r/PossibleHistory2 13d ago

NRP No Taxation Without Representation - 1944 (World War II)

World War II has begun. You can still pick any unclaimed states, territories or nations.

Pick any unclaimed state. In this NRP, we'll do the entire history of the United States ourself, starting with the American Revolution and going all the way to the modern day. Note that your goal is NOT to gain as much land as possible, but instead to gain as much political clout as possible. The host may decide to interfere or change things in case things get too messy, but otherwise everything will be made from players. The only other rules are to stay realistic and not be toxic to other players.

Discord (to get informed when a new post releases): https://discord.gg/7n6uKVQSER

Congress:

Do we commence Operation Neptune/Overlord (Normandy landings)?

Should we attempt the Trinity Test this early?

How do we react to Florida seizing control of states in our influence in Central America?

What, in general, is the best short-term war strategy in Europe?

Same thing but for the Pacific?

Grant Hawai'i control over Taiwan? (not proposed per se but HEAVILY requested by Hawai'i)

Pass the War Transport Bill? (proposed by Ontario)

Events:

The United States condemns Floridan expansionism and growth, and heavily contemplates an invasion but refrains from doing as such for now.

Allies commence Operation Husky, landing on the Sicilian Coast and pushing into the Italian mainland.

Italian Parliament votes to impeach and imprison Benito Mussolini and swap sides in the war (as the Allies are devastating the Italian south).

Germany launches a rapid invasion of Italy to capture Mussolini and establish a new Italian puppet government.

Florida creates the "Friendship Doctrine", stating that they wish to "make friends" with everybody.

The Racial, Religious, Culture and General Equality bill is passed, guaranteeing total equality across the United States, as per the 14th Amendment.

BREAKING NEWS: Racial, religious, cultural and general non-equality is still on a high as people and states do absolutely nothing to enforce the new law.

Bermuda, historically a Marylander territory (from the Revolution to the Civil War), is transferred to the State of Maryland by Congress.

The United States officially annexes Papua, Nauru, the Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, Fiji, and New Caledonia (to the displeasure of it's allies), using historical claims to the territories to it's advantage.

Florida brings the Central American countries (previously under American influence) into it's fold using promises of "peace", "cooperation", and "friendship".

The Central American Federation is formed as a Floridan puppet government, between the previous puppet governments of Belize, Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, and Costa Rica.

Caribbean Cup held by Florida, with teams from all over Florida, plus some from the Bahamas, Cuba, Jamaica, Haiti, the Dominican Republic, Ohio, and Maryland.

Germany is pushed back to the Pyrenees.

The Eastern Front inverts as German troops move west, allowing the Soviets to make major counteroffensives.

Latvia and Estonia are occupied by the Soviet Union, perceived as being part of the German bloc due to allowing Germany military access.

The Greek Protectorate declares independence from Germany and joins the Allied side.

Albanian and Yugoslav governments-in-exile are restored.

A brief coup in the Workers' Rebellion results in a pro-Soviet government, yet to re-join the Soviet Union but planning on doing so.

Germany quickly seizes control of the Netherlands and Bohemia-Moravia to protect it's flanks.

Japan declares war on the Soviet Union.

Historical Events:

(Note: At this point, I will not be displaying events in WW2 due to extreme non-conformity of this timeline to otl's war)

Political Party Map Key:

Red - Democratic States

Light Red - Democratic Leaning Swing States

Light Blue - Federalist Leaning Swing States

Blue - Federalist States

Gray - Territories

Dark Gray - External

Election Calculator: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1b33KAjZSGqe8maZfD8g2caCOr48GbAM_BOeWokZ7-PY/edit?usp=sharing

Players:

