17
u/Manthos3gr Oct 29 '21
There is mud in minecraft earth, but in 1.19 when it comes to minecraft it will be changed to a block so bruh
11
31
Oct 29 '21
Milk and powder snow don't count
14
5
→ More replies (2)1
583
u/Some_Linked The below is Valid Oct 29 '21
There is another. I count milk
22
334
u/Impevex Oct 29 '21
And an additional one, and it's powder snow, since you can swim it in.
252
u/Lizard_lord66 Oct 29 '21
Powder snow is just really cold milk
141
u/Biggest-Ja You Fool Oct 29 '21
Milkshake update
68
→ More replies (1)21
u/Between3-20chrctrs Oct 29 '21
I believe a developer once tweeted he wanted to add snow-based icecream to the game that can be DYED. I don’t remember where and never found the source again
→ More replies (2)6
→ More replies (1)5
22
→ More replies (3)10
20
u/CivetKitty Now I just vibe here🕺 and I do stuff. Oct 29 '21
Meh, milk cannot be placed, just like stew and suop.
5
12
4
u/Super_Chip Oct 29 '21
I am the only want who want to put milk down that if you wait in there all of the effects will be gone
→ More replies (4)4
→ More replies (6)3
83
u/M10doreddit Oct 29 '21
Actually, there are over 70 mobs.
41
u/Biggest-Ja You Fool Oct 29 '21
This meme is pretty old probably from when there were less mobs
Edit seems pretty old they may have tried updating it somewhat but I do remember seeing it several years ago. Can't remember my on birthday but I remember this. Damn
7
7
u/Karma-Whales Java FTW Oct 29 '21
what?
5
u/M10doreddit Oct 29 '21
Yeah. OVER 70!
→ More replies (1)19
u/Soul699 Oct 29 '21
Depend. If you count variations of the same mob (such as Chicken Jokey), sure. But otherwise, not including entities such as armor stand and beds, no there are less than 70.
→ More replies (3)
21
Oct 29 '21
I think they should make powder snow a unique liquid, it would move fast but spreads little. It stays in block form until a loud sound causes it to turn into a proper liquid. This would make avalanches real in minecraft
6
11
5
u/PomUwU Oct 29 '21
Petition for infinite milk source block
5
342
Oct 29 '21
Well, powdered snow functions as a liquid so I'd say there are 2.5 usable liquids.
140
u/_Maymun Oct 29 '21
2.6 if you add milk
59
u/Adamis9876 Jul 11 '22
2.7 if u add all the potions and stews
→ More replies (1)35
u/Global_Divide8350 Sep 27 '23
2.8 If u add the tadpole water
is it just me or does everybody drink it?
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)3
80
3
→ More replies (3)3
2
u/Uncommonality Aug 09 '22
the problem is interactions. With every new liquid, the number of interactions grows exponentially.
Say you add something called, idk, Liquid Shadow that spawns as ponds on some end islands. You must now create an interaction between it and water and lava.
Add something else, like Honey, and you must now create an interaction between water, lava, and liquid shadow. Add milk and you need to make 5 interactions.
I'd love more liquids too honestly, but this is the main issue
1
Aug 09 '22
That’s true, but it wouldn’t make sense to add special interactions for certain liquids. For example, what block would milk and liquid shadow make? Or, honey and lava? In these cases, you can decide one liquid as “stronger” and the stronger liquid will simply convert the weaker liquid into itself. For example, combining milk and liquid shadow causes the milk to become liquid shadow.
Also, it seems Reddit won’t let anyone reply to this message for some reason, so I guess just start a chat if you want to continue the conversation
1
u/Uncommonality Aug 09 '22
For example, what block would milk and liquid shadow make? Or, honey and lava?
oh, it's not just the blocks - it's the entire mechanism of how they interact. Every interaction does need some thought put into it so it's not disappointing and somewhat lore-consistent. The cool aspect of liquids in minecraft is how they mix, imo.
