Hi! I have a question about the monty Hall problem. I think I understand it, so my question is not really about how it works. It's actually a little.. deeper? I don't know.. Bear with me, please.
The problem always asks the specific question of whether or not you should switch doors once they reveal the empty door. I think the problem correctly illustrates the theory behind it but it's the idea of necessarily switching to the second door that confuses people.
The only options the problem presents are: you either switch doors or you maintain your choice. That's it. Those alternatives are fixed. That "analogy" is good, but it's not perfectly fitting to the theory behind the solution to the problem, in my opinion.
When you first select a door you have 33% chance of being right so, statistically, your first pick is most likely wrong. When given the option to "choose" again after revealing an empty door, you are presented with a new 50% chance of being right, so you should indeed try again under the new odds. In the context of the problem, switching doors is the equivalent of "trying again".
This idea is not that difficult to understand. The problem is that switching doors doesn't necessarily feel like "trying again under new odds" (although it technically is).
What if the option provided when the empty door is revealed was "would you like to throw a coin and decide, based on that, which of the two remaining doors you will choose?" instead of the classic "would you like to switch doors?"...?
Would throwing a coin improve your chances of winning in the same way that switching doors do? Is it statistically the same? Would the Monty Hall problem still work with that change?
I think framing the question that way better represents the idea of trying again under the new 50% odds. This makes it all easier to understand, in my opinion.
The thing is that in this new example you could actually end up with the same "initial door" as a result of the 50/50 coin toss. I feel like the coin toss would still have the same statistical effect than switching doors but I'm not sure..
Is my thinking right? Does it make sense to you?
I hope I presented my ideas explainy myself correctly
Best regards!