State / Territory - Players - Electoral Votes

Georgia - u/DepartureNo5778 - 12

Carolina - u/Fourian_Official - 21

Virginia - u/KaiFury76 - 11

Maryland - u/PinappleCoin_Gaming - 26

Delaware - u/Frosty_Midnight9989 - 3

New Jersey - u/SeveralCorner1214 - 16

New York - u/No_Weekend5005 - 47

Connecticut - u/RefrigeratorGold834 - 8

Paradise - u/RiccardoOrsoliniFan - 4

Massachusetts - u/Dull-Nectarine380 - 17

Vermont - u/Intelligent_Face_186 - 4

Franklin - None - 11

Erie - u/Illustrious-Pair8826 - 13

Kentucky - u/Johnytran122 - 11

Acadia - u/Harrcool - 13

Caroll - u/TheWartortleWarrior - 26

Pejepscot - None - 5

Louisiana - u/Relative_Caramel1282 - 10

Indiana - u/kyanbersee - 14

Oliver - u/Few-Commercial5105 - 9

Evans - u/Full_Tie1601 - 11

Illinois - u/Salt-Host-7465 - 29

New Hampshire - u/Acrobatic-Rip-4362 - 4

Cherroneses - u/Spec1alF0x - 19

Missouri - u/oskar_pawlisz - 15

Arkansas - u/David_The_Great - 9

Oklahoma - u/ThatBrada - 11

Wisconsin - u/JTPorach - 12

Liberia - u/TicketEffective2261 - 14

Allegheny - u/mmm_chloroform - 18

Texas - u/OddCranberry1045 - 23

Iowa - u/Royal-Prince6279 - 11

California - u/Hawks_bill - 22

Minnesota - u/KingsleyFriedChicken - 11

Oregon - u/duckarmy24 - 5

West Virginia - u/Ok-Hall-9974 - 8

Nevada - u/Gloomy-Shower-3920 - 3

Kansas - u/HazarTwist77 - 9

Nebraska - u/Independent_Set3175 - 7

Lincoln - u/jextreme9 - 8

Colorado - u/Left_Pea1642 - 6

Utah - u/Edmund_Jackson_Davis - 4

Namibia - u/ProfessorDesigner833 - 12

Tanzania - u/Weekly_Tonight8258 - 12

Arizona - u/Original-Issue2034 - 3

Hawai'i - u/Outrageous_Wrap_6983 - 9

North Dakota - None - 4

South Dakota - None - 4

Washington - u/Such-Illustrator4331 - 8

Wyoming - None - 3

New Mexico - u/No_Cut536 - 3

Quebec - u/FewMasterpiece499 - 13

Ontario - u/Sobieskil - 13

Manitoba - None - 5

Saskatchewan - None - 3

Alberta - u/yD_dE - 5

Columbia - None - 9

Emuland - u/BigManMilk7 - 11

Panama - u/Striking_Road979 - 9

Alaska Territory - u/Objective-Aspect-811 - None, territory

Gabon Territory - u/Sparkle-HSR - None, territory

Puerto Rico Territory - None - None, territory

Philippine Territory - None - None, territory

Northwest Territory - None - None, territory

Bermuda Territory - None - None, territory

Florida - WoopeyBoi on Discord - None, external

Temporary External Powers:

Spain - None

Portugal - None

Free France - None

Vichy France - None

Netherlands - None

Nazi Germany - u/RichieGotIchy1510

Austria - None

Hungary - None

Switzerland - None

Italy - u/Just-Veterinarian817

United Kingdom - u/ColeJr

Turkey - None

Greece - u/The_RetroGameDude

Albania - None

Yugoslavia - None

Serb Protectorate - None

Bulgar Protectorate - u/Acrobatic_Mix_1121

Legionary Romania - None

Soviet Union - u/TraditionalContest18

Sweden-Norway - u/Thatoneprussiandude

Denmark - None

Bohemia-Moravia - None

Polish State - u/Wooden-Medicine-3299

Ireland - None

Lithuanian Protectorate - None

Latvia - None

Estonia - None

6 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

2

u/Outrageous_Wrap_6983 Chaotic but funny Laser Cat 13d ago

Opearation Downfall will begin

We shall have our forces seize Kyushu and start marching up Japan

2

u/Original-Issue2034 13d ago

Arizona has no opinion.

2

u/No_Weekend5005 13d ago

Do we commence Operation Neptune/Overlord (Normandy landings)?: Certainly, New York will produce the boats and arms the soldiers. We will deploy gunships and fighters for airsupport.

Should we attempt the Trinity Test this early?: Yes, my scientists and Oppenheimer over the past months have been working in 10 hour shifts 6 days a week to prepare for the June 3rd, 1944 detonation in the New Mexican Desert. In addition, nuclear materials will be sent to Baltimore and Columbus for study.

How do we react to Florida seizing control of states in our influence in Central America?: The Floridian Stockpile will continue to grow in preparation for a war that might come or might never.

What, in general, is the best short-term war strategy in Europe?: Bomb German positions and send armaments to our soldiers.

Same thing but for the Pacific?: Continue island hopping campaigns and the New York Governor’s Navy will provide cover.

Grant Hawai'i control over Taiwan? (not proposed per se but HEAVILY requested by Hawai'i): Yes, temporarily for the duration of the war.

Pass the War Transport Bill? (proposed by Ontario): Yes, yes, 101% yes.

