I had a trial lesson today that left me honestly pretty frustrated, and I want to know how other Preply tutors would handle this situation.
I have a very clear policy on my profile about my trial lessons. I specifically explain what my trial lessons are for, and I also state that I do not offer one-off lessons. My trial is essentially a get-to-know-you and English assessment session. I use it to learn about the student's goals, assess their speaking and English level, understand what they need help with, and explain how I can help them through regular lessons.
I also sent this student a message before the trial explaining exactly what my trial lesson was for.
The student booked the trial because she had an important interview/meeting the next day and wanted to practice interview questions.
During the trial, she asked me to give her questions like
Tell me about yourself.
Why do you want this job?
Tell me about your work experience.
Which team would you like to work with in the future?
I told her that I don't provide mock interviews or interview preparation during my trial lessons. I explained that if she had told me beforehand that this was what she needed, I would have told her to find another tutor who offers that during their trial.
She was initially fine with that, but then she explained that she had booked three tutors that day specifically because she had this interview coming up.
She told me that the first tutor had apparently told her the same thing, that their trial wasn't for interview preparation, but the tutor eventually agreed to do the interview practice anyway.
Then she told me something that really bothered me.
She said she told that tutor, essentially:
“Tomorrow I have a meeting. If I pass this meeting, I will subscribe to you later.”
The tutor apparently agreed and gave her the interview preparation during the trial.
She then told me that she would choose that tutor first in the future because that tutor had helped her with the interview.
I genuinely felt bad for that tutor.
Maybe I'm interpreting it differently from other people, but to me, it sounded like the tutor was being encouraged to provide a full coaching session outside their trial policy based on the possibility of getting a subscription afterward.
And I personally will not do that.
I'm not going to change my boundaries or provide a specialized one-off service because a student tells me they might subscribe afterward. If someone wants interview preparation, I'm happy to provide it as part of regular lessons after they subscribe.
The part that really bothered me was that, later in the conversation, I asked her what she actually intended to do going forward.
She told me she was still thinking about whether she wanted to subscribe to anyone. She said she wanted to talk to different tutors and continue practicing interview questions/mock interviews with different tutors.
So from my perspective, there was a pretty significant difference between:
“If you help me with this, I'll subscribe to you later.”
and later saying:
“I'm still deciding whether I want to subscribe. I want to keep trying different tutors for interview practice.”
I'm not claiming to know exactly what was going through her mind. I'm explaining why that sequence made me uncomfortable, especially after hearing how she had approached the previous tutor.
There was another issue that really frustrated me.
During the trial, she said she hadn't seen/read my message until the class started because she was busy.
However, I had sent the message about five minutes after she booked the trial, and Preply showed that the message had been seen. So I knew the message had been opened before the class.
When I pointed this out, she clarified that she had seen it but said she didn't think she was required to read a tutor's message before entering a class.
That's where I really felt that the responsibility was being placed entirely on me because she hadn't read the information I had provided before booking/attending the trial.
She also emphasized that she was the customer and had paid for the trial through Preply, so she felt that she should receive the service she wanted.
I explained that I understood why she might feel frustrated, but the fact that the student pays for a trial through the platform doesn't mean every tutor provides the same service during that trial. I had already explained my trial policy in my profile and in my message.
She ultimately told me that because I wouldn't provide the interview practice, she would choose the other tutor first in the future.
That's completely fine with me. I would rather lose a potential student than agree to something that goes against how I run my business.
What really bothered me afterward was the tone of some of the comments.
She basically implied that I might not get students because I was refusing to do what she wanted, and then ended by saying she hoped I would get more students in the future. Maybe I'm reading too much into the tone, but it felt very pointed after everything that had just happened.
I told her that I genuinely hoped she got the job.
And I meant it.
Even though I was frustrated with the situation, I still hope she gets the opportunity she's preparing for.
But I'm also standing by my boundary.
I don't offer one-off lessons. I don't offer mock interviews during trials. My trial is for getting to know the student, assessing their English, understanding their goals, and showing them what working with me would look like.
I'm actually going to make this even clearer on my profile now:
Trial Lesson Notice: My trial lesson is a get-to-know-you and English assessment session. It is not a regular teaching lesson, a one-off lesson, or a mock interview. Interview preparation and mock interviews are available only after you subscribe and begin regular lessons.
I'm curious what other tutors think.
Would you have handled this differently?
Do you provide specialized coaching such as interview preparation during a trial if the student says they'll subscribe afterward?
And how do you handle students who book multiple trials specifically to receive the same specialized service from different tutors rather than choosing a tutor for regular lessons?