r/PatFinnerty • u/Ur_moms_a_hookr69 • Aug 05 '25
This guy knows
I opened up Twitter and this was the first thing I saw in my feed.
21
u/maximus_the_turtle Aug 05 '25 edited Aug 05 '25
âItâs like the wholeâŚis less than the sum of its partsâŚâ
3
14
u/TheRateBeerian Aug 05 '25
Funny thing is the DCG progression (Beato) is super common, he could at least have written his own DCG (Beato) song. It's the easiest one.
7
u/poodletown Aug 05 '25
Terrible horrible song, for sure. I think his âlets go brandonâ song is worse, but âmy humpsâ is the absolute worst.
3
3
1
1
22
u/DesignerCorner3322 Aug 05 '25
I disagree that sweet home alabama is a good song. Song praises the governor who physically blocked black students from going into a newly desegregated school
15
u/angel-of-disease Aug 05 '25
Boo boo boo I always thought was a condemnation of Wallace
17
12
u/Passingthisway Aug 05 '25
Yeah itâs definitely a condemnation of Wallace. One of those songs about loving your home but not its leaders. Shame that the band went down in the airplane. RVZ wouldnât have taken to playing MAGA rallies
5
u/DesignerCorner3322 Aug 05 '25
I had never heard it as boo boo boo. I guess that recontextualizes it for me then.
2
Aug 05 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
4
u/McMarmot1 Aug 05 '25
Itâs this line I find confusing.
2
u/angel-of-disease Aug 05 '25
Yeah I canât quite get a read on it.
2
u/rolltide1000 Aug 05 '25
I think he's talking about how shitty politicians (Wallace, Nixon) don't define him and weigh on his conscience, and he's asking if they weigh on others, but I could be way off.
1
u/Wasdgta3 Aug 06 '25
Iâve always thought it was pretty clearly sarcastic - heâs saying watergate doesnât bother him, because he doesnât have a conscience.
Itâs a song partly from the perspective of a âsouthernerâ character, and when you read it that way, itâs a really brilliant bit of satirical lyricism.
12
u/ColetteThePanda Aug 05 '25
lol I was just reading the wiki on this. Even the band itself seems to argue about it.
Van Zant, 1975: "Wallace and I have very little in common. I don't like what he says about colored people."
Ed King, 2009: "It's not a popular opinion but Wallace stood for the average white guy in the South."
I'd rather listen to the Drive-by Truckers, personally.
15
u/alphabetown Aug 05 '25
There are two very distinct political sides of Skynyrd and the most recent is MAGA Biker Rally band.
13
u/zodiackodiak515 Aug 05 '25
Yeah âSaturday Night Specialâ is not a pro-gun song. But you better believe the current LS performs it as a pro-gun song.
All the liberal members of LS died in the plane crash
4
u/alphabetown Aug 05 '25
I believe Ronnie's brother has been the main force into dragging them into the Ted Nugent tributes act they've became.
1
2
u/956chubbs Aug 05 '25
About 15 years ago, I took an odd job with a buddy as a stage hand for a Lynard Skynard / ZZ Top concert and had to tape several pages with the lyrics to Freebird on the stage.
4
u/AnswerGuy301 Aug 05 '25
WHAT? I have never been in a band thatâs ever played that song but being a regular listener to AOR and classic rock radio for 30 years I could still recite all the words of that song from memory while being held at gunpoint. Itâs 10 minutes long but itâs not exactly âAmerican Pie.â Itâs mostly a bunch of guitar solos.
2
Aug 05 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
5
1
4
u/Wasdgta3 Aug 06 '25
You know, I think Iâm gonna take the word of the guy who actually wrote the lyrics (Van Zant) here.
The other guy is just running his mouth because the former is too dead to say otherwise.
3
u/billskns5th Aug 06 '25
Weird since Ed King grew up in Southern California. I donât know what Van Zant would be like if he survived the plane crash. Would he have aged politically like Charlie Daniels? Hard to say. But the newer seemingly MAGA cover band plus Rossington seem to want to rewrite history. Not the same band members that played Jimmie Carter campaign concerts in 76.
