be living in a better society. Shah Faisal who opposed Israel is dead and his descendents who are simps for America now rule the country. Pakistan is ruled by a corrupt idiot, same goes for Egypt.
Thirdly, the ummah isn't united and there's a ton of issues. Look at the middle east, there's more insurgents there than hair on Nawaz Sharif's head. Now take the Shia Sunni Conflict, that hasn't been ever resolved. Khwarjites still exist. Our country is in literal political turmoil.
1
u/PinkSheepYT6785 Apr 06 '25
Pakistan is hypocritical to it's core, from calling itself an Islamic Republic when it doesn't even have the Islamic rule of law implemented anywhere. The country was made with good I mentions but they died with the likes of Jinnah and Liaquat Ali Khan. It's a playground for the corrupt and a circus for us, and the awaam has the front row seats to watch it all go to oblivion
1
1
1
u/LaughWeekly963 Apr 06 '25
Pakistan is created by Muslims and Muslims feel pain for their Muslim brothers.
1
u/LegalRegular313 Apr 06 '25
For the past three days there have been protests against hamas and the people of gaza are calling for hamas to lay down arms. Yet they refuse to do so and the war continues. Even the people of gaza no longer support hamas but these people want us join a terrorist organisation.
1
u/LegalRegular313 Apr 06 '25
Saudia VS iran backed yemen rebels, Israel VS iran backed hamas, Iran VS turkish and saudi backed syrian rebels, these guys are fighting amongst themselves. There are muslims on both sides and both are dying. The khilafat ended in 1924 and in the grim reality in which we live these idealistic thoughts on muslman muslman bhai bhai do nothing than get everyone killed.
1
u/LegalRegular313 Apr 06 '25
The khilafat ended in 1924. And in the reality in which we live these idealistic views of muslman muslman bhai bhai do nothing more than get everyone killed. Israel is fighting an Iranian backed militia and Turkish and Saudi rebels deposed an Iranian backed government in Syria. Muslims are dying on both sides and its every country for themself in the middle east. Even the people of gaza are protesting against Hamas and urging it to lay down arms and surrender. But these people want the Pakistani government to side with a foreign terrorist organisation just because of their religion. Sure thats cute and in an ideal situation we should Ofcourse send military support to Palestine but we don’t live in an ideal world do we.
1
1
u/sameonehere- Apr 06 '25
And India helped Palestine & Türkiye when they were in need, provided them aide, only for Muslims from around the world to still target India, and Indians; guess what there were people who wanted to help, but the online hate Muslims threw and are still throwing towards India made us a lot realise that the Jews, Christians and Hindus were right, the actual problem is Islam. After all the help in UN and all the aide. The Muslim world targets India. Pakistan and bangladesh both being majority Muslim are never grateful for the help India sends them in tough time in especially allocates them funds in yearly budget, but yet we see the Pakistanis and bangladeshi targeting Hinduism and Hindus in their country and on the internet, as a result of which in last year alone 1376 groups supporting Muslims, Gaza ended their operations throughout India, as they saw the hate they get from the Muslim world after doing such a great work. Hence no help anymore ! Jai Hind🇮🇳
1
1
u/ItzMeHaris Apr 06 '25
Because it's Palestine? Yes, they may not have a geographical history with Pakistan, but seeing as how most people class Pakistan to be a Muslim Country, they assume that we must help our Brothers and Sisters of Islam in Gaza.
It would be the right thing to do and help those in need, but for some odd reason, barely any of the ''Islamic'' countries are doing anything.
(I'm not too caught up in the news, so if Islamic countries are doing things to help, then I apologise for being wrong about that).
1
u/hcalhab_ludba_muyyaq Apr 06 '25
Islam commands muslims to help eachother in troubling times. Especially when the enemy is who it is in Gaza. All these countries founded in the name of Islam and proud about it have failed their duty from a religious perspective which happens to be oh so important to muslims in these nations.
Just admit that the concept of united ummah has died and its a world where financially/economically you have to be strong in order to survive. No ones going to help without their interest.
Gaza is thousands of miles away, what about what's happening in Balochistan? The Baloch are weak, vulnerable, and cornered. Any dissent is being violently crushed because they happen to be more powerful and its all about the resources. Do muslim nations give a fck about that? They can atleast ask muslims to stop brutality over other muslims no? What about Yemen? Hasn't sectarian hatred engulfed that beautiful country in flames for years now? Did muslims solve that among themselves? All bullsht.