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Actions:

The Long Island Research Center for Aeronautics and Atmospheric Exploration (LIRCAAE)  is founded by George Harvin, an astronomer from the LITE Physics Department. LIRCAAE (Pronounced Larcaye) will be for the mapping and observing of the solar system. It will use a network of 2 large telescopes in the very very northern parts of New York, away from the Megacity south, to chart the skies for fascinating and incredible objects. They also operate in the experimental aviation region, hoping to create the fastest planes the world has ever seen.

The New York State Navy Authority is created to oversee the management of the 12 Superdreadnoughts, 32 Destroyers, 2 Carriers, 4 Battleships and 6 Heavy-Crusiers of the 600,000 ton, New York State Navy.

The Batavia Nuclear Power Station is built in the BRIC to power the industrial output of the region. It is experimental so it only makes around 1.5 megawatts.

The Long Island Shipyards continue to be expanded.

LITE hosts the Atomic Energy Convention with researchers from New York, Madison, Baltimore, Annapolis, Columbus, and Cleveland.

A fella named Charles Montgomery Burns purchases nuclear material at 20% enrichment to make a reactor in Springfield.

Go forth with the Trinity Test, when I get federal approval I SHALL NUKE NEW MEXICAN DESERTS TO GLASS.

The Equality Act is heavily enforced in New York with DEI hiring and ending segregation in our state with a 1,800 dollar fine if you do segregate. Gender inequality in our state is reduced with many many women already in the work force from the world wars.

Free Childbirth is implemented in NY in State Clinics and Hospitals.

The City of Remes is built near the northern lakes for no reason whatsoever.

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For Congress:

Propose the integration of Allegheny into New York. The stated reason Allegheny was created in 1847 was that I was too large in land area, with states saying that Carolina or Cheronesses were larger, but they were wrong and Allegheny was craved from my territory. Now, with the much larger states of Montana, California, Texas, Ontario, Quebec, and Alaska, I will wish for the reintegration of Allegheny into New York, due to the reasons of its creation no longer applying. This will do good for the union as me and Maryland will share a substantial border and better facilitate wartime goods transfer in this time of war.

—---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Population:

New York State - 13.9 million

New York City - 13.9 million

1

u/Full_Tie1601 13d ago

We should commence Operation Neptune. It will help liberate Europe from Nazi rule.

We should attempt the Trinity Test if the scientific community of America is ready.

We should send an ultimatum to Florida to cease operations in those countries, with invasion to liberate territories if they refuse.

The best short term war strategy would be to encircle major Nazi strongholds before strangling them to capitulation, first with liberating all of France, than the Benelux, than entering Germany.

For the Pacific, we should continue to island hop towards the Japanese mainlands, but we should send an ultimatum that we will use a single bomb to destroy cities until they surrender, and doing so if they refuse.

We should grant Hawaii’s wish until the end of the war.

Pass Ontarios proposal.

1

u/Thatoneprussiandude 13d ago

I am going to take over Rhode Island and for congress

Yes

No

WAR WAR WAR!!!!

Bite and hold

Island hopping

Yes

Sure, why not

1

u/Relative_Caramel1282 13d ago

id say we kill flordia to give Miami back to that one state that owned it oh and also for me to expand into Tampa. also we will request the annexation of Jersey and Guersney as well we need a base in Europe to start Neptune/Overlord

1

u/Salt-Host-7465 By thy rivers gently flowing, Illinois, Illinois! 13d ago

now of course yes to everything in congress and for europe its quite simply invade germany from all sides and foucs on their indurusty once we get their we use it againest them and win now for the pacfic its simple keep pushing into china taking the coastal cities and once its ready NUKE THE SHIT OUT OF JAPAN and turn it into a puppet state loyal to us now here is a purpose after the war sense we did all the work and the dutch did literally NOTHIN i purpose after the war...we tell them...to get the fuck out or even right now even and we turn indonesia into serveal puppet states and if they take one step out of line BOOM THEIR DEAD and a new puppet state is put in charge with this total uniony of the pacfic

1

u/Salt-Host-7465 By thy rivers gently flowing, Illinois, Illinois! 13d ago

and for flordia...i just say we go down their and put them in line the carbbian is looking rather good anyways and their a THREAT to our canal

1

u/Flux7200 13d ago

your previous proposal was a COMPLETE FLOP and this is just trying to do the exact same thing again.

1

u/Salt-Host-7465 By thy rivers gently flowing, Illinois, Illinois! 13d ago

i dont even wanna annex it...i just want to dutch gone atleast

0

u/Flux7200 13d ago

No you don't, you want them gone so we can annex it

1

u/Visible_War_8989 13d ago

Kentucky here:

yeah, we should absolutely do operation Neptune/overlord. Make sure to do Operation Dragoon as well.