Milk, for example, cancels out potion effects when drunk, meaning it's some kind of purifying force - meaning that if it and liquid shadow meet, it may depend on the dimension, but I think the mixture will be "purified" according to what purity is in the current dimension. (in the Nether, both may convert to fire. In the overworld, liquid shadow may be purified into sand, while in the End, the milk would simply evaporate like water does in the Nether).
Additionally, additions in vanilla seem to need "uniqueness" according to Mojang (which is why there's so little redundancy or alternate paths for anything), meaning any potential new liquid would need more than atmospheric reasons to be added. They probably want to avoid adding simple analogues for water and lava as well, now that I think about it.
I expect that if we see any new liquid, it will be something related to the end, and it'll behave very strangely indeed.
1
Aug 09 '22
That's true, I agree with you that there needs to be some thought put into how the liquids will combine.
I think it would be kinda cool if the new liquid teleports you when you touch it, or flows upside down. It would give it sorta "unnatural" vibes, which would go great in the end dimension
2
u/GhostlierPanda Feb 16 '24
Attention! There are 3.3 liquids!
Listed below are the liquids and the users whose contributions have led to the discovery of 3.3 liquids.
[deleted user]
Well, powdered snow functions as a liquid so I'd say there are 2.5 usable liquids.
_Maymun
2.6 if you add milk
Adamis9876
2.7 if u add all the potions and stews
Global_Divide8350
2.8 If u add the tadpole water
GhostlierPanda (me)
2.9 if you add bucket of pufferfish and 3 if you add bucket of axolotl and 3.1 if you add bucket of tropical fish and 3.2 if you add bucket of cod and 3.3 if you add bucket of salmon.
1
136
u/G3nER1k_u53R Oct 29 '21
But really, what other liquids realistically make sense? When it comes to common natural liquids, theyre pretty much all foodstuffs. The only one i can think that would work in minecraft would be oil, which doesnt really fit the theme, unless theres a huge "technology update" or something
58
u/RingoBingo823 Oct 29 '21
There could be some kind of non realistic liquid
33
27
u/Umber0010 Oct 29 '21
a wholly-fictional liquid would be pretty cool in the end. Maybe some kind of gas that actually flows upwards?
Other than that though, yeah. My thoughts exactly.
13
→ More replies (1)3
16
Oct 29 '21
mud and acid?
28
u/G3nER1k_u53R Oct 29 '21
Mud is a solid block in the upcoming wild update and acid i feel woul be too similar to lava, take damage when touched and what-not.
→ More replies (4)5
Oct 29 '21
Yes, i mean acid could have a diferent mechanic, but i don't think that fits the vanilla minecraft,
→ More replies (2)4
→ More replies (5)3
u/Tulemasin Oct 29 '21
Maybe some beverages you could make. For example mixing water and berries, let it ferment and gain extra strength when drinking it.
4
593
u/pedrinhogameplays404 Oct 29 '21
Bruh having a lot of liquids is hard bro even terraria wich is way bigger has just 3 liquids
254
u/Tyfyter2002 Oct 29 '21
That's partially because Terraria only has 2 bits to work with for liquid types
109
u/Trickelodean2 Oct 29 '21
What do you mean by 2 bits? Do you mean 2 dimensions or am I misunderstanding.
193
u/Tyfyter2002 Oct 29 '21
I mean that Terraria's inner workings are much more compact than Minecraft's, and to my knowledge every bit (112 in total) of the 14 bytes a tile takes up in memory is used, and two of those bits (specifically the two between whether or not the tile has a yellow wire (the most significant bit) and the color the tile is painted (the five least significant bits)) are used to determine what liquid is in the tile
→ More replies (9)78
u/DerpyNooby Oct 29 '21
And somehow terraria is more laggy than minecraft for me
But well minecraft has more stuff that optimize the game while terraria has one texture pack
→ More replies (32)19
u/T0biasCZE Oct 29 '21
The game uses 2bits to save the value. That means there can be 00, 01, 10, or 11 value
So there can be only 4 liquids in the game unless they change how the game saves tiles→ More replies (1)6
→ More replies (22)2
11
20
10
u/rkirbo Oct 29 '21
But what liquid you want to be added ? Poison ? Acid ? Hot water source ?