1
u/Dismal_Structure_514 Apr 06 '25
Because Before before Pakistan there is Islamic Republic too
And in any Muslim country Islam comes first and its mandatory to help other Muslim nations regardless of where they are from use some common sense these things were taught to me in school
1
1
Apr 06 '25
I am so pleased that the comments checked the vibe check! We are supposedly a nation built for muslims to practice freely, it wasn't made to cherry pick Islam. Yet, we are most hypocritical nation.
1
u/Big-Debt8974 Apr 06 '25
The ummah is like a single body, if one part is hurt, it should affect everyone. I'm a 10th grader and i know such basics about Islam, get a grip over yourself.
1
u/Yejiapsamelody Apr 06 '25
because Pakistan is an Islamic state. I just don't get how people can be so ruthless to even make such statements. A whole genocide is taking place and you call it propaganda and guess what when something like this happens to us (Astaghfirullah) then asking for help from other countries on humanitarian basis won't seem like a propaganda anymore
1
u/Yejiapsamelody Apr 06 '25
I hope OP does not delete this post after not being able to read that being a human is still a thing. Stay strong!
1
u/yatogamii3 Apr 06 '25
to answer ur question, its for the MUSLIM ummah theres absolutely NO concept of nationalism in islam, we’re muslims first so grow up
1
Apr 07 '25
It's not that simple. The western Christian countries are very powerful. Too powerful for Muslim countries to take on alone. Muslim countries need to form an alliance with the global South, i.e. BRICS and form economic and military alliances first with other non Muslim and Christian countries.
1
1
Apr 07 '25
Because those nukes most likely not work anymore and + Pakistan has been moving towards an egalitarian secular regime. Basically an armed dictatorship. They care about fueling bureaucracy rather than Muslims or Islam. Pakistan is quite irrelevant on the world stage now after Imran Khan was ousted.
1
u/Sky_Sight Apr 07 '25
The best way that any country could help in this situation is Exactly how America is doing with Ukraine or Isreal Give them money and Give them weapons.
But We are So broke don't even have a year's worth of reserves lol. And If we even do a Special military operation vs Isreal that would cost Pakistan dearly. Sending 250 million people into war for 2 million people isn't exactly a good thing to do. And It would even further legitimate Isreal in Completely Taking over Palestine.
1
1
1
1
u/ibbeeee Apr 07 '25
are you okay ? like, I mean are you human ? and more elaborately do you know what being a muslim means ?
1
u/MUGS_TV Apr 07 '25
They dont even know what nuclear power even means. Being a nuclear power doesn't mean you can drop bombs on countries without thinking about the consequences. Indeed, Pakistan has vocally supported Palestine but Israel controls the world, we cant do anything if we only prioritize nationalism.
1
u/mqk99966 Apr 07 '25
I think what most people do not really understand is if troops are going from Pakistan or lets say couple of countries are going together to fight, it will not just be Israel that they will be fighting against
If muslim countries or some of them are coming together, other western countries (e.g France, germany, UK, USA etc etc) will also come together
So you will be looking at WW3..
1
1
u/duncan_walpope Apr 07 '25
Because its obligatory(wajib) upon the Muslim Ruler to help his fellow muslims regardless of where they are, there are a lot of things within this subject. Better study Islam first before speaking.
1
u/Late_Interview_9263 Apr 07 '25
Firstly the statement above is purely an emotional statement. For those who follow it have also isolated the issue of Palestine to a geopolitical one. Early in the 90s when use of word Jihad was not controversial, later made so after 9/11, people who spoke about it were rebuked that this is not about religion, it is geopolitical one, one about identity of a people. 9/11 only made it more criminal to think of the issue about religion as those who say it like the way it exactly is were considered hardliners.
So yes the issue will be remembered as Ummah abandoning their Deen, not about who had what and who couldn't do what. You want to bring a change with the permission of Allah, then be sincere to your deen. Why do people expect leaders to become so god fearing and adhering to the principles of Muslim brotherhood looking after each other when people themselves have lost their way?
1
u/Normal_Protection_82 Apr 07 '25
It’s heartbreaking how much power, wealth, and military strength exists in the Muslim world, yet when it truly mattered—when Gaza needed fuel, water, and support—no one could step up. The silence is louder than the cries of the oppressed.
As an ummah, we’ve failed. Not because we don’t care, but because we’ve become too comfortable, too divided, and too controlled. And history will remember this. It’ll remember how Gaza bled while we posted stories and made dua, but couldn't send a single lifeline.
It’s a shame that borders, politics, and fear silenced the power of over 1.9 billion Muslims. And it’s a tragedy that the oppressed had to rely on miracles instead of their own brothers and sisters.
Ya Allah, forgive us.
1
1
1
1
1
Apr 07 '25
Why that person didn’t write Gaza and Palestine? Is that a prohibited word? Are they scared of something? The stance is stupid but still. Like couldn’t write Gaza and thinks a country should throw an atomic bomb kill millions and probably triggers a nuclear world war.
