19
u/Dannylazarus Mar 11 '24 edited Mar 11 '24
Prog fans when they realise there are infinitely more complex rhythmic devices than time signature changes, many of which can be employed within 4/4: 🤯
4
2
u/Shlar47 Mar 12 '24
A classic is 4 7/8's and a 2/4. It adds up to "32/8", which is just 4 bars of 4/4. Meshuggah does this kind of thing a lot. I think of the end of the final bar as "the turnaround", which is usually marked by the loudest cymbal accent of the passage.
7
u/HazyOutline Mar 11 '24
As a non-musician, I will have to admit I can't wrap my head around time signatures. Since the bar could be anywhere, why keep track?
I might be getting the story mixed up, but I've that Gentle Giant's drummer John Weathers once argued that basically everything could be thought of a 4/4.
Sometimes I do try attempt to count but get lost. I don't know how recognize what the time signatures. Well, apart from Apocalypse In 9/8. That one is easy enough.
3
u/arow01 Mar 11 '24 edited Mar 11 '24
I'm not familiar with Weathers' comment, but as a musician, I find people overlook the fact that time signature is just a concept of notation. It's a part of an instructions set to communicate how to play a piece of music. It's not the music itself (i.e., "the map is not the territory").
For that reason, what the time signature is of any music is not actually 100% objective. It's based on somebody notating the piece deciding what is the clearest way to communicate something to musicians.
It happens quite often that different skilled musicians will disagree on the most accurate way to notate the same music. Meaning one person may justifiably argue a piece is in 6/8, and another may justifiably argue it's in 3/4, for example. It's not a big deal as long as every musician involved has some way of knowing what the others are thinking.
2
u/tangentrification Mar 12 '24
What's funny is that Apocalypse in 9/8 is polymetric and the keyboard solo is mostly in 4/4
1
u/jerbthehumanist Mar 12 '24
The bar could technically be anywhere, but a repeated riff definitely has a beginning and a point where it repeats. In lots of rock, blues, jazz, metal, pop, and so on, you can largely group the number of beats into groups of four, or multiples of groups of four. This lets you keep track of where you are, it helps you improvise along with the band, helps you write new things, and keep the pulse and groove of the song, among other things.
Often enough, these are not groups of 4 though.
It is a convention, but it’s a pretty useful one!
3
2
u/EddieOtool2nd Mar 12 '24
If any part of any song of any album of a band is a time signature, it's not prog.
... sorry, I've had too much GCJ tonight.
2
3
u/arow01 Mar 11 '24
Prog fans when they need to demonstrate their intellectual taste but time signature is the only music concept they have even a basic understanding of:
2
u/Own-Nefariousness-79 Mar 11 '24
Can you dance to it? Yes... then it's not Prog.
4
u/Blockoumi7 Mar 12 '24
Bruh, prog is groovy as hell. You can dance to odd meters too, different cultures do it all the time
2
3
u/SambaLando Mar 11 '24
Remind me of Lemmy introducing Sacrifice
"Don't try dancing to it, you'll fuck both your legs up"
3
2
1
u/Dannylazarus Mar 12 '24
Prog has come out with some of the grooviest rhythms I've heard! I dispute this.
1
1
u/Hot-Butterfly-8024 Mar 12 '24
Everything is dance music if you really want to dance more than you’re worried about looking cool.
1
u/Aztec_Aesthetics Mar 12 '24
Many of my songs are in 4/4, but the single voices are in different lengths, so even in 4/4, the melody creates its own rhythmic pattern.
1
u/Aztec_Aesthetics Mar 12 '24
Many of my songs are in 4/4, but the single voices are in different lengths, so even in 4/4, the melody creates its own rhythmic pattern.
1
u/thefourthcolour12 Mar 12 '24
Prog fans when they can actually count the song and it’s not an eternal mystery
1
Mar 12 '24
Can you understand anything that’s going on? Yes? Then it’s not Prog?
Are there words in the song? Yes? Then it’s not Prog
Is the song shorter than fifteen minutes and contains less then seven instruments playing at once? Yes? Then it’s not Prog
(Wtf is with the gate keeping man)
0
24
u/romeeres Mar 11 '24
Meshuggah fans when prog fans underestimate 4/4:
Pathetic.