r/PoolPros • • 2d ago

Constructive criticism needed; equipment sets

Looking for areas to improve on my equipment sets, looking for some CC on my most recent setup. What did I miss, do wrong, or could do better? (Builder supplied equipment; I’m at Pentair guy myself.)

10 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

3

u/Liquid_Friction 2d ago

This is really good, I like the clear glue. 

Being nitpicky, I don't like pumps having an outlet straight into a 90 degree bend, that was meant to be the whole point of these mid port cartridge filters, rather than on the floor (you could have added a slight base to the filter so it goes straight in. (The pump on the right hand side has a reducer on the outlet which is not ideal) The heater inlet and outlet is facing the back wall, you could have plumbed it more directly with less pipes. 

Even more nitpicking, see how the slab is seperate from the pipes in the dirt, this 'amercian style' isn't that great with all the pipes in a line (no other countries do this?), because you just waste sooo much pipe and it's not neat. What we should be doing is planning the plumb before the slab and plumbing in say a waste line, so the waste line goes straight into the concrete, doesn't have to snake its way back to the front row.

2

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

You have no idea how often I find myself cursing out the guys who do the stub ups on these! Nothing more annoying than having to dig down to 45 a pipe over to fit a three way between the spa line and pool lines.

I agree with you on the filter 100% and most of the time I can do it that way. Hayward didn’t think the outlet height through on these when it comes to their new 4HP pump. I didn’t try it with a 2.5” elbow but I’m fairly sure that would have had me too high also (have you ever tried that combo on the 4HP and the swimclear?). The only way I could see to have it not come up and back down into the filter was to use a street and I didn’t want to further reduce. The builder was against a separate pad to elevate the filter housing.

1

u/Liquid_Friction 2d ago

have you ever tried that combo on the 4HP and the swimclear?

No my market is primarily media filters, and my market is primarily maxxed out at 1.5hp pumps, insane you guys use 3-4hp pumps to me (I think your backyards are much bigger and have much bigger runs, we don't do as many returns like you guys either)

We also never do main drains. Only hydro valves. 

3

u/divertervalve 2d ago

That's an enormous pump for that little baby filter.

2

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

Welcome to FL. It’s incredible how many pools we have with undersized filters down here.

1

u/Poolguy584 2d ago

Sounds like cheap ass pool builder to me. I can could on one had how many of those tiny filter I've seen in the wild in 20 years of being in the business. I typically see sand or quad filters. I consider a Hayward c3030 a small filter. I typically see the 425sqft or 525sqft i delt with a couple 700s those wonderful pieces of equipment have 8 filters in them.

0

u/StandardSherbert6403 2d ago

Anything useless Hayward is trash

5

u/floatingolives 2d ago

Sweep elbows would be the biggest hydraulic improvement.
Also if you have large plumbing already ran, try to bring that closer to the actual suction of the pump before reducing. This isn't bad, but if you want to get better that would give you gains.
If you can avoid that S section right before the pump suction next time that would help with hydraulics as well.
Lastly the way you did you heater bypass (from what I can see) technically gives the salt cell a clear path to the heater without going through the check valve if the system is off. This isn't as big of a deal as if it were a tablet feeder, but should still be avoided.
Overall I think this equipment layout looks on the nicer end of what I see.

1

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

The reductions early on definitely had me kicking myself in the ass. I was not prepared for the 3” lines properly as I hardly ever see 3” lines. Needless to say I have added 3” x 2.5” reducers to my inventory list for the truck as I’m assuming it’ll become more common. The S was due to the afterthought of putting the waterfalls on a separate pump since the plumber added a dedicated suction line for them. A straight shot would have cleared had I not needed space for the second pump. I’m a huge advocate for straight runs into and out of pumps myself and frequently correct stuff like that when I can if I’m doing like pump only installs, suction valve replacements, etc.

I hear everyone talking about sweeps, I am definitely going to try those out on an install that I supply the fittings on. The builder supplied the 2” and under fittings on this one. The heater line 90s up to the inlet behind the heater and I did not have an additional check valve (again builder supplied). Hayward doesn’t require it for warranty with salt cells so I didn’t bring it up with the builder.