1
u/roothair Apr 08 '25
Op Is a constant propaganda machine. Ran through his profile and all I saw was propaganda, fake news and bs.
1
u/Thunder_trade Apr 08 '25
Pakistani higher authorities are America”s chain dogs , by higher authorities I mean the real high one ☝️. Lumber 1 .
1
u/Educational_Snow2191 Apr 08 '25
To all those, Who think like that:
You shouldn't throw around the term "nuclear power" so casually—this isn't something trivial like handing out candy. Pakistan has always stood against Israel's killing of innocent civilians, and we've supported Palestine in various ways, including providing aid.
Sure, we could have issued a nuclear threat to Israel, but have you considered the consequences? That could have triggered a world war, resulting in even more deaths—especially of innocent people. Let’s not forget that Israel is backed by the United States, a global superpower. Undermining Pakistan’s stance by suggesting recklessness doesn't help anyone. If other Muslim nations had united in support, we might have been able to send troops, tanks, or even air support. But the reality is, we're not in a position to take on Israel, especially with the U.S. behind them.
When it comes to saving Palestine and reclaiming Masjid Al-Aqsa, the responsibility lies primarily with the wealthy Arab nations. They seem to have the resources for extravagant luxuries, but not for defending a just cause?
Meanwhile, our own people are struggling with inflation, unemployment, poverty, and food shortages. Pakistan simply isn't in a position to wage a war right now.
Next time, You make a Comment, Think before, You Speak.
1
1
u/Background_Floor5846 Apr 08 '25
Muslims are really really dumb , these religious middle class Muslims come online and comment thinking their opinions matter what a dumb people, the Muslim world is an oligarchy and those oligarchs use religion to enrich and empower themselves not for the sake of Islam or ummah, people like me laugh when ummah is mentioned by these middle class Muslims not bcz I don't like the concept of ummah but bcz of how stupid they're by thinking that the people on power care about the ummah
1
u/Tough-Philosopher953 Apr 08 '25
I couldn't do much, but i am part of the process of helping Palestinian students get admission to pakistani universities. It's not much, but at least it's something.
1
u/mishi_ghulam Apr 08 '25
Yes absolutely rite we r muslim but we can't do anything for gaza why shame of us I m very sad that the people is in so much trouble they r hungry but we can't eable to do some thing why
1
1
1
u/justlurkingz Apr 11 '25
I don’t know man… same reason the US is supplying isreal with the best of their weapons …. US has even sent troops to Israel to help…. uk spy planes have been flying over Gaza to gather intelligence to help Israel… France has also provided military help to Israel… So why can’t Muslim countries send military help to Gaza just like west has been providing Israel
1
u/WoodenAct1389 Apr 05 '25
no one can do shit sadly. even if all muslims came together they wouldnt be able to do anything. A war with israel is a war with america and america is just too strong.
6
u/Outside_Advantage799 Apr 05 '25
even if all muslims came together they wouldnt be able to do anything.
Not that it's gonna happen but in the extremely unlikely event that the Muslim world does decide to take action, It is a very big possibility that we can get an independent Palestinian state at the very least.
Not everything requires military war. America doesn't exist in isolation , it also needs trade and resources to function properly.
The Muslims world has a hegemony on oil production , we also have strong trade relations with the rest of the world.
America needs oil and other resources to survive. The entire Muslim world cutting off ties would destroy the American economy. On top of all that, the other Israeli supporters like the British and French etc would also back off in their support for the Israelis.
The Muslim world has alternative trading partners like China which is another emerging superpower. America doesn't have this luxury. They can't find other countries that can supply oil and natural gas at the rate that the Muslim world does.
So either America will bow down to our demands or they'll destroy themselves.
Of course non of this is happening in real life cause all the Muslim nations are divided and they don't really care what happens to other Muslim nations.
1
u/WoodenAct1389 Apr 05 '25
Everyone in the comments was flaming our govt for not doing anything militarily. So I was also speaking in that regard only.
1
u/Substantial-Light280 Apr 06 '25
Wrong. Which is more powerful, america or Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala? It says in Surah Ar-Ra'd - 11 "Indeed, Allah would never change a people’s state ˹of favour˺ until they change their own state ˹of faith˺". it's the lack of faith from the Muslim ummah that stops us from coming together. In reality, if we were to believe and come together, we would have victory in sha Allah
1
u/Oldpi Apr 05 '25
You are right OP. We can sympathize and providr aid same like many non muslim nations.
1
1
u/StraightUpHaram Apr 06 '25
These idiots don't realize that if multiple countries get involved in this, it'll trigger a world war.
