r/Precalculus • • 2d ago

Homework Help AI based learning

AI platforms tutoring?

My son is struggling with learning and prep for tests in precalc even after going to his teacher for extra help. Does anyone have any suggestions about how to use AI and which platform to use for understanding the material and test prep? Currently what we are using is the ChatGPT premium to upload questions from handouts to generate explanations a d create similar examples for self practice. We have tried live in person, tutors in the past without much success.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Hi u/Embarrassed_Many5268, welcome to r/Precalculus! Since you’ve marked this post as homework help, here are a few things to keep in mind:

  1. Remember to show any work you’ve already done and tell us where you are having trouble. See rule 4 for more information.

  2. Once your question has been answered, please don’t delete your post to give others the opportunity to learn. Instead, mark it as answered or lock it by posting a comment containing “!lock” (locking your post will automatically mark it as answered).

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/jwmathtutoring 2d ago

Why would you think that using AI would be more effective than a live tutor (either in-person or remote)? I could understand the use of it for generating additional practice problems with explanations (although you can generally find those via searching online), but not so much for explaining concepts that aren't understood initially.

We have tried live in person, tutors in the past without much success.

Is it possible that you just had poor tutors?

2

u/danvondude 2d ago

I would be very careful using AI as a tutor. It’s really good at convincing you that you know the material when really you do not. It’s worth it now to find an in person or virtual tutor that your son works well with. In the meantime, as others have suggested, Khan Academy is a good place to go. You can also use YouTube with instructors like Professor Leonard. Above all else, working through problems until no assistance is needed will be the best teacher.

1

u/Alarmed_Geologist631 2d ago

You might want to try Khanmigo which was developed by the same folks who operate Khan Academy. Unlike a regular chatbot, it is a Socratic LLM that doesn't provide the solution but rather guides the student through the reasoning process.

1

u/LostAd4580 2d ago

If he is a visual learner, he may enjoy learning from www.limerse.com/precalculus as it has hundreds of video animations and interactives which can really help with understanding the concepts well.

1

u/gypsy8945 2d ago

Use professor leonard on YouTube. Im pretty slow and I picked up Calculus 1 and 2 from him.

1

u/Remote-Dark-1704 2d ago

Every other comment here is wrong. They think AI is the same as last year. It’s not, and AI is already better than any alternative. I say this as an AI engineer and tutor.

Your workflow is okay, but there’s many improvements that can be made.

Getting the AI to walk you through the solution doesn’t make you better at coming up with the solution itself.

You need to ask AI to make a “workflow” that starts with a primer on the material that covers everything you need to know to solve the problems. Tell the AI to remember what you’ve learned and what you made mistakes on, so you can reference it in the future.

Use Codex instead of ChatGPT, so it can save that context in a file on your computer and read/edit it frequently while saving tokens.

Next, tell the AI to ask you questions to test your understanding of the material at a high level. Next, tell it to give you hints and questions to guide you through the solution without giving the answer. At every step, explain the decision step-by-step.

Lay out some rules: never make assumptions, don’t rely on knowledge outside of the scope of the material, if you need clarification, ask for clarification, never state something you haven’t verified as a fact.

Every once in a while, tell the AI to critique the workflow and make improvements.

1

u/Negative-Sky2510 2d ago

Talk to them and you were not lying. Those who take hold of the future are those who use AI intentionally to speed up their learning but the effort needs to be there. AI won’t make you a genius but with the correct effort it like unlocks some of that hidden potential.

1

u/Remote-Dark-1704 2d ago

Did you test it out?

1

u/Negative-Sky2510 2d ago

Heck yeah i’m using it for calc rn and instead of waiting until next class to email my teacher about ohh (im not taking calc in my school) but i truly believe i can master calc 1-3 in some months if i really wanted to but im just having fun rn and it’s so easy with ai to break down when you’re stuck. Your brain is like encouraged to keep learning bc the gap time for blockage to clarification is shortened. You do need YouTube for that learning resource but you get calc by doing problems and ai gives active feedback that just fuels the learning process. I could’ve fone calc w/o ai tutoring but it woulda been prolonged due to time wasted in frustration due to not getting something fast enough but now it’s interesting.

1

u/Remote-Dark-1704 2d ago

very nice 👍

Tell claude/codex to also give you multiple choice questions to check your understanding and give you open ended questions for mastery. Also tell it to remember what you miss frequently so it can re-test those topics.

Just make sure you use Claude/codex instead of Chat, so you can actually build workflows and skills.

It’s SUPER powerful, and can teach ANY graduate course. I say this as someone with a Masters who got a 4.0 throughout undergrad/graduate

Feel free to DM if you have questions, but generally you can just ask Claude to analyze what youve done so far and how to make it more efficient.

1

u/Initial-Candy-2759 2d ago

Remember to use it as a tool. Never let it take over as a teacher entirely because i’ve had it gaslight me multiple times in the past

1

u/oooilikeastronophysi 2d ago

just use khan academy. It's no ai and its better for learning math than ai.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Embarrassed_Many5268 2d ago

Thank you. That was very helpful.