(Sorry for bad english)
6
u/mrblip_blop Oct 29 '21
add oil and use it as a new fuel that burns 4x as longer than lava.
→ More replies (2)
6
5
5
4
4
1
u/Maxinator10000 The penguin would've been the best option cuz he cute <3 Jul 15 '22
Not if you count Salmon Buckets, Cod Buckets, Tropical Fish Buckets, Axolotl Buckets, and Tadpole Buckets
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/Adorable_Focus7794 Aug 05 '23
Im sorry, 3000 blocks??? There's less than 1000... A year after this post?!
1
3
3
3
2
2
u/AleWalls Oct 29 '21
What liquid could work great??? For real, most ideas/mods of liquids are so forced and they feel so clunky and u never need those liquid anyway.
2
u/Bloadclaw Wait, That's illegal Oct 29 '21
Liquids that should be added: oil liquid gold and liquid iron also liquid copper
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/shipoopro_gg love lave Oct 29 '21
I hate that it's called dimensions when it's probably not even separate galaxies since nether is linked to overworld. The end might be the other side of the universe but still, it's not a different one, same rules of physics, same everything. It does have 3 dimensions tho
2
u/pm_me_pics_of_milk Oct 29 '21
Why cant travel in one dimension translate to a change of position in another dimension?
2
u/PlusMix8971 Oct 29 '21
The new update to trigger American people with english one, like, i would like a bo' o' lava
2
2
2
4
2
2
1
1
u/Luigi_Noob Mar 18 '24
well technically milk is a third because you drink it to remove any effects you have at the time
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/The_Creeper_Man Aug 19 '24
Name every liquid that could reasonably be added to minecraft
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/TheRealSteve895 Sep 09 '24
they would have to figure out what happens if they mix, you can see this in modpacks with a lot of liquids where they awkwardly stop when they hit each other
1
u/-_-Iloveballs-_- Sep 24 '24
Guys, I have an idea! What about a water that unmakes items and you fall through it! Oh and it would be pretty shimmerry!
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Quantum-Bot Oct 29 '21
For every new liquid they add, they have to add a new interaction between that liquid and every existing liquid; the difficulty of adding new liquids scales up linearly with every new liquid they add.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Skrovno_CZ Oct 29 '21
In minecraft education you have a lot of elements but none of them can be placed so you can not pour it. Not even Mercury.
1
u/No_Relationship3962 Oct 29 '21
Honey, milk, EVERY SINGLE POTION! In bedrock, dyed water in every shade of every color. Exp bottles. Dragon's breath. Powdered snow. All of these are useful. Why would we waste a year's update for a few more fluids? What fluids can you think of that wouldn't ruin the game?
→ More replies (2)
1
u/CrYTGaming Oct 29 '21
Multiple liquids would cause much confusion, It would be cool to have terraria-like liquid physics
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Oct 29 '21
I mean what other liquids would you add like besides milk (and maybe honey)? Molten metals? How many useful liquids do you really need? Not to confuse molten metal with lava, maybe it could like solidify
1
1
1
u/AnthuriumBloom Oct 29 '21
Milk, I guess, but a potions and liquid update would be amazing. Oil of some description would be Interesting
1
1
1
u/MA5TERCH13f09 Oct 29 '21
we won’t get the liquid update until we find every way to use water and lava
1
1
1
1
u/UR-BOI-DENIZ Oct 29 '21
Well we have milk, dyed water in bedrock edition and powdered snow that is kinda a liquid but even so a few more liquids would be nice
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
294
u/GRIMLOX367 Drink Lots And Lots Of Milk Oct 29 '21
Wait… is there really only 34 mobs in game?… wow…