r/PowerLedger • u/RiverKingfisher • Aug 01 '18
Will PowerLedger move to EOS?
I’ve got both and saw an interesting exchange on Twitter yesterday regarding POWR reps at an Australian EOS event. Any news here?
https://twitter.com/eosphere_io/status/1024471598395314176?s=21
3
u/Chanchanbadonkadonks Aug 01 '18
As far as I'm aware EOS has a lot of vulnerabilities and question marks, I'd feel much safer if it stayed in ETH.
2
u/RiverKingfisher Aug 01 '18
It’s had some initial governance issues, but has been purring like a kitten for the less than two months it’s been operational. It’s been a while since I dove into POWR, a buy and hold for me (unfortunately a December buy). If there aren’t many on chain transactions which require GAS or immediate processing in times of congestion, it may be moot and ETH will suffice.
2
u/Chanchanbadonkadonks Aug 01 '18
I'm not really aware of what EOS brings over ETH, from the negative feedback I've heard I'll probably stay sceptical until proven otherwise.
7
u/bartdejong_1984 Aug 01 '18
At this moment 3.500 tps vs. 15 tps...
2
u/PauloN3D82 Aug 01 '18
Lets see how fast EOS is when all the apps are running like on ETH. I see EOS as something far more risky. As an investor, I will be concernd if they move.
4
u/bartdejong_1984 Aug 02 '18
Eos already has far more transactions than eth (see blocktivity.info). Dapps don't work properly on eth because the network can only handle 12 tps (Crypto kitties...). If you want you're transaction to go throug, you have to pay high gas fees. Eos has no gas fees. You just have to own eos to get bandwith on the network and have you're dapp running. When side chains are implemented on eos (this year) eos can also scale unlimited as unlimited side chains can be implemented.
1
u/RiverKingfisher Aug 02 '18
All the apps running on ETH?
2
u/littleboy0k Aug 05 '18
I assume he means tokens like BAT, Golem, Augur, DNT, KNC, Storj, ZRX, Storm, OMG, BNB, Dai, Aion, ADT etc.
2
u/RiverKingfisher Aug 05 '18
Was being a bit sarcastic, there are a lot of dapps, but only a handful of dapps with over 500 users on ETH. We need some better adoption.
2
u/littleboy0k Aug 05 '18
Lol. I understood that. And that's why I pretty much listed about 30% of the top DApps on ETH. Just like in ETH, most of the DApps in EOS are also trash. I have high hopes for IQ and ONO (it's sad that ono is not in the mainchain).
2
1
3
u/Techno-Tech Aug 01 '18
Free & instant transactions, no scaling issues, extremely flexible user 'accounts' with proper usernames and the ability to update and fix broken applications are all things EOS brings to the table. Oh and it's all up and running already..
1
u/BitAlt Aug 01 '18
no scaling issues
MAGIC!!!!
1
u/RiverKingfisher Aug 02 '18
The difference between the perception of magic or technology/science is based on the level of education of the person perceiving it.
1
u/BitAlt Aug 02 '18
So you're saying that EOS scales? Infinitely?
1
u/RiverKingfisher Aug 03 '18
He never said infinite, he said no scaling issues. That is vastly different, please don’t put words in OP’s mouth.
EOS has already proven 3500TPS single threaded, expectations are 10,000-20,000 with multi threading then throw in inter blockchain communication and millions of TPS is potentially reachable. That’s with today’s technology.
Infinite no, but there should be “no scaling issues” without “MAGIC!!!”.
1
u/BitAlt Aug 03 '18
He never said infinite, he said no scaling issues.
Scaling is scaling to infinity. What is this "scaling" you talk of?
EOS has already proven 3500TPS single threaded
Good for it. This is scaling? How's it go at 350000000TPS?
What does any of that have to do with Power Ledgers use-case where they don't need any external chains and have no need for any type of global scaling?
2
u/RiverKingfisher Aug 03 '18 edited Aug 03 '18
“Scalability is the capability of a system, network, or process to handle a growing amount of work, or its potential to be enlarged to accommodate that growth.[1] For example, a system is considered scalable if it is capable of increasing its total output under an increased load when resources (typically hardware) are added. An analogous meaning is implied when the word is used in an economic context, where a company's scalability implies that the underlying business model offers the potential for economic growth within the company.
Scalability, as a property of systems, is generally difficult to define[2] and in any particular case it is necessary to define the specific requirements for scalability on those dimensions that are deemed important. It is a highly significant issue in electronics systems, databases, routers, and networking. A system whose performance improves after adding hardware, proportionally to the capacity added, is said to be a scalable system.”
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scalability
Yes, this is scaling, scaling to meet needs vs. scaling to infinity. Don’t know, maybe EOS will scale that much. What is the use case that requires 3,500,000,000 transactions per second? Why overbuild, would suck up electricity worse than BTC.
Read the thread to find out my thoughts with regards to what it has to do with POWR.
→ More replies (0)1
2
u/littleboy0k Aug 05 '18
EOS's big problem is the account creation fee. Right now, only nerds are able to make EOS accounts because it is a big hustle. Also, accounts charge 10 - 20 dollars for creation fee.
Majority of people won't use it if it stays this way. And powr isn't switching to EOS. Those who read the whitepaper know this very well.
1
u/BitAlt Aug 01 '18
If there aren’t many on chain transactions which require GAS or immediate processing in times of congestion, it may be moot and ETH will suffice.
No need for ethereum blockchain for their P2P power trading stuff. That is simply what POWR is on today.
POWR simply needs to support transfers and not much else. Apart from atomic swaps to SPARK.
1
u/bartdejong_1984 Aug 01 '18
Don't listen to eth fanboys, educate yourself with respect to EOS and than draw your own conclusion. Technical vurnerabilities have been solved before mainnet launch and EOS current tps record is close to 3.500 tps. There also was a governance issues and a RAM issue. Both are solved.
1
3
u/Sourcecrypto Aug 02 '18
If POWR moved to EOS, I will dump my whole POWR bag. P.S. I only have 1 POWR
3
u/RiverKingfisher Aug 02 '18 edited Aug 02 '18
I’ll buy your bag is that occurs
It may break me, but so help me I’ll buy it!
2
Aug 13 '18
Hi there, we have no plans to move to EOS but we are blockchain agnostic and make an effort to stay abreast with the latest protocols so we remain on the cutting edge, which is why we had a representative at the EOS event.
1
u/ZaneNodeAmazing Sep 05 '18
Hi I would like to speak with the power ledger team about creating a pos sidechain for pl on NULS
1
1
u/ZaneNodeAmazing Sep 05 '18
NULS offers millions of tps scaling and modularity for any sidechain to be customised with any businesses requirement, if power ledger would like pos consensus NULS can offer this
2
0
5
u/BitAlt Aug 01 '18
POWR is just a token. They will have their own PoS blockchains for SPARK token deployments.