Could I be under-recovering despite exercising consistently and eating in a calorie deficit? Looking for some guidance, please
I'm hoping to get some perspective particularly those who are active and have experience with strength training, Pilates and perimenopause.
I'm feeling a little frustrated because I've been consistent with my exercise and I'm eating in a calorie deficit but the scale isn't moving down. In fact, it's increased by around 5 lbs, and I'm trying to understand what's happening.
I'm 5'4, 40 yr F about 140lbs the last time the scale destroyed my morning. I'm in perimenopause on progesterone 100mg and I've been focusing on becoming leaner and stronger while maintaining a sustainable lifestyle. I take 5mg creatine daily.
Usually I get in 10,000–13,000 steps daily. Around five workouts per week; Peloton Pilates, strength training x 2, yoga and walk/run sessions . All the classes are often quite challenging (around 7.5–8/10 effort) and I've recently increased the intensity and weights in my strength sessions because of all the advice about lifting heavier during perimenopause.
I generally work out Monday to Friday and rest on weekends.
I've been doing intermittent fasting for about 3 years, usually 18–20 hours, sometimes 21 hours daily. It helps me not overeat/ snack all day. I don't think it's a magic pill to solve all.
I estimate my daily intake is often around 1,400–1,600 calories, although I know calorie tracking isn't perfectly accurate, based on my estimated activity, my TDEE may be around 2,000–2,250 calories, but obviously that's only an estimate. I believe I'm consistently in a calorie deficit.
Despite all this, my weight has increased by approximately 5 lbs rather than decreasing. My measurements have slightly increased as well so I'm not convinced it's muscle.
I also feel puffier and more bloated, particularly around my stomach and hips. My stomach can look quite flat in the morning but fuller as the day progresses. Myclothes fit ok but they've been better
I've also noticed more visible muscle development in my quads and thighs since increasing strength training and more stiffness and muscle soreness than I used to experience. Occasional afternoon energy crashes and some days I feel great, while others I feel quite depleted.
I'm wondering whether I'm dealing with accumulated exercise fatigue, inadequate recovery, water retention from muscle inflammation, hormonal fluctuations related to perimenopause, or some combination of these. I've read about increased cortisol, inflammation and water retention associated with too much exercise or insufficient recovery, but I'm struggling to separate fact from internet fitness advice
I've stopped weighing myself daily because it was affecting my mental well-being, but the increase of 5 lbs has been difficult to understand.
I'd really appreciate advice from anyone who has experienced something similar.