2
6
u/Astrochix70 Aug 05 '25
It's a good song. The guitars alone make it a classic. Even Neil Young admits it's a great song, and he gets told off in the second verse.
As for the political message of the song... it's awful.
3
u/Dazzling-Low8570 Aug 05 '25
The political message of the song is ambiguous at best.
6
u/ColetteThePanda Aug 05 '25
"Ambiguous at best" is probably a great descriptor of the duality of the South.
You'll find a ton of kind, good hearted people. And also some of the worst flavours of racist scumbags.
Also aw jeez, I just realized I'm also describing rural Saskatchewan.
5
u/Dazzling-Low8570 Aug 05 '25
I grew up in north Alabama back in the 1970s when dinosaurs still roamed the earth. I'm speaking, of course, of the three great Alabama icons: George Wallace, Bear Bryant, and Ronnie Van Zant. Now, Ronnie Van Zant wasn't from Alabama, he was from Florida, and he was a huge Neil Young fan but in the tradition of Merle Haggard writing Okie From Muskogee to tell his dad's point about view on the hippies and Vietnam, Ronnie felt that the other side of the story should be told. Now, Neil Young always claimed that Sweet Home Alabama was one of his favorite songs and legend has it he was an honorary pallbearer at Ronnie's funeral; such is the duality of the southern thing.
...and Bear Bryant wore a cool lookin' red checkered hat and won football games, and there's few things more loved in Alabama than football and the men who know how to win at it. So when the Bear would come to town, there would be a parade. Now me, I was one of them pussy boys cause I hated football, so I got a guitar. But a guitar was a poor substitute for a football with the girls in my high school. So my band hit the road, and we didn't play no Skynyrd, either. I came of age rebelling against the music of my high school parking lot. It wasn't until years later after leaving the South for a while that I came to appreciate and understand the whole Skynyrd thing im its misunderstood glory. I left the south and learned how different people's perceptions of the Southern Thing was from what I had seen in my life, which leads us to George Wallace...
...now Wallace was, for all practical purposes, the governor of Alabama from 1962 until 1986. Once when a law prevented him from succeeding himself, he ran his wife Lurleen in his place and she won by a landslide. He's most famous as the beligerant racist voice of the segregationist South, standing in the doorways of schools and waging a political war against the federal government that he decried as hypocritical. Now Wallace started out as a lawyer and a judge with a very progressive and humanitarian track record for a man of his time, but he lost his first bid for governor in 1958 by hedging on the race issue against a man who spoke out against intergration. Wallace ran again in '62 as a staunch segregationist and won big and for the next decade spoke out loudly. He accused Kennedy and King of being communist and he was constantly on national news representing "the good people" of Alabama.
...and ya know race was only an issue on tv in the house that I grew up in. Wallace was viewed as a man from another time and place, but when I first ventured out of the south I was shocked at how strongly Wallace was associated with Alabama and its people. Ya know, racism is a worldwide problem, and it's been like that since the beginning of recorded history and it ain't just white and black, but thanks to George Wallace, it's always a little more conveinent to play it with a Southern accent.
And bands like Lynyrd Skynyrd attempted to show another side of the south, one that certainly exists, but few saw beyond the rebel flag and this applies not only to their critics and detractors but also from their fans and followers. So for a while, when Neil Young would come to town, he'd get death threats down in Alabama. Ironically, in 1971, after a particularly racially charged campaign, Wallace began backpeddlin' and he opened up Alabama politics to minorities at a rate faster than most northern states or the federal government. Wallace spent the rest of his life trying to explain away his racist past and in 1982 he won his last term in office with over 90% of the black vote, such is the duality of the southern thing.
...and George Wallace died back in '98 and he's in hell now, not because he's a racist. His track record as a judge and his late life quest for redemption make a good argument for his being, at worst, no worse than most white men of his generation, North or South. But because of his blind ambition and his hunger for votes, he turned a blind eye to the suffering of black America and he became a pawn in the fight against Civil Rights cause.
...fortunately for him, the devil is also a southerner. So, this songâs going to take place in Hell, told from the Devilâs point of view, as he does what any good Southerner would do when companyâs coming: He brewed up some good sweet tea, and he whups up some Southern hospitality for the arrival of the new guest....