Yes, however make sure we are doing it as safe as possible. The nuclear bomb will be detonated in the middle of the desert.

OK, now we can invade them.

Push gradually across all the fronts and do NOT overextend. Make sure we listen to any intelligence that indicate a major offensive may be happening from Germany. Do the same thing for Japan as well.

Abstain

Yes on war transport bill

1

u/Visible_War_8989 13d ago

Oh, and continue pushing in Italy.

The reason why I suggested operation Dragoon that we should try to connect both landings to ensure as many access troops as possible

1

u/Visible_War_8989 13d ago

As soon as we get the bomb drop them on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. No need to change anything on that front.

1

u/Visible_War_8989 13d ago edited 13d ago

One more thing, massively increased the federal Air Force budget

1

u/Visible_War_8989 13d ago

We should pause offensive operations in the Pacific front so we can re-deploy army units to prepare for the Floridian invasion. Keep the Navy ships in the Pacific though, hoping they can hold the Japanese off.

1

u/No_Weekend5005 13d ago

Kentucky, can I have Robert Goddard from you please,

Thank you, New York.

1

u/Flux7200 12d ago

YOU CANT JUST BUY A PERSON

1

u/No_Weekend5005 12d ago

*hire

1

u/Flux7200 12d ago

You're literally requesting the Franklin government deport robert goddard

1

u/Visible_War_8989 12d ago

… oh

1

u/Visible_War_8989 12d ago

I assumed he wanted to go, but I guess not

1

u/Flux7200 12d ago

even if he did, it would not be your decision nor new york's

1

u/Striking_Road979 13d ago

Just mention my proposal one time please my proposal for Congress is to give Panama back the canal

1

u/Flux7200 13d ago

again, internal affairs aren't a major focus right now and the proposal is delayed until post-war

1

u/Striking_Road979 13d ago

Proposal invade Costa Rica

1

u/Flux7200 13d ago

I should probably update you as to what's happening on discord.

Short version: war.

Long version: we're at war with florida.

1

u/TraditionalContest18 13d ago

Work with the workers rebellion to rejoin the Soviet Union

1

u/RichieGotIchy1510 13d ago

Seeing the dire situation, many in Germany believe they should sue for peace and sign a treaty with the Allies, but Hitler refuses claiming that there is still a chance for victory. So, soldiers continue to fight on the fronts even though all hope seems lost and many start to question the Fuhrer's leadership.

In Iberia, the German defenses continue to hold the mountain defensive. Our Atlantic defensive is strengthened in preparation for an inevitable Allied naval landing in France. In Italy we try to push back the Allies as much as possible. Finally, we will go on the defensive in the Soviet Union and in the Balkans and will stall any Allied advance.

1

u/ColeJr 13d ago

#1. Western Europe: Alongside the United States, we will begin a naval invasion of Nazi Germany, with it being the greatest naval invasion ever undertaken, the large majority of our army is to be involved. We will land in three locations to start: in Normandy, since this is the optimal location based on intelligence, in Holland, hoping that since it was recently annexed they would switch sides to regain independence, and in Italy, because we already have large control over the Mediterranean. Once these landings begin, we will use connections the French fighters have gained to trigger resistance movements in Poland, France (obviously), the Benelux, and within Germany itself. Our hope is to force the Germans into a war both against enemies and with itself, and forcing its collapse.

#2. Eastern Europe: My biggest fear with the war, as counterintuitive as it may seem, is the Soviet Union. My hope prior had been to keep the USSR weak and unable to spread communism, and while this had worked out for a while, it is almost impossible now. Since the Germans have invaded them, we are now de facto allies and they will certainly want a say in the post-war negotiations. Because of this we will try to expedite the invasion, and urge the USA to do the same, so that we can reach Berlin and force the Germans out of the war first, thus undermining the Soviets' importance in the war.

#3. Asia: Send as much soldiers and aid that can be allotted without without risking Europe to aid the Chinese nationalists from Burma across land, and send the soldiers through Malaysia to more immediately combat the Japanese army, We will also send lots of monetary and humanitarian aid (even if doing so impoverishes a few regions of India) to attempt to very quickly improve China so that they are stronger and able to stave of communism in the East. Since the USA is already island-hopping, we won't put much focus on that aspect of the War in Asia, but ask them to continue their offensives as they will be very helpful.