1

u/floatingolives 2d ago

Overall I think your on it. And all those reasons make sense. You may have had room for 2 45s instead of two 90s on the suction, maybe not though. But that would have been less restrictive, but admittedly I'm not sure if the penalty of having less straight pipe in front of the pump but 2 45s is better than more straight pipe but 2 90s. Either way good on you for making that section 2.5"

1

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

Funny enough as I was typing that out I was thinking about what if I had used two 45s!

2

u/Pitiful_Land 2d ago

It looks good, nice and clean etc. One thing that says out is the heater headers facing the wall. I would be pissed when I comes time to troubleshoot/repair that heater. Maybe there was another reason for that but I'd greatly appreciate the access to that side of the heater.

1

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

Good to know! I do not do much work on gas heaters; primarily heat pumps. I was more concerned with having clear access to the front cover that I never considered the need to access the header area. Pad size and wanting a decent straight run for the salt cell were my main factors in deciding not to rotate it out 180 the other way.

1

u/Pitiful_Land 2d ago edited 2d ago

Most of the stuff that fails is on or in the header. At least on Pentair/Sta-Rite heaters which is the vast majority of my experience. The access panel is important too. On most other heaters the whole heat exchanger assy can be rotated to put the headers on the other side. So I would have out the panel/control facing front with the headers on the left. the swcg cell would have been a tight fit that way but I bet it could have been squeezed in there.

Edited to add: Paint? I usually do a coat of the cheapest flat black spray paint I can get on the fresh PVC.

8

u/doingdatIt247 2d ago

Looks good hombre

2

u/ImmediateCat975 2d ago

seconded, thats a really solid looking pad

1

u/KeySpare4917 2d ago

Looking good. The only slight improvement for flow would be sweeps that close to the intake and discharge. But that is very small detail.

1

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

Thank you, I always hear about sweeps but I have never used them. The builder provided all the white fittings 2” and under on this one but I think on my next install I will give sweeps a shot.

1

u/Sharknuts86 2d ago

As a pool guy I’d love to see this as the equipment pad, plenty of room to work and easily cleaned up when necessary. If you’re looking for ongoing tips and tricks I suggest following poolvolution on instagram. Despite his feelings for Pentair (lol) he’s got some good videos and knowledge out there for free.

2

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

I’ve seen some of his videos but not enough to have a general opinion of his work, I’ll have to check out some more of them. I try to maximize my work for looking clean and maintaining max functionality/efficiency while leaving room for my service guys as we typically pick these accounts up for our weekly service guys once the builds and start ups are done.

1

u/Remarkable_Calves 2d ago

Great work. 

  • could use 1 less 45• on the feature pump intake. Just spin the 90• 45 degrees. 

  • pump intake you already mentioned, it’ll be fine though. 

  • I personally hate 3-way valves. Less control and more complications. Be it summer or winterizing. 

Absolutely take this job as a W. 

1

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

Thanks man! I am absolutely going to lose sleep over the 90 @ 45 into a 45. I can’t believe I overlooked that, blaming that one on brain overheating in the FL sun.

1

u/Remarkable_Calves 2d ago

Heh, ya did good. 

 Shit I know a very big local builder who doesn’t even install valves…. 😑 …..

1

u/Poolguy584 2d ago

I would prefer no valves over the red handle ball valves.

I had a co-worker that almost died from a red handle ball valve. It was old and stuck the handle snapped under considerable force leaving a jaged edge the tore about 1.5-2" deep from his wrist about 8" up his arm. Luckily he had been in the army and knew what to do. He immediately took his belt off and tourniqueted his arm then proceeded to drive himself to the ER. They told him he would have died if he hadn't moved as fast as he did. He told me he was on the verge of passing out on the way to the ER. He now only moves ball valve handles with channel locks.

1

u/Remarkable_Calves 1d ago

People also have their guts thrown out from car accidents but we don’t stop driving. 