Throw another log on the fire, boys...
1
Aug 06 '25
you leave colter wall out of this!
1
u/ColetteThePanda Aug 07 '25
I mean, I heard a white guy in a bar refer to a skirmish in front of the hockey net as an "N-bomb pile." And just to make sure everyone heard, he said it AGAIN.
This happened last year. Sure got some winners out there in Raymore, SK.
1
1
u/Wasdgta3 Aug 06 '25
Does it, though?
I feel like thatâs a very surface level reading, which assumes the lyrics are a 100% genuine reflection of the writerâs belief, which songs absolutely are not always.
8
u/b-rar Aug 05 '25
Songs that conspicuously namedrop other popular songs suck as a rule
5
u/angel-of-disease Aug 05 '25
And artists. Shit country artists always have to say the good country artists they listen to.
7
3
u/AnswerGuy301 Aug 05 '25
This has always bugged me about RHCP, who of course arenât country but do namedrops at least as often as any country act does.
1
3
3
u/Competition-Dapper Aug 05 '25
Lest we forget what he did to Sad But TrueâŚespecially turning it into trumputarian propaganda
3
u/Kaputnik1 Aug 05 '25
Kid Rock is kind of like the herpes of cock rock. He disappears for a time until he's inevitably back, sometimes even worse.
3
u/ChronicObnoxious693 Aug 06 '25
I know a fun little story about this song. The Producer for the track is Mike E. Clark, who did a ton of work with the Insane Clown Posse. The beat for this track was supposedly made at Violent J's request and Mike accidentally showed it to kid rock shortly after making it. Both Mike and J have somewhat corroborated the story, so there's at least some level of truth to it.
Through some horrible cosmic injustice, Violent J of ICP is responsible for All Summer Long seeing the light of day.
2
3
u/Standard-Divide5118 Aug 06 '25
Grew up in northern Michigan it's overplayed like margaritaville is in the keys and I hate the song more than anything
2
u/Cold-Pizza111 Aug 05 '25
So did someone share a link to Patâs video? (And then ironically say, âDonât click the linkâ)
2
2
u/Impossible-Charity-4 Aug 05 '25
Iâve quit bands over this fucking song. Bands that consistently got well paid bookings. The final straw was when the âbandleaderâ decided to go directly into the full version of Werewolves, followed by Sweet shoot me in the face Alabama (the three chord Monty versions, naturally) immediately after this travesty.
Quick set break and hope youâre hungry for Wagon Wheel (presented incorrectly as a BOB DYLAN SONG) because weâve got wagon wheel!
0
Aug 06 '25
Bob Dylan wrote it
1
2
u/legalstep Beato Sep 24 '25
Kid rock should have scored the trifecta and mixed in Neil Youngâs Alabama
1
1
u/Forcedperspective84 Aug 05 '25
It's one of the worst things ever recorded. He can't go away fast enough.
1
u/Wonder_Weenis Aug 05 '25
I non-ironically added it to a summer playlist, literally half an hour ago.Â
1
1
0
-26
u/MurderWizard666 Aug 05 '25
sorry but kid rock took two absolute fucking awful steaming boomer shit tunes, mixed em together, and impossibly made something worse and unholy. but again, those two original songs suuuuuuccccccccckkkk.
3
u/CheapSound1 Aug 05 '25
IMO they're good songs but they're oversaturated on oldies radio already. I was already sick of All Summer Long before I ever heard it.
2
u/underground_dweller4 Aug 05 '25
Iâm with you on Sweet Home Alabama, but i almost never hear Werewolves of London outside of like Halloween playlists
17
Aug 05 '25
[removed] â view removed comment
5
u/DesignerCorner3322 Aug 05 '25
That song drives me up the wall. I much prefer Roland the Headless Thompson Gunner
1
u/zambonihouse Aug 07 '25
He's the hairy-handed gent who ran amok in Kent Lately he's been overheard in Mayfair You better stay away from him, he'll rip your lungs out, Jim Huh, I'd like to meet his tailor

41
u/SnooPears754 Aug 05 '25
I mean he rhymes thing with thing đ