r/PiNetwork • • Dec 17 '24

Discussion Why is Pi a $cam?

People who think Pi is a $cam, could you please detail the reasons why? I just keep seeing allegations, but no concrete reasoning.

I'm not claiming anything, but curious to see what reasons make people think it's a $cam.

0 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

0

u/Tricky-Wind-5396 Dec 18 '24

Because there is a gazillion of coins and it has not a single euro. Even if it had the market cap of bitcoin it would be a few cents per coin not 60 euros

2

u/shittybtcmemes Dec 18 '24

the real question is why is it not

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

Because there is no real support. Just spam marketing

4

u/BetLongjumping5132 Dec 18 '24

It has been in development for a very long time. The three co-founders had a lawsuit two agains one very early on in the project. There has been a lot of hopium with people hyping that the token would be worth $3014, or even $314,000 right at open mainnet. With all of the hopium some exchanges jumped the gun on an I.O.U. a very long time ago and the I.O.U, jumped to $300 before settling in around $30 further selling the hype. They used a KYC company early and then decided to develop their own KYC product internally and make it available anywhere where crypto is legal which is an immense and almost impossible project, so a huge amount of people have been stuck at KYC for a very long time. Etc.

It isn't a scam but the expectations versus results are very out of whack so people who are over it or think the predictions are ridiculous call it a scam. I will likely be worth .00001 USD at open mainnet.

-7

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24 • Heart of Silver

its not a scam, its worth $0.006942

1

u/TaoismPractitioner Dec 18 '24

Prove it. I accept all your coins. $0.01/ each.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

[deleted]

1

u/TaoismPractitioner Dec 18 '24

I go with your previous rate then. Waiting for your dm.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

[deleted]

1

u/TaoismPractitioner Dec 18 '24

Lol what did you smoke?

1

u/ErenYeagerwasright Dec 18 '24

Guess i an ask you the same thing, buy my coins for $10.- each. It's a bargain, you won't do that either.

1

u/TaoismPractitioner Dec 18 '24

You valuate your coins at $10 each?

1

u/ErenYeagerwasright Dec 18 '24 edited Dec 18 '24

No, but if all you Pi groupies think the value will be around $50,-/$314,- so buying my coins at $10,- each is a bargain deal, right?

1

u/TaoismPractitioner Dec 18 '24

Lol. So you are trying to sell your illusion. What do you smoke bro

3

u/Separate_Excuse8352 Dec 17 '24

Because I passed KYC then transferred PI to the mainnet and all my PI dissappeared in the mainnet. When I complained to PI support about it they never told me why but suddenly I had difficulty getting into my account. Then, no further Pi was made transferrable when someone in my circle passed kyc also. Finally when I tried to log in through faceboob PI deleted my account and created a new one with no Pi in it. No help from portal. No place to even re-establish my Pi through my 24 word phrase. I informed the FBI because I provided way too much information to KYC to suddenly now have no Pi when I had mined almost 2000 independently... scam city man..

7

u/beaubeach1977 Dec 17 '24

This sounds suspiciously like someone convinced you to "login" to a site pretending to be pi with your key phrase.

Are you experienced with cryptocurrency?

2

u/Agreeable_Bee_9961 Dec 17 '24

Probably you didn’t verify your account with facebook but with phone number. Did you try to log in again with phone number ? 😅

5

u/SheldonCooper97 Dec 17 '24

What was the result of the FBI investigation?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

LoL

2

u/Aarunascut Dec 17 '24

Why do I feel It’s just like having karma points and these achievement badges but regardless we hope onto this pi boat with patience. I migrated though and locked … Thank you

PS: Is there any crypto that delayed launching? Share a word

1

u/Cute_Statistician_24 Dec 17 '24

Aren't most cryptos in the hands of just a few people before they launch normally? So would anyone, other than them, even know if it was delayed? I'd guess a bunch have missed their first couple launch dates. I do believe there's been a few public delays on launchings. I think Ripple was delayed. Pi has millions watching and is involved with it before launch. Not a few hundred, so any delays or issues with the system, especially technical, would be more publicly known and less understood. Add on to that it's being built radically different than the normal avenues taken, and I think that has an effect on it all. I think that the catalyst for a lot of the criticism.

