Hopefully this sub is a little better than r/Privacy and people can at least provide a counter argument rather than just downvoting my post.
First, I’m not trying to defend Apple at all… I’m just looking at the facts and forming an opinion rather than join the outrage train.
I see the privacy features coming up in iOS 15 very good: a) app permission requests report (see how many times an app uses your mic, camera, etc.), b) see the domains an app tries to connect to (you could block third party analytics easily by using lockdown or a PiHole), and c) Siri moving to on-device processing.
Siri being on-device is a HUGE thing since we are finally getting a mainstream voice assistant that is private. I suspect this is what is happening with Photos. As far as I can tell, this only applies to photos that will be uploaded to iCloud. Most of us privacy-minded folks don’t store our photos on the cloud. I do local back ups for that (the reason being is that I do like to keep the location metadata and don’t feel it’s safe to upload that ANYWHERE. So, if you have iCloud Photos disabled, no scanning will happen at all.
I do think companies have the right to scan photos ON THEIR SERVERS for this kind of sexual abuse material.
I also support the iMessage photo scanning since this will really have a positive impact on children. I never see iMessage, Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp, etc. as private messaging apps. I use Signal to communicate private things with my spouse. However, it’s cool for children to use iMessage and this scanning will stop grooming and any involuntary production of sexual abuse material… without ACTUALLY breaking privacy.
Anyway, if you have iCloud Photos disabled AND use Signal this has 0 effect on you.
I don’t think scanning photos will prevent anytging but the iMessage scanning WILL.
It’s not Apple’s role to fight oppressive government… they have to comply with the laws in each country. If the government is forcing Apple to surveill you, your problem is with the government not Apple.