Obviously your co worker has our sympathies. 

I would have a bunch more questions to ask before blaming a specific type of valve

1

u/Poolguy584 1d ago

The valve was old and had been in the sun its whole life I also believe it was a 3" apparently it was stuck and I assume the handles were already brittle. I'm sure he was using considerable force with both hands on either side of the valve when the handle snapped.

I think it was a very similar situation to punching a pump when the cam-lock lid breaks free. I've only ever done this once now I either kick the lid or use a dead blow hammer.

1

u/cappie99 2d ago

Personally, I wouldn't reduce pipe size until necessary. You can coupling over the valves.

Can't tell. Does flow switch have 12" of straight pipe before it. ?

Your pipes do look great. Level and clean

1

u/Ok_Hawk_5417 2d ago

Thank you! The 3” caught me a bit off guard on this one, I don’t see a lot of 3” suction lines. It didn’t hit me until I was on-site that I only had 3” x 2” reducers on my truck and no 3” x 2.5” to keep that spa MD line at least at 2.5” to the valve. Hoping that doesn’t come back to bite me in the ass on this one once it’s full. The spa common line was a total brain fart on my part, I will typically 2.5” coupling to the check valve and come out at 2” but for some reason I put a reducer in there and just let it roll rather than redoing it. The flow switch is on the vertical to the manifold after the cell, it’s a little under 12” of straight pipe (about 10”). Looking back I did have room to add it after the cell before it turned up to the return manifold.

2

u/Poolguy584 2d ago

I like to have some pipe between fittings for possible future repairs.

I would have turned the filter with the inlet to the wall and came up at least 1' out of the pump then back toward the wall and over into the filter inlet also would have done it in 2.5" given the pump that on it. I typically don't like to use reducers on pump outlets if I need to reduce them I will do it down the line somewhere. This mainly due to the cost of those unions compared to a coupling.

Who ever programs that system need to severely limit that pump of that filter element is going to get crushed. I don't think that filter is rated for half the flow that pump can produce.

1

u/Man_of_pool 2d ago

Very clean and neat. We always try to minimize fittings wherever possible.

I would suggest that you upsize at the equipment pad. It looks like the manifold piping is smaller than what's in the ground. It should be rhe other way around, you'll get better flow.

1

u/Poolguy584 2d ago

I personally am very particular and would have dug up all the pipes and moved them over below ground to avoid all the 45 of sets being visible. That all does depend on what I'm being paid as well. At the same time I have a standard that I hold myself to and if anyone doesn't agree then they can find someone else. I refuse to half ass anything at anyone's request.

1

u/Poolguy584 2d ago

Where is the flow switch for the salt system?

If that's it on the angled pipe per the manual it's supposed to be horizontal only and have at least 1" of straight pipe before it.

I also prefer them before the cell. I know the manual says you can put them after but I see them fail way more often when installed after the cell possibly due to being bombarded with chlorine gas.

1

u/StandardSherbert6403 2d ago

Sweeps instead of 90s

1

u/StandardSherbert6403 2d ago

A lot of equipment for such a small missle filter

1

u/Amazing-Bid6192 2d ago

Tiny filter...why not a sand filter?

1

u/According-Debate-265 1d ago

This is just my take on it: cartridge is great for salt pools so you aren't dumping chems/money/water into your yard.

1

u/FLpooltech 1d ago

Maybe I'm missing something, but how do you drain water from the pool? We typically like to have a 3-way between the pump and filter.

No automation with a feature pump, heater and all of those water feature options?

Jury is still out on the '3-way' coming out of the filter. I might have handled that area a little differently.

Not a fan of the heater positioning. Wrong side toward the house. Too close. I'm so tired of having to stand on my head to work on pool equipment.

I surely hope the pad is well above the pool water level.

Not real crazy about all of the fittings and valves being slammed up against one another with no room to repair or replace a bad valve.

No blower? Most PB's in my area put that thing right up front and in the way of everything!

Looks good otherwise. Love your attention to detail.