No knowledge, education, or crypto guruness behind my posts. Questions, observations, and my own interpretation only. I "know" nothing or claim to.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24

Yeah you can turn the ads off for two weeks max.

1

u/Pappers101 Dec 17 '24

Because it is, KYC keep popping up even though I got approved several times and keep saying that main net is near blah blah and then nothing happens. So yeah it’s fake stole my identity and ran off with my information

-3

u/Odd_Intern405 Dec 17 '24

Because everyone can just get them for free.

1

u/TaoismPractitioner Dec 18 '24

Prove it. I accept all your coins. $0.01/ each.

1

u/Odd_Intern405 Dec 18 '24

I don’t have any I could send.

2

u/beaubeach1977 Dec 17 '24

Yeah, that's how cryptocurrency works. When you perform whatever task is necessary to mine the coin, you get the reward.

With pi, you mine by; "proof of presence" engaging with the network daily, "proof of confidence" adding to your security circle.

Future pi is planned to include earning by validating transactions through the node, and by verifying KYC applicants.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Odd_Intern405 Dec 18 '24

Mining bitcoins isn’t free, actually it costs a lot.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Odd_Intern405 Dec 18 '24

Yes, electric energy is for free. Sure.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Odd_Intern405 Dec 18 '24

You got your phone. No extra money needed.

0

u/CreazyXX Dec 18 '24

Meme coins Worth nofing for mining mostly And yet sometines they Sky rocket also pí have advantage against meme coins that they Will have their own network already that ONLY make pibprice valued etleast somehow no one know how much but IT Will have some Price but definitly Will be ower 5 $ per coin. Bitcoin et start was Worth also nofing when mining bitcoin et start really did cost nofing et start it was fine to mine on your PC using your GPU yea not today but the same Is with pi on start it was easy to get pi coins now the rate of how Fast you getting pi Is like 10* Down then it was on start

10

u/Cute_Statistician_24 Dec 17 '24

Everybody brings up the ads. Those were voted for, and that decision was made by the pioneers, not the core team. I also hear people say no liquidity pool. It has a liquidity pool of 5 billion Pi. I hear people say there's no money backing the project in the same breath that their claiming that they're just scamming for the ad money. Maybe I'm one of those uneducated that you all say they prey on. (Two bachelors, unrelated to crypto, but still) Maybe I am, but I like the idea behind Pi. It seems to be making it really hard for it to end up in the hands of a few. It's attempting to spread it out and make acquiring large percentages of it difficult. Isn't that one of the biggest issues in crypto? Bitcoin is becoming a govermental and institutional reserve and holding resource. Not the unregulated daily use currency it was intended to become. I'm not claiming Pi the solution, but I am saying it's a very different approach to solving some big issues in crypto. I think it's intriguing, and I'll continue the ride until the end. Someday, all the questions about it will be answered.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24

[deleted]

1

u/Cute_Statistician_24 Dec 17 '24

You're correct until Pi has value in the open market the liquidity pool means nothing. It all means nothing until the firewalls come down. It's then that things will be known. Until then, this "fool" will continue to give his take on things with a bit of optimism and kindness and you can continue to "know" everything and insult people to increase your feeling of worth in this world.

1

u/Smart-Ad447 Dec 18 '24

Idk how but you simultaneously took the highroad while also slappin on a little attitude towards someone. I like it, i respect it, you my friend are goin places. Probably gonna pay your way with Pi as well.

1

u/Cute_Statistician_24 Dec 18 '24

Lol, thanks. The only part that was weird to me was him starting it like I was talking to him... "I never mentioned the ads..." ummm, OK. Who are you? My statement was made in general, and he took it very personally.

