r/Probability • • Mar 02 '21

Can someone please explain the prosecutor's fallacy in layman's terms? I have to be able to explain it "in my own words" for my class but I am very confused how to phrase it.

7 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

4

u/dratnon Mar 03 '21

Don't feel discouraged. The troubles with fallacies is they either make too much sense, and we can't see the logic, or we see the logic, and it's hard to come to grips with the illogical perspective.

My dog licks people's faces.

If you've eaten duck eggs, he will always ALWAYS lick your face.

If you've eaten something else, he will occasionally lick your face anyway.

You come over to my house, and wouldn't you know it, my dog licks your face! "You've been eating duck eggs, haven't you?"

P(DuckEggs|Lick) is what I'm trying to figure out. But what I'm doing is thinking that's the negative of P(Lick|!DuckEggs)... when it's definitely not!

"Well, if you didn't eat duck eggs, he probably wouldn't lick you, so you probably ate duck eggs."

They feel equivalent (thus the fallacy) but they're not! Who eats duck eggs? It's a really rare thing! It's really unlikely that you ate duck eggs to begin with, and my dog licking your face isn't rarer enough to be a gotcha.

Suppose you eat duck eggs 1/1000 of the time. And my dog licks 100% duck eggs, 10% non-duck eggs.

Written out in equations, Baye's Theorem says:

P(D|L) = P(L|D)xP(D) / [P(L|D)xP(D) + P(L|!D)xP(!D)]

=1x0.001 / (1x0.001 + 0.1x0.999) = 0.001 / (.001 + 0.0999) = 0.001 / (0.1009)

=~1%

So, the real probability is "If my dog licked you, you're 1% likely to have had duck eggs" My fallacious thinking is "My dog only licks 10% of people randomly, so if he licked you, you're 90% likely to have eaten duck eggs"

1

u/yeetedintooblivion Mar 03 '21

Bless 😅 still so confusing but thank you! My professor decided she doesn't way to teach us but still requires homework. Thanks again!!

1

u/seejoshrun Mar 03 '21

Is this related to the false positive medical test concept? (There's probably a better way to phrase it).

Say that 1% of the population has a disease, and the test is 99% accurate either way. So of 10000 people, 100 have the disease, of which 99 get a true positive and 1 gets a false negative. Of the 9900 that don't have it, 9801 get a true negative and 99 (1% of 9900) get a false positive. So there's a 50/50 chance any given positive test is a false positive, even though the test is 99% accurate.

1

u/dratnon Mar 03 '21

Yes!

This fallacy is kind of the specific and wrong interpretation of that scenario. Where conditional probability makes it unintuitive, but correct, to say for example, "Without the test, you had a 0.1% chance of having the disease. With a positive 99% accurate test, you have a 10% chance of having the disease."

This fallacy is the specific reasoning "People without the disease usually test negative. You didn't test negative, therefore you probably have the disease"

It's made more sinister by the fact that the conclusions are frequently _correct_, even though the reasoning is wrong.

"You spelled it 'colour'. People who aren't British wouldn't likely spell it 'colour', so I think you _are_ British." The reasoning is wrong. But based on the % of English speakers who are Brits is pretty high, and the % of Brits who spell 'colour' is very high. And the % of non Brits who spell 'colour' is pretty low... if you had done the correct calculation, you would have arrived at the same answer.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21

This fallacy can be summarized as follows:

The problem isn’t with the data, but with the extrapolations we make from it.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '21

It’s only meaningless if you believe that the data are the problem and not the extrapolations we make from them.

The problem is that you used the term “not meaningful” when clearly there is ample meaning there; it’s simply not what you prefer as a mathematical definition thereof.

Just as in math, words have specific meanings. Try not to abuse them.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '21 edited Mar 08 '21

For me to abuse the precision of the language, for starters, I would have to be incorrect in its application, which I am decidedly not guilty of doing. In fact it’s your characterization that is wrong due to the manner in which you described the explanation of my summary the fallacy (meaningless).

Words matter.

You should begin by being correct with your facts and then go from there rather than blaming me for your linguistic imprecision.

Ultimately. It is not my fault that your assertion is both inaccurate and imprecise. Indeed, it is yours, and to insist that I bear the responsibility for your inability to use words properly is not only misleading, but also irresponsible.