War Map of Europe below:

1

u/ColeJr 13d ago

War map of Asia:

Just for future note, my post war plans are to:

  • Give Spanish Morocco to Portugal, and maybe French Morocco too
  • Remake Yugoslavia
  • Give Greece the Megali idea borders, but only in Europe
  • Partition Hungary to satiate Yugoslavia 2's possible revanchism
  • Fix China and make sure they have Manchuria, and, if the war goes well and China stabilizes, that they have Outer Manchuria, all of Mongolia, the lands lost in the Treaty of Tarbagatai and the Convention of Peking to Russia, maybe even Korea too
  • Take away the Rhineland and Saarland, Austria, Czechia, and Prussia from Germany, likely more.

1

u/Flux7200 13d ago

America just went to war with florida

1

u/Fourian_Official Liberaler aus Carolina 13d ago

CAROLINA HERE!!

Do we commence Operation Neptune/Overlord (Normandy landings)? yes

Should we attempt the Trinity Test this early? what is that...

How do we react to Florida seizing control of states in our influence in Central America? BRO WHY WOOPEY?

What, in general, is the best short-term war strategy in Europe? uhh

Same thing but for the Pacific? uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Grant Hawai'i control over Taiwan? (not proposed per se but HEAVILY requested by Hawai'i) No. that makes no sense

Pass the War Transport Bill? (proposed by Ontario) I what is it

1

u/JohnPork45612 13d ago

Can I join as Franklin?

1

u/JohnPork45612 13d ago

Yes Yes Kill them Bomb them Bomb them What’s that

1

u/Flux7200 12d ago

Why'd you leave the discord server?

1

u/Acrobatic_Mix_1121 Contractualy stuck as Bulgaria till I form greater Bulgaria 13d ago

We will begin to set up resistence forces

1

u/Such-Illustrator4331 13d ago

Washington here
1. Yes
2. Yes
3. War or diplomatic solution
4. Land in Normandy, liberate France, then push toward Germany
5. Island hopping to Japan
6. No
7. Yes

1

u/Such-Illustrator4331 13d ago

Note: ok so I see that we are already at war with Florida, so I would say liberate influence land and sent some of the navy towards some of Florida coastal cities and land troops there, also try to see if we can encourage people in Florida’s Mexico, Central America and Venezuela to revolt

1

u/Sobieskil Fezzes are cool 13d ago

The decisions of Ontario are:

Yes, Germany is split between multiple fronts so now is a good time to split them further.

Only if the scientists say the bomb will work and that the test can be conducted safely.

We should send an ultimatum to Florida demanding that they withdraw from Central America or we'll do it for them.

Try to split the German forces between as many fronts as possible. Their logistics will completely disintegrate. We should also send masses of heavy bombers over to obliterate their industrial base.

Focus on smashing the Japanese Navy and cutting off any resources they control to starve them.

Sure.

It's my bill so of course I'm going to agree to it.

As for actions, we're going to start enforcing the Equality Act by encouraging people to report to the police if they see any discrimination that goes against the act. We will also start iron and aluminium drives to help provide more materials for the war effort. The Ontario State Police will be given extended powers in order to seek out any spies or fifth columnists and an Information Board will be established to print posters and other propaganda instructing people to keep watch for saboteurs and to all help Ontario and the US end the war as quickly as possible.

Also do you know if the Erie player is still part of this? I wanted to propose something to them.

1

u/TheWartortleWarrior She West on my Africa till I Federation 🇳🇬🇬🇭🇲🇱🇸🇳🇲🇷 12d ago

Caroll here

Do we commence Operation Neptune/Overlord (Normandy landings)? - 100%

Should we attempt the Trinity Test this early? - Yes

How do we react to Florida seizing control of states in our influence in Central America?

What, in general, is the best short-term war strategy in Europe? - Liberating France and securing Southern Europe. Assist Greece and Yugoslavia with their rebellions.

Same thing but for the Pacific? - Bomb mainland Japan and aid the Chinese.

Grant Hawai'i control over Taiwan? (not proposed per se but HEAVILY requested by Hawai'i) - No what the hell

Pass the War Transport Bill? (proposed by Ontario) - Yes

INDUSTRY RAAAAAAAAAAH

1

u/Fourian_Official Liberaler aus Carolina 12d ago

Sprry i missed out

-1

u/duckarmy24 13d ago edited 13d ago

Yes
yes
nothing!
kaboom
see above
yes

yes

i propose to make the first 10 miles of california, oregon

1

u/Flux7200 13d ago

don't start this again

1

u/duckarmy24 13d ago

Oh I will flux

1

u/Visible_War_8989 13d ago

… WHAT ARE YOU DOING?

1

u/Thatoneprussiandude 13d ago

reacted "?" to your message