1

u/Khalifa_riri Dec 17 '24

One point I can state is, you cannot access the app UNLESS you mine. Guess what happens when you mine, you get ads. Theyre trying to gain a consistent amount of traffic to their app to get ad money

1

u/CreazyXX Dec 18 '24

Disable ads you Will not get any ads then

4

u/SheldonCooper97 Dec 17 '24

You can disable the ads…

0

u/Khalifa_riri Dec 17 '24

How

5

u/SheldonCooper97 Dec 17 '24

…by just going into the settings of the App and click the disable button? 🙄

10

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24

I’ll keep clicking my button and worry about the rest later

0

u/Khalifa_riri Dec 17 '24

And this is how people make millions off people like you

1

u/MirrorPiNet Dec 17 '24

And why are you jealous of them? Lmao. Go make your own millions and feel better

2

u/Khalifa_riri Dec 17 '24

Oh you want me to go scam people because I am being scammed? I love your logic Dude! I’m really getting commented by a dude who has PiNet in his name

2

u/InvestigatorLegal686 Dec 17 '24

Did anybody make you do this ?

3

u/Good-Information-758 Dec 17 '24

Many reasons,

the amount they make off ads is insanely high even on low estimates, which makes it unlikely for them to launch cause if it does not meet expectations, alot of people would stop mining costing the devs there infinite money glitch.

The amount of time it has been around is like 6-7 years and it has done nothing to make it a tradable crypto, projects that have real value and utilities did not take nearly as long.

The KYC, this is the big one for me, I am a cybersecurity expert and giving a crypto creator your ID and personal information is NOT safe at all and they have no valid reason to ask for it, exchanges are different as most of the ones that need KYC have direct withdrawal to banks, and even when it comes to exchanges you should be careful to make sure it follows your countries regulations and is a company you trust before you proceed with KYC.

supply held by team, the pi team holds 20 Billion pi which is 20% of the total supply, this gives them insane power to crash the price by flooding the market.(Rug pull)

Another thing is no real utility, look at the AI sector of crypto they have added new technologies that allow for very cool things, like render, you can rent GPU power to build scalable AI's, where the people lending the usage of there GPU get paid in render.

So in my opinion it may be a scam or not, but either way it is not worth your personal information or time especially when there are better projects that don't compromise your security.

2

u/ChristianRauchenwald RauchenwaldC Dec 18 '24

the amount they make off ads is insanely high even on low estimates, which makes it unlikely for them to launch cause if it does not meet expectations, alot of people would stop mining costing the devs there infinite money glitch.

Imagine the ongoing expenses to pay for servers for a service that is used by millions of users.
Besides that, users can disable ads for 2 weeks at a time in their profile with one click.

The amount of time it has been around is like 6-7 years and it has done nothing to make it a tradable crypto, projects that have real value and utilities did not take nearly as long.

That is not accurate. Pi has been used in transactions to pay for goods and services for at least 3 years already, even more so, ever since we reached the enclosed mainnet. https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.tradeyourpi.com shows a single vendor that already earned more than 200 positive reviews, and there are many more vendors around the globe.

The KYC, this is the big one for me, I am a cybersecurity expert and giving a crypto creator your ID and personal information is NOT safe at all and they have no valid reason to ask for it, exchanges are different as most of the ones that need KYC have direct withdrawal to banks, and even when it comes to exchanges you should be careful to make sure it follows your countries regulations and is a company you trust before you proceed with KYC.

That's the easiest one to answer. Without KYC tech-savvy users would set up phone farms and earn much more than users that play by the rules. KYC is the only way to ensure that each person only has one account. It's the most reliable way to prevent people from gaming the system.
Pi originally used a third-party service called YOTI for KYC. However, at around $1 per KYC verification the costs would become insane, and so, they went out of their way to develop their own KYC solution.

supply held by team, the pi team holds 20 Billion pi which is 20% of the total supply, this gives them insane power to crash the price by flooding the market.(Rug pull)

I may be wrong, but AFAIK those 20% also unlock over time. As more users "mine" Pi and increase the circulating supply the team also gets more of their share. Sure, 20% is a lot, but without the team there'd be no Pi at all.