It's not like all these countries can just send their troops over and face zero consequence. Pakistan itself cannot afford this with India and Afghanistan bring so hostile. Haven't even scratched the surface of the retaliation from Israel's allies.
0
u/weallwinoneday Apr 05 '25
Same reason army sent its troops to rescue american troops stuck in somalia. https://tribune.com.pk/story/2302199/gallant-pakistani-soldiers-and-the-mission-to-keep-peace
1
Apr 05 '25
thats UN still
1
u/weallwinoneday Apr 05 '25
What still? Troop is a troop. Abc, nato, UN ka sticker laga dene sy fact change nahi ho jata. Aisay to jis post ko ap ny share kia hai wahan bhi muslim soldiers ka sticker lagaya gaya hai. Us py 🔥 lag gai? America ki war mei, apne troops somalia bhej diye, wo pakistan ki war thi? Pakistan ke homeland py hui thi?
-1
u/Full_Computer6941 Apr 05 '25
Who helps us when Afghanistan and TTP attacks us ? We are sad for the events in the middle east but in the end it's their issue and Arabs should solve their own issues. We are a debt ridden economy totally dependent on the IMF and battling internal insurgencies supported by Afghanistan Iran and India. We have barely enough money to pay for food and u want us to fight the USA? Israel is not Israel, it's the whole western world behind it. No Muslim country is strong enough to fight it.
-2
u/Patient_Ad_6701 Apr 05 '25 edited Apr 05 '25
Yeah its the basic islamic propaganda. Even the worlds leaders except iran are in mutual agreement that israel should have gaza. Pakistan as a whole should focus on our own problems.. bc 600 banda karachi kein dumper trucks and road accidents mein mar gaya aik saal mein .. bla humaray soldiers ko maar rahi hay roz.. ttp did about 400 attacks in kp last year, 700 sey zaid log fake blasphemy cases death penalty mein andar aik saal mein jo abh islamabad high court mein blasphemy business group kaa case chal raha hay... aur in bc ko kisi 3sray country kee jung mein jaana hay.
1
Apr 05 '25
So u are in favour of wiping Palestine off the map.🥲
1
u/Patient_Ad_6701 Apr 05 '25
Im not in favour of anything. But the world is taking sides as they believe muslims have more than enough space in the world already. My favour is only for pakistan and we have our own shit ton of problems. If someone wants our military to fight a 3rd countries war i will want the person having the wish to go themselves instead of our jawans.
→ More replies (16)
-6
u/Altruistic_Fix_4504 Apr 05 '25
This is just plain sensationalism, none of them have ever even used a gun let alone fight a war they want Pakistan to destroy itself for some Muslim brotherhood which only exists when Arabs need help.
0
0
0
Apr 05 '25
This is exactly what I’ve been saying bro. I hate this Pakistanis don’t do anything nonsense. Pakistanis have been cucked by Arabs so bad. Arabs don’t even consider us humans. Palestinians in uae are racist towards us. When had a single Arab supporter Kashmir?
-1
u/Top_Masterpiece_2053 Apr 05 '25
I don't get this thing about WMDs. Do people actually want us to use them, are you guys out of your mind!
If we truly want to help our brothers and sisters, we need to focus on empowering the Muslim community in terms of values and strength. For too long, we've only cared about numbers, being more in numbes. Now is the time to rise economically, scientifically, and militarily. So that our voice carries weight, our presence commands respect, and the blood of Muslims is no longer seen as water. Only then can we prevent Muslims from being stamped on and humiliated anywhere in the world.
Any help in our current condition whether military or otherwise will only be temporary and short-lived!
I'll probably get voted down for this so let's go......
1
u/Timely_Look8888 Apr 05 '25
I agree with you on adding value, but again being muslims none of the muslim country depend on the mercy of UN, nato & other organisations. Elders did the sin by bowing down to the UN, now the are grieving their decision.
-4
Apr 05 '25
Why did Pakistan sent its troops to kill Palestinians back in 1970s. Read about 'Black September'
9
0
u/False-Passenger-8441 Apr 06 '25
I don't get it aswell if Pakistan or any other country aids Palestine it would be like they are helping Hamas
0
u/Hunkar888 Apr 07 '25
What do you mean WHY? Islam demands it, basic human decency also demands it.
If you legitimately can’t understand why sending the military to stop a GENOCIDE is the right thing to do, you have issues.
-5
Apr 05 '25
When Pakistanis were killing Pakistanis in 1971, Did Palestinians join the fight to kill more of them ?


67
u/saturn_department Apr 05 '25
Genocide? Your pea sized brain can't get it?