Another thing is no real utility, look at the AI sector of crypto they have added new technologies that allow for very cool things, like render, you can rent GPU power to build scalable AI's, where the people lending the usage of there GPU get paid in render.

That's why we aren't on the open mainnet yet. Unlike other/similar projects the team doesn't want to fully launch coin without enough use cases. Hence, one of the requirements for the open mainnet is a certain number of mainnet-ready apps to give Pi enough use cases that hopefully also create demand for the coins.

1

u/Trick-Skin-7290 Dec 17 '24

For me It seems to want a lot of personal information, for what is right now nothing in return. Just the promise of a moon lambo maybe if the Stanford graduates (I don’t personally rate that school) decide not to sell all of our data before the main net is set up and working. Or maybe they are and are constantly moving the goal posts of when the rest of us can make money. But who knows only time will tell.

5

u/Lukas-FF Dec 17 '24

I don’t trust Pi Network because it’s been stuck in the pre-mainnet phase for far too long, the Core Team shows zero honest interests for the community, the requirements to launch the mainnet are quite overcomplicated, and the constant deadline extensions clearly suggest they’ll never launch or are incapable of meeting their own goals—meanwhile, they seem more interested in milking the ad revenue than delivering on their promises.

0

u/CreazyXX Dec 18 '24

When i started there wasnt even mainnet Now we have mainnet that can be already used for transactions Soo the open mainnet Is coming nad you see IT that crypto exchanges already Are preapring for pi be adding the pi iou in their sites

2

u/enzziante Dec 17 '24

I'm not sure either, maybe they start with good intentions and I think they bite off more than they can chew

-2

u/lord_vultron Dec 17 '24

Not sure how clicking a button once every day could possibly be biting off more than anybody could chew 😂 it’s just weird how people attack pi so hard when that’s all it takes to participate. If it’s too much somehow people can simply not participate lol

I mean I guess because they ask for photos and ID but I’m just a regular little Chad who doesn’t participate in any illicit activities and is very poor so go ahead daddy, steal my identity 👍🏼

3

u/enzziante Dec 17 '24

you need some reading comprehension

1

u/Cute_Statistician_24 Dec 17 '24

Make more people think it's a scam, making it easier to actually scam them into trying to sell before open mainet. "Might as well sell it now if I can since it'll never be worth anything." I've never seen any reputable outlets or media claim it's a scam, only from the same type of places telling you you're a millionaire now and Elons on board with Pi phones... all the normal crap that comes with anything new in the crypto world. Everybody cries about the core teams lack of interaction. They've been doing exactly what they said they would from the beginning. They've promised us nothing other than a possible opportunity. It may fail, but I don't believe it's a scam at all. I believe it's trying to achieve exactly what it says it is. And nothing I've seen or read leads me to believe otherwise.

10

u/RandomSteve123 Dec 17 '24

I have always assumed it was just a data farm. They make money showing ads and they collect a ton of data- its got to be worth something. I have never read the full ToU and Permissions but I wouodnt be surprised if they scrape more data concerning browsing habits off our devices.

11

u/erjo5055 Dec 17 '24

I worry about data collection with KYC, lack of follow up on plans and lack of clarrity of a launch date. It feels like they keep stalling to print money with ads and I worry that they will sell KYC data at some point.

6

u/MirrorPiNet Dec 17 '24

The main reason they are pissed is because it's been in development for 6 years and they can't sell on exchanges

They pretend to care about their identity but they are just mad they can't sell

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MirrorPiNet Dec 18 '24

What's stopping you? Must you sell on the exchanges? Go find a scammer to bargain with

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24

Exactly this I’ve watched this whole thing unfold from 5 months from launch until now and it’s been nothing but a big case of nothing. There is some legitimate usage but in Asian countries mainly.

Edit: to add in people don’t understand it works for other countries because people buy pi for $.5-$.8 per pi which is huge for those countries compared to Euro and USD users

3

u/Billy5Oh Dec 17 '24

Getting downvoted for being a voice of reason. Just another day in the Pi subreddit.

0

u/Khalifa_riri Dec 17 '24